| Rank | Name | Pos | Location | Stars | Ht | Wt | School |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| #1 | Patrick Towles | QB | Ft. Thomas, KYHighlands Towles threw for 3,820 yards and 42 touchdowns with only one interception in 2011. | 4 stars | 6'5" | 232 | Kentucky |
| #2 | Zeke Pike | QB | Edgewood, KYDixie Heights A U.S. Army All-American, Pike was 163-of-262 passing as a senior for 2,011 yards, 14 touchdowns and seven interceptions; he rushed for 883 yards. | 3 stars | 6'5" | 220 | Auburn |
| #3 | Thomas Chapman | DT | Louisville, KYDuPont Manual Chapmanās team reached the second round of the playoffs. | 3 stars | 6'4" | 290 | Kentucky |
| #4 | Jeremy Clark | DB | Madisonville, KYMadisonville North Hopkins Clark accounted for five non-offensive touchdowns in 2011. | 3 stars | 6'4" | 205 | Michigan |
| #5 | Tyrone Pearson | DT | Louisville, KYSeneca Pearson made the all-district team after recording seven sacks. | 3 stars | 6'3" | 265 | W. Kentucky |
| #6 | Anthony Wales | RB | Louisville, KYCentral Wales rushed for 2,784 yards and 40 touchdowns this season. | 3 stars | 5'9" | 170 | W. Kentucky |
| #7 | Joe Manley | OL | Bowling Green, KYBowling Green Manley anchored offensive line for state championship team. | 3 stars | 6'7" | 307 | Louisville |
| #8 | Josh Harris | DB | Maysville, KYMason County Harris missed his senior season with a foot injury. | 3 stars | 6'1" | 200 | Kentucky |
| #9 | Daniel Ross | DE | Jeffersontown, KYJeffersontown Ross was an all-district performer who helped lead a defense with three shutouts. | 3 stars | 6'5" | 280 | list |
| #10 | Patrick Graffree | DT | Elizabethtown, KYCentral Hardin Graffree was selected to play in the Best of the Bluegrass All-Star game. | 3 stars | 6'4" | 277 | Kentucky |