| Rank | Name | Pos | Location | Stars | Ht | Wt | School |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| #1 | Jaylon Smith | LB | Fort Wayne, INBishop Luers Smith finished off his high school career in November with his fourth state title in as many years | 5 stars | 6'3" | 212 | Notre Dame |
| #2 | Elijah Daniel | DE | Avon, INAvon Daniel finished his senior season with approximately 80 tackles and 12 sacks | 4 stars | 6'3" | 249 | Auburn |
| #3 | Tim Kimbrough | LB | Indianapolis, INWarren Central Kimbrough had 121 tackles, 11 tackles for a loss, seven sacks, four forced fumbles and one interception in 10 games as a senior | 4 stars | 6'1" | 226 | Georgia |
| #4 | Danny Etling | QB | Terre Haute, INTerre Haute South Vigo Etling finished his senior season completing 109 of 211 passes for 1,505 yards and 11 touchdowns with nine interceptions | 4 stars | 6'3" | 200 | Purdue |
| #5 | Antonio Allen | DB | Indianapolis, INBen Davis Allen had 73 tackles, two tackles for loss, two interceptions and a fumble recovery as a senior | 4 stars | 5'10" | 205 | Indiana |
| #6 | David Kenney | DE | Indianapolis, INPike Kenney finished his senior season with 60 tackles including 17 for loss and 13 sacks | 4 stars | 6'2" | 250 | Indiana |
| #7 | Darius Latham | DT | Indianapolis, INNorth Central Latham collected 46 tackles, 10 tackles for loss and four sacks in nine games as a senior | 4 stars | 6'5" | 291 | Indiana |
| #8 | John Kenny | LB | Carmel, INCarmel Kenny had 86 tackles, 14 tackles for loss, four sacks and two forced fumbles as a senior | 3 stars | 6'2" | 210 | Iowa |
| #9 | Chase Dutra | ATH | Brownsburg, INBrownsburg Dutra had 790 yards of total offense and returned three punts for touchdowns as a senior | 3 stars | 6'1" | 190 | Indiana |
| #10 | TyVel Jemison | DB | Fort Wayne, INBishop Luers Helped lead Bishop Luers to the Class 2A state title in 2012 | 3 stars | 5'10" | 175 | Purdue |
| #11 | Dan Samuelson | OL | Plymouth, INPlymouth Samuelson earned first team all-state honors in class 4A as a senior | 3 stars | 6'5" | 275 | Michigan |
| #12 | Calvin Blank | TE | Terre Haute, INTerre Haute North Vigo Blank earned first team all-state honors in class 5A as a senior | 3 stars | 6'4" | 226 | Ball St. |
| #13 | Nate Wozniak | TE | Greenwood, INCenter Grove Wozniak caught 26 passes for 520 yards and five touchdowns as a senior | 3 stars | 6'9" | 255 | Minnesota |
| #14 | Skylar Lacy | OL | Greenwood, INSouthport Lacy had 31 pancake blocks as a senior | 3 stars | 6'6" | 290 | Louisville |
| #15 | Thomas Shoaf | OL | Columbus, INColumbus North Shoaf earned first team all-state honors in class 5A as a senior | 3 stars | 6'6" | 255 | BYU |
| #16 | Michael Hicks | LB | Fort Wayne, INConcordia Lutheran Hicks ran consistently in the 4.5 range for the 40-yard dash this off-season. | 3 stars | 6'3" | 237 | list |
| #17 | Timothy Gardner | OL | Indianapolis, INLawrence Central Gardner earned first team all-state honors in class 5A as a senior | 3 stars | 6'5" | 340 | Ohio St. |
| #18 | Andrew Spencer | DB | Fort Wayne, INBishop Luers Is the younger brother of Dallas Cowboys linebacker Anthony Spencer. | 3 stars | 6'0" | 185 | list |
| #19 | Isaac Griffith | WR | Fort Wayne, INHomestead Griffith earned first team all-state honors in class 5A as a senior | 3 stars | 6'0" | 180 | Indiana |
| #20 | David Yancey | ATH | Saint John, INLake Central Yancey carried 150 times for 1,362 yards and 17 touchdowns as a senior | 3 stars | 5'11" | 200 | Purdue |