Big plays lead No. 8 Pitt past Notre Dame 27-22

Preview | Box Score | Recap
  • Print

PITTSBURGH (AP)—In need of a big win, Charlie Weis and Notre Dame couldn’t turn around a troublesome trend. Pitt keeps winning and winning like it hasn’t done in 27 years, and now the Panthers are one more victory away from a really big bowl.

Jonathan Baldwin made two exceptional catches that allowed No. 8 Pittsburgh to open up an 18-point lead in the fourth quarter. Notre Dame rallied behind two touchdowns by Golden Tate, but the Panthers held on for a 27-22 victory Saturday night.

The cries for Weis’ ouster among Irish supporters will surely grow louder after Notre Dame’s second straight loss.

Notre Dame (6-4) trailed 27-9 with 12:44 remaining after Dion Lewis’ 50-yard touchdown run, then had a chance to take the lead on its final possession before Jimmy Clausen fumbled with just over two minutes remaining.

“We got a little scare, but we always have confidence in our defense to make a big stop and they did,” Lewis said.

The Irish followed up a 23-21 loss to Navy with their eighth consecutive loss to a top-10 team—the longest streak in school history. Weis is 1-10 against ranked teams since 2006, and has the same record (35-25) as former coach Bob Davie and the same winning percentage (.583) as former coach Tyrone Willingham, both of whom were fired.

Pitt relied on big plays by Baldwin and running backs Lewis and Ray Graham to improve to 9-1 for the first time since 1982, Dan Marino’s senior season, and is headed for a Dec. 5 home date against No. 5 Cincinnati that will decide the Big East Conference champion and BCS bowl representative. A Nov. 27 game at rival West Virginia won’t factor into the conference race.

A game the Panthers needed to win for prestige and to remain in the top 10 couldn’t have gone much better for three quarters-plus.

Tate, one of college football’s most dynamic talents, nearly brought the Irish back.

“But when you get down three scores, at the end of the day … ” Weis said.

Tate ended with nine catches for 113 yards in his second 100-yard game against Pitt in as many seasons, though Pitt followed up its 36-33, four-OT win in South Bend last season by outgaining the Irish 429-349.

Called the best player Pitt has faced all season by coach Dave Wannstedt, Tate caught an 18-yard touchdown pass from Clausen to cut it to 27-16 with 9:10 remaining. Tate then ran right up the middle of Pitt’s punt coverage unit on an 87-yard touchdown return less than two minutes later.

That score quieted a raucous crowd of 65,374, including thousands of suddenly nervous students who only minutes before loudly sung their adopted good-luck song, Neil Diamond’s “Sweet Caroline.”

Until Tate broke loose, Baldwin upstaged Tate and fellow Notre Dame star receiver Michael Floyd. Despite being matched step for step by defender Darrin Walls, Baldwin stretched out all of his 6 feet, 5 inches to catch Bill Stull’s perfectly thrown 36-yard touchdown catch late in the second half to make it 10-3. Stull went 15 of 27 for 236 yards and no interceptions.

Baldwin then made an even better grab, a soaring 51-yard grab over Walls— like him, a former Pittsburgh-area high school star—to the Irish 29 that led to Dan Hutchins’ second field goal, a 38-yarder, and a 13-3 lead. After the Irish punted, Graham ran through half of the Notre Dame defense on a 53-yard run that led to his 2-yard score one play later.

Baldwin made five catches for 142 yards.

“This was a statement game for him,” Wannstedt said.

Baldwin was more motivated by pre-game promotional commercials on ABC that he felt played up Notre Dame and downplayed the Panthers.

“They probably thought we were going to lose,” he said. “We just wanted to come out and take care of business.”

Lewis, the freshman who ran for 152 yards, took over on the next drive to score from the 50 and make it 27-9, answering’s Clausen’s 1-yard TD sneak on the first play of the fourth quarter. Clausen has pulled off four comeback wins in the fourth quarter this season and, in another frantic fourth, nearly did it again.

Nearly.

The Irish got the ball at their own 20 with 3:39 remaining and had a chance to pull off an improbable comeback, but a 15-yard chop block penalty prevented the drive from taking off and Clausen (27 of 42 for 283 yards, one interception) fumbled while under pressure on a third-and-16 play—one initially ruled an incompletion but reversed on replay.

Weis wasn’t happy with the reversal, saying it seems “the replay officials are the stars” by repeatedly reversing calls.

Notre Dame finally got going on offense after being held to three points in the first half, a week after being shut out by Navy before halftime—a loss that rallied the Weis-must-go forces in South Bend once again. Weis wanted to play conservatively and not let Pitt’s multidimensional offense get going, but Pitt’s big lead changes those plans.

“We didn’t want to get into that (a wide-open game) that early,” he said.

Weis isn’t accustomed to his teams not scoring points in Heinz Field. He began his Notre Dame career by beating Pitt 42-21 in 2005, only nine months after his Tom Brady-led Patriots offense rolled past the Steelers 41-27 in the AFC championship game.

Now, there will be speculation Weis’ college career may have effectively ended in the same stadium where it began. The Irish still must play Connecticut and Stanford, which has beaten top-10 teams the last two weeks, and they have again failed to beat any nationally prominent teams.

Updated Nov 15, 12:37 am EST
digg del.icio.us
more

Head to Head - Week 11

Team Total Yds Pass Yds Rush Yds First Downs 3rdD% Pen./Yds Turnovers Time of Poss.
Notre Dame 349 283 66 20 42.9% 5/53 2 30:52
Pittsburgh 429 236 193 17 25.0% 1/5 0 29:08

254 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. icantmakeyouthink
    254. Posted by icantmakeyouthink Tue Nov 17 6:21am EST

    Report Abuse

    [David
    250. Posted by David Mon Nov 16 4:52pm EST
    I'm a 63 year old life time Pitt fan and I agree with TJW on the younger fans. These are not Pitt fans, they are they young "fans" in Pittsburgh. The real Pitt fans will welcome others to our field as we are welcomed to theirs!

    So far as Charlie Weiss. I think he is a wonderful person who is not mean enough to coach a team that must win 9-10 games a year. I hope he lands where he is appreciated.]

    David, thanks for welcoming us to your field, and we always welcome a classy program like Pitt to South Bend. Don't worry, we true Irish fans appreciate the job Charlie has done, and our A.D. has stated he will evaluate the PROGRAM after the season finishes.

    It won't be evaluated on articles so-called "experts" write, or comments from immature children at keyboards.

    We have a great offense, and we were in every game, including against highly ranked teams like USC and Pitt. We have mostly juniors and underclassmen starting.
    Our defensive coordinator is in his first year here, I hope to see improvement soon. Our defense needs to gain consistency, and perhaps more talent on the D-line.
    Charlie has addressed that by recruiting a 4 and a 5 star DE.

    I hope he stays. I hope the A.D. seeks long-term solidity and performance, which I think Weis will give us

    People and journalists act like it was an upset N.D. lost this game! Pitt was ranked #12, and we weren't even ranked! On the road!

    Pitt has a very good team, and although I am disappointed we lost, hope you win out. Makes us look better if you do!! We lost to a very good team!!
  2. icantmakeyouthink
    253. Posted by icantmakeyouthink Tue Nov 17 6:05am EST

    Report Abuse

    [TJW
    244. Posted by TJW Mon Nov 16 12:19am EST
    The Irish aren't that far away from being very good, they have been in every game with the possibility of winning.]

    Wait a minute, can it be??

    [The players lost that game. A roughing the kicker penalty led to points. Horrible punting led to great field position all night for Pitt, they had a short field most of the night. Poor tackling led to big running plays by Pitt. The one TD by pitt was a great throw and catch, the man was covered, a 5'11' DB cannot outjump a 6'5'' receiver. Pitt's DE(#98, I think) was all over Clausen and in the backfield all night. I do question the incomplete pass overturned, the play was whistled dead and all players stopped, I don't see how you can overturn that call and give the ball to Pitt. It would have still been 4th and long.]

    No, tell me it isn't true: a real Irish fan with vision and patience???

    [Jon Gruden is not the answer, he has never developed any players. Urban is not going anywhere, he has a powerhouse team with plenty of players to take over after Tebow leaves. He is able to get athletes who don't have to worry about ever graduating. If it's anyone it should be Kelly from Cinci, he has won everywhere he has been, he's tough.]

    Kelly? The coach for Cincy that U Conn laid 45 points on? How many times have N.D.'s up and down defense allowed 45 points this year? ZERO.

    Read your own comments, have patience, we're improving, and will establish a fine program with coaching stability. Fans and colleges seeking "instant gratification" almost always find none.
  3. PhilipH
    252. Posted by PhilipH Tue Nov 17 12:25am EST

    Report Abuse

    Wm Q, you don't sound "real great" at the books either.

    There are a number of schools with "academic standards" that are as tough, if not tougher, than Notre Dame. Georgia Tech, Iowa, Penn State, Virginia Tech, Wisconsin, Stanford, California, BYU. Even Texas and USC, I bet!
  4. David
    251. Posted by David Mon Nov 16 5:59pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Point #2. To "KeyWestBaller". The University of Pittsburgh has been playing football for 120 years, has won 9 national titles and has played ND 60 odd times. So, we don't need to be taught how to play football.
  5. David
    250. Posted by David Mon Nov 16 4:52pm EST

    Report Abuse

    I'm a 63 year old life time Pitt fan and I agree with TJW on the younger fans. These are not Pitt fans, they are they young "fans" in Pittsburgh. The real Pitt fans will welcome others to our field as we are welcomed to theirs!

    So far as Charlie Weiss. I think he is a wonderful person who is not mean enough to coach a team that must win 9-10 games a year. I hope he lands where he is appreciated.
  6. Aaron
    249. Posted by Aaron Mon Nov 16 4:25pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Im on the fence on Charlie. Where I am sick of losing these kind of games it could be worse. We could be a full 2 games better then last year at the end of the season. Was it right to expect a ten or eleven win season in the first place? Also if they fire Charlie they BETTER have someone already in place. It does the team no good to AGAIN interview 3 other head coaches who will only tell them no and then settle for our fourth choice. If thats the case you might as well keep Weis. Lastly, how good is our next coach gonna be if Clausen, Tate, the whole offensive line, and possibly Te'o leave for the NFL, graduation, and transfers due to Charlie's firing? Its a big fat mess...
  7. Mark N
    248. Posted by Mark N Mon Nov 16 12:29pm EST

    Report Abuse

    I think the problem may go beyond Coach Weis. It is the athletic department. They got duped into believing that Coach Weis is going to be the answer to their recent woes, just because he almost beat USC his first year, (while coaching Willingham's recruits) and that has not turned out to be the case.

    Look at the errors that the Notre Dame athletic department has made since Lou Holtz left.

    #1 Hiring Bob Davie - I liked Bob Davie, but Head Coach at Notre Dame should be reserved for experienced and proven head coaches at the D-I college level - the job is too high profile and requires too many demands and expectations for someone who has never been a head coach before (Gerry Faust should have taught them that).

    #2 Hiring George O'Leary - When you hire someone to coach for the highest profile program in the country, you better do a thorough background check, because if you don't, someone else will - the AD's inattention to detail compromised the professionalism of the program.

    #3 Firing Ty Willingham - They hired Willingham out of semi-desperation because they were still reeling from the O'Leary debacle; therefore, he otherwise would not have been their first choice. With that said, they should have given him at least another year to prove himself. Firing him so quickly was just not the right thing to do because it intensified the perceived instability in the program.

    #4 Hiring Charlie Weis - see #1 above.

    The academic standard excuse is a poor one. ND has their own tv network - they should not have any trouble recruiting top talent that has the SAT scores to get in the school.

    Until improvements are made in the AD office, we will continue to see mediocrity on the field.
  8. ollie
    247. Posted by ollie Mon Nov 16 11:44am EST

    Report Abuse

    ND and academic standards: right now, Stanford is playing better football, and their academic standards are even higher than NDs.

    I think that ND will send people to the NFL, so I don't see this as a talent problem. ND has less talent than Navy??? I don't think so.

    I really think that coach Weis has to learn how to deal with immature college players; not every player is a Brady Quinn.
  9. Math_Maestro
    246. Posted by Math_Maestro Mon Nov 16 5:48am EST

    Report Abuse

    # 246, To "Complete" Page 10 & Reach 11!
  10. Wm Q
    245. Posted by Wm Q Mon Nov 16 1:04am EST

    Report Abuse

    First CW must go he is definitely a poor college coach. You also got to look at the way ND handled the Navy option, this is the oldest running scheme in football. ND was not forcing the option every time a good defense coordinator worth his weight should have a had a way to stop Navy. I know everyone thinks Clausen is the greatest QB. I'm a die hard ND fan and I think Clausen is OK. He tries to much to figure out defenses and then he ends up throwing it away. Also has anyone notice how long it takes for plays to develop with ND. It seem like every passing play was being thrown clear across the field. This give so many teams they played time to cover their passes. Pitt was a perfect team for Clausen to shine because Pitt's deep defense was not that good. I realize their defense put a lot a pressure on clausen but there was some times a long pass would have worked. You saw very little quick in or out passes by ND.

    I'd settle for Jerry Faust coming back versus CW, Gruden is not a college coach. Also seen in the post about lowering academic grades. If you want to compete you need to lower them. Sorry to say most of the players from schools in the top can't even pass the BS classes, as much as taking regular classes. Personally wish it was different but many inner city kids that have the FB skills and speed aren't real great at the books.
  11. TJW
    244. Posted by TJW Mon Nov 16 12:19am EST

    Report Abuse

    The Irish aren't that far away from being very good, they have been in every game with the possibility of winning. The players lost that game. A roughing the kicker penalty led to points. Horrible punting led to great field position all night for Pitt, they had a short field most of the night. Poor tackling led to big running plays by Pitt. The one TD by pitt was a great throw and catch, the man was covered, a 5'11' DB cannot outjump a 6'5'' receiver. Pitt's DE(#98, I think) was all over Clauseen and in the backfield all night. I do question the incomplete pass overturned, the play was whistled dead and all players stopped, I don't see how you can overturn that call and give the ball to Pitt. It would have still been 4th and long.

    Jon Gruden is not the answer, he has never developed any players. Urban is not going anywhere, he has a powerhouse team with plenty of players to take over after Tebow leaves. He is able to get athletes who don't have to worry about ever graduating. If it's anyone it should be Kelly from Cinci, he has won everywhere he has been, he's tough.

    For all of those who have forgotten, when Lou Holtz was at ND, they relaxed their admission standards and football players were admitted with less than stellar academic records. Check out some of the players SAT scores and such, not all of them are at the top of their classes. The academic standards are not and should not be used as an excuse for not winning.

    One last itme, the Pitt fans are the worst that I have ever seen, mainly the younger ones. I have been in many stadiums including State College wearing my ND jersey the last time they played and it was not fun but Pitt was horrible.
  12. FYFE
    243. Posted by FYFE Sun Nov 15 11:21pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Jon Gruden is not the answer. Just another distraction. I like Gruden but I think he's too harsh for college football. I mean, if NFL players can't stand him then how is a young man going to react to him? I say keep Weis but make him the highest paid Offensive Cordinator in college football. Seriously. I say we get Lou Holtz back and right the ship. Or go after the Cinncinati coach who is more than interested in ND. Plus, he runs an offense that Clausen will prosper in. Personally, I say don't fire Weis unless you have a suitable replacement. I think Weis will have 1 more year to prove himself. I think ND will really try and go through the growing pains with this coach. Especially if ND goes 8-4.
  13. Corey M
    242. Posted by Corey M Sun Nov 15 10:03pm EST

    Report Abuse

    If weis goes so do clausen and tate. so there goes our only bright spot, the offense. And next year, dont be surprised to see us go 4-8....
    Not happy with this season.
  14. Mr College Football
    241. Posted by Mr College Football Sun Nov 15 6:33pm EST

    Report Abuse

    KeyWestBaller - I'm sure the SEC Commissioner sends the ND AD a thank you note daily for helping to make that conference relevant. Surely, if it weren't for the storied history, strong academic standards and other traditions that ND has exclusively developed, then I guess there just wouldn't be any football! I guess ND developed the internet too!

    You are a complete twitt!
  15. Beat the Bruins!  Fight On!
    240. Posted by Beat the Bruins! Fight On! Sun Nov 15 6:32pm EST

    Report Abuse

    people will always hate a winner. SC is going through it, Nd is going through it. Nebraska, Miami, Oklahoma and ohio state have all gone through it. Just like the hate for the dallas cowboys or yankees, fans hate to see the same teams always in the talks of championship. Florida is getting to get that hate also from what i read. As an SC fan, its fine with me. Just shows that SC is not irrelevant in the grand scheme of things. Fans are still complaining that SC is ranked still this week. They are a good team that lost all of its hope after that Oregon loss. Now they have psychologically imploded.
    As i heard Harbaugh make fun of the SC players running off the field after the clock went to zeros, he says look at em run to the locker room and shook his head.....all i have to say is that these players are not used to losing like you are. Kind of like your players arent use to winning. The ones that talked trash to the abc cams on the sideline during the final minutes of the game.
  16. KeyWestBaller
    239. Posted by KeyWestBaller Sun Nov 15 5:31pm EST

    Report Abuse

    To all you Notre Dame bashers, just remember, there would not be major College Football with out Notre Dame showing all of your little time teams how to put together a program and recruit. Notre Dame may never be the greatest team again, but it sure does help your little teams when Notre Dame plays them, and you get that wonderful full stadium, TV revenue, and of course, that 15 minutes of fame, beatting Notre Dame
  17. TobyDad
    238. Posted by TobyDad Sun Nov 15 5:23pm EST

    Report Abuse

    219. Posted by Brian C Sun Nov 15 3:01pm EST Report Abuse
    213. Posted by Bill Sun Nov 15 1:59pm EST Report Abuse
    Weis has to go, period. how can he ask his players to get in shape, when he looks like a white o. winfrey?
    *******************
    How about a WHITE Rosie O'Donnell ??
  18. EB
    237. Posted by EB Sun Nov 15 5:17pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Was it just me or does anyone think that Pitt didnt win the game the refs did. I'm not saying Pitt didn't play well they did, but those res were crap. They called 1 penalty all game on PItt. 1 PENALTY!!!! And on our side every penalty against us was at a key point that screwed us over. It was bs. Some where good calls i will say that but how come those same calls werent made in our favor on the Pitt side. 1 offside penalty for the whole game. Thats highly likely. Then add 2 blown replay reviews. The fumble at the end and Pitts big 3rd down conversion pass that the wr pinned against the ground(they later scored on that drive). Total bs. Highway Robbery.
  19. patrickj
    236. Posted by patrickj Sun Nov 15 5:16pm EST

    Report Abuse

    At least ND players have to open books to stay there. I feel sorry for Charlie but he knew what the situation was. Maybe he was ego dreiven to believe he could counter the football factories in Fla, Tex and LA.
  20. Michael
    235. Posted by Michael Sun Nov 15 5:10pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Notre Dame? So who needs Notre Dame? Now the Panthers must suck it up and face a serious threat--Cincinnati!
  21. Michael
    234. Posted by Michael Sun Nov 15 5:10pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Notre Dame? So who needs Notre Dame? Now the Panthers must suck it up and face a serious threat--Cincinnati!
  22. Fighting Iwish
    233. Posted by Fighting Iwish Sun Nov 15 5:05pm EST

    Report Abuse

    ND is running on fumes and it won't get any better until they hire a real football coach, not somebody who looks like he ate a couple of them. How's that decided schematic advantage working out for ND so far? Too many high school hotshots fade away at ND which is indicative of poor coaching. When Stanford kicks the Fightless Irish around like a soccer ball, maybe ND will realize that going to a bowl game for money and another televised beat down might not be worth it in terms of HS recruiting. "Whine, Whine For Old Notre Dame..." MUUUHAHAHAHAHAH!
  23. Michael M
    232. Posted by Michael M Sun Nov 15 5:02pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Charley recruits well and is a great O co-ordinator. And he loves ND. Keep him on in these capacities.

    But, Big Cha can not be head coach

    He fails to win
    He fails to inspire
    He fails to coach D at all
    He mismanages clock, even on O (USC endgame, Pitt last 2 min 3q and Mich all 4th qtr)
    He fails to get top flight assistance.
    He fails to win
    He fails to win and
    He fails to win
  24. Mr College Football
    231. Posted by Mr College Football Sun Nov 15 4:53pm EST

    Report Abuse

    If you want to send a message to administration that you've had your fill of Weiss, then sell your ticket (if you can) to the folks at Connecticut. When the stands are filled with as many or more Huskie fans the administration will move quickly.

    Imagine as the NBC cameras pan the crowd and the stadium that usually is filled with Irish green has as much or more Connecticut blue.

    I guarantee you'll get results or your money back!
  25. Angry Dad
    230. Posted by Angry Dad Sun Nov 15 4:44pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Sometimes to get something fixed, it has to be totally demolshed I hope that the Irish don't win another game this year, not because I dislike them, but because they need some repair work. Charlie Weiss needs to be replaced, and if the alumni and boosters get sick enough of him, then they will send him packing, Batter Luck next year, Irish. GO GATORS!!!
Sign in to post a comment, or sign up for a free account

No upset!

85%
of College Pick’em users chose Pittsburgh to win the game

Did the Yahoo! Sports Experts make the right picks?

Top Performers

 Top Performers
 Notre Dame
J. Clausen J. Clausen, QB
27-42, 283 yds
1 TD, 1 INT
7 Rush, -9 yd, 1 TD
 Pittsburgh
D. Lewis D. Lewis, RB
21 Rush, 152 yds
1 TD

Conference Scoreboard

NCAAF - Week 11