Winners and losers: Irish make a habit of failure

  • Print

Look at Notre Dame, huddled on the shadowy fringe of irrelevance.

The Fighting Irish have become a national punch line with each successive defeat. The latest kick in the gut: falling 33-30 to Connecticut on “Senior Day” under the Golden Dome.

It was a familiar story line in South Bend, as Notre Dame’s defense was run over. UConn rushed for 231 yards, averaging 4.8 yards per carry.

Don’t out all the blame on coordinator Jon Tenuta. This is an Irish defense that lacks athletic ability and playmakers.

Hey, who are we kidding? It’s an Irish program that’s lacking a lot of things, including a competent head coach.

Too bad ND isn’t coached by the Huskies’ Randy Edsall. There’s no way Notre Dame and its wealth of built-in advantages ever should lose at home to UConn. The school is in its first decade as a FBS program and came in near the bottom of the Big East.

Making this win even sweeter for UConn is that it was quarterbacked by a Notre Dame castoff, Zach Frazer, who took off for UConn after losing a four-man race in the spring of 2007 to become the Irish starter.

UConn limped into this game with four successive losses since the stabbing death of cornerback Jasper Howard.

” ‘Jazz,’ this is for you,” Edsall said, referring to Howard by his nickname. “Best win we have ever had.”

This may be the worst loss Charlie Weis ever has had, given what was on the line. But the way the defeats have been stacking up the past three seasons, it’s hard to pick an all-time clunker. How about the Navy loss in 2007? Or what about the Syracuse embarrassment last season on “Senior Day?”

Next up: A trip to Stanford, which may be the hottest team in college football. How badly do you think Cardinal coach Jim Harbaugh will pile on the Irish?

It would be only fitting for Weis to leave Notre Dame in a blaze of defeat. Any shred of hope Weis had of retaining his job has washed away. In fact, this will be the easiest decision Notre Dame athletic director Jack Swarbrick will make during his tenure. It also will be an expensive one, as reports have put Weis’ buyout as high as $18 million.

Quarterback Jimmy Clausen and wide receiver Golden Tate also may exit South Bend by turning pro a year early

Notre Dame is 6-5 and this loss makes Weis 35-26 in his five-season tenure, a .573 winning percentage that’s worse than predecessors Tyrone Willingham and Bob Davie.

Now, the speculation on who will take over will hit overdrive. The ideal candidate would be an established coach who has proven success. He also ideally would have a defensive background. The coaches who best fit that profile: Oklahoma’s Bob Stoops and TCU’s Gary Patterson. Others who may be hot are Cincinnati’s Brian Kelly and Northwestern’s Pat Fitzgerald.

The winner of the job needs to know this: Notre Dame never may be a consistent relevant national power again.

With that, we say goodbye to Weis. You never will be forgotten.

Winners

Alabama/Florida: Let’s lump these teams together after each played a glorified exhibition. Alabama beat Chattanooga 45-0 and Florida routed Florida International 62-3 to set up games next weekend against their archrivals: Alabama at Auburn and Florida playing host to Florida State.

Clemson: It took Dabo Swinney one year to do what Tommy Bowden never did—get the Tigers to the ACC title game. Clemson’s 34-21 win over Virginia sets up an ACC title game matchup with Georgia Tech. Tech won an earlier meeting this season, 30-27. Swinney turned 40 on Friday.

Iowa: A 12-0 win over Minnesota makes the Hawkeyes 10-2 and keeps them in line for an at-large BCS bowl slot.

Florida State: It took some last-second heroics, but the Seminoles toppled Maryland 29-26 to become bowl eligible for the 28th consecutive season.

Missouri: The Tigers finally ended a three-game home losing streak by beating Iowa State 34-24. Mizzou wide receiver Danario Alexander is on fire; he has 34 receptions for 578 yards and five TDs in the past three games.

Northwestern: The Wildcats’ season got even better with a 33-31 upset of Wisconsin ; it was Northwestern’s third victory in a row and gave it an 8-4 regular-season record. Wouldn’t Pat Fitzgerald look good under the Golden Dome?

Penn State: Many experts think the Big Ten will get an at-large BCS bid, and it will come down to Penn State and Iowa. The Nittany Lions’ 42-14 demolition of Michigan State could swing the verdict in their favor.

Ohio State: Jim Tressel improved to 8-1 against Michigan with a 21-10 triumph in Ann Arbor. The Buckeyes have won six in a row in the series, matching the best streak in the rivalry since Michigan won six in succession in the 1920s.

Ole Miss: A 25-23 win over LSU is the latest bright spot for a Rebels program that is rebounding to have a nice season after some early-season struggles. That’s five wins in their past six games for Ole Miss, which may be playing in Orlando in the Capital One Bowl on New Year’s Day.

TCU: So much for a hangover following the Utah game. The Horned Frogs ripped Wyoming 45-10 to move to 11-0 for the first time in 71 years and remain in good shape for a BCS bowl bid—and one crazy upset from maybe playing for the national title.

Texas Tech: The Red Raiders became bowl eligible for the 16th consecutive season and Mike Leach became the school’s winningest coach—and it all happened in a resounding 41-13 romp over Oklahoma.

UCLA: A 23-13 win over Arizona State made the Bruins bowl eligible in Rick Neuheisel’s second season. Credit the defense, which forced six turnovers and scored two touchdowns.

USF: Redshirt freshman B.J. Daniels became the first quarterback in school history to pass for 300 (304) and rush for 100 (104) yards in the same game in leading the Bulls to a tough 34-22 victory over Louisville. USF became bowl eligible with the win.

Losers

Arizona State: A 23-13 loss to UCLA was the fifth in a row for the Sun Devils. ASU has averaged 15 points during the losing streak, and the loss means coach Dennis Erickson will have back-to-back losing seasons for the first time in his career as a college coach.

Louisville: A 34-22 loss at USF was the Cardinals’ ninth road defeat in a row and guaranteed them a second consecutive losing season.

LSU: What on God’s green earth was Les Miles thinking? Get that field-goal team on the field ASAP! Too late, as LSU lost 25-23 at Ole Miss, hurting the Tigers’ bowl positioning.

Maryland: A heartbreaking 29-26 loss at Florida State was the Terrapins’ sixth defeat in a row and dropped them to 2-9.

Michigan: Poor Tate Forcier. He tossed four picks and saw his fumble in the end zone recovered for a score in a 21-10 loss to Ohio State. U-M will finish 5-7. The Wolverines now have suffered back-to-back losing seasons for the first time since 1962-63.

Oklahoma: A bad season became much worse in a 41-13 loss at Texas Tech. The five losses are OU’s most since going 7-5 in 1999. With a home game left against Oklahoma State, the Sooners may be staring at a 6-6 record.

Rutgers: Last week, the Scarlet Knights whipped USF 31-0. This week, they were was hammered 31-13 by Syracuse. Don’t try to figure it out.

Wisconsin: Any faint hope the Badgers had for a BCS bid is over after a 33-31 loss at Northwestern.

Tom Dienhart is the national senior writer for Rivals.com. He can be reached at dienhart@yahoo-inc.com.

[rl]

Tom Dienhart is the national senior college football writer for Rivals.com. He can be reached at dienhart@yahoo-inc.com.
Updated Nov 21, 8:18 pm EST
digg del.icio.us
more

9 Comments

  • 0 users liked this comment Please sign in to rate this comment up. Please sign in to rate this comment down. 0 users disliked this comment
    Thomas M Sun Nov 22, 2009 03:12 pm PST Report Abuse
    I seriously don't understand how Texas can go to the national championship in baseball, most likely go to the national championship in football, and quite possibly go to the final four in basketball this year, and they can't get any national coverage. I call bias reporting.
  • 0 users liked this comment Please sign in to rate this comment up. Please sign in to rate this comment down. 0 users disliked this comment
    Thomas M Sun Nov 22, 2009 03:09 pm PST Report Abuse
    Guess Texas didn't win this week. Guess Texas never plays because they get no national coverage. How shocked will you be when Texas wins the national championship?
  • 0 users liked this comment Please sign in to rate this comment up. Please sign in to rate this comment down. 0 users disliked this comment
    Disappointed Mom Sun Nov 22, 2009 02:10 pm PST Report Abuse
    @6. Not dissing the teams, but the bad reporting. Just really saying that Colt was a very relevant winner that was missed in the article this week.
  • 0 users liked this comment Please sign in to rate this comment up. Please sign in to rate this comment down. 0 users disliked this comment
    tomas Sun Nov 22, 2009 11:48 am PST Report Abuse
    NCAA history was made yesterday when a quarterback scored the 43rd victory of his career, his team secured the division title and set itself up for the conference championship game, and no mention of it is made in this column that purports to be about winners and losers. Had you covered this headline story, you might have pointed out that simple arithmetic indicates that this number of victories will be difficult for another quarterback to beat and has a good chance to stand for awhile.

    Florida and Alabama, on the other hand, played easy nonconference games and are listed first among the winners.

    Thank you for the thorough and unbiased coverage. You don't really have a vote in the polls, do you? If you do, please reference the overwhelming number of comments registered by the public throughout the season regarding the nonsensical nature of these polls.
  • 0 users liked this comment Please sign in to rate this comment up. Please sign in to rate this comment down. 0 users disliked this comment
    Disappointed Mom Sun Nov 22, 2009 10:49 am PST Report Abuse
    Long time reader. Shocked that you mention Florida/Alabama exhibition games as winners, but no mention of Colt McCoy breaking the NCAA record for most wins by a quarterback.
  • 0 users liked this comment Please sign in to rate this comment up. Please sign in to rate this comment down. 0 users disliked this comment
    Dan Sun Nov 22, 2009 07:08 am PST Report Abuse
    "Look at Notre Dame, huddled on the shadowy fringe of irrelevance."

    It's difficult to understand that comment until you realize who is writing it. Notre Dame has one of the largest fanbases in the country. They were ranked in the top 15 this season, almost beat USC, and have a perennial drawing-power in recruitment. Yes, they have under-performed, and today is yet another example of them not playing to the potential that they have. But what is with all the schaudenfraude from a guy who is supposed to be the senior college football writer at a major online sports website? You sound a little like a pimply weasel of a schoolyard bully ("Look at ND...")

    Mr. Dienhart, could you at least pretend to be a professional sportswriter so it's a little less obvious how badly you hate a) Charlie Weis and b) Notre Dame? Try to be at least a little professional and show a little less bias. We all know when you write a column on the Irish that it's going to be just more vitriol and spittle.

    You never may be a meaningful sportwriter until you learn about having a little class.
  • 0 users liked this comment Please sign in to rate this comment up. Please sign in to rate this comment down. 0 users disliked this comment
    Dr. Evil Sun Nov 22, 2009 06:33 am PST Report Abuse
    Why is the nation fixed on the coaching situation at Notre Dame. He at least is winning. There is only coach that is on the hot seat and it is Louisville's Kragethrop. He takes over a team that was among the elite in the country, and one that should have been playing for the national championship in 2006, not Florida, and had gone to being the national disgrace and joke. I want to know why no sport reporter is not covering the real story instead of going after coaches at Notre Dame and Texas A&M for examples. Why is it no big deal that Louisville Cardinal football is at the bottom of the hill. WE ARE NOT JUST A BASKETBALL UNIVERSITY! WE ARE BUILDING TO BE THE SPORT UNIVERSITY AND NOT A BASKETBALL UNIVERSITY LIKE THAT OTHER INSTITUTION THAT IS 90 MILES EAST OF U OF L! We are making strides in all college sports. YES, we are known for our basketball, but we also want to be know in all sports and when a couple of years ago we were going to to the step of being an elite to fall to the outhouse that should be NATIONAL NEWS. I question the sport reporters who treat real issue as irrelevant and going after trival issues as nation news.

Post a Comment

Sign in to post a comment, or Sign up for a free account.

Video Spotlight