Dr. Saturday - NCAAF

Join the Doc's game day live blog, covering every game all day long.

Tennessee 45, Georgia 19. Here comes the dramatic understatement of the season so far. Okay, are you ready? Okay: Jonathan Crompton had the best game of his career.

Now for the appropriately-calibrated statement: Say what? To put Crompton's 310-yard, four-touchdown day against one of the SEC's (and therefore one of the nation's) most talented defenses, some perspective: Before last week's fourth-quarter rally against Auburn, Crompton had never topped 200 yards passing against an SEC defense; that was also the first time he'd thrown multiple touchdown passes (two) in a conference game. For his career, Crompton had completed slightly fewer than half his passes against SEC opponents, with more interceptions (8) than touchdowns (7) and a dismal 99.5 efficiency rating to solidify his name as the one most synonymous with contemporary college quarterbacking failure. His efficiency rating today? Two-hundred twelve, and that's with a Georgia interception return for touchdown off a flubbed reception that wasn't really the quarterback's fault.

There's a dissonance there that I don't really know how to address. On one hand, the implications of a competent Crompton on Tennessee's offense are colossal: The Vols were already pounding out a viable running game behind Montario Hardesty and Bryce Brown with no threat from the passing game at all -- against Auburn, Crompton was occasionally hitting surprised receivers in the side of the helmet. This kind of break-neck turnaround, off a season-and-a-half of nonstop futility from the quarterbacks, is jarring and totally alters the perception of Tennessee's offense as a paleolithic attack that can only succeed when it keeps the ball between the tackles -- and when the defense keeps it close enough to keep the running game viable.

On the other hand, it's tempting to lay the sudden Vol explosion at the feet of the Georgia defense, which has already been gutted twice in league play -- for 427 yards and 37 points by South Carolina and 485 yards and 41 points by Arkansas -- and couldn't keep LSU's nondescript attack from rallying for a couple late touchdowns to win last week. Without the offense's response against the Gamecocks and Razorbacks, UGA would have been in dire straits ages ago, and the offense wasn't there at all today. Let's just call it here: Those dismal stat rankings weren't just the result of playing real offenses every week. Georgia's defense is legitimately bad.

And so you have two teams in the same division, with the same overall record and a pair of conference losses apiece at midseason, but staring at the second half in starkly different terms: Tennessee has its best win in almost two years, the first signature victory of the Kiffin era, and is just six combined points against UCLA and Auburn from being 5-1 instead of 3-3; Georgia has lost two in a row, isn't good at anything outside of throwing the ball up to A.J. Green and is a combined seven points against South Carolina and Arizona State from being 1-5 instead of 3-3.

Meanwhile, South Carolina won another nailbiter and actually is 5-1. Behind Florida, the script in the SEC East has completely flipped.

digg delicious
more

8 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. david b
    1. Posted by david b Sat Oct 10, 2009 5:17 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Nice game from Crompton, but no, come on, Auburn is not one of the better defenses in the country. They're 85th in the country in points allowed, which puts them well into the bottom third. How the hell do you figure them for one of the best defenses in the country? Wait, you are a college football writer?
  2. david b
    2. Posted by david b Sat Oct 10, 2009 5:22 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Oops, wrong blog, sorry. I gut confused on who I was refuting since I was just reading a tout site that was hyping Auburn's defense. Yes, you're right, Georgia has a great defense, but the most important thing to take from this is how bad it makes LSU's offense look after last week's game. Their chances of scoring double digits at home against Florida tonight are very, very low. Bet the under.
  3. jsc
    3. Posted by jsc Sat Oct 10, 2009 8:29 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Including an awful performance from Danny Sullivan of ASU and a rather pedestrian performance from Zac Robinson, here are the stats that opposing QBs have posted against UGA:
    Comp - Att - Yards - Comp % - Y/A - Sacked - Loss - TD - INTs
    111 200 1494 55.5 7.47 11 69 14 4
    249 Y/G
    Without Sullivan the Comp% is: 60.1
    This doesn't include rushing stats which Garcia and other probably had some yardage.
    I don't know how to calculate QB Rating, but I am guessing this would be in the top 20 for college football.
  4. david b
    4. Posted by david b Sat Oct 10, 2009 9:05 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Wow, I suppose I didn't miss by much when I was talking about Auburn's D instead of Georgia's. The fact is that some SEC teams like LSU and Alabama have great defenses, and Georgia has an average one, but assuming that any team in the SEC has one of the best D's in the country by default is ridiculous.
  5. cheatypants mcsweatervest
    5. Posted by cheatypants mcsweatervest Sat Oct 10, 2009 9:33 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    It really wasn't hard to predict that Crompton was likely to have his best game of the year against this Georgia defense. Willie Martinez doesn't make logical adjustments and doesn't put his players in a position to succeed. Add to that a bunch of missed tackles and an offense that was going in reverse all day, and it's time for the Dawgs to have a come-to-Jesus meeting.
  6. conor b
    6. Posted by conor b Sat Oct 10, 2009 10:25 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    "To put Crompton's 310-yard, four-touchdown day against one of the SEC's (and therefore one of the nation's) most talented defenses," ... I hope this is sarcastic inference. if not, what do you base that on Matt? On that convincing win that LSU had over UW? Or on Florida's smothering of their local highschool.? Hmmm. I would enjoy watching any SEC offense against a PAC 10 or Big 12....Or even Big 10 defense.
  7. atlfan30605
    7. Posted by atlfan30605 Sun Oct 11, 2009 12:33 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    UGA quit in that game and the coaches are to blame
  8. atlfan30605
    8. Posted by atlfan30605 Sun Oct 11, 2009 1:20 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    ok conor i can go with you on the big 12 but where do you get that the pac or big 10 have any D at all? I vote UGA the most under performing team of the decade. They recruit well and too have so many talented players and be embarrassed like that is disgraceful, but i vote USC in second as a under performing team and ohio state is overrated every year. The SEC has D the big 12 has O do you even watch college football? you must be a fair weather fan...

Dr. Saturday

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Matt Hinton

Dr. Saturday is a college football blog edited by Matt Hinton. Email him tips and feedback.

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Dr. Saturday Recent Readers