Dr. Saturday - NCAAF

Another sign of the mercenary times in the SEC: One of the byproducts of Georgia's sudden swoon, and the accompanying realization after Saturday's debacle at Tennessee that the Bulldogs are probably en route to their worst season in more than a decade, has been a rapid reassessment of Mark Richt, heretofore on track to become the most successful coach in school history. That was two weeks ago, when UGA was still in the polls at 3-1; a pair of hard-to-swallow losses later, Dawg partisans are beginning to hear the ghosts of a couple recently departed, championship coaches dragging their chains through the foyer.

And frankly, they don't have much choice: Everyone recognizes that Richt's glittering resumé to date is great, and dutifully rejects any premature "hot seat" talk. But the fact in the modern SEC, as proven by the rapid descents of Philip Fulmer at Tennessee and Tommy Tuberville last year -- both summarily dismissed for hitting bottom after periods of relative stagnation, at the same time that cold, calculating counterparts Urban Meyer and Nick Saban executed nearly instant turnarounds at rivals Florida and Alabama -- is that the ax can come down with the slightest provocation, for which allowing 300-plus yards and four touchdowns to Jonathan Crompton clearly qualifies.

With Georgia now destined for also-ran status in the East for the fourth year in a row, the parallels are becoming a little too obvious to ignore for UGA blogger (and Doc Sat regular) Doug Gillett, who cast Richt as the next Tuberville on Tuesday, just ahead of columnist Mark Wiedmer's vision of Richt as Fulmer-in-waiting for the Chattanooga Times Free Press:

In Phillip Fulmer’s first full seven seasons as Tennessee’s head football coach, the Volunteers won 72 games and a national championship and posted five years with 10 or more wins. In Mark Richt’s first seven seasons at Georgia, the Bulldogs won 72 games, finished second nationally one year, wound up third nationally another and won 10 or more games five times. We all know how Fulmer’s career ended. Is Richt headed for the same sad fate with Georgia somewhere down the road?
[...]
None of this will cost him his job this season, nor should it. But to coach beyond 2010, Richt needs to end his comparisons with Fulmer’s tenure now, when such numbers are still cause for congrats rather than concern.

Of course it won't cost Richt his job this season; that would be ridiculous. The coordinators come first, beginning with much-maligned defensive coordinator Willie Martinez, and possibly continuing with offensive coordinator (and former UGA quarterback) Mike Bobo if necessary. But if those changes don't produce an immediate turnaround, the implication is clear: Those three division titles (and two SEC titles, off a 20-year championship drought) in four years from 2002-05 aren't going to carry much goodwill when the disappointments of 2006, 2008 and now, apparently, 2009 are much fresher in everyone's mind. Stockholders in the program (emotional and otherwise) demand consistent returns, and evidence that the very well-compensated CEO is stopping at nothing to ensure them.

For now, the head of a coordinator or two will give them that; we'll see where the stock goes from there. But make no mistake: On the heels of Fulmer and Tuberville, the fact that this discussion even exists for a coach as wildly successful as Richt is as good an indicator as any that we'll be having it at some point about every coach at one of the league's heavier hitters for many, many years into the future, without exception. With the kind of money departments are throwing at them and thus expecting in return via BCS bids, ticket sales and ever-richer TV contracts, they can't afford not to have it when things start looking a little stale. If it's a cutthroat, mercenary environment the SEC wanted, brother, they've got it.

digg delicious
more

10 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. Robert C
    1. Posted by Robert C Wed Oct 14, 2009 3:48 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I am not a Georgia fan, but I am a Richt fan.
    This article is right on about not firing now, but giving him a bit more time to make the required adjustments. After that Voluntary beat down...someone should have cleaned out their desk already. But not Mark.
    Who knows...maybe they turn it around and beat Florida. I wouldn't bet on it, but I would not be totally shocked either.
  2. PHUC NUTT/as in houston
    2. Posted by PHUC NUTT/as in houston Wed Oct 14, 2009 4:24 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    WHAT DID I SAY YESTERDAY !!!!!!!!!!!! BWAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA how you love that Kev Oh huh ? they put your Georgia program on point today Kev Oh. ahhhhhhh life is good finally somebody is finally telling Georgia their not as good as everyone alway's want's to make them out to be. the kool - aid taste good til it run's out (OR THE SPACESHIP COME'S TO TAKE YOU AWAY GUESS THAT DIDN'T WORK OUT HUH ?) every damn year we all have to listen to it, every year for some inexplicable reason everyone coast to coast give's the assumption Georgia is more deserving than someone else, and every year you fail. every GOD - DAMN year. well guess what just because everyone tell's you how talented you are doesn't mean you are. shocking isn't it ? your middle of the pack face it. oh how it must burn your asses. secret's out Georgia.
    and i think richt is one hell of a person, & coach, everyone does. my beef is that poll's should come out after the first couple of week's to gauge strength's, & weaknesses, then have a fair, & accurate top 25.
  3. K
    3. Posted by K Wed Oct 14, 2009 4:45 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    First off there needs to be a wholesale change of the assistants at the end of the season. Richt's success really came at a time when the league was down. Coaching changes at UF,AU and Carolina and now he appears behind the eight ball. After he makes the changes we will see how UGA adjusts. If he refuses to change then send him packing.
  4. ess-eee-seee
    4. Posted by ess-eee-seee Wed Oct 14, 2009 4:47 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    That final link to the picture of the Kiffins and the Orgeron still makes me laugh. It will remain funny unless or until he beats my team.
  5. falconfan
    5. Posted by falconfan Wed Oct 14, 2009 7:15 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    #2 you really don`t have to listen to how good everyone thinks Ga. is going to be every year.It seems like everyone thinks Ga is going to be good and you just hope they suck. Anything to take your mind off how shi#@y your team is. If you don`t want to hear about Ga., then they on a blog about your own team. Oh, thats right, there is no site for your team because no one is interested in talking about them. Ga. can`t control what the pollsters ans writers say every year, all we can do is try to play at that level. Uh-oh, I mispelled a word. That`s probably cause i`m from Ga., right?
  6. jo mama
    6. Posted by jo mama Wed Oct 14, 2009 10:11 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    please come back to fsu
  7. D.N. Nation
    7. Posted by D.N. Nation Thu Oct 15, 2009 2:24 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    "With Georgia now destined for also-ran status in the East for the fourth year in a row"
    11-2, #2 in the nation, and bypassed for the national championship game off of unwritten rules (ones apparently not applicable to Nebraska) qualifies as "also-ran"?
  8. PHUC NUTT/as in houston
    8. Posted by PHUC NUTT/as in houston Thu Oct 15, 2009 10:57 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Ga. can`t control what the pollsters ans writers say every year, all we can do is try to play at that level.
    WHAT LEVEL WOULD THAT BE ? look's to me your playing @ the same level for a couple of decade's
  9. PHUC NUTT/as in houston
    9. Posted by PHUC NUTT/as in houston Thu Oct 15, 2009 11:05 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    it's kinda like dangling a carrot in front of you isn't it ? national magazine's you keeed you keeed..........
    STOP TEASING GEORGIA
  10. Kevin
    10. Posted by Kevin Thu Oct 15, 2009 12:25 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    You're a moron man.
    Georgia is the only school in the SEC that is going out of thier way to schedule against good OOC opponents Oklahoma St., Arizona St., Boise St. just to name a few. Then come back and play Florida, every other year LSU, and we all know each year there's more than them in the SEC that look great, Bama, Auburn, Tennessee, South Carolina, last year Vandy played big in their big games. And they have been the most consistantly good team in the SEC the past decade. They might not be the best in the nation but they are the most consistant. Why are you dangling on the Dawgs nuts because you sound envious. Get off our nuts loser.

Dr. Saturday

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Matt Hinton

Dr. Saturday is a college football blog edited by Matt Hinton. Email him tips and feedback.

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Dr. Saturday Recent Readers