Dr. Saturday - NCAAF

As far as preseason expectations go, losing Percy Harvin to the draft probably doesn't change anything for Florida: The second Tim Tebow sent the Swamp into apoplexy by announcing His Return, the Gators were locked in at the top of this summer's preseason polls. It helps that Brandon Spikes will be back, meaning UF will be returning every single member of the defensive two-deep from last week's mythical championship win, pending academics and offseason shenanigans. The Gators are still stacked.

Of all Florida's weapons, though, none have been remotely as versatile as Harvin, whose career rushing (1,852 yards) and receiving (1,929) numbers are almost identical, and whose consistency as a big play threat is unmatched anywhere in the country: For his career, Harvin had 14 games in which he broke a 15-yard run and hauled in a 15-yard reception, and did one or the other 34 of the 36 times he stepped on the field.

Harvin's role in Urban Meyer's offense was unique, and they were so perfectly suited for one another. Meyer has plenty of blazers who can run, and plenty more who can catch, but no one who's so lethal in both regards, from almost anywhere on the field. Even if UF has every reason to expect its 40-point barrages to continue behind Tebow and his band or merry speedsters, corks should be popping in defensive meeting rooms across the South by coaches who don't have to "prepare" for this guy anymore, as if they could to begin with. The only things that ever really stopped Harvin were his own ankle and hamstring, which just aren't evolved to handle that much torque.

Here's another really scary thought re: Florida's speed: C.J. Spiller's family urged him to commit to the Gators out of high school, and he was close to transferring after his first semester at Clemson. The place has obviously grown on him: The electric all-purpose demon will be back for his senior season, ignoring his mother again ($) and passing up a likely first round grade to have the Tiger backfield all to himself for the first time.

Spiller's return is a surprise, but maybe it shouldn't be: Even in the midst of Clemson's fall from preseason grace and midseason coaching change, this was his best year, and he exploded -- five games over 180 all-purpose yards in the last six -- after Dabo Swinney was promoted to the interim job in place of Tommy Bowden. Spiller said he was coming back if Swinney took over full-time, and he's honoring that commitment, even when nobody really expected him to.

Plus, we're still waiting for him to top this:

In other early entry news, Ohio State cornerback Donald Washington is joining the parade of early exits, but Ole Miss defensive end Greg Hardy has bucked earlier reports that he'd be leaving school and will be back with the Rebels instead, on what should be another pretty solid outfit in Oxford.

digg delicious
more

13 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. Carl V
    1. Posted by Carl V Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:03 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    As a gator, it is sad to see Percy Harvin go, but it's clearly in his best interest. He's been so injury prone, and as a running back has such a limited 'shelf life', jumping to the NFL while his draft stock is high and is reasonably healthy (Sure, he has a broken ankle, but Oklahoma still couldn't stop him. That's healthy enough. It should be healed by the combine, anyway.)
    Thanks for the memories, Percy. Good luck, and god speed (or is that slowing down, for Percy?)
  2. Barry Zuckerkorn
    2. Posted by Barry Zuckerkorn Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:39 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Harvin leaving for the NFL makes perfect sense. He will play immediately. His injury(s) this season leave no room for doubt. He needs to go make his money now. Harvin is one the more versatile players coming out. Best of luck to him.
  3. Barry Zuckerkorn
    3. Posted by Barry Zuckerkorn Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:39 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    By the way... Why wouldn't Tebow come back?!?! He has no chance of playing in the NFL the way he does now with Florida. After next season, there is a good chance Tebow will never be heard of again.
  4. just4funsies
    4. Posted by just4funsies Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:44 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Percy Harvin is a gamer. The things he put himself through to come through the various injuries, most of them to his stock in trade... his legs, were testimony to his heart, which will always be that of a Gator. He put the fans and his team before all else, so we can't begrudge him for going out to get some for himself. He's going out on top. I hope he can endure at the next level, because there are still many great plays left in him. I know he'll be rooting harder than anybody for his Gators to repeat next year.
  5. Joshgator
    5. Posted by Joshgator Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:41 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I am very sad to see Harvin go as he is one of the best receivers ever at UF (right up there with the likes of Chris Doering, Ike Hilliard, etc.). However, for him to stay at UF another year might have been too risky. He could have had a career ending injury or reaggravated his Achilles tendon injury. We will miss him next year, but with just about everyone else back for next year, I think the Gators will do fine next year (especially with Tebowand Spikes returning). Good luck, Percy... And thank you for amazing me withyour speed and agility for the last 3 years and for bringing home TWO National Championships!!!! Once a Gator...ALWAYS a Gator!!!
  6. Traci
    6. Posted by Traci Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:19 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Cj Spiller is a darkhorse for the Heisman
  7. Jimmy Y
    7. Posted by Jimmy Y Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:56 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    As a gator fan C.J Spiller is going to battle for the heisman
  8. Rob
    8. Posted by Rob Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:55 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Andrew - three years ago, all Tebow did was come in for a few red zone plays and spell Chris Leak, two years ago, he ran and passed for the Heisman, this past year he threw better and had less picks than all the other QB's who got a vote in the Heisman race (and had the most 1st place votes). Who's to say he didn't come back for his senior year to work on his reads, his footwork and take more snaps from under center and become more of a typical "NFL" quarterback that the scouts love? You cannot fault his determination and I wouldn't bet against him. Everyone seems to forget about one of the most succesful NFL QB's of all time was not a typical "NFL" quarterback. Anyone remember Joe Montana? Weak arm, not so great footwork and a new style west coast offence that no one said would work. a couple of Super bowl rings and MVP awards later he's in the HoF. Who's to say some team doesn't pick him next year and try the spread offence in the NFL. Say someone like Detroit - let's face it, they can do any worse that this year; 0-16 can they?
  9. Ricco
    9. Posted by Ricco Thu Sep 03, 2009 2:47 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Spiller seems like a real quality guy. I hope he succeeds by staying at Clemson.
    Harvin will make it big in the NFL
  10. derrick
    10. Posted by derrick Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:50 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Andrew 5, are you really an idiot? There's a good chance that after this year Tim Tebow will never be heard of again? What? I don't think he's going to make that great of a pro qb. But he is one of the best college qb's of all time. He's a guaranteed top 10 pick whenever he goes pro. He has the size of a tight end in the NFL and he runs better than any of them. It's ok to be a Gator Hater. The world is full of them. But don't make yourself look silly in the meantime. Tebow will go to the NFL and he will be heard of again, probably not as a hall of fame qb but he will play.
  11. A.J.
    11. Posted by A.J. Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:40 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    spiller should touch the ball every third play at the very least
  12. cK
    12. Posted by cK Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:26 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Andrew 5........ sheesh! People talk smack about how good someone will be at the next level based on "expert" scouting reports. Same scouts that said take Tim Couch first (or how about Ryan leaf, Heath Shuler, Akili Smith, or Andre Ware....???) good calls! "Tebow's got good TE or FB size" so they then discount him as a QB! I don't get it??? Also remember a lot of folks sayin' the same thing about Big Ben back in the day as well - "too big, should be a TE."
    Nobody can truly assess somebody's heart and love for the game which almost always makes up for the undersized, not strong enough, not smart enough for the game. By the way - Tebow's got all three. Keep readin' you're "expert analysis" and spittin' out the same dribble! It only motivates folks and time will tell!
    BTW - you can google all the "busts" from the NFL / NBA and whatever other sport to try and get some further insight. For even a little more free football analysis 101 Andrew 5 - google the best undrafted players that all the "experts" missed - totally!
    Now stop bloggin' when you're smokin' crack - makes you sound like you don't know what you're talkin' about!
  13. nineiron
    13. Posted by nineiron Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:39 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Andrew you are an idiot. Tim Tebow will be heard of after next season. He will go to the NFL and play, maybe not as a qb, but he will definitely play and be good at it.

Dr. Saturday

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Matt Hinton

Dr. Saturday is a college football blog edited by Matt Hinton. Email him tips and feedback.

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Dr. Saturday Recent Readers