Dr. Saturday - NCAAF

I let this go yesterday, having already nodded to Mike Leach's refreshingly unprofessional tirade against Eric Mangini, which the Cap'n may or may not have fabricated out of thin (or or nearly thin) air. And as targets go, Stephen McGee, frankly, is low-hanging fruit for Leach, whose teams were 4-0 against Texas A&M during McGee's tenure, by an average margin of 22 points, and 2-0 against McGee as a starter. When Texas Tech traveled to College Station for a 43-25 win last year, McGee, a senior, was planted on the bench in favor of sophomore Jerrod Johnson for all but one pass. So when the Cap'n decided to sarcastically diss the pros for drafting McGee in the fourth round while allowing prolific Leach protegé Graham Harrell fall out of the draft completely --

"I'm happy for Stephen McGee," Texas Tech coach Mike Leach said. "The Dallas Cowboys like him more than his coaches at A&M did."

-- it struck me mainly as, you know, accurate. McGee spent the vast majority of his only season under Mike Sherman sitting behind the promising but very erratic Johnson, who started nine of the last 11 games between the opening loss to Arkansas State and the closing loss at Texas.

But it shouldn't be a surprise that Sherman doesn't necessarily see it that way. And -- unlike Mangini, who spends 22 hours a day watching game film in a high-tech cave burrowed into a seaside cliff in southern Maine, nourished by antioxidant-enriched intravenous sludge -- he proved willing today to defend his quarterback's besmirched honor, which is kinda what Leach was trying to do in the first place:

"I don't understand Coach Leach's comments about Stephen McGee," Sherman said Monday. "He was named our starter until he got injured. I've always believed in Stephen's character and I've always believed in his talent, and I always will. I see him having an outstanding NFL career.

"Coach Leach is in no position to comment about my relationship with Stephen McGee."

Not to put too fine a point on it, but this seems more accurate: McGee, emerging from two mostly fruitless years as the primary runner in Dennis Franchione's option-based scheme, promptly injured his throwing shoulder early in the second game last year, at New Mexico, and re-injured it three weeks later against Army. Whether or not it accounted for his entire absence -- Aggie partisans were clamoring louder than ever for Johnson after the horrific start, and McGee's return to the lineup coincided with Johnson's four-interception meltdown in the humiliating blowout loss at Baylor -- the shoulder injury was well-chronicled. (As for Sherman's opinion of his quarterback's pro prospects, the effusive praise he offered to A&M's official game notes prior to the Texas game, in which the hilariously hot-headed QB was hounded and hit often in a 40-point TAMU loss, are a good record to have in this sort of argument.)

Still, if Leach's facts miss the mark, the general tenor of his smack is right on target -- I, for one, would really like to know the answer to this rhetorical question:

"There's been far more rhetoric around this than I ever would have expected," Leach said. ... "But based on all the fuss and commotion on this, I can’t help but wonder what round Coach Sherman would’ve drafted Stephen McGee, given the fact he was once a head coach in the NFL."

Every now and then -- not very often, but occasionally -- honesty can trump facts. (Although, when it does, the lawyer is usually on the other side.)

digg delicious
more

12 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. settes0
    1. Posted by settes0 Tue Apr 28, 2009 3:55 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Who cares about two career backups at best? This is like two girls getting into a pissing contest
  2. mikez34
    2. Posted by mikez34 Tue Apr 28, 2009 3:57 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    This isn't honest, it's just Leach running his mouth. I like the guy as a coach, but he needs to shut his mouth about things tha don't concern him. Harrell (or any of the other QB's he has coached) may have thrown for 5,000,000 yards in college, but that does not mean he will translate to the NFL! It's not a slight on Leach, it just is the way it is. The McGee thing is just sour grapes.
  3. Jay Mac
    3. Posted by Jay Mac Tue Apr 28, 2009 4:10 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Leach seems like a big fat hippo
  4. Phil M
    4. Posted by Phil M Tue Apr 28, 2009 4:23 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    It is strange that an incredibly accurate passer that has enough zip on the ball to get it 2/3 of the way down a field didn't even have a flyer taken on him.
    Look at Brady, Romo, DelHomme, Garcia, etc. These NFL scouts go for the "image" and fail more times than not.
    Akili Smith, Ryan Leaf, Tim Couch, Drunkenmiller, etc were all "NFL arms" and where are they now?
  5. rick gill on sports
    5. Posted by rick gill on sports Tue Apr 28, 2009 4:38 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Let's not forget about guys like Joey Harrington or even Jeff George. Say what you want about George(big arm),
    but both were major disappointments.
  6. JohnC
    6. Posted by JohnC Tue Apr 28, 2009 6:56 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    College football has seen a million Graham Harrells. And he is a SYSTEM QUARTERBACK! They dump the ball off to some guy three yards downfield and he runs twenty yards withn it and the QB gets credit for a twenty three yard completion. They need to subtract YAC from the completion and give QB's the yardage at the point of the reception. If they did that could you Imagine what Phil Simms career stats would look like!He probabley actually only passed for a couple thousand yards. But he managed to ride some bogus stats into the Hall of Fame. So don't give up Harrell, there is always Arena Football!
  7. JohnS
    7. Posted by JohnS Wed Apr 29, 2009 12:11 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    If you follow Aggie football:
    1. I feel your pain: a once proud program on a steep decline. Here's hoping we Ags have brighter tomorrow's
    2. Sherman was a very vocal McGee fan. He seemed to very much want to get McGee into games, but the shoulder injury kept holding McGee back. He was always very positive on McGee's draft prospects.
  8. 4.0 Point Stance
    8. Posted by 4.0 Point Stance Wed Apr 29, 2009 2:52 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I read this as an insult not to McGee, or even to the Cowboys. It's an insult to Mike Sherman, who is a mediocre and unoriginal coach who has spent his entire time at aTm trying to fit square pegs into round holes.
    For what it's worth I've always thought McGee was a better quarterback than he was given credit for. For that matter, so was Harrell - say "system QB" all you want but Harrell is certainly a more talented all around quarterback than, say, Kliff Klingsbury. And I do understand Leach's frustration that NFL coaches won't take a chance on his quarterbacks because they don't think they can take a 3 and5 step drop. It's ludicrous.
  9. Matt
    9. Posted by Matt Wed Apr 29, 2009 2:54 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    ha, I'm waiting to see what Leach says when the Browns cut Harrell before pre-season games even start.....
  10. blindfusion
    10. Posted by blindfusion Wed Apr 29, 2009 6:05 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Leach is harsh, but he's right.
    Fran screwed over McGee trying to make someone who was recruited for his passing skills into a running-option QB because he saw McGee run fast. McGee never developed any passing skills in the read-option scheme.
    Sherman wanted to look forward with Jerrod Johnson instead of having a one-year starter in McGee.
    It's not a hack on A&M or Sherman, it's just saying that McGee got screwed when he was at A&M. Leach will go off and give his opinion when he's asked about it. Shocking, it's what he's always done. I know he's upset about Harrell. Harrell's an okay QB, but he can't play under center and he can be streaky. Still should get a shot in my opinon, and should have gotten drafted, although probably a very late pick.
  11. Joshgator
    11. Posted by Joshgator Sat May 02, 2009 2:02 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    7. Posted by Zachary K Tue Apr 28, 2009 10:38 pm EDT Report Abuse
    @ JohnC
    Yeah, any retard could just pick the most open receiver and get the ball through the defense to him (in a position that lets him gain extra YAC) seven out of ten times.
    Also, every [profane]ing quarterback everywhere is a SYSTEM QUARTERBACK. They all play in a system. Graham Harrell just happened to play in--and master--an absurdly prolific system.
    Zachary...While I agree with most of your comments, I completely disagree (and there are many others like me who disagree) with your last comment....that Harrell...master[ed] an absurdly prolific system. It has been stated repeatedly so I will not try to beat a dead horse, but the Tiny 12 has such outstanding offensive stats BECAUSE they have VERY POOR DEFENSES!!!!! He may have about 5 billion yards passing in the Tiny 12, but if Harrell played in the meat grinder of the SEC, he would be lucky to get 1500 yards passing in a 13-14 game season!!!!
  12. Joshgator
    12. Posted by Joshgator Sat May 02, 2009 2:10 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    To continue....All you have to do is look at Sam Bradford....won the Heisman (but didn't deserve it), had far more yards passing than Tim Tebow, and more highly regarded than Harrell, yet against Florida's defense, Bradford was shut down and OK only scored FOURTEEN points when they were AVERAGING 54 points a game and had scored more than 60 points a game in EACH of their last FIVE games prior to playing an actual defense. When they played an ACTUAL defense, they were STYMIED at EVERY turn. Why?!?!?! Because scoring all those points (and gaining all those yards) against inferior defenses proves NOTHING!!!! Doing the same thing against tough defenses...then that proves something!

Dr. Saturday

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Matt Hinton

Dr. Saturday is a college football blog edited by Matt Hinton. Email him tips and feedback.

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Dr. Saturday Recent Readers