Dr. Saturday - NCAAF

Here's the thing: I've grown up loving college football with an unfathomable passion. I do this every day, and I have a respectable mainstream audience here. And still, somehow, I sense there's something I'm fundamentally missing about a very, very large swath of college football fans. I base that perceived disconnect largely on the surprisingly long life of this travesty, for which I apologize in advance:

Again, apologies.

But I only bust out the Big 'N Rich to prove a point: Everything about that abominable production is an insult to college football fans, most of whom (from what I gather) hate it with a furious, unifying passion that very nearly transcends the many other intense hatreds that define the sport. Or at least it should be, and I thought it did, until confronted today by the latest in a long, long list of evidence that a) Where aesthetics are concerned, the consensus opinion of any large group of people always leads to horrible results, no matter their individual preferences, and b) The suits behind the ABC/ESPNiverse think college football fans are best attracted to the glow by generic redneck rockers. To be more specific, they've tabbed Kenny Chesney for the latest College Football on ABC/ESPN theme song:

The song, "This is Our Moment," captures the passion and dedication of the players to perform at the highest level each week with the understanding that every game counts. It will be used during game and studio telecasts and during promotions of upcoming programs and show elements across ABC, ESPN, ESPN2, ESPNU, ESPN360.com, ESPN Mobile TV and ESPN International. On select occasions, the song will be accompanied by a video montage of Chesney performing at a recent concert, along with college football highlights.

The song will reek and drive you slightly more insane with rage each time the first chords chime out of your speakers, which will be 50 billion times per season. I have haven't heard the song, and still I'm absolutely certain there is zero percent chance that anyone anywhere will find it tolerable over any period of time.

Well, OK, so make that a 50 percent chance, just based on demographics. I am also absolutely certain that this decision was market-researched to the ends of the solar system and it was scientifically determined that, yes, college football fans as a targetable consumer group are best defined as, um, non-pretentious sorts who -- if not as an actual majority, at least as a per capita consensus -- are prone to enjoying Kenny Chesney. Certainly more so than the suits who actually decided on the music, who probably like whatever quasi-obscure emo whimpering was on Grey's Anatomy last week, or the population at large, which is instead bombarded with Fall Out Boy or Green Day or some other homogenized punk act and clearly has no patience for another homogenized country act. Which is why Awful Announcing may be depressingly right when it says Chesney is "a brilliant move" from a marketing perspective, considering college football's locus of popularity in Red States, and particularly in the South. I don't know how "brilliant" any piece of bumper music could be in terms of gaining or especially retaining viewers -- "Whoa, Kenny Chesney, guess you know where to find me for the next three hours, baby doll" -- but it is probably a broad demographic match.

Yet it still mystifies me based on personal experience. I've lived my entire life in the South. I am so from the South I just met my first Canadian in June. Almost everyone I know is from the South, and I could not at this moment call, text or e-mail a single person whom I suspect of even potentially enjoying Kenny Chesney. I'd be a little bit surprised if I could go out on the street right now in the middle of Texas and yell for anyone who liked Kenny Chesney. The absolute worst thing I can possibly think to say about Tim Tebow is that he appears to be a Kenny Chesney fan.

Of course, the Child is not alone: Somehow I've lived my life mostly oblivious to the fact that (according to various returns from a search engine which shall not be named) Chesney has wooed huge movie stars; pitched major beer brands and who knows what else; won like a billion awards I've never heard of; sold out a huge percentage of his shows and sold something like 25 million albums in his career. That's about two-thirds of the total attendance for all college football games last year, and there's good reason to infer some substantial overlap in those two numbers -- enough, at least, to suggest that fully half of college football fans will probably support or at least be very comfortable with Kenny Chesney as the de facto Musical Voice of the Sport for the next three or four years, some of whom may be reading this blog and wondering where I get off acting like his intrinsic lameness is a scientific principle*. And the other half of us will spend the fall scurrying to change the channel before we're tempted to smash our televisions into 25 million pieces.

- - -
* Even though it is: Light travels faster than sound, every force has an equal and opposite reaction and Kenny Chesney's music is turrrrrrrrible.

digg delicious
more

27 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. Jmart
    1. Posted by Jmart Thu Aug 27, 2009 8:40 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Um bring the old one back pl0x.
  2. HawkeyeGirl
    2. Posted by HawkeyeGirl Thu Aug 27, 2009 8:59 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Good God, that was the most horrific piece of crap I've ever heard!! They do realize that there is LOTS of football played outside of the swamps in the Southeast, don't they?
    Look, I can't stand country music but I do realize it's a relatively popular genre in some areas. However, this is getting out of hand. I'm a Hawkeye, and I can promise you that 99.9% of Iowa would be offended by that honky-tonk travesty. And I currently live in Ohio and I guarantee that "Dem Buckeyes" are pretty pissed off about how they are portayed right about now.
    For the love of God, it's 2009! We have a black president!! Can we PLEASE get the racist redneck stereotypes out of this stupid Gameday promo?
  3. Nathan
    3. Posted by Nathan Thu Aug 27, 2009 9:24 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Back in the day, we didn't need some music group, craptacular or not, to intro our football. When I was growing up and first watching the sport (the mid to late 80's), nothing said "FOOTBALL" like the CBS intro. It still gives me chills to hear it. ESPN, quit "branding" and just give us an instrumental intro to associate with your product--FOOTBALL--and not with any other cross-branding. Does Chesney do Disney, or are we doomed to have Miley Cyrus as the next Gameday opening theme?
    At least the last schlock had "Cowboy Troy" as a token African-American element.
  4. cuauhtemoc_gutieruiz
    4. Posted by cuauhtemoc_gutieruiz Thu Aug 27, 2009 9:37 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    that was super gay. Almost makes me not want to watch college football.
  5. fountainmountaindew
    5. Posted by fountainmountaindew Thu Aug 27, 2009 9:48 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Amen, amen Dr. Saturday! Being another lifelong Southerner, I share your views unhesitatingly. The assumption that we will gladly submit to whatever unit-shifting, homogenized, twangy country-lite is available feels so insulting. And yet, of course, would we expect anything different? It seems that the approach to the GameDay branding is coming frighteningly close to that of the regional Ford/Chevrolet commercials that are on constant repeat during Jefferson-Pilot telecasts of the ACC and SEC games (i.e., let's display images of the trucks pullin' big stuff through the mud, set to homogenized country tunes, and repeat as many times as possible, often multiple times in the same commercial break!). Perhaps it is the SEC shift to ESPN that has further galvanized ESPN's use of this strategy.
    But what do I know . . . I'm probably a weird consumer. At least I've got Dr. Saturday by my side!
  6. slassy
    6. Posted by slassy Thu Aug 27, 2009 9:55 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Needs more Bubba Sparxxx: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zl329LHWraU
    Now that was a hootananny of an intro I reckon.
  7. Big D
    7. Posted by Big D Thu Aug 27, 2009 11:20 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    im friggin awesome
  8. Alexander
    8. Posted by Alexander Fri Aug 28, 2009 12:11 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    What the hell do you expect from the people who hired Mussburger when CBS finally wised up and fired his moronic ass?
  9. Alaska Hokie
    9. Posted by Alaska Hokie Fri Aug 28, 2009 7:20 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    All I want is that classic drumline college marching band music that sends chills up my spine. Y'know, like CBS has.
  10. TessP
    10. Posted by TessP Fri Aug 28, 2009 8:20 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    With degrees from Harvard and Florida, I necessarily have mixed feelings about college football. I love the Gators and I love it when Harvard beats Yale. As far as the Game Song, I think it is as magnificently crafted video that should be adopted for NASCAR, even the SEC, but it is far too 'country' to represent the rich tapestry of college football.
    BTW, I'm TessP's dad
  11. FresnoDave
    11. Posted by FresnoDave Fri Aug 28, 2009 8:51 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    I understand someone not liking country music, but "racist redneck stereotypes?" Stereotypes? How ironic.
  12. PurdueMatt
    12. Posted by PurdueMatt Fri Aug 28, 2009 8:57 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Matt Hinton doesn't like country music.
  13. e80ohio
    13. Posted by e80ohio Fri Aug 28, 2009 9:42 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    i agree with Alaska Hokie - just make it a drumline intro and mix in images of various plays. That *has* to capture more of the college football audience than this faux twang idiot. I also can't stand how often he references Ohio State, mostly because he makes us all look like the kmart jersey wearing townies who can barely spell college and riot every saturday that he probably sells to
  14. Cry Into the Pillow
    14. Posted by Cry Into the Pillow Fri Aug 28, 2009 10:03 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Ahh, whither John Tesh? Our nation turns it's assaulted ears to you.
    I actually don't watch more than 10 minutes of College Gameday on any given Saturday any more. I despise Florida, Notre Dame, Michigan, Ohio State, Texas and USC and that's about 90% of their programming. I am disappointed that it will adjoin their other "show elements", unless it will be used to drown out Pam Ward's sultry baritone pipes...
  15. John K
    15. Posted by John K Fri Aug 28, 2009 10:21 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    My TiVo gets its biggest workout while watching E$PN... yet another reason to do more fast-forwarding.
  16. Go CU Tigers
    16. Posted by Go CU Tigers Fri Aug 28, 2009 11:02 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Should of went with Kenny Rogers.
  17. steodorovich
    17. Posted by steodorovich Fri Aug 28, 2009 12:07 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I don't know what is worse - that song, or the shameless pandering ESPN does to the SEC. Perhaps the folks at the WWL ought to consider removing their heads from the rectums of the hog-hollerin' necks in the South and realize that not only is the SEC quite over-rated (check their bowl results from last year), but that they only represent a very small minority of the college football fans in the country. But, what is the point. Yeeee Haw!
  18. Tracker
    18. Posted by Tracker Fri Aug 28, 2009 12:51 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    "racist redneck stereotypes?" Sounds like Hawkeye girl has a streotyping issue herself. Hinton, stick to discussing the game. The marketing types know more than you. After all, The "redneck" theme seems to work pretty well for "Monday Night Football," does it not?
  19. kj7
    19. Posted by kj7 Fri Aug 28, 2009 2:41 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    You can't compare MNF and Hank Williams Jr. to this Kenny Chesney/Big and Rich mess they are playin on gameday! The " Are you ready for some football" theme is legendary its been there for 20 years or so and there are probably even a lot of ppl that don't like country that like it. I am a SEC fan too, but they should play rap or hard rock you know at least something that is amped up a little bit, they could edit it just like radio and tv does ne ways, if it was dirty. So, it makes no sense to me. I would say about 90% of the actual college football players would not like this, except for ppl like Tim Tebow who admits to loving Kenny Chesney, which is probably the reason they picked it since everybody in the media/espn is own his nuts!!!
  20. threestepdrop13
    20. Posted by threestepdrop13 Fri Aug 28, 2009 2:45 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    We need MORE Country Music in Football. I mean, Classic Rock is all over College Football and has been for years. Hells Bells, Welcome to the Jungle, Thunderstruck, etc. I am fine with both, but I would love more Country. My other Buckeye fans and I, here in Columbus OH, jam Country Music on game day, and especialy like the different variation of Coming to Your City by Big'n'Rich. I don't see a problem with it, unless your one of those people who believes that it is only red neck music, in which case I tell you to grow up!!! I love country music, but I WON'T sit here and claim that they should remove Rap from the TV because it is a stereotype for gansters. Grow up!!!
  21. kadee
    21. Posted by kadee Fri Aug 28, 2009 4:28 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Well it looks like I'll be watching the game with the mute on. That was the worst promo that I've seen in a long while. It's bad enough that Hank Williams Jr. had to get involved with Monday Night football, now this--please why not give me a paper cut and then pour lemon juice in it, that won't be as bad as having to listen to that crap before or during a game. I grew up listening to country music but that promo sucked!
  22. Woekie
    22. Posted by Woekie Fri Aug 28, 2009 10:08 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I don't object to Big 'N Rich and Kenny Chesney because they're country. I don't like them because they're the blandest possible fusion of country and rock. At least Kid Rock dissipates his lack of talent with noise.
    And anyways, I doubt the Chesney stuff is replacing Comin' to your City. The way I read that press release, it sounds like they'll be blasting it in/out of timeouts like they did with AC/DC last year and that Perry Farrell embarassment two years ago.
  23. jl0810
    23. Posted by jl0810 Fri Aug 28, 2009 10:18 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    ESPN has it wrong on so many levels:
    Any self-respecting man wouldn't be caught dead listening to Kenny Chesney (yes, even your wife's CD)
    Any reasonable person would not confuse Kenny Cheseny with country music,
    No college football fan, at least during daylight hours on Saturday, wants to "capture any passion"
    So we have ESPN marketing to the musically-challenged; passion-seeking; barely-masculine men and non-men
    An interesting demographic indeed.
  24. The Huffs
    24. Posted by The Huffs Sat Aug 29, 2009 9:34 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    If I tolerate Kirk Herbstreit, I'll tolerate that.
    Maybe the idea is to make Lee and Kirk look good in comparison.

Dr. Saturday

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Matt Hinton

Dr. Saturday is a college football blog edited by Matt Hinton. Email him tips and feedback.

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Dr. Saturday Recent Readers