Dr. Saturday - NCAAF

Doug Marrone is dealing with a mountain of problems going into his first bye week as a head coach -- Syracuse is 1-4 against I-A competition after Saturday's loss to West Virginia, 0-2 in the Big East and after the initial optimism of a new coach, a new quarterback, a close call against Minnesota in the opener and an upset over Northwestern, the 'Cuse faithful may be beginning to waver a bit on the first phase of this "rebuilding" thing. Still, the first issue Doug Marrone felt compelled to address after the 34-13 pasting at the hands of the Mountaineers was Greg Paulus' immediate future as the Orange quarterback.

And for now, Marrone insists, the former Duke point guard is still the Orange quarterback, despite being yanked at halftime for following up last week's five-interception catastrophe against South Florida with another pick on Syracuse's first drive against WVU, tying Paulus for the national "lead" with 10 interceptions on the year:

"I just didn't feel comfortable with the way that Greg was responding to questions that I was asking him, we were asking him, on the sidelines," Marrone said. "I don't know what the right word is. But I told Greg, he's our quarterback. He will start versus Akron. We will get him settled down in this bye week, which will be good for us."
[...]
Marrone said he asked questions of Paulus during the first half such as, "Why would you do this? Why would you do that?" Marrone lit into Paulus on the sidelines after his quarterback was intercepted on Syracuse’s first possession. ...

"It's just not characteristic of what my experience with Greg has been in the past," Marrone said. "Therefore, I felt uncomfortable about the situation and made the switch, knowing that Greg is still our starting quarterback. We'll move on from here."

If you didn't know better, you'd think Marrone was describing a player with a concussion who couldn't remember what town he was in. But Paulus is healthy -- his coach just doesn't trust him. Or didn't trust him, at that moment, against West Virginia, after his sixth pick in just five quarters. But now everything is ... cool?

If Marrone was "uncomfortable" with putting Paulus back on the field Saturday, what's going to increase that comfort level over the next two weeks? And how could he be so certain about Paulus returning to his good graces just moments after watching backup Ryan Nassib (who has "everything you want in a quarterback," according to Marrone after naming Nassib the starter in the spring, before Paulus' high-profile transfer just before the season) throw a pair of garbage-time touchdowns?

Syracuse's performance in its first two Big East games has been all too characteristic of 'Cuse fans' experiences with the team in the past. The Orange are still residing at or near the bottom of the conference in most of the major stat categories, including total offense, total defense and scoring defense. Three of the last four visitors to the Carrier Dome have left with at least 34 points on the board, and the plague of interceptions enveloping Paulus has left him with the lowest pass efficiency rating of any regular starter in the Big East. On the field, the initial steps forward are melting into something distressingly close to the familiar jalopies of the Greg Robinson era.

The good news: At 1-4 with one of the worst offenses in the nation itself, Akron is a team the Orange can beat with ease; the Zips have been pounded in their last three by Indiana, Central Michigan and Ohio U. The bad news: An equally lame Zip team won by two touchdowns in the Carrier Dome last September, the inexcusable loss that sealed another year of misery and Robinson's imminent demise. With or without Paulus, if 'Cuse doesn't put Akron out of its misery in fairly comfortable fashion, the cautious optimism of September can pack its bags against until next year.

digg delicious
more

5 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. Recliner
    1. Posted by Recliner Sun Oct 11, 2009 5:53 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    1st!!!!
  2. zibby
    2. Posted by zibby Mon Oct 12, 2009 11:57 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Nassib should have been the starter from the beginning. What's the point of playing a guy who isn't going to be there next year? Anybody who thought this team could win this year is an idiot.
  3. jeffrey
    3. Posted by jeffrey Mon Oct 12, 2009 1:41 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    There is no question that the attitude, desire, and intensity of the football players has significantly improved under Marrone and his staff. The apethy and lethargy of play in the Robinson era is gone and Joe Pa and other coaches as well as players of other teams have commented positively about the change. Moral victories are still like kissing your sister!
    The bottom line is a complete lack of talent and depth, which will take several years of successful recruiting! The team has last years 3rd string quarterback switched to tight end, physically small running backs switched to linebackers, and this week after a corner back got burned, a wide receiver replaced at that position. The team is down some 15 scholarship players!
    Nassib throws a better deep ball and I agree that the " we need a point guard to be our quarterback" hip is foolish When you are trying to build back up your program, why would you start Paulus, a one year only guy. I know the coach may have is intangibles and gut feeling about Greg, but in watching both of them this summer and in all five games, Nassib certainly is as, if not more talented!
    Its going to be a SLOW process. I do think that Marrone has the fire to bring the Orange back, but its going to be a slow several year process, only coming to fruition IF he and his staff are successful with future recruiting classes.!
  4. J-D
    4. Posted by J-D Mon Oct 12, 2009 3:29 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    You know, usually Duke basketball players just end up failing in the NBA. Paulus is breaking ground here by failing in a completely different sport.
  5. jeffrey
    5. Posted by jeffrey Mon Oct 12, 2009 8:18 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Its interesting...most of us sports fans in Syracuse, five years ago all thought Paulus would never make it in the NBA! Most of us thought he was making a mistake career wise then. Agree with J-D's comment. Look at where JR Reed and most other Dukies are !
    Paulus's high school football statistics were however simply staggering !!! OVER 11,000 YARDS PASSING and he was rated the number one QB in the USA that year !
    Oh well , live is about timing and decisions.

Dr. Saturday

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Matt Hinton

Dr. Saturday is a college football blog edited by Matt Hinton. Email him tips and feedback.

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Dr. Saturday Recent Readers