Dr. Saturday - NCAAF

I feel like I've been bringing up politics a lot lately, when I'd much rather write about football and football players and so forth. On that note, here is a picture of Pat White as Steve Urkel:

As for the political intrusion, I find it distasteful and unprincipled but also telling, and possibly inevitable. Some people think a college football playoff will never happen, but I can't remember not thinking the sport was headed for a bracket. It's too obvious: The big conferences formed the Bowl Coalition, which became the Bowl Alliance and then, after the SWC dissolved to make way for the "superconference" concept in the Big 12 and SEC (the sacrifice of the Big East for the sake of the ACC a few year's later hasn't quite panned out, yet), the Bowl Championship Series as we know it, all of them centered around creating bigger, better bowl matchups and, finally, a "true" champion. That's not going so hot, so a mini-playoff -- a "Plus One," maybe, or a four-team setup -- is the next step in that process, then a full-fledged version and so on, until it's a bloated monstrosity that everyone loves.

Every year, another barrier falls and the pressure increases from among the ranks of the staunch suits who are always said to be fiercely guarding the status quo. In 2007, it was Florida's president presenting a plan to the rest of the SEC; last year, it was Georgia's president making the push, open discussion by BCS honchos of instituting a mini-playoff format under the "Plus One" tag and Florida State's president publicly declaring a playoff "inevitable" over the summer. Since the start of the last season, six different high profile coaches -- including four with a BCS championship on their resumé, along with the winningest coach in the sport's history -- publicly supported a playoff.

Coaches are one thing; coaches are on the payroll. Grandstanding politicans, antitrust lawsuits, Congressional committees and bills in the House of Representatives are another level entirely. If the College Football Playoff Act of 2009 has anything to say about it, not only will there be a playoff, but it will happen in 2011, on the dot, and the revolution will be televised when ESPN takes over the show. The president is another level still, and he won't shut up about a playoff. In principle, this may be a waste of time, energy, money and governmental power. In practice, it's something of a landslide.

We may be years away, but as we prepare to watch the snowball picking up steam throughout the offseason, the question for anyone who still thinks a college football playoff "will never happen" will be this: Who's going to stop it?

digg delicious
more

6 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. 4.0 Point Stance
    1. Posted by 4.0 Point Stance Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:55 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I'm convinced that a large part of the WE MUST HAVE PLAYOFFS meme has been created by cfb writers who need article topics and pick this low-hanging fruit. It gets repeated ad nauseum both in print and on Sportscenter, and everyone starts to believe it.
  2. Andrew
    2. Posted by Andrew Thu Sep 03, 2009 2:53 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    want to get ads and presidents to agree to a playoff system. use the bcs to seed the teams in a playoff and then play the brackets like the do in dii, higher seed gets the home game. put the championship on a neutral field. ads and presidents with foam at the mouth to think they will get 1 or 2 more home gates with some tv money thrown in. i bet most of the bcs teams barely broke even or lost money on their bowl trips. you could play the minor bowls for non-play off teams, but it would put an end to the current bowl system.
    i mean realistically how many fans or schools for that matter could afford to go atlanta for round 1, california for round 2 and back to florida for the championship if the playoffs were played at the bowl venues.
  3. marcillac
    3. Posted by marcillac Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:06 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    "Who's going to stopi A similar question was perhaps being asked in Berlin and its surroundings at the beginning of th 1939 just as General Neyland was preparing to lead his volunteers to glory they enjoyed that season on their way to the Rose Bowl. All right kids, lets not get carried away. I don't doubt that a playoff is coming in 10, 20, 30 years at most, a playoff which will no doubt make a great deal of money for many people, satisfy many casual fans and conformists (the author of the present blog, his advocacy of what he himself anticpates is likely to be monstrous in many ways, most definately excepted) and is likely to degrade the spot to depths many of us would rather not fathom.
  4. squirrelyearl
    4. Posted by squirrelyearl Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:37 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I really am not so convinced this thing is going to happen soon. We might get a plus one system sometime soon, but frankly I feel like that thwarts the efforts of anybody who wants an actual playoff. It will be too easy for them to simply say there is already a playoff in place and there's no reason to take it any further, so I don't see them transitioning to at least an 8 team tournament if the plus one system is put in place. A plus one system is a nice step in the right direction, but that's still only 4 teams that are involved, as we saw from this season, that just isn't enough.
  5. Alex Ovechkin
    5. Posted by Alex Ovechkin Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:06 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    "I can't remember not thinking the sport was headed for a bracket" Me either. It's getting done, the only question is when.
  6. Big Jim
    6. Posted by Big Jim Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:25 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    YES NCAA we do want a playoff! America is about winners who win by their own hand -- HEAD-TO-HEAD!!!!!!! Not some sissy feel good bowl system that lets half the teams go home a winner. That's for the Frogs. The only game that matters is the last game and that only matters if there is a playoff AND the last game IS for the National CHAMPIONSHIP....PERIOD!!!!! So NCAA get us a playoff or drop football and we will watch gymnastics and let the judges vote for a number one! ...At least the girls look good in tights.

Dr. Saturday

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Matt Hinton

Dr. Saturday is a college football blog edited by Matt Hinton. Email him tips and feedback.

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Dr. Saturday Recent Readers