Dr. Saturday - NCAAF

Over-the-top, high-dollar recruiting tales are so heavy on rumor and conspiracy theory that they seem more like something out of a clichéd movie, The Program or Caligula Goes to Studio 54 or something. But in the last half-decade alone, you need look no further than either of the major books published on the subject (Michael Lewis' Blindside and Bruce Feldman's Meat Market), Willie Williams' long lost recruiting diary for the Miami Herald or anything written about Colorado recruiting under Gary Barnett to realize that, even after the excesses of the eighties, wild rumor is closer to reality than today's hyper-regulated process leads us to believe.

To that genre, add the testimony of five-star defensive tackle Jamarkus McFarland of Lufkin, Texas, whose midnight commitment to Oklahoma was broken Thursday by The New York Times, of all places, nominally ending one of the most accusation-ridden courtship displays of the year. For months, the Times had access to Jamarkus, his mother and their evolving relationship with coaches from Oklahoma, Texas, LSU and Southern Cal -- including an array of under-the-table perks ranging from the relatively benign (LSU's recruiting hostesses sit on prospects' laps) to the somewhat suspicious (USC players take Jamarkus to a party in a stretch Hummer limo after their win over Notre Dame) to the hilariously flagrant (McFarland's mother, in addition to more straightforward bribes from third parties, says a former classmate called her and said she'd been promised any kind of loan she wanted if she could persuade Jamarcus' mother to push him toward Texas).

But the true piéce de résistance in a generally outstanding piece is an excerpt from an English paper McFarland wrote about an unhinged party with Texas fans in a Dallas hotel following the Longhorns' win in the Red River Shootout in October:

"I will never forget the excitement amongst all participants," McFarland wrote. "Alcohol was all you can drink, money was not an option. Girls were acting wild by taking off their tops, and pulling down their pants. Girls were also romancing each other. Some guys loved every minute of the freakiness some girls demonstrated. I have never attended a party of this magnitude."

He continued: "The attitude of the people at the party was that everyone should drink or not come to the party. Drugs were prevalent with no price attached."

He compared that with a house party hosted by a sorority at Oklahoma.

"Drinks were plentiful, but not to the extent they were" at the Dallas party, he wrote. "Some people were tipsy, but in control of themselves."

He described the atmosphere as pleasant and added: "Some people who attend the University of Oklahoma seem to represent different values than some people who attend the University of Texas."

Has this kid ever heard of Barry Switzer, by any chance?

Oklahoma fans, of course, will frame this piece next to their autographed copy of "Billy Sims chants 'Boomer Sooner'" and love it forever. Not only did the Sooners beat Texas for the dream recruit while the Paper of Record portrayed UT as opulent, arrogant, disorganized, debauched, pushy and, in the case of boosters, not all that concerned with the formalities of the NCAA's recruiting regulations, but they had to pull off a steep sales job: Very early in the process, McFarland's mother told OU defensive line coach Jackie Shipp she was "never setting foot in Norman, Oklahoma, again” after an unofficial visit in April. Shipp and Bob Stoops won her -- and, eventually, Jamarkus, who "initially had his heart set on Texas," for obvious reasons -- over by being "persistent," "no-nonsense" and gracious during home visits (Stoops offers to set the dinner table and "chuckles" during the movie Beauty Shop, while Mack Brown has the family over and asks them to compare the luxuries of his house, including two flat screen TVs outside, to Stoops' and Les Miles').

Texas fans, I suspect, will declare "stage mom" and await McFarland's inevitable flameout/fallout in Norman, where he never wanted to be in the first place. And anyway, no commitment is official until Feb. 4. There's time to work that Longhorn "magic," yet.

digg delicious
more

22 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. scottyc5
    1. Posted by scottyc5 Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:10 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    This article is ridiculous. Everyone -- please look at the author's blog archives on the NYT site. It's all Sooners all the time. Also notice there isn't a single source from UT, LSU or USC, nor is there even a no comment. This guy didn't even try to verify the stories coming from the recruit and especially his mother. This stuff may or may not have happened, but it is shoddy journalism hiding under a New York Time umbrella. As far as the NYT is concerned, it is getting a great recruiting story -- they don't care about the schools involved. This hack knew that and used it as a way to do an absolute smear against UT and to some extent, LSU.
    There are so many facts in the story that are questionable, it's simply irresponsible that they were not verified. McFarland was at a post RRS party with Texas fans on a weekend he was doing his official visit with OU? Really? That's just one.
    I'm not saying OU didn't do a better job recruiting, or that they cheated or whatever that you'll hear a lot of UT fans blathering about. It may or may not have happened, whatever. But this article is a plain and simple hack job written by a homer whose bosses didn't realize that he was a homer, or if they did, they didn't care.
  2. stu s
    2. Posted by stu s Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:14 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    ohhh 45-35, you poor texan soul...didn't i see you in on the slopes in jeans at winter park last week?
    You nailed Hinton...he's just a scurrilous carpet-bagging connecticut yankee wolf-writer in sheeps clothing that dirty librul sum [profane]...what we need is some generous southern writers to be truthful about TU and all else that is right and just in college football...maybe a writer from Mississippi who is well respected for his opinions around the blogosphere with a little Southern Miss homerism thrown in there.
    ta hell with that dirty fascist rag they call the new york times! and ta hell with all of its fancy-schmancy salt of the earth hating muslim lovin' fancy word usin' salad eatin' writers too!!!
    oh yeah, 45-35, which no-defense playing big twelve school is gonna get whupped by florida for the national championship?
  3. Matt H
    3. Posted by Matt H Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:48 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Thayer Evans' bio is here, if anyone is interested in the last comment: http://thequad.blogs.nytimes.com/author/thayer-evans/. He looks very young, played basketball at some small schools in Oklahoma and writes often for the Houston Chronicle. The New York Times is not into shoddy hack jobs (especially wherein the supposed hackery is entirely quoted from the main sources of the story), but if you're going to accuse the NYT of bias in a recruiting matter between Oklahoma and Texas, you may as well move into a cave that only gets Orangebloods.com. They're all in on it!
  4. GorgeForeman
    4. Posted by GorgeForeman Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:38 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    The entire recruiting process is so absurd. The way these coaches demean themselves is just gross.
  5. scottyc5
    5. Posted by scottyc5 Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:10 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Matt -- Sorry to confuse. I meant the NYT article is ridiculous, not yours. But Thayer Evans has written virtually all of his NYT articles about OU this year. He's essentially a NYT OU beat reporter:
    http://thequad.blogs.nytimes.com/author/thayer-evans/
    I'm cool with JM's decision. Kids make decisions for all sorts of reasons. Good luck to him. But this is the second time Thayer has done this. NOWHERE did I accuse the NYT of bias-- I'm saying it's a salacious article for the neutral observer and they simply don't care that it doesn't present both sides. It has already caused a stir in the blogosphere -- so hits galore. But in the process the article impugns at least 2 schools of dirty dealing and/or generally bad behavior without even allowing those schools to defend themselves. Was that party a "Texas" party? Or were there simply Texas fans there? Or was it written for JM's creative writing class? Who knows? It's a lazy article that creates internet hits and is exemplary of what a lot of newspaper reporting has become.
    I'd be happy with a simple "The UT and LSU Ath Depts were contacted for comment, but didn't return our calls." Maybe it's there and I missed it. But if not, as far as I'm concerned JM and his mother's statements were taken for what they were with no verification. Anyway -- hopefully that clarifies my initial post some.
    And Stu S. Thanks for the reasoned and well written response. I don't know where to begin, so I'll let it speak for itself. Good luck next week. You'll need it.
  6. JB
    6. Posted by JB Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:18 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    May be alot of substance in all that, think NFL is starting to notice alot more productivity out of sooner picks than
    all the washouts from UT over the last 5 yrs.
    Like always, UTs ability to outmoney falls short and inferior to OUs ability to manipulate and outthink. UT standing pat on their BS non conference schedules with E cupcake u and slippery rock while the sooners are quietly scheduling a probable 10-2 BYU team to go play in Jerrys new stadium in Dallas for a season opener. That will be BYU, TU and Miami for starters on OUs NonCon. Probably 3 top 20 teams, and playing with all kind of pompt circumstance and pagentry in Arlington for season opener on Nat tv.
    Don't you get sick of it. Just kicking your ass every way but loose. No go get ready for a Buckeye asskickin.
  7. A Yahoo! User
    7. Posted by A Yahoo! User Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:20 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    MJ, dude, what's that smell? You might want to get your personal hygiene on. Know what I'm saying?
    With that said, glad net goaders like you are stoking the coals. Dallas PD had better start hiring and training Commerce street enforcers 'cause I think there will be a lot of dark alley confrontations October 16, 2009.
    So you guys keep it up because you ain't seen asskickin....yet.
  8. JB
    8. Posted by JB Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:18 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    BurntUp, Thats not me you're smelling, thats your upper lip. Don't know if its from your butt licking or shiit eating.
    Sounds like you're living in yesteryear you nitwit. Nothing going on on Commerce since 1980. Might be a good place for you to headquarter yourself.
    I'm sure you and 45-35 will strike the fear of God into everybody wearing crimson. Maybe if your coach stopped crying long enough someone might believe something so propostorous.
    Now take your [profane] schedule and get set for for your computer and poll placement away from the action. Thats what you get when your afraid to compete. Doesn't make much difference, OSU will beat you in Stillwater and your done again.
    Sounds like the only thing going on in dark alleys in big D will be alot of drug trade between the longhorn faithful.
    Maybe thats how you guys cope. In the adjoinging alley you'll probably find your wife looking for the real longhorn.
    You [profane]
  9. scottyc5
    9. Posted by scottyc5 Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:10 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    damn mj -- i try to make a reasonable argument about the quality (or lack thereof) of this nyt article on a message board. an argument that i'd love to hear a rebuttal on other than "the nyt times wouldn't print it if it weren't true" and an argument that is being made across the interwebs, b the way. i don't say one bad word about ou, and you put out that tripe. i guess i forgot that message boards are more for *%^# talking than reasoned discussion. too bad. i am not generally a geoff ketchum fan, but his evisceration of this nyt article on rivals is pretty darn good.
  10. todd.murray@...
    10. Posted by todd.murray@... Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:14 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    it's way too easy to say it's a biased article since the guy is an OU beat writer for the NYT. how would you even begin to know such a thing unless you yourself had inside knowledge about the recruiting process or this recruit in particular? otherwise, it's just your speculation from the view of burnt orange-colored glasses. to me, the fact that he writes about OU is the reason he was doing the article in the first place, it's OU-related. it could be that JM and his mom watered down their take on what happened since they ended up picking OU (don't want to bite the hand that will ultimately feed you), but it really doesn't sound that way since mom didn't want to step foot in norman again and JM didn't want to even play there until near the end of his decision making process. or it could be that it all played out very near to how they related it to the writer and all those schools did all those things, including there still being parties with alcohol attended at OU (which is surely some kind of infraction). the article doesn't really paint OU in the greatest light, but it is better than that of UT, LSU and USC. JM also mentioned that the training was more individual-based at OU, thus he felt his pro prospects would be better attending OU. and that probably held more weight in the decision making process for JM and his mom, than all the other things combined. my thought is that if UT had made that impression on him as well, that's where he'd be verbally committed to right now, instead of OU.
  11. the juicer
    11. Posted by the juicer Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:00 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    MJ thanks for letting everyone know how you are just another typical no class choklahomer 45-35 loser!
    the truth hurts!
  12. Nik
    12. Posted by Nik Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:38 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Bottom line- McFarland chose OU because he felt this was his best avenue to the NFL and a multi-million dollar contract. True, he was always a UT fan growing up in Lufkin, but sometimes you have to put away childhood dreams and be realistic about your future. Tommie Harris, the best defensive lineman in the NFL, just recently signed for millions in Chicago. Gerald McCoy will be the next Sooner D lineman to get his millions in the NFL, probably leaving early to the NFL after ''09. When Jackie Shipp speaks to you and says that OU has a scholarship for you, you have to sit and listen, otherwise you put your future in jeopardy. Ruben Randle is the next target. Sure, he's maybe dreamed for years about playing in Baton Rouge, but the reality is that catching balls from Sam Bradford, and then Landry Jones, will lead to millions in the NFL.
  13. adamlongley
    13. Posted by adamlongley Thu Sep 03, 2009 2:45 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    hey mj--nobody's living in yesteryear. in case you forgot, texas handily whooped ou's ass on a neutral field in october. to me, and most every ut fan, that is all that matters. yes, i'm disappointed that you land thieves stole another one from us (with nearly all texas-bred players, as always). but the bottom line is your team folded like a cheap suit in the fourth quarter at the cotton bowl, and will, in all probability, fold in their bcs bowl game once again.
    as for mcfarland, whatever. we'll reload like we always do and beat you once again in october. and you can keep making some doomed argument about your out-of-conference schedule.
    good luck in the title game, and please don't embarrass the big xii like you usually do.
  14. JB
    14. Posted by JB Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:18 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Ming, your an idiot buy al least entertaining. FYI, "It's folded like a used lawn chair" or "I'll be on you like a cheap suit".
    Regardless, throughout history its always been the same. Yes your top recruits always opt for the better team, regardless of UT faithful trying to persuede them while drunk or under the influence of drugs. Sooners will fill the trenches with Texas best, but always take a local product lead the team as triggerman. Just like the Dallas Cowboys copied the only time they were successful lately. getting a solid Oklahoma triggerman, Troy Akman.
    Just go back to my initial post, we're critical thinkers with to much vision for you to understand. You will always take a back seat. Now get your ass over to the fiest. I've got a plane to catch to South Beach, where I here Ricky Williams has got some good week he wants to smoke with me if I'll tell him the secret to life.
  15. adamlongley
    15. Posted by adamlongley Thu Sep 03, 2009 2:45 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    right MJ, when i think of oklahoma the two things that always come to mind are "vision" and "critical thinking." i hear that sort of critical thinking can lead to lucrative careers on used car lots. just ask rhett bomar.
  16. luv bus Russ
    16. Posted by luv bus Russ Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:56 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    As if there were any doubts, McFarland stated during his first interview since this came out that the story he wrote for the class was, and these are his words, "spiced up." That means the NY Times basically took a class paper that was not factual and presented it as though it were fact. If that is good or responsible or any other positive adjective reporting, then I must not have ever understood journalistic integrity. Thayer's article belongs in the gossip column because it is already being proven to be fiction. Anybody notice how the story first and foremost dumps on Texas? If Oklahoma won a battle, shouldn't the focus of the story be on what OU did right? Or if the stoy is about Jamarkus, shouldn't the focus be on him? The fact that the obvious focus of the story was presenting UT in a bad light, coupled with the fact that Thayer obviously used Jamarkus' paper w/out his permission and w/out fact-checking it, undermines any attempt to say the article's true intent was anything other than to smear UT. To Nik, post #12, if you want to compare the "best" current d-linemen from the schools, please notice "that guy" in the middle of the d-line of the #1 rated defense in the nfl, the Steelers, and please tell me where Casey Hampton went to school. Answer: Texas. And if you want to compare how current players will fare, I'll take whatever future Brian Orakpo has over any player on OU's d-line. Jackie Shipp? You don't think high school kids think Will Muschamp is worth listening to? Maybe you should remember he was defensive coordinator for LSU when LSU beat OU for the national championship. How are you going to downplay him after he beat you in that game, & beat your highest scoring offense ever this year?
  17. scottyc5
    17. Posted by scottyc5 Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:10 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Care to backtrack on the statement ". . . the true piéce de résistance in a generally outstanding piece."?
    Matt, you are the best blogger in CFB in my opinion. But you jumped the gun on this one along with everything else. Thayer didn't do his job.
  18. scottyc5
    18. Posted by scottyc5 Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:10 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Whoops.. too much spiked egg nog. Meant to post a link:
    http://blogs.suntimes.com/sportsprose/2008/12/jamarkus_mcfarland_oklahoma_re.html
  19. Matt H
    19. Posted by Matt H Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:48 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    No, 45-35, I don't care to backtrack. I think Kevin Allen is a little over-the-top in his criticism of Thayer Evans here. To be clear, Evans didn't embellish anything: McFarland did (he says), in his English paper, and Evans quoted from that. If the paper is quoted accurately (and apparently it is), I think that's legitimate. Especially when "he (McFarland) and his mother stand by the rest of the article and that the majority of the English paper was not embellished." I strongly disagree with Allen's describing that segment as a "rebuke" and a "work of fiction."
    I know Texas is smarting from this story, but it's not like every school isn't equally shady in these matters. It's understood that there are wild parties and illegal offers at every turn, on every campus, among every school's alumni and boosters. For whatever reason, JeMarkus and his mother, as Evans' sources, didn't share those stories about Oklahoma. But it's not personal or conspiratorial.
    And as a blogger, when a story appears in a newspaper -- any newspaper -- commenting on its contents is not "jumping the gun." It's blogging.
  20. scottyc5
    20. Posted by scottyc5 Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:10 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Fair enough. I think what has UT fans more upset is that Thayer didn't do his homework. McFarland came out at the US Army game today and said that English paper was "spiced up" for purposes of his class (see Rivals article/video) and he didn't even know that Thayer got a hold of the paper. It's pretty clear Thayer didn't verify the veracity of the statements in the English paper and printed them as fact. Thayer himself leans on the description of the party as one of the biggest points of his story. So if he was too lazy (and that's giving him the benefit of the doubt) to check those facts, how accurate can the rest of it be? That's Allen's point. I think he wants this to be a good piece of journalism and is pissed that Thayer dropped the ball on this.
    I'm not saying it's a work of fiction. I have my doubts, but have no proof one way or the other. I'm not saying OU isn't a much better fit than UT for JM and his family. I'm just saying it was a piss poor piece of journalism, and JM's comments today bring the whole article into question.
    I think I'm done with it, though. The kid got taken advantage of. That's clear from the fact that his paper was quoted without him even knowing. I feel bad for him.
  21. Charles H
    21. Posted by Charles H Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:31 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    MJ -
    OU fans are "critical thinkers?" Seriously, Cletus, you people can't even read. You got the kid because of his mother and because UT and LSU backed off (again because of his mother). Anyway, your recruiting class needs it more than ours- he's the first and only five star you will get this year.
    Enjoy the trailer park.
  22. Allen N
    22. Posted by Allen N Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:33 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    nyt admitted the article sucks:
    http://www.nytimes.com/2009/01/18/opinion/18pubed-web.html?_r=3&sq=mcfarland&st=cse&scp=1&pagewanted=print
    good commentary, biased, but good at bon:
    http://www.burntorangenation.com/2009/1/19/727706/at-long-last-the-gray-lady

Dr. Saturday

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Matt Hinton

Dr. Saturday is a college football blog edited by Matt Hinton. Email him tips and feedback.

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Dr. Saturday Recent Readers