Dr. Saturday - NCAAF

A weekly look at the weekend’s high profile losers and other tales of shattered ambition.

Blue vs. Blue. In times of strife, the Michigan Internets look to blogging virtuoso Brian Cook for guidance and perspective, a clearheaded light in the fog of anger of confusion. When a home loss to 1-4 Toledo -- the first loss to a lowly MAC team in Wolverine history, just a week after the Rockets were shut out by Ball State – leaves the proud program at its lowest point in more than 40 years, Cook's inimitable MGoBlog can serve as the anchor for level heads seeking to take the long view. Its summary of the state of Michigan fandom following the Toledo loss:

In other words, it’s civil war in Ann Arbor, between the horrified multitudes already clamoring for Rich Rodriguez's hide on one side, and the patient, Rod-loving defenders -- of which Cook is the beachhead – who keep repeating "rebuilding year," "rebuilding year," "rebuilding year ..." Yes, they're throwing things inside the Big House:

He was angry. I was angry.

I stooped to pick up whatever flingable bit of detritus I could find, seized upon an empty water bottle, and chucked it at the booer. I missed, lightly damaging an older man a row behind him. But I did get his attention. And the old guy looked like he was on The Other Side, so eff him.

The Detroit News helpfully point readers in the direction of FireRRod.com, which offers the spectacular Countdown to the Expiration of Les Miles’ Contract at LSU clock. Don’t worry, Rod-haters: only four years to go!

Welcome to rock bottom. Wait, on second thought, I don’t even want to consider rock bottom. This particular version of Washington State is the worst major conference outfit in recent memory – worse than Syracuse, worse than the familiar Duke fiascos, worse than Minnesota last year, none of which allowed 60-plus points in three of their first four conference games, a distinction that belongs solely to the Cougars after Saturday’s 66-13 debacle at Oregon State -- and it's hard to put it all on Paul Wulff. The Wazzu alum not only inherited clearly the least talented roster in the Pac-10, but he’s had to watch it buried under an avalanche of pain: the Cougars have lost six games by an average of 41 points, more than two dozen true or redshirt freshmen have started for the first time, only one offensive lineman has started every game, and the top two quarterbacks both left the only win, over I-AA Portland State, with serious back injuries.

And so, improbably, cruelly, the Cougars’ misery deepened Saturday. When Wulff held an open call for a quarterback last week, the “winner,” Peter Roberts, was only supposed to run the scout team. But Oregon State pounded redshirt freshman Marshall Lobbestael into submission, sacking the poor kid five times, hitting him on almost every dropback and finally knocking him out with an MCL sprain in the fourth quarter. The coaches threw in fourth-string walk-on Daniel Wagner, and the prospects for the position went downhill from there:

Even Wagner couldn’t be spared from the injury issues. He rolled his ankle on a play and was limping around in the final minutes and never got to attempt a pass.

“They told me just to manage the offense and not get hurt,” Wagner said.

So that leaves [J.T.] Levenseller and recently recruited scout quarterback Peter Roberts, who was selected after an open student body tryout, as the only completely healthy quarterbacks in the program.

The third-team redshirt freshman goes down, the end-of-the-bench walk-on starts hobbling around, and suddenly the not-even-on-the-bench guy the Cougars literally pulled off the street six days earlier is about two series and another missed blitz pickup from actually getting into a live Pac-10 game. The original backup, senior Kevin Lopina, is scheduled to return to the lineup this Saturday against … oh lord, no: USC. If ever there was a game that really, really did not need to be played, for the physical safety and futures of the young men on the Cougar sidelines, this has to be it.

Petrino will have Tuberville’s seat yet. Oh, the terrible irony of Auburn’s loss to hapless Arkansas, and Tommy Tuberville’s faltering employment status at the hands of Bobby Petrino:

It's been five years since anyone felt compelled to ask Tuberville about his job security. Five years since Jetgate. Five years since Bobby Petrino was prepared to take his job.

Of all people.

The same Petrino who, as the Louisville coach, snuck off to an airport to meet Auburn's secret agents of change, returned as the Arkansas coach to author this upset. It will come as no surprise if his first SEC win as a head coach helps set those runway wheels in motion again.

This is what the beginning of the end could look like: Auburn loses to a Vanderbilt team that turns around and loses to Mississippi State. Auburn bounces back by getting bounced by an Arkansas team that lost its three previous games by 108 points.

And the ugliness isn't confined to the offensive possessions or the final scores.

Open week, meet open wound.

At least some Auburn fans are willing to stand by their man, but Tuberville’s own answers to questions of his potential demise probably sound more halting and unsure than he intended – “I hope, you know, to be here” – and he clearly recognizes the whole train wreck of an offense thing. He tried tocreate a spark by ditching coordinator Tony Franklin, and now that that move resulted in the worst total yardage output in the season against the Razorbacks, Tubs is apparently going to shake up the quarterbacks. Neither Chris Todd nor Kodi Burns has provided a spark with any aspect of their game, so it looks likely that true freshman Barrett Trotter will spend the off week as the favorite to start at West Virginia next Thursday night in the Disappointing Offense Bowl. If not Trotter, the Tigers may reach further down the depth chart for Neil Caudle, another tall, pocket type they’ll hope flashes the arm Todd has not, and burns was never expected to.

Elsewhere in disillusion … Missouri’s loss to Oklahoma State was like paying for Hulk Hogan and getting Dusty Rhodes. … Crimson and Cream Machine sorts through Oklahoma’s loss -- seriously, everything -- to figure out what went wrong in the Cotton Bowl. … And you can say "if if if" all day, but you can't take away Notre Dame's five turnovers at North Carolina.

The Doc apologizes to everyone who must now go to YouTube to excise "I am a Real American" from their heads. Fight for the rights of every man …

digg delicious
more

21 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. troy
    1. Posted by troy Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:06 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    time to get rid of rich, wv crap doesnt work here but its funny, hope they dont win another game
  2. James S
    2. Posted by James S Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:02 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Michigan is a state hit hard during economic hard times because they rely so much on the Auto industry, which is terrible right now, and the fact Ohio State dominates you at ALL TIMES; Buckeyes, babyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy.
  3. habs1rule
    3. Posted by habs1rule Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:15 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Michigan fans are crying now because you used to have problems with Ohio State, now you might not beat Chico State, tisk tisk..
  4. bigboo's bro
    4. Posted by bigboo's bro Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:38 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Well, gosh, under pressure from its boosters UM did go out and fire a solid honorable coach and hire just about the biggest douche in college athletics today. So why is it a surprise that the douche nozzle, and the joke, is on them?
  5. Dion G
    5. Posted by Dion G Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:43 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Love the Buckeyes but hate U of M. HOWEVER, the student athletes at Michigan deserve better than what they are getting from that coaching staff. I'd like to see the annual rivalry game be competitive, at least. And if my beloved Buckeyes don't find an offense, it may make any difference, anyway.
  6. Joshua H
    6. Posted by Joshua H Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:23 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Lane Kiffen is going to feel like a 5-star recruit when Washington, Clemson, Auburn, Tennessee and Syracuse court him (bid on him) for his services. This can only enhance his recruiting skills.
  7. y_not_garrekk
    7. Posted by y_not_garrekk Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:58 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    RR was not a good choice for the Wolverines. He did well at WVU because of that conference. Michigan is worlds away from WV. Maybe UM should stay with the current trend and fire him mid-season..get one of the better coaches avail. before someone else does. The only thing the ACC has on the Big Ten is 1 more university. I am Garrekk and I approved this message.
  8. jimmie honey
    8. Posted by jimmie honey Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:29 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I'm not a Rich Rod fan,but lighten up,Michigan fans! Rich Rod may not have much class, but give him a little time and he will produce. He knows football and will get the team on track.
    In the meantime cry for WVU's Coach Stew. He's engineered 4 wins out of 6 games in a rebuilding year and the Boo-birds are still after his hide. I'm a WVU grad, a loyal fan, and I think we got a good deal with Stew. A class act and a Class Man.
  9. John G
    9. Posted by John G Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:41 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Im a Buckeye fan and i think Rich will have UM on top again . Gotta give him a little time.
  10. SpartanDan
    10. Posted by SpartanDan Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:11 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Michigan fans who want Rodriguez gone now are bonkers. You really think they'd be doing any better in a smash-mouth offense when they have a lousy QB (on his better days), a bad O-line, decent-at-best RBs and WRs (although they'll improve once they're no longer all freshmen), and an average-or-worse secondary? This was going to be an ugly year no matter who the coach was; if you're going to change schemes, what better time than when you're going to have a down year anyway?
  11. oldmountie
    11. Posted by oldmountie Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:44 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I betcha good old Coach Rod is wondering where he went wrong. I wold bet he is second guessing why he left WVU. I went to the same High school as Coach Rod, he seemed like a nice enough guy but he should have stayed another year at WVU. He is well hated in the state of West Virginia. I hope they win the rest of their games but I kinda doubt it. When I see Michagan has lost I can't help but snicker.
  12. Allan Sizemore
    12. Posted by Allan Sizemore Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:56 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    WVU in a REBUILDING YEAR?!?! HAve you lost your mind?
  13. E
    13. Posted by E Thu Sep 03, 2009 2:45 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I find it amusing that Brian Cook felt the best way to stop someone from booing college kids (i.e. taking things too seriously) was to throw something at said boo-bird (i.e. taking things too seriously). Just because you refer to your projectile as detritus doesn't mean you DIDN'T throw something at another grown man who was shouting a monosyllabic jeer at a group of large men. Ahh, perspective.
  14. ArrogantBastard
    14. Posted by ArrogantBastard Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:32 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    As a lifelong Michigan football fan-- you haters are ridiculous. A coach or program can't win with you people! Lloyd Carr has UM in the top 25 almost all of his 13 years, wins a title, and in 2006 loses to a team that played for the title by 3 on the road (Ohio State) and a team that probably should have played for the title by 12 in the bowl (USC), and people say he should be fired. Rodriguez comes into a program that has players leaving early, transferring, and reversing commitments because they fear they won't fit in the spread. He goes 2-4 and people want to fire him. PATIENCE!!! Michigan State ran off Nick Saban.....and he's won a title with LSU and has Alabama at the top.
  15. Shyster
    15. Posted by Shyster Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:56 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Why do Ohio State fans feel the need to chime in on every story? I can't wait till MSU beats them this week; that should shut 'em up for the rest of the season.
  16. Steelersfootball
    16. Posted by Steelersfootball Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:02 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    This is great, I hope Coach Rod never wins another game. He is a low class jerk and deserves what he is getting. I hope they get destroyed by Penn State. Coach Paterno is a class act, maybe Richie boy will learn something.
  17. bigboo's bro
    17. Posted by bigboo's bro Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:38 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    ArrogantB, UM doesn't deserve patience for throwing the underclassmen on the football team and recruits under the bus in order to entice RichieRich. Wasn't throwing another $2 million down the sewer to buy him out enough of an ego strokejob? Forcing Lloyd Carr out for this POS is a disgrace, and making kids on the team pay the price is even worse. RichieRich and everyone who played a role in bringing him to UM should be riding a rail our of Ann Arbor. And then he should be given a timeout with his protege Pacman.
  18. ArrogantBastard
    18. Posted by ArrogantBastard Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:32 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    bigboo's bro:
    There was no forceout with Lloyd Carr, the man retired! I don't think hiring a new coach when the old one retires can accuratly be described as "throwing underclassmen and recruits under the bus" either. Once WVU sued Rodriguez and created bad pub (much of it false in the end), the University of Michigan stood by their new coach and settled things.
  19. ArrogantBastard
    19. Posted by ArrogantBastard Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:32 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    People seem to miss the fact that Michigan's defense is as good as any in the country. The offense is horrible....because there is no good QB. THAT is how vital that one position is. A decent quarterback, and UM is probably 4-2 or 5-1 instead of 2-4.
  20. jamesr_1973
    20. Posted by jamesr_1973 Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:28 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    First, it was time for Carr to go. He just didn't have the fire in the belly for it any longer. You could tell by watching his lack of emotion on the sidelines. Secondly, this is not the team Rodriguez would have recruited. He was left with a second and third string QB, both freshman, and only one returning starter on offense. He is implementing a new style offense that neigther of his QB's has had any experience with. Watching the games from the sidelines, you can tell that there are communication problems, confusion, and a lack of basic understanding of the offense. If you read the scouting and recruiting reports, there is some solid talent coming to Michigan next season, so give the Coach a chance to build the team he envisions, not the one Carr left him with.
  21. Lance L
    21. Posted by Lance L Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:36 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    The problem is this.... the michigan offense wasn't the problem.we did good beating florida with that offense.We had problems stopping the spread.I understand implementing a little of the spread but totally scrapping the traditional michigan offense was ahuge mistake.If you don't have the personell to do it you don't do it.there is no such thing as a rebuilding year you recruit so when the older players leave someone else steps into their shoes.Michigan has fallen hard.I don't see them beating anybody in the big ten unless they go back to michigan football.Remeber are problem wasn't us not running the spread our problem was defending against it like most big ten teams.

Dr. Saturday

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Matt Hinton

Dr. Saturday is a college football blog edited by Matt Hinton. Email him tips and feedback.

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Dr. Saturday Recent Readers