Dr. Saturday - NCAAF

On the same weekend we huddle around the mangled remains of USC and Florida's national ambitions, it's also an occasion to embrace the balance in nature, the circle of life, yin and yang, the energy that can be neither created nor destroyed, etc. Yes, the same catchphrases you learned in chemistry class, your local head shop and various Elton John songs can be applied to the polls, too, where some championship contenders die -- for the time being, anyway -- and new ones rise to assume the glories and burdens of life at the top. Exeunt Southern Cal, Georgia and Florida, entrer Penn State and Alabama. Along with Oklahoma's ascension to No. 1, it's feeling very 1979 up in here.

Forgive the suggestion that the Tide and Lions -- or Sooners, or anyone else -- might be destined for something. Fate is a cruel myth, as the Trojans and Gators can well attest this morning, and as Bama, PSU, Oklahoma, Missouri and LSU have two months still to learn, with freshly-affixed targets on their backs.

If you're looking to anoint the winners of September, though, no other frontrunners look quite so well-adjusted as the surprises, the Tide and Lions. Alabama, especially, has not only dominated two top ten opponents on neutral and hostile turf. but put them away quickly, convincingly, precisely according to the template Nick Saban established for LSU's championship run in 2003: a steady, efficient, veteran quarterback, backed by a run-first philosophy and a committee of strong runners that eat up the clock; and more importantly, a dominant defensive line that takes away the running game immediately.

Against two of the most dynamic backfields in America, the Tide front seven has been virtually perfect. Clemson logged exactly zero yards on the ground on opening night, and Georgia ran up all of 50 on Saturday. All together, James Davis, C.J. Spiller and Knowshon Moreno combined for 56 yards on 17 carries, and because they were rendered so obsolete so quickly, Cullen Harper and Matt Stafford were inevitably pounded into hamburger as the game wore on and comeback lights grew dim. Stafford held up much better Saturday than Harper earlier in the year, but Big Matt, too, was hit, flustered and frustrated into his share of desperate, off-balance, sure-to-end-badly throws. It's by his golden arm alone that not every one ended badly, but Bama won't see another limb even in Stafford's ballpark for the rest of the regular season, if it sustains the same level of pressure.

In fact, this is the template -- steady, senior quarterback making a dramatic leap forward, deep backfield, hellacious front seven -- that's defined all of the SEC's best teams this decade, from LSU in '03 to Auburn in '04 to Florida in '06 and LSU last year. Unlike any of those teams, Bama's already handled its toughest test on the road (albeit with Baton Rouge still to come) apparently has not just an adequate offensive line, but a potentially legendary bunch of maulers at their current pace. The front five are deservedly the stars of the offense.

If borderline teams like Alabama and Penn State have to "pay their dues" before they're allowed into the discussion for No. 1, certainly both teams put down whatever was left on their tab Saturday. Does it matter that the Tide struggled mightily on offense against Tulane? Possibly -- John Parker Wilson will be called on eventually to pull a win back from the edge of a cliff in the fourth quarter, a feat he's pulled off exactly once (last year against Arkansas) in two full years and at least a half dozen game-saving opportunities as a starter. The jury remains largely out on the Lions until they manage trips to Wisconsin and Ohio State. Both teams have long-standing streaks to bust to get anywhere: PSU has been consistently routed in Columbus since joining the Big Ten and hasn't beaten Michigan anywhere in more than a decade; Alabama is 0-10 since 2003 against LSU and Auburn.

We'll look back at Halloween and see if any of this talk still makes any sense; in retrospect, it rarely does. For now, though, revise your expectations accordingly.

- - -
Photo of Matt Stafford being brought down and Evan Royster vs. Illinois via Getty Images.

digg delicious
more

49 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. BrianD
    1. Posted by BrianD Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:14 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    just keep sleepin' on the Big 12 people... you'll come to regret it.
  2. JF
    2. Posted by JF Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:26 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Go Bama! I'm a Tn. Vols fan but they are not very interesting to watch. Get a new quarterback. Also make the offensive coaches get their act together. Why did you ever agree to let Karen's husband ever leave Tn? I think he's in N.C. somewhere and they are probably winning.
  3. JF
    3. Posted by JF Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:26 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I just called my brother in Tn. and the name I wanted was David Cutcliff. He was an offensive coach in Tn. and like Tony the tiger HE'S GREAT. Go N.C.
  4. Eazy E
    4. Posted by Eazy E Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:51 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Someone please explain to me how USC can remain in the top 10 after that beating they received from OSU. OSU I tell you! The team that took a beating of there own by Penn State just a week prior. Yet there is a unsubtle falling of teams in the Big 10 i.e. OSU who fell to 13 and the SEC i.e. Georgia who also fell out of the top 10. Mind you after losing to top 10 ranked teams. This ranking system is rigged I tell you. Bias' are evident after this week. This is a bunch of BS!!!!!!
  5. Hawk in Ohio
    5. Posted by Hawk in Ohio Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:32 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Why is it that then #3 OSU lost to #1 USC and they drop to #13. #1 USC loses to UNRANKED OSU and they only fall to #9!! Go Irish!
  6. Linton
    6. Posted by Linton Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:11 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    #4 and #5,
    You hit the nail on the head. Just a glance at today's poll, one sees the obvious mistake is USC in the Top 10. The bias is as bad as it was last year. Anyone who knows football saw USC's offensive and defensive lines blown off the line of scrimmage play after play by an 8th to 9th decile team. Pollsters get real.
  7. Chris M
    7. Posted by Chris M Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:27 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    But they are USC, don't you see! That obviously means something...I guess.
  8. BrnxBmbr
    8. Posted by BrnxBmbr Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:25 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    #7 I really hope you're being very sarcastic. Why is it every year the polls get worse and worse? And it always centers around USC. Pre-season rankings are bogus... always will be. If you wait until after the 4th week of the season to start ranking people based on how they have played AND who they have played... you'de get a much better outlook on who's really the top teams in the nation. And that being said, USC looks right now like a #15 team at best. Say what you want, UF lost to Ole Miss at home... they werent losing 21-0 at halftime. USC was DOMINATED the entire game, on both sides of the ball. Florida was not. Georgia got pummeled by Alabama... Alabama was ranked #8. You can go on and on, but you cant come up with any reasons why USC belongs anywhere near the top 10, let alone 9th. I'm an FSU fan so I have no ties to the Pac 10, Big 12, Big 10 or the SEC. It's all b.s. The ESPN jack offs that consistently make as many excuses for USC as USC fans do are partly to blame. But nothing will change, at least anytime soon. The only thing USC fans do is make excuses. The Pac 10 is on no level near the Big 12 or the SEC.
  9. stiff
    9. Posted by stiff Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:16 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Well, it's like this, if you dorp USC out of the top 10 in the polls. They can't jump over a undefeated non-BCS team to play for the national championchip. The Big 12 did it twice already when they twisted the arms of the BCS to allow the Sooner and the Cornhusker to play in a national championchip. Oh, and remember that they both got there tails kick in the Big 12 Championchip Game. I tell you, it's all who's sleeping with the voter man.
  10. Chris C
    10. Posted by Chris C Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:47 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    What would you say about this loss if Oregon State proceeds to go on a tear and wind up winning 9 or 10 games? Oregon State is a completely different team later in the season. In 2006, OSU was 2-2 with a 42-14 loss on the road to a WAC team by week 5. From week 6 on, OSU was 8-2, including a win over #3 USC. In 2007 OSU was 2-3 by week five, including a 34-3 loss on the road to Cincinnati. From week 6 on, OSU was 7-1, including a win over #2 Cal. They ended both seasons ranked. At Week 5 this year, OSU is 2-2 with a 45-14 loss to Penn State. Where do you think they're going to end up? An 8th or 9th Decile team? How can you say that definitavely? We don't know a thing about the actual quality of the teams thus far. The amount of exhasperation people get from these power rankings is absurd.
  11. marcillac
    11. Posted by marcillac Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:06 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    The chance of PSU winning buy 3 TD's much less 31 points at Columbus are minimal. The PSU mania is excessive and, if you will, absurdly premature.
  12. HelloKitty
    12. Posted by HelloKitty Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:42 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    QUOTE:
    "I'm a Tn. Vols fan but they are not very interesting to watch"
    LOL
    How true. I feel ya. I visit Alabama alot and their loyalty is one of the best.
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y3XGKaPgqfg
  13. marcillac
    13. Posted by marcillac Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:06 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    What I mean is that while PSU deserves their current lofty ranking their resume is hardly MNC worthy with minimal prospects for significant enahancement. Objective observers will have to concede that wins over Coastal Carolina, Syracuse and Temple have ZERO probative value. The one over Oregon State not much more. Surely the team that was demolished in Happy Valley bears almost no relationship to the one that not merely beat but physically dominated USC in Corvallis last Thursday.
    Given OSU's flops in big games recently, PSU struggle in 8-5 FSU in the 2006 Sugar Bowl and Wiscy's difficulties at Fresno State which had its onw problems with UCLA, one would be hard pressed to argue that an undefeated Penn State would warrant a preferance over a 1 loss SEC or Big 12 champion.
  14. Be Honest
    14. Posted by Be Honest Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:08 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    its ridiculous how obvious the buckeye bias is. yes osu has had there fair share of fortunes in the past few seasons but isnt that the beauty of being a college football fan. The program you support recruiting to maintain its level of performance year in year out despite what happened in the past. Fair is fair and fair is not the ap poll which didnt even move osu up 1 slot. Georgia got whalloped by a ranked team just like osu but at home, usc and florida lost to unranked teams and are still ahead of osu. If youre a florida, georgia, tennessee or lsu fan call your alumni now and beg them for marlon brown cause him, devier posey, and pryor are really going to light up the scoreboards for years to come. Dear buckeye haters, we are continuing to recruit and sign the best so to qoute the honest words of our young phenom terelle pryor, it sure is great to be a buckeye.
  15. mark t
    15. Posted by mark t Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:29 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Bama is so bad!!!!! Big O line Big D line,kids runnin all over d place on both sides o the ball !!!! Go Irish and you gotta love Vanderbilt!! What a blast to watch!!
  16. big b
    16. Posted by big b Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:37 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Ok all these folks made the big deal last week about the SEC having 3 teams in the top ten. Now its 3 teams to 2 in the big 12's favor. If Oklahoma and Texas meet each other and are undefeated, then most likely nothing will stop that winning team from getting to the national championship
  17. SpartanDan
    17. Posted by SpartanDan Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:11 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Chris - If Oregon State goes on a tear, we can re-evaluate the USC loss to them. But for now, it looks like a really terrible loss. That said, most of the teams behind them have equally ugly performances on their resumes (losing to Ole Miss, beating Miss State 3-2, getting annihilated by said USC team). USC should probably be #11 - Georgia and South Florida should both be ahead for sure.
  18. blasenified
    18. Posted by blasenified Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:09 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    13. OSU fans are living in a fantasy world. We all know what happens when OSU plays an SEC team, BLOWOUT for the SEC. The number one recruiting class this year was Alabama followed by Norte Dame.
    Lets face it, putting Ohio State into a championship game with an SEC team is like offering human sacrifice.
    All you USC fans, please explain why you deserve a top 10 ranking after getting destroyed by an unranked, sorry team like Oregon State. Especially when Georgia gets knocked down to 11 after loosing to currently #2 Alabama?
    Speaking of bias, who has Oklahoma played to deserve a #1 ranking?
  19. Be Honest
    19. Posted by Be Honest Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:08 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Why does USC Trojans get so much props for dismantling big ten teams in the rose bowl and they're playing at home? LSU won both their titles at home this decade, man I can't wait for the playoffs.
  20. BrnxBmbr
    20. Posted by BrnxBmbr Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:25 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I agree with the last comment #13. As much as I cannot stand Ohio State, and as much as I know they had no business being in the last 2 title games they were in, its complete bull that they dropped as much as they did, losing to the #1 team in the country without their offensive star RB, and USC is still in the top 10 losing to a 1-2 unranked team. You cant base rankings on what you think a team might do the rest of the year. Oregon State may win more games then they lose and may end up with a decent looking record... but look who its against... other Pac 10 teams. UCLA and Cal are beyond horrible this year. Dont pay attention to the rankings and the what if's... watch the games. You cant make the comparisons either, for instance like, Penn State killed Oregon State, Oregon State owned USC, so Penn State is better than USC. It always seems like most of the poll voters dont watch the games, or they are so biased they dont vote true how they should. Granted, they got it right moving Alabama to #2. But its utterly atrocious that USC is #9. I'de love to see a rematch between them and USC with Ohio States RB healthy. And as much as I hate to throw love out for a Buckeye... Pryor will be better than Sanchez could even think about being, and he'll prove it playing better teams.
  21. BATSON
    21. Posted by BATSON Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:02 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    The ranking system blows. Im a Georgia fan when they are not playing Vanderbilt (yeah im a vandy student! Go Dores!). If someone can just explain how USC is ahead of UGA, im all ears! USC loses to OSU, while UGA loses to then #8 Alabama and they drop out of the top ten!? How does that make any sense? Well I guess this just shows how RIGGED tthe BSC is! thank you and goodnight.
  22. bluebrown2656@yahoo.com
    22. Posted by bluebrown2656@yahoo.com Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:09 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    ive been a sooners fan for decades now and although i admit their schedule so far has been fair--cincy and tcu especially are decent teams--IF they get thru the rest of their schedule winning they will deserve to be in the national title game. when you consider theyd probably have to beat texas texas tech kansas at oklahoma st.--then probably mizzou in the conference title game--they would then definately deserve to be there--all i know is they are a lot better off since bob stoops took the ou head coaching job--GO SOONERS
  23. Ernie R
    23. Posted by Ernie R Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:45 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I'm a ACC fan,please don't feel to bad for me{We'll getting better} I love to watch football. As for USC being higher in the polls than Ohio St., they should be. Ohio St. got beat bad,real bad by USC, so why should USC be lower than them. If Penn keeps playing like they are, this years Big 10 Champions. As for the polls, I would like to know how they pick the top teams too. From the games i've seen no Big 10 team but Penn should be in the top 15. The Big 12 is almost as bad. there are better teams out there that play harder games so the win to lost record is not as good. I myself don't think that no Big 10 team can play in the SEC {maybe Penn this year} and come out with a winning record.
  24. Ron J
    24. Posted by Ron J Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:29 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Ok all im saying the crimson asshats have to play in rocky top and they WILL get waxed in Death Valley, we'll definately do what we did last year in 'loosa.... saban may not make it out of the big raggety.... and don't forget the iron bowl.... Bama will sparkle and fade
  25. Rusty G
    25. Posted by Rusty G Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:23 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    #24, with your wonderful grammar and stellar vocabulary, I recognized you for a LSU fan even before you bashed Bama. Don't have such an inferiority complex. It is OK for you to be of diminished mental capacity. Please don't try to cover your own shortcomings by bashing Bama. Contrary to your popular belief, Nick Saban left the NFL for Alabama, not LSU.

Dr. Saturday

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Matt Hinton

Dr. Saturday is a college football blog edited by Matt Hinton. Email him tips and feedback.

Related Photo Gallery

Featured NCAAF Video

Y! Sports Blogs

Dr. Saturday Recent Readers