Dr. Saturday - NCAAF

Delaware State endured the rare one-two punch Saturday: Not only were the outmanned Hornets on the wrong end of a ghastly 63-6 beating at the hands of Michigan, the most lopsided defeat in Michigan Stadium in nine years and the first 60-point effort by the Wolverines since 1992; in effect, they also suffered their second conference loss, a forfeit to North Carolina A&T, dropping DSU to 1-2 in the MEAC standings at the same time it was getting the taste knocked out of its mouth in the Big House in a game that never should have happened.

On the first, obvious level, it never should have happened because resource and talent-rich programs like Michigan should never descend on the likes of Delaware State for an easy win, even as Homecoming fodder, though the practice of paying lower-division teams for "bodybag games" continues to expand across the country. (The only I-A teams that have never played a I-AA opponent are Notre Dame, Southern Cal, UCLA and Washington, and the Huskies have just added one such cupcake to their 2011 schedule.) But Delaware State shouldn't have been in Ann Arbor, either, because it had a previously scheduled MEAC date on Saturday with NCA&T, a conference rival it had defeated five years in a row.

When Michigan called up Delaware State's administration in the spring -- when DSU was temporarily operating without an athletic director, who surely would have intervened -- with an open date and a $550,000 offer to fill it, Delaware State took the payday without a second thought. But because it couldn't find another date on its schedule that also worked to reschedule with North Carolina A&T, DSU was also hit with an automatic forfeit by the MEAC. The Hornets lose twice in the deal: Once in the conference standings, where they had a fighting chance, and once in front of the largest assembly of humans in college football, where they had none whatsoever.

The final ledger against the Wolverines could not have been more grisly: Michigan outgained DSU by more than 500 total yards despite pulling starting quarterback Tate Forcier after the first series, averaging 10 yards every time it snapped the ball while also blocking a punt for a touchdown for good measure. The Wolverines led 49-0 after two quarters and began emptying the bench at halftime to keep the margin below 100. I hope Michigan's belly is full, the Hornets are enjoying their half-million-dollar payday and the MEAC championship doesn't come down to handing a win to NCA&T, because children had to watch this.

digg delicious
more

115 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. CHIPSWON
    1. Posted by CHIPSWON Sun Oct 18, 2009 10:23 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Do you write this same story alot and just change the team names? This happens all the time now in college football. It happens in the SEC, Big 12, Big 10, ACC, Big East and Pac 10. All the major schools do it now.
    Do you have a problem with Michigan or could you not think of anything else to write?
  2. footballfreak2014
    2. Posted by footballfreak2014 Sun Oct 18, 2009 10:43 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    I agree with chipswon. I didn't see you bash Florida after the 56-6 rout of Troy. Or how bout Cal and East Washington? Oklahoma and Idaho St. It happens every week in every conference, so why don't you put your time and effort into writing about something substantial.
  3. peoplespigskin
    3. Posted by peoplespigskin Sun Oct 18, 2009 10:46 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Michigan should be ashamed of itself for scheduling this 1-AA opponent. Delaware State should be ashamed of itself for sacrificing its own conference hopes. The NCAA should be ashamed of itself for allowing travesties like this to happen on a regular basis with no consequences for the Michigans of the world. (The NCAA should also be ashamed of itself for allowing the B(c)S to continue, but that's for another comment thread.)
  4. jakeisagator
    4. Posted by jakeisagator Sun Oct 18, 2009 10:54 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    You're not getting it. This is a story because Delaware State forfeited a conference game to take a half-million dollar payday. Without that element, it's just another homecoming rout, and the good Doctor doesn't blog about it. Also, Troy isn't I-AA. They play in bowls.
  5. ezryder03
    5. Posted by ezryder03 Sun Oct 18, 2009 10:55 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    To all of you anti Wolverine fans (no one likes a winner do they?) and especially Matt Hinton, another one who does not like the Big Ten, Michigan did not schedule Del St for an easy win. They did so because of the fact that Del St was without a AD at that time and they had a $650,000 hole in their budget that needed to be filled. By playing Michigan in the big house that was Del St's take off the gate receipts - $650,000. Add to that the fact that Rich Rod did not play the starting QB for after the drive, the first drive of the game. UM started emptying the bench before the 1st half ended. Unlike the Tom Osbourne of the 70's who thrived on beating a weak opponent by scores of 70 -0, 80-0 repeatedly, by never taking the first stringers out of the game, UM is and always will be a class act. As for the comment that ND has never played a division 1AA school that may be true, but anyone who has followed college football over the years will realize that Notre Dame's schedule has included Army and Navy since the beginning of time. And those two schools have not fielded a decent team since WWII. Go Blue!!
  6. sacman701
    6. Posted by sacman701 Sun Oct 18, 2009 11:34 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Under the current system, Oklahoma-Idaho State and Michigan-Delaware State combined raise more money than Oklahoma-Michigan and Delaware State-Idaho State would.
    If networks were allowed to bid on tv rights to individual games, it would be the other way around. Send a small fraction of the Oklahoma-Michigan take to Delaware State and Idaho State and everyone comes out ahead, especially the fans.
  7. ezryder03
    7. Posted by ezryder03 Sun Oct 18, 2009 11:47 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Kudos to sacman701
  8. Anne
    8. Posted by Anne Sun Oct 18, 2009 12:11 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I'm a Michigan fan, and even I think Michigan deserves a LITTLE criticism for scheduling such a lopsided mis-match. But Delaware State? They don't deserve it. The cash they got for this could possibly fund their entire athletic budget for this year, and maybe the next. They didn't intend to forfeit a game, that was an unavoidable consequence. And the Hornets were 1-2 in conference play before this, I doubt they were favored to win, and does anyone really think it likely this forfeit will decide it? Sheesh, lighten up.
  9. mikebonowc
    9. Posted by mikebonowc Sun Oct 18, 2009 12:30 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    This was not Michigan's homecoming game - homecoming was Indiana a couple weeks ago.
  10. SheilaE
    10. Posted by SheilaE Sun Oct 18, 2009 1:15 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    You know, up until 2 years ago, Michigan was on that short list of schools to have never played a 1-AA/FCS opponent. Then they brought App State in.
  11. dougr188
    11. Posted by dougr188 Sun Oct 18, 2009 2:12 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Hey look everyone yet another half researched blog by one of the worse writers out there.
    Fancy that.
  12. Adam O
    12. Posted by Adam O Sun Oct 18, 2009 2:16 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    @11 yeah then they brought App State in, and we all know how that worked out for UM. LOL
  13. Mark
    13. Posted by Mark Sun Oct 18, 2009 2:19 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Michigan got an easy win. Delaware State's athletic department got more money than they could have ever asked for. Win win situation.
  14. Rick Y
    14. Posted by Rick Y Sun Oct 18, 2009 2:21 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    1st ,yes
  15. Rick Y
    15. Posted by Rick Y Sun Oct 18, 2009 2:21 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    1st ,yes
  16. Richard
    16. Posted by Richard Sun Oct 18, 2009 2:25 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    The entire practice of stronger division teams playing lower division is stupid. Who wants to watch such a mismatched game other than drunk students and alumni?
  17. ZachariahT
    17. Posted by ZachariahT Sun Oct 18, 2009 2:25 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Obviously, this shouldn't happen mid-season. This helps small programs (1-AA) fund their athletic fees. It also provides underclassmen real game experience in their first few games. When done at the beginning of the season, they work. Some of these games play out a lot worse than the administrations thought they would because they are generally scheduled a couple of years in advance. Keep in mind, 1-AA teams schedule D2 schools and both benefit via the same reasons.
    Of course, top caliber teams could schedule fierce opposition to break in their younger players, but it jeopardizes the money and prestige they would get if they schedule these cupcake games. A loss unfortunately takes you out of the conversation early. Two losses and you'll be forgotten by week four.
    And, then, again, if you didn't have these lopsided schedulings, you'd never have that Montana State win over Colorado three years ago. That was glorious. Go Cats.
  18. Doug
    18. Posted by Doug Sun Oct 18, 2009 2:27 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    They should have play Applachian State woops they did and their standings went from #1 to whatever. They also lost to APP STATE. Well!!! Next time pick a harder team.. just imagine if delelware would have beat them.
  19. Jake
    19. Posted by Jake Sun Oct 18, 2009 2:29 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Some of these games are set because someone in one athletic department knows someone in the other and the small school desperately needs the money for its athletic program. Delaware State can now provide it's kids with quality equipment for the sports they want to play.
  20. brandon.gevaert
    20. Posted by brandon.gevaert Sun Oct 18, 2009 2:29 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    who doesn't see the bias in this story????????????
  21. The Florida VIP Discount Card
    21. Posted by The Florida VIP Discount Card Sun Oct 18, 2009 2:30 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    to ezryder03, what village are you from, I need to contact them to let them know their idiot escaped.
    TO, One of the most well liked and respected coaches of all time did not leave his starters in during blow outs as with most top notch programs. If you are unable to keep up with reality you might just want to sit out of this posting business.
  22. willtalley3rd
    22. Posted by willtalley3rd Sun Oct 18, 2009 2:30 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I do understand that many Division 1 schools do play Division 1AA schools and even though I am not a Michigan fan I think Michigan did nothing wrong here. The only thing I dislike is that some of these Division 1 schools shecdule these Division 1AA opponents in the middle of their schedule. Michigan could have gotten someone to play. I am sure West Virginia would welcome Michigan any time. I am though disapointed that Deleware State truly did this all for the money, and willing to forefit a confrence game. I hope it was worth it.
  23. Michael M
    23. Posted by Michael M Sun Oct 18, 2009 2:32 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Oh... this is just plain and simply awful.... The NCAA should fine teams for doing this... Why don't they (MIchigan) HIre a high school team to beat up on? This is the most unsportsman like thing I have ever heard of in my life! I can't believe they let this go on... Unbelievable... Maybe if the Division II team was averaging 400 yards per game in offense, has an unbelievable defense and is destroying all their opponents and needs a challenge, and scoring an average of 35 points per game or something... but this is ridiculous.... This wasn't even a challenge for Michigan... They emptied their bench in this game and put in 2nd string and 3rd string in this game, and they still stomped on them! I have lost all respect for Michigan! And any team that does this... They should get a $1million dollar fine for doing this!
  24. Mark
    24. Posted by Mark Sun Oct 18, 2009 2:32 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    does anyone remember what app. st. did to michigan a couple years ago in the big house?
  25. Michael M
    25. Posted by Michael M Sun Oct 18, 2009 2:35 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    One more thing... It's unbelievable how the NCAA will punish as student athlete for accepting gifts, but Universities can do the most horrendous things and then pay $1/2 million dollars to do something so completely unsportsmanlike, and nobody says nothing! The athletes do all the work, and the Universities indiscriminately make $$$ Millions and millions of dollars doing these unscrupulous things and get away with it every single freaking year! I say make a Labor Union for the college athletes so they have legal representation in every area so the Sick, Freaking Universities can't get away with Bull [profane] like this!!!!!

Dr. Saturday

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Matt Hinton

Dr. Saturday is a college football blog edited by Matt Hinton. Email him tips and feedback.

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Dr. Saturday Recent Readers