Dr. Saturday - NCAAF

In the long lean months of summer, from the bloggers to the beat writers, no one itching for content is immune from a little easy offseason squirrel bait. Equal parts non-story, laziness and hot-button rabble-rousing, it's the refuge of even the best of us at one time or another.

Then there are veteran Mad Libbers like columnist/hobgoblin Paul Finebaum who, while actual Alabama news is breaking, can shake the 8-ball, open the inbox, blame Tommy Tuberville for the last three years of Iron Bowl backbiting in one swoop and be on the first tee by two:

In the wake of this war between the two fan bases, the question must be asked: Who started the fire? Did Auburn fans simply come up with these allegations? Or did someone higher up start making allegations privately, thus tangentially encouraging fans to start spreading the word on Saban?

Well, there is simple answer to that complex question.

Tommy Tuberville.
[...]
Within weeks of Saban's arrival, Tuberville was making claims the new Alabama coach was breaking rules of every kind. He told this to his staff, certain media members and boosters.

The objective here is twofold: a) To remind the audience that Paul Finebaum is a Certain Media Member, and to b) rile up his core audience of baiters, haters and conspiracy theorists. Note how he expertly invokes the two topics guaranteed to draw blood from the Crimson Tide faithful: Auburn and Phillip Fulmer (briefly mentioned in a cunning aside for his alleged snitchin' on Tide recruiting malfeasance earlier this decade).

He paints by the belligerent numbers so skillfully that you hardly bother to notice that ... there's nothing there. Nothing to such a degree that we honestly wonder what Finebaum's doing putting this much effort into his word count. He could write the headline, "Is Tuberville at the heart of the rumor mill?" followed by an entire column consisting solely of the words, "Probably not," and gin up precisely the same level of traffic and righteous indignation on the Alabama boards.

The more we reread this piece, the more we admire its diabolical simplicity, the craft of it. It's not only a two-page gossip column about nothing of any verifiable substance whatsoever -- it cops straightaway to its vacuousness:

To date, there hasn't been a single allegation publicly made, but it hasn't stopped a barrage of charges to surface all over the Internet and in the mailboxes of major media members throughout the state.

Again, notice he's perfectly on message: Paul Finebaum is a Major Player who receives Major Allegations, and there's nothing to these allegations ... unless there is! We're reasonably sure he knows something about his sources and all, but it ain't in this story. He just says "Yeah, Tuberville, I heard about that," but he doesn't come close to backing it up even with second- or third-hand heresay. No, Finebaum carefully skirts even the barest hint of actual sourcing:

People have heard him make allegations about Saban and Alabama's recruiting in a public place with several ears trained on his voice.

Heady stuff. They heard 'im! It's sort of genius, in its way -- he's maximizing Alabama's dudgeon potential and will receive minimal pushback from Auburn fans, since Tuberville's not their problem anymore, which will just lend it additional credence. Until tomorrow, that is, when they're presented with their next shiny object. (Our money's on Lache Seastrunk being spirited around in an Escalade ... driven by the costumed Auburn mascot. Unless ... j'accuse! Lache Seastrunk is the Auburn mascot!)

The only bit of the whole operation that conveys a fact-like substance -- and the only part that suggests Finebaum has ever communicated with anyone in possession of actual information -- is a 25-year-old anecdote meant to convey the columnist's intimate knowledge of How These Things Work:

I'll never forget Pat Dye screaming over the phone one night to me about the man from Georgia Tech (then-Alabama coach Bill Curry), using every curse word in the book and some I had never heard. He was less concerned about the allegations (the NCAA ultimately cleared Auburn) than the fact Curry never bothered to call first.

"We had a deal," Dye said. "I did with Coach Bryant and Ray (Perkins), and I had the same arrangement."

Simpler times. When men were men, mice were mice, and sweetheart deals could be protected from the Internet. (Unrelated: Any remembered quote from Pat Dye should end, "Now where are my pants?" "We had a deal! Now where are my pants?" Carry on.)

Yes, as paint-by-numbers gossip pieces go, this is a masterstroke. A ton of smoke coming out of the windows, and no fire. And Paul Finebaum's tossing the smokebombs. But here's what we can't figure out: Finebaum's ears have to be filled with this kind of chatter, day in and day out, for years on end. Why is he lending credence to this age-old spat now?

Well, there is simple answer to that complex question. Tommy Tuberville. (See? The system works!)

digg delicious
more

23 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. Benjamin
    1. Posted by Benjamin Tue Jun 09, 2009 6:06 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    It's not nice to pick on the special people, Miss Holly. Leave Finebaum alone.
  2. Holly
    2. Posted by Holly Tue Jun 09, 2009 6:14 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Everyone needs a hobby.
  3. JSR
    3. Posted by JSR Tue Jun 09, 2009 6:45 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    hobgoblin! thats great, i've been searching for a troll-like category to file the f-baum under
  4. Carl V
    4. Posted by Carl V Tue Jun 09, 2009 6:55 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    "Unless ... j'accuse! Lache Seastrunk is the Auburn mascot!"
    Clearly, he fits the description of a War Tiger Plainsman Eagle.
  5. bamasux
    5. Posted by bamasux Tue Jun 09, 2009 7:22 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    PLEASE, OH PLEASE DOC: REMOVE FINEBAUM FROM YOUR SOURCES. HE HAS NO ADDED VALUE TO ANY DISCUSSION ABOUT FOOTBALL IN AL.
    Yes, I am a life long AU fan (grew up in Auburn).
    The man is a hack pandering to the lowest common denominator of both AU & UA fan base to increase his ratings.
    Please boycott this idiot.
  6. bamasux
    6. Posted by bamasux Tue Jun 09, 2009 7:26 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Holly:
    Please boycott this idiot.....I just assumed it was Hinton....my bad!
  7. Holly
    7. Posted by Holly Tue Jun 09, 2009 7:31 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    bamasux, I try not to read him unless I absolutely must...but there was no staying away from this one. Even for Finebaum, it's looney tunes.
  8. justmetalkinghere
    8. Posted by justmetalkinghere Tue Jun 09, 2009 7:43 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Holly:
    Proves my point....the guy is lower than pond scum...right there with his listeners. He does not deserve one mention from you, Doc, Orson, Blutarsky and Hinnen and every other credible college football blogger.
    Ya'lls silence as it relates to him, hurts him more than your desire to bash him. Let's boycott him and make him irrelevenant.
  9. bamasux
    9. Posted by bamasux Tue Jun 09, 2009 8:08 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    BTW:
    All you readers:
    Do not click to him...BOYCOTT BOYCOTT BOYCOTT!!!!!!
    POWER TO REAL SEC ANND COLLEGE FOOTBALL FANS!!!!
  10. Jai
    10. Posted by Jai Wed Jun 10, 2009 9:00 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    I haven't listened to Finebaum in well over five years...and it's been wonderful. :D
  11. Michael
    11. Posted by Michael Wed Jun 10, 2009 9:28 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Excellent article Ms. Anderson. He really does the same rhetorical template over and over. Thanks for the good read.
  12. Keith
    12. Posted by Keith Wed Jun 10, 2009 9:32 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Holly,
    Outstanding article. I wonder, when Finebaum reads this, if he gets all teary-eyed thinking about the days when he used to give a crap about what he wrote and considered a good column...and how he migrated into a slothful, pathetic hack.
    Keith
    P.S. Extra credit for slipping a "j'accuse!" into your article. Well done, indeed.
  13. Jim S
    13. Posted by Jim S Wed Jun 10, 2009 10:15 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Finebaum is nothing more than a muck-raker who lives in filth and ineundo. Auburn people ignore him except for a few people who still call in and make a fool of themselves. If it were not for his bammers, he would have no program. This article was an attempt to rile the few Auburn fools I mentioned and hope to increase his sagging ratings. This state would be so much better off if FineSCUM was taken off the air. If people would quit listening, he would simply go away.
  14. Edmond Dantes
    14. Posted by Edmond Dantes Wed Jun 10, 2009 10:16 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Holly,
    Job very well done. Keep up the great work.
  15. aufantatufa
    15. Posted by aufantatufa Wed Jun 10, 2009 10:31 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    FINALLY! I haven't seen this kind of passionate denouncing of this jerk before in print - but it is well deserved and a long time coming. There aren't strong enough words to describe how evil this man is. I only ever listen to him when my talk radio station gets left on until over in the afternoon, when he's on. I always regret not turning it immediately. What a hack - It was well said above - he panders to the lowest common denominator of both fan bases (all of whom could fall off the earth for all I care). THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU
  16. Jonathan D
    16. Posted by Jonathan D Wed Jun 10, 2009 10:33 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    The Rush Limbaugh of sports writers? First of all, Limbaugh isn't a writer genius. ; ) But if you want to compare him to anyone in the entertainment industry, I think Jerry Springer is the most appropriate.
  17. PurdueMatt
    17. Posted by PurdueMatt Wed Jun 10, 2009 11:01 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Limbaugh is actually insightful and provides valuable information and analysis. Not even comparable.
  18. CrimsonJake
    18. Posted by CrimsonJake Wed Jun 10, 2009 12:17 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I like your style Holly, but you're no Finebaum. Ü
  19. Holly
    19. Posted by Holly Wed Jun 10, 2009 12:53 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    "....you're no Finebaum. "
    And thank the good Lord for THAT.
  20. Ray H
    20. Posted by Ray H Wed Jun 10, 2009 1:17 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    At last someone that will say whats on their mind without being scared to go against the grain, Finebaum is a person who for some reason starts more crap than the law allows just in the name of ratings, He really has no substance outside the alabama football fans... Its his whole purpose to keep the fans of alabama slobbering at the mouth and fake callers to bash Auburn. The state of alabama needs a real sports talk show , We have the fans from both sides and others such a Troy university and Alabama state , Many others as well , Thanks Holly Anderson...Could Yahoo have a sports show in Alabama for the sports fans?
  21. Sapper
    21. Posted by Sapper Wed Jun 10, 2009 2:34 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Great job seeing through the thinly disguised Finebum. He is definitely a hack playing to the different fanbases emotions with much less than a thread of evidence. If you get a chance Holly, ask him about all the info on the recruiting improprieties at UA that he suppossedly has and why doesn't he write about that?
  22. two_smellyfeet
    22. Posted by two_smellyfeet Wed Jun 10, 2009 9:27 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Jim S "FineSCUM" is a great name for him. Thanks for that one. I had always been partial to "Slimebaum" until now.
  23. johnofbham
    23. Posted by johnofbham Thu Jun 11, 2009 10:57 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Finebaum poses as a "Bear" authority but had no cred until Bryant's retirement. He couldn't stand little Bowden and absolutely hated Tuberville because the coach wouldn't give him the time of day. That is why he blames Tubs.
    He has fallen all over himself trying to groom a relationship with Lil Nicky whom we know only uses him as a tool.
    And the fact is: Tuscaloosa and Auburn have no real problems coexisting, nor have they in the past. Fulmer was a bigger problem for UA during his tenure than the total of Auburn head coaches since Shug Jordan. The "bad blood" term is one of invention. The comment after the shanked punt re: "...don't you know how much I hate those bleeping bleeps is the first negative snipe by one coach toward another team in the series since the sixties. And I think mini-Satan knew that would be repeated to add to the folklore. The series is actually very tame, sorry to disappoint.

Dr. Saturday

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Matt Hinton

Dr. Saturday is a college football blog edited by Matt Hinton. Email him tips and feedback.

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Dr. Saturday Recent Readers