Dr. Saturday - NCAAF

Unless he's injured -- and I imagine he walks around with both personal body guards and a custom foam bodysuit as preventative measures -- the odds of Jimmy Clausen not starting Notre Dame's season opener against Nevada are somewhere around zero. Clausen was all but anointed the moment he signed on with Charlie Weis, he's entrenched two seasons in and he's coming off the best effort of his career, having finally shown the promise in the bowl win over Hawaii that made him the most hyped quarterback recruit in the country two years ago.

But, just for the sake of argument, as long as we're navigating the dire straits of March, Weis would like to remind the other five-star slinger on his roster, sophomore-to-be Dayne Crist, that the door remains open:

Crist is right with Irish coach Charlie Weis' thoughts as the team moves through its first week of spring drills: Weis wants Crist to push starting quarterback Jimmy Clausen -- even if Clausen is fairly entrenched at the spot -- and Crist intends to do just that.
[...]
"It's an obstacle. Jimmy has paid his dues and he's done great. But I can't let that stop me from being who I am ... Whether it be tomorrow or in a week or a year, I'm not going to stop until I get what I want. And what I want is being out on the field and winning games for Notre Dame."

Weis personally backs up the "competition" angle, which is very big of him, but I think the language here is appropriate: Crist pushing Clausen is still mainly about Clausen's progress into becoming the kind of quarterback he was recruited to be.

On that front, Year Three should be the "Leap Year," when substance replaces potential, which is presumably what Weis and Clausen (and Crist, in his way) are striving for. Taken as a whole, Clausen's numbers show him right on schedule to take that next step up:

That's a strong improvement across the board, with the notable exception of interceptions, but the accompanying leap in the average gain and especially in touchdowns still led to a fairly dramatic improvement in the most important categories: efficiency rating, scoring and, of course, winning. This is exactly the schedule you'd expect for a young passer growing into his role.

Look a little deeper, though, and suddenly that rate of progress nearly disappears when you cut away the chaffe:

The improvement is still there, but nowhere does it even remotely match the huge strides Clausen made against inferior defenses (of which he saw twice as many in '08 as in '07); in most respects, especially when it comes to touchdowns and overall efficiency -- and, yes, to his offense's and his team's overall success -- sophomore Clausen wasn't discernibly better than freshman Clausen against the best teams on the schedule.

This would be the next logical step in Jimmy's career trajectory: Competence against competent defenses. If Weis can't get that at this point in the story -- and assuming he's still around to make decisions, which isn't a very likely combination -- then Crist might be worth a serious look. But not until then.

digg delicious
more

11 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. the_voidoid138
    1. Posted by the_voidoid138 Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:06 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    (Note - ND opens against Nevada, not San Diego State)
  2. NDFAN
    2. Posted by NDFAN Thu Sep 03, 2009 11:00 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Clausen has a good arm and can make all the throws..if he is VERY well protected. Outside of that I think he is an unathletic quarterback. He has poor foot speed and basically looks like a statue in the pocket. In no way comparing the two's overall experience and abiltiy, Brady Quinn could move in the pocket and run when he had to; Clausen is a statue. Maybe his judgement would get better if he could buy himself some time in the pocket. No one expects him to be Vince Young; how about just a little more "Quinn-ish"
  3. dodgers fan 99
    3. Posted by dodgers fan 99 Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:31 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    first page
  4. gtne91
    4. Posted by gtne91 Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:43 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Doc - I refer you to your study of freshman starters from last offseason. Unless he is one of those few who grows into a superstar, the expectation for a freshman is reversion to the mean, which he has done. Another 2 years of 2008 numbers seems the most likely outcome.
    However, if he is one of the lucky few, ND will be competing for the national title in 2010.
  5. Matt H
    5. Posted by Matt H Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:48 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Thanks Void. Noted and corrected.
  6. HERETIC
    6. Posted by HERETIC Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:30 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    The bottom line is that they will still be praying a lot. having daily magic shows to back the team up is like putting 22 players on the field against the infidels.
  7. glen
    7. Posted by glen Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:09 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    they have a pretty solid schedule next year too, with uconn, usc, boston college, nevada, pittsburgh, navy and mich st, all bowl teams in 09, time to show all us ND haters, whether they're worth all this hype, if i don't see marked improvement, its time to move up in the big east
  8. bobby
    8. Posted by bobby Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:10 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    clausen is a good qb that has suffered on a team that needs an line and a coach
  9. Iken-Biken
    9. Posted by Iken-Biken Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:03 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    If Crist has to go on the field in place of Clausen, all Weiss has to do is whisper in his ear: "Brigade 9"!
    The Irish will be BCCS champs by end of season, guaranteed.
  10. everloyal
    10. Posted by everloyal Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:27 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    What exactly does the second chart prove? Don't you expect ANY quarterback's numbers to decrease when comparing all games to only the good teams?
    For example, pick a beloved QB, let's make one up. Jim Jebow has really good numbers against the Coastal Carolinas and the LSUs, but only decent numbers against the LSU-caliber teams. Isn't that logical? Isn't that obvious? These numbers prove nothing except that good teams are harder to beat than average teams....which has nothing to do with Jim Jebow or Jimmy Clausen.
  11. Matt H
    11. Posted by Matt H Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:48 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Everyloyal -- I think you've missed the main thrust of the post. It's not that the numbers aren't as high against winning teams as against losing teams; as you say, almost no team's or quarterback's are. The point, though, is Clausen's rate of improvement: He showed a huge leap from freshman to sophomore year against losing teams, but performed basically the same against better teams. The improvement in those games -- again, compared to his freshman year against the same level of competition, not his performance against weaker teams last year -- was minimal. That's the next step in his development.

Dr. Saturday

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Matt Hinton

Dr. Saturday is a college football blog edited by Matt Hinton. Email him tips and feedback.

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Dr. Saturday Recent Readers