Dr. Saturday - NCAAF

Scroll down or click here to join the Doc's game day live blog.

Penn State 13, Ohio State 6. Well, that was more like your grandfather's Big Ten than the electric light show promised by athletic quarterbacks operating out of the spread. Penn State will take it. Up until Pat Devlin lunged for the only touchdown with about six minutes to play, Ohio State would have taken it, too. A tough road win is a tough road win, and PSU comes out the other side looking even feistier on defense, with only Iowa, Indiana and Michigan State between it and 12-0.

As Brent Musburger pointed out late in the the game, there were two big goose eggs for the Lions: zero penalties and, more importantly, zero turnovers. Ohio State's best starting position of the night was its own 39, and when the ball squirted out of Terrelle Pryor's hands on third and short at midfield, with the Buckeyes up 6-3 and already in clock-killing mode, Penn State took advantage of the only major mistake and the only good field position of the night to drive 38 yards for the winning touchdown -- and a good chunk of that came via another OSU mistake, a pass interference penalty for the full 15 yards. Between Wells and Terrelle Pryor, the only Buckeyes to log carries, Ohio State averaged two yards per carry with a long run of nine. You know, disciplined defense, taking care of the ball, punting, all that rot. Even in HD, sometimes it works.

I may be less bothered by the Lions' "style points," or lack thereof, for the same reason it doesn't bother me that Alabama didn't blow Kentucky or Ole Miss out of the stadium. For one, Penn State earned plenty of style points in crushing Oregon State and Wisconsin and convincingly beating Illinois and Michigan. The tempo of tonight's game didn't lend itself to big scoring -- Pryor clearly was not going to hurt Penn State downfield, even when he had guys open, and there was no reason to give him a chance by making a mistake against the Buckeye defense -- and the team that can hang in a slugfest and let its defense carry it through a big game on the road should be able to hang tough with anyone. That's the theory, at least, and assuming either Texas or Alabama has a loss in front of it down the stretches, we're only three more Lion wins (and probably a few creepy, quasi-eulogies to poor Joe Paterno) from testing it with a championship on the line.

digg delicious
more

25 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. Ummmm
    1. Posted by Ummmm Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:34 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    The score was 13-6. And Pryor fumbled.
  2. HUh!!
    2. Posted by HUh!! Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:06 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    ugly but its a win congrats to state, keep it going
  3. Adam S
    3. Posted by Adam S Thu Sep 03, 2009 2:45 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    13-6
  4. Jon
    4. Posted by Jon Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:02 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    awesome. im glad penn state won this way. cause now they need to re-tune their already stellar offense and now we know how the defense works against a good team. after all the trash the media was talking about penn state, they came out with a sloppy offense, but a stellar defensive victory. penn state, who was the true underdog in the media, contained beanie wells (dont use an injury as an excuse) and held pryor the best they good. awesome win, win out state!
  5. Jon
    5. Posted by Jon Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:02 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    plus osu, to show how inexperienced pryor is, he said after the game "i was on my way to scoring a touchdown, and i lost it." he was at midfield behind the line of scrimmage with 4 PSU guys in front of him, why on earth are you looking for a touchdown, you need a first down 1st! this aint high school terrelle. it's just a rookie move, he'll learn and become a great QB for the bucks for the next few years. he's got the potential, but obviously was on another planet thinking he was gonna score a TD on that play. not even michael vick or randall cunningham would have scored a TD on that play. (maybe randall). tressel will be on him for that comment.
  6. Sabes
    6. Posted by Sabes Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:59 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Joe Pa is not coaching PSU anymore! he's just on the bus for the ride to collect wins and hopefully beat Coach Bowden! Good thing Joe has a competent coaching staff!
  7. Eric K
    7. Posted by Eric K Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:55 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I was disapointed with all the ANAList this vweek, not giving PSU a chance. Stack 8 men in the box, shut down OSU. It's that simple. Beanie Wells = Overrated. Come on people.
  8. Sam @ WWAHT
    8. Posted by Sam @ WWAHT Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:16 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Never understood the point of calling your opponent overrated. Beanie Wells is as good as advertised, but the Penn State defense is better than advertised. Think about it: Wells had huge games Wisconsin last year, Penn State last year, Michigan State last year, Michigan last year, LSU last year, and Michigan State this year. Penn State did a good job of limiting him, but don't demean that by calling him overrated.
    Of course, logic and common sense are not PSU fan's fortes, as we all know.
  9. Clay
    9. Posted by Clay Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:00 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Crushing mediocre teams like Oregon st., Wisconsin, Michigan, and Illinois means earning "style points"? C'mon Matt, you're better than this. So much better.
    I like Joe Pa as much as the next guy, but this team belong nowhere near the championship game.
  10. pilgrimway.geo
    10. Posted by pilgrimway.geo Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:11 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    The snottiness and elitism of the BCS and the voters is already starting, saying Penn State is unworthy to play in the BCS championship if they go 12-0 for the simple reason that they play in the Big 10. If Penn State is 12-0, they have earned their shot, even if they don't play in the holy Big 12 or SEC. The point is to WIN, and Penn State has played impressively so far. If there are 3 teams (Texas, Alabama and Penn State) who are undefeated at season's end, then you might have a problem because I think Penn State is #3, but if there are only two undefeated teams and Penn State is one of them, they had better be in the championship game or the BCS will exposed for the farce that it is, once again.
  11. michael
    11. Posted by michael Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:11 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    All this talk of saying Penn St. doesnt desrve a shot at the title is nuts. What about the times Penn St. won the title and wasnt in the Big 10. Nobody complained then. Penn St. proved last night they are not a fluke and are in the running. Joe pa is coaching from the box now instead of the sidelines. So I say go Penn St. and show them all you have what it takes.
  12. kyle m
    12. Posted by kyle m Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:55 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Important note: I watched this football game like former Linebacker AJ Hawk of OSU Football. What stood out to me the most was not the clear cut reasons PSU beat OSU but the clear cut reason why Terrelle Pryor should have not went to OSU in the first place. Jim Tressell dangled over his head the simple recent facts that OSU plays in the top games year and year out. T.P. you can run a pro-set offense for the pros. "PLZ" But so does UM that's right MICHIGAN Baby. Michigan plays in the same top games and T.P. you would have been in a system "Taylor Made" for you.
    Terrell Pryor you do not fit in the OSU offense, they suckered you into playing for them and the loser of the UM & OSU battle are both Football Programs. Until Michigan and coach Rich find a quarterback capable of running that offense they will have no luck. I am hopefull we Michigan fans will find that QB. I think we have one that has not played yet in Feagin.
    Michigan should have kept the Q.B. that left for Arkansas. He had playing experience, This situation at Michigan has back fired on Rich Rod but I believe he knew his season would be like this the moment Terrell Pryor signed with OSU.
    Now for PSU take it all PSU JO Pa Go out in style my man. Bring the BCS Home to the BIG TEN. I am a BIG TEN FAN. Part Detroit and New Orleans. SO, I am a Michigan man. North vs. South.
  13. kevin
    13. Posted by kevin Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:34 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Thank you Penn Statte. All u suckeye fans pretty quiet today, couldnt win a big game at home. Beanie who? You got outplayed, outcoached and everything else last noght, like you do every tome in the big games. You will go to a BCS game by default again this year and get crushed by USC again. Save yourselves some time and dont bother going, the country does not want to watch you band of chokers in another BCS blowout.. The better team won last night, lets back track youve played 2 descent teams this year and lost them both, way to go suckeyes. Toledo is the best team in that state.
  14. Jarrekk
    14. Posted by Jarrekk Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:28 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    OSU has better looking guys.. #4, 33, 17, etc.....if PSU does make it to the NC..Texas will crush them..poor Joe Pa..retire already..
  15. 2 Comma Kid
    15. Posted by 2 Comma Kid Thu Sep 03, 2009 6:56 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    i'd hope people would not judge psu on the failures of osu the past few years such as mr. dienhart...
    penn state does much better in bowls and is very balanced this year.
  16. go08lions
    16. Posted by go08lions Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:45 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I can not believe the media already after the game and sunday morning are saying penn state doesnt deserve to be in a bcs championship game. this team is as good as any other undeafeated team in the country, and what puts them above the rest is there defense. Lou Holtz was right last nite you win championships with defense. the offense will be back to form you can bet that. The O didnt play a bad game this is your typical Big Ten grudge. GO PSU I WANT TO BE IN MIAMI IN JANUARY
  17. Price HD
    17. Posted by Price HD Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:04 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I'm as much of a Penn State fan as anyone, but this weekly "team x lost so they're obviously overrated" needs to stop. Ohio State proved it's a tough tough football team last night, and one that will probably be accurately ranked at the end of the season. This game was a classic big11ten slugfest, and a nice reprieve from the weekly sloppy Big XII blowouts where defense need not apply. This was a great game, regardless of who played, regardless of rankings. WE ARE! Undefeated.
  18. y_not_garrekk
    18. Posted by y_not_garrekk Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:58 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    PSU and Joe Pa will need life-support IFand after they make it to the NC...Texas, Alabama, TT, Fla. will beat them down.
  19. go08lions
    19. Posted by go08lions Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:45 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Thats what everybody said about Testeverde and the Hurricanes back in 86. Lions will prevail. The team knows this is JoPa's last season and there going to take him out a winner. This was disgussed in the beginning of the season. Theres Ninety Players and coaches in Penn State that know what lies ahead at the end of this season.
  20. Eric K
    20. Posted by Eric K Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:55 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    well poguemahone at the beginning of the season, he was one of the leading heisman candiates. 22 rushes 55 yards = overrated. osu hasn't impressed me at all this year. they get loved for reasons unknown. beating powerhouses like troy, youngtown st, and ohio and getting crushed by usc, not scoring an offensive touchdown against purdue, and barely beating wisconsin. those factors should be proof enough osu is over-rated as a whole. the above is logic and common sense, something you claim psu fans lack.
  21. Sam @ WWAHT
    21. Posted by Sam @ WWAHT Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:16 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Eric, have you played a down of football in your life? Do you know what an offensive line's responsibilities in the run game are? Can you tell me why most great running backs go to crappy NFL teams and do nothing?
    Barry Sanders could have played for OSU last night and gotten maybe 70 yards. OSU's offensive line is bad, PSU's defensive line is a rabid pack of Vandal chieftains. Does that make Beanie Wells overrated? When he's picked in the top ten next year and is one of the top 5 rushers in terms of yardage in the pros, we'll see. He just doesn't have anything to work with behind a fat, slow, poorly-conditioned offensive line.
  22. Ron F
    22. Posted by Ron F Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:49 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    eric k must have stayed up well past his bedtime last night. little eric k is grouchy this morning and his mommy should talk with him about being a gracious winner since winning is new to him.
  23. tom m
    23. Posted by tom m Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:14 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Would someone please tell me where to get off this crazy ride????? wtf is going on in ann arbor? Michigan was not "that" bad this guy needs to get out of michigan!!!! so what if loyd carr couldnt beat ohio state..at least they had a chance. They cant beat anybody now... great f'n move mi.
    \
  24. PhilipL
    24. Posted by PhilipL Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:00 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    pogue... by your definitions, then the PSU o-line suck as well because they were contained even more than OSU was. They had one successful drive all night against a team that couldn't stop USC worth anything. What do all you Penn State fans have to say about that?
    Ohio State does not have a "great defense" they don't nationally, they do locally. Both Penn St. and Ohio ran incredibly dull and unimaginative plays that were so easy to predict that the defenses just stuffed. 12-0 against teams that don't deserve to be in the BCS bowl games is a good accomplishment. Florida for example lost against one such team. So did USC. But what are we rewarding? Most games won or best team in the nation... now there lies the question... If the disparity wasn't so great that I didn't think Penn would be blown out in the championship game, I'd be happy with them being in the final showdown... but not if they are so mentally weak that a team that doesn't deserve a top 20 ranking gave them such a hard time yesterday. They won not because of their great defense but because of the horrible offense that Ohio State ran with Terrel at the helm.
    That fumble broke his spirit... and it was nobody else's fault but his own. OSU would have won otherwise.
  25. SpartanDan
    25. Posted by SpartanDan Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:11 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Tom: Michigan would be terrible this year no matter who the coach was. When you have about three players on the offense that aren't freshmen, Yakety Sax happens.
    But by all means, please fire RichRod. Make the Year of Pain all for naught and bring in a coach who won't be any better (likely far worse). Make all those spread recruits he's bringing in try to fit into a conventional ground attack next year.
    Michigan will get better ... if they have the patience to wait out the first couple of ugly years while Rodriguez gets his system installed. If not - if they choose to listen to the nutcase wing of Michigan fandom instead - then there will be plenty of schadenfreude to be had by MSU and OSU fans for the next decade.

Dr. Saturday

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Matt Hinton

Dr. Saturday is a college football blog edited by Matt Hinton. Email him tips and feedback.

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Dr. Saturday Recent Readers