Dr. Saturday - NCAAF

The week in the undercards.

Stop me if you've heard this one already.
Navy beat Notre Dame, did you hear? It's been analyzed quite thoroughly in this space already, but one postgame quote deserves some additional attention:

"I wanted to run on the field and jump up and down, but I was kind of tired," said linebacker Ram Vela, who had an interception and fumble recovery. "We'd done it before and we went into this game not really placing as much emphasis or too much importance on it. We just treated it like another game."

Talk about knowing your audience. Notre Dame, just another opponent for the Middies? Defeating the Irish on their own field for the second time in as many trips is one thing, but failing to acknowledge their status as beautiful and unique gridiron snowflakes is really hitting the Domers where it hurts.

On to things of national import.
Check it! TCU hops to No. 4 in the BCS standings with another thorough dismembering of an overmatched Mountain West opponent and, more crucially, an Iowa loss. Ostensibly their toughest remaining matchup for the Horned Frogs is next week's home stand against Utah, but this year's Utes have been skating by so quietly against a lackluster schedule, it's kind of hard to believe last year's undefeated darlings are still very much in the mix at 8-1.

A brief, heretical thought: We're reasonably confident Texas could handle TCU in head-to-head competition ... but wouldn't you kind of love to see the Horned Frogs jump them (sorry for all the frog metaphors) in the standings, just for a week or so, to see the reaction on Lone Star message boards? Some of the more orange corners of the Internet could actually catch fire.

Smurf-turfers, keep the Ducks in your prayers.
Boise State moves up a notch in the BCS standings, to No. 6, thanks to Iowa's demise and despite a close call at Louisiana Tech that has us wondering, mid-major partisans though we are, what the Broncos are still doing in the top ten. With Oregon's loss to Stanford, the Broncos' only signature win is dramatically devalued, and the Ducks remain all Boise has in the way of a BCS-worthy resumé.

A fond farewell to the "Tommy West Is So, So Fired Watch."
We've had our eye on this all season, but with the length of Tommy West's tenure at Memphis we didn't actually think he'd be the first midseason coaching casualty. (OK, maybe we did, but not until the Tigers' first snap against Tennessee Saturday night flew right over the quarterback's head.)

It's hard for us to feel bad about this, mostly because we are of East Tennessee extraction and are bound by blood oath from the cradle to loathe all sporting endeavors from that other end of the state. What we do wonder about is David Elson's near-simultaneous ousting from Western Kentucky just three-quarters of the way into the Hilltoppers' first season as a full-fledged I-A program. What, did they think everything would just fall into place? It's been a bad year for the program -- 0-9 with a 28-7 loss to I-AA Central Arkansas and the worst statistical defense in the nation -- but they've got every excuse to be cellar-bound for a season, right? Unless something happened off the field that we don't know about, it's too soon.

Bleep, bleep, bloop.
Another week, another preposterous set of numbers from Houston quarterback Case Keenum (40-of-60, 522 yards, three touchdowns), another stupidly close call for the Cougars against a Tulsa outfit that should have given a top-15 team little trouble. Did the Golden Hurricane finally lay hands on a post-Malzahn identity offensively, or is Houston's defense really just That Bad?

Elsewhere in C-USA teams we cannot corral ...
We're exhausted trying to make sense of UTEP at this point, so we'll just point out that in the space of six weeks, the Miners have lost to Texas by more than 50 points, knocked Houston out of the top ten, handed Memphis the Tigers' only conference win, upset heavily favored Tulsa and now lost to Tulane, in overtime. Much like anyone who tries to get a handle on the maddening contradictions in El Paso, we give up.

Oh, Yarbnalls.
Our steady, sunny confidence that Idaho will be the team to take down the blue Bronco threat next week in Boise took a body blow Saturday, when the Vandals fell to Fresno State, 31-21, despite outscoring the Bulldogs 21-7 in the second half. Desolee.

Watch your MAC backs.
Temple's seven-game winning streak, unlikely romp to a near-certain bowl bid and position atop the MAC East are securely intact, but a 1-9 Miami (Ohio) team fresh off its first win of 2009 gave the Owls quite a scare, cutting the Temple secondary to ribbons for 426 aerial yards and holding fast to their final lead until the Owls knocked through the game-winning kick with three seconds on the clock.

Profiles in continuing ineptitude.
Four winless teams trudged into the weekend, and four winless trudge out. Eastern Michigan was downed by Northern Illinois, 50-6, but from there things got a little more interesting: Rice played SMU close to the final minutes, New Mexico hung tough for a whole quarter against Utah, and Western Kentucky only trailed by one at the half en route to a 40-20 loss at the hands of Sun Belt powerhouse Troy, which apparently wasn't enough improvement to save their coach's skin.

What should have been ...
We really wanted that Virginia Tech-ECU tilt to tilt the other way. The Pirates had a rebranded field and everything! The ominous new aesthetics alone should have been worth the upset.

... and what never had a prayer:
Memphis has beaten Tennessee once in the program's entire history, and even for Memphis, this Tigers team is atrocious. It wasn't quite the gruesome blowout we predicted last week until you remember the Vols led 42-7 at the half and began pulling starters three minutes into the third quarter.

Player of the Week: Vai Taua, RB, Nevada.
We'd like to give this to UAB quarterback Joe Webb, after his six-touchdown, 400-plus yard performance in the Blazers' win over Florida Atlantic, but the C-USA Tebow held this spot last week, or to Ram Vela for his big afternoon in South Bend, but that would be mean. So let's give it up to Taua, who was a banged-up shadow of his 1,700-yard 2008 self through the first two months, but busted out big with 144 yards on the ground against San Jose State, 138 of those in the first half, and did it all in front of his family in his native California.

Dan LeFevour Stat Watch.
Young master LeFevour had a much-needed bye this week, and has our fervent hopes for a gunslinging return against Toledo Wednesday night.

(A Somewhat Arbitrary) Mid-Major Top 10
1. TCU (9-0) - Look out, world, here comes another undefeated Mountain West team.
2. Boise State (9-0) - Irish loss dramatically improves the Broncos' BCS odds down the line.
3. Central Michigan (7-2) - A bye leaves the Chippewas in better standing than what Houston and Utah managed.
4. Houston (8-1) - A last-second field goal to edge Tulsa? Well, at least it wasn't Tulane ...
5. Utah (8-1) - The worst 8-1 team in the mids, at least.
6. Temple (7-2) - Enjoy your transitive win over Notre Dame, Owls.
7. Navy (7-3) - Lost in the ND hoopla is the realization that the Middies only have one non-quality loss this year (last week at Temple).
8. BYU (7-2) - Back in the Top 25 for reasons passing understanding, but at least they ate their cupcake without smearing frosting on the walls, Utah.
9. Nevada (6-3) - The Wolf Pack continue to delight with the success they should've had in September.
10. Troy (7-2) - Sun Belt frontrunner is our fourth sleepwalking, complacent squad of the top ten. Tsk.
Dropped out: Idaho (dammit)

Stay Tuned.
Our viewing agenda for Week 11: Toledo at Central Michigan, UAB at Memphis, UTEP at SMU, Idaho at Boise State, Fresno State at Nevada, Troy at Arkansas, Utah at TCU, and Louisiana Tech at LSU.

Most Realistic Upset: VMI at Army. No, seriously. We think they could lose this one.

Most Unrealistic Upset: Idaho at Boise State. That doesn't mean it won't happen. We believe, Yarbnalls. We believe.

Most Inevitably Gruesome Blowout: Inter-mid-major horrorshow alert! BYU at 0-9 New Mexico's gonna get ugly, we have a feeling. And just about the only thing higher than the 27-point line on that game is ... the 29-point spread assigned to Boise State and Idaho. Whatever, Vegas. Whatever.

Scoreboard.
Ten weeks in, mid-major schools are 19-89 against BCS conference competition. Three C-USA teams (Memphis, East Carolina and Central Florida) lost by a combined margin of 73 points against "Big Six" foes last week. The lone win for the little guys was Navy's, which, again, you may have read about somewhere. (Note: For our purposes, we count Notre Dame as a BCS program due to its bowl tie-ins.) Be of good cheer: the Mountain West has three teams in the top 25, one in the top 10 for the second year in a row, and Boise State and Houston are repping the WAC and C-USA quite nicely in the top fifteen.

- - -
Holly welcomes your adulation and veiled threats at nastinchka-at-yahoo, etc.

digg delicious
more

20 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. Purple Wimple
    1. Posted by Purple Wimple Mon Nov 09, 2009 5:03 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    BYU is only favored by 27? The Cougars are gonna make their betting fans some money this week.
  2. Elliott J
    2. Posted by Elliott J Mon Nov 09, 2009 5:10 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Navy lost to Temple. The 7-2 Temple Owls, which are currently on course for the MAC championship game. Even thats not a bad loss really. And it was by 3. They also lost to Ohio State by 4 and then Pitt by 13 points, and thats it.
  3. Chris A
    3. Posted by Chris A Mon Nov 09, 2009 5:13 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    VMI over Army?! Absolutely no Way!! VMI is a horrible I-AA team (2-7) who lost by 40 to Liberty last week. Army pummeled them 62-7 the last time they played in 2006 and Army is better this year. Army will win by at least 30 points. Army wins it easy and beats North Texas next week to reach 5 wins for the 1st time since the 20th century.
  4. A!
    4. Posted by A! Mon Nov 09, 2009 5:23 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    You say "despite outscoring the Bulldogs 21-7 in the second half"...
    most people would conclude that the last 14 pts by Idaho were scored AFTER the game had been decided.
    Did you list the South Florida-Rutgers game in this post?!?!?!?... last I checked they are part of the Big East, an 'Automatic Qualifier' BcS conference!
  5. so sad
    5. Posted by so sad Mon Nov 09, 2009 5:41 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Go Navy, just goes too show that Notre Dame is over rated.
  6. William S
    6. Posted by William S Mon Nov 09, 2009 5:50 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    And let's not forget that Navy lost to temple with a plethora of injuries on offense, defense, and ST...including QB Ricky Dobbs and SB Marcus Curry.
    But regardless, a loss is a loss...and temple is a bad loss, regardless of their record. Al Golden sends a monthly fruit basket to the Big East for kicking temple out and allowing them to settle in the MAC where expectations and competition are so low he looks like a decent coach.
  7. PaulT
    7. Posted by PaulT Mon Nov 09, 2009 6:18 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Yea, Navy is really hitting the Irish where it hurts, by getting them to hire a stud coach and fire the fat tub of goo who the ND admin would otherwise have found some excuse to keep.
    Let's be honest here - Navy, for the 2nd time, saved ND football. Their reward? Probably another 40 year losing streak.
  8. Dawn
    8. Posted by Dawn Mon Nov 09, 2009 7:52 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Holly, stop trying to make Yarbnalls happen! It's not going to happen!
  9. Holly
    9. Posted by Holly Mon Nov 09, 2009 9:28 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Too late. It's already been broughten.
  10. Jacob
    10. Posted by Jacob Mon Nov 09, 2009 11:33 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    There's a gays-in-the-military joke based on the picture in this article... Anyone? Anyone? Bueller? Bueller? Remember, those midshipmen are attending that game sober!
    Seriously though, hats off to Navy with their win. And yes, they have once again saved ND football. The same way you save someone's life by amputating their arm, Navy has shown that ND must amputate the fat blob on the sidelines, and replace that fat blob with Urban Meyer, Mike Leach, Bob Stoops, Chip Kelly, Jim Harbaugh, Chucky, Bill Cowher, or perhaps Tony Dungy. My money is on Chip Kelly.
    Any other names anyone want to bat around?
  11. Jacob
    11. Posted by Jacob Mon Nov 09, 2009 11:38 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    DARN IT! I meant Brian Kelly, from Cincinnati! That's who's gonna be ND's next coach! Chip Kelly is from Oregon! Ooops!
  12. bobby
    12. Posted by bobby Tue Nov 10, 2009 1:42 am EST

    Report Abuse

    ah nov and the firings have started. now have ? about counting notre dame as a big six team i assume this is not based on preformance. next a comment brian kelly must be loving life look at all the job openings coming this year notre dame, virgina, michigan, maryland and that is just a start to the list
  13. PaulT
    13. Posted by PaulT Tue Nov 10, 2009 3:36 am EST

    Report Abuse

    If the smarter ND messageboards (so NDNAtion, basically, because the rest are chimps and mouthbreathers) are to be believed, the first three candidates should be Meyer, Saban and Stoops - then after all 3 say no (which they almost certainly would), it's a tie between Brian Kelly and Jon Gruden - either of whom seems like he'd say yes in a heartbeat. Both seem slam dunks, but Irish nation being what it is, both are inspiring disgust in certain segments of ND fandom - the excuses people come up with to hate on either guy are amazing, especially considering who we've got coaching right now. If ND hires one of those 5, all is well. Anything else, and it's more interesting. In a bad way. But I'd like to thank Navy again, and encourage Pitt to crush us this Saturday.
  14. Alaska Hokie
    14. Posted by Alaska Hokie Tue Nov 10, 2009 6:49 am EST

    Report Abuse

    Case keenum for heisman.
  15. bobby
    15. Posted by bobby Tue Nov 10, 2009 7:50 am EST

    Report Abuse

    nd does not have pockets deep enough to hire meyer, saban, or stoops and i find it funny that nd fans think any one of these three would even consider leaving thier winning schools and great contracts to go to nd just shows how out of touch from reality nd fans are
  16. mikez34
    16. Posted by mikez34 Tue Nov 10, 2009 1:49 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    ummm - actually Meyer has said that Notre Dame is his dream job and would probably leave Florida, especially with Tebow gone.
    Golden Homers need to realize that Notre Dame hasn't been relevant for a long time now and they are no longer an elite program. I don't understand why that hasn't sunk in yet. They play a pud schedule and still lose.
  17. Nate
    17. Posted by Nate Tue Nov 10, 2009 3:53 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Can Kevin Sumlin get a little Coach of the Year love for bringing a team with a QB that was a Houston sholly away from being a walk-on somewhere and a bunch of freshmen and sophomores back to the grown-ups table of college football in his second year?! Yes, the defense is young and sans-identity (unless 'porous' counts), and the Cougars will probably end the season with fewer fans than they started it with due to the strokes and heart-attacks (see 9 points in 25 seconds for the 1-point victory over Tulsa). But, Case Keenum is doing a fairly rockin' Andre Ware impersonation, and everybody's coming back next year! Eat 'em up, Coogs!
  18. bobby
    18. Posted by bobby Wed Nov 11, 2009 6:07 am EST

    Report Abuse

    nate beware just how many props you give to coach sumlin nd might try to steal him
  19. lovetruncheon34
    19. Posted by lovetruncheon34 Wed Nov 11, 2009 1:41 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    How is Pitt 8-1? I've largely always believed that Wannstedt couldn't coach a pervert to a kiddie pool. I say Charlie flails his front 7 about the neck and shoulders with his discarded lap band as punishment for last week's showing, they come out crapping fire and wizzing tradition and they, uh, probably still lose actually.
  20. Nate
    20. Posted by Nate Wed Nov 11, 2009 3:59 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Call me arrogant or ignorant, but I'm not worried. Talk to me next year or the year after that. Houston could become what Memphis was in basketball for CUSA. Then ND could pull a Kentucky, but I don't see the domers buying into a "one-year wonder". Even though everyone around here knows he's much more than that.

Dr. Saturday

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Matt Hinton

Dr. Saturday is a college football blog edited by Matt Hinton. Email him tips and feedback.

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Dr. Saturday Recent Readers