Dr. Saturday - NCAAF

Iowa 30, Michigan 28. The really big question from all quarters of the many-headed Michosphere is going to revolve around the decision to keep glorified single-winger Denard Robinson at quarterback to guide the Wolverines' last-ditch drive with a little over a minute to go, which, yes, was fairly weird: Robinson had just led a nice touchdown drive to bring Michigan within two, and even completed a pass on that drive, after Tate Forcier was pulled in the wake of the worst game of his young career. But given that Forcier has already conjured up three dramatic fourth-quarter drives in his first five games, and Robinson is a noted nonentity in the passing game, you'd think the reins on the must-have drive in the dying seconds would be passed to the proven magic-maker in that situation, not the hot hand with no accuracy beyond 10 yards -- and in hindsight, having witnessed Robinson's wobbly duck of an interception to end the threat and the game, you'd be right.

But the Wolverines still scored 28 on the road against one of the Big Ten's feistiest defenses (seven on an early interception return), and the trials of the freshman quarterbacks were secondary to the ongoing issues that allowed the Hawkeyes to pass their way to 30.

I mean, Iowa quarterback Ricky Stanzi is competent, but hardly a world-beating figure in the pocket; his 287 yards through the air tonight was a new career high, half of it coming on four completions that covered at least 35 yards -- including two touchdowns down the middle to tight end Tony Moeaki, who found no one waiting in the Michigan secondary. But even going back to the chin-raising September winning streak, this is something of a theme by now for the Wolverines, who'd already been gashed for at least 400 yards three of the previous four weeks, looking hopeless in coverage against Notre Dame, chasing after big plays by lowly Indiana and being slowly choked to death by long drives last week at Michigan State. At least they held up well against the run tonight (the Hawkeyes had a season-low 63 yards on less than two per carry) for the first time since the opener against Western Michigan; for the nation's 91st-ranked total defense, getting shredded only by the pass is an improvement.

So there's a fairly obvious reason Forcier has had to don the comeback cape on a weekly basis to pull the team's feet out of the fire, and it can't be a surprise that the trend is starting to break down. Aside from terrific corner Donovan Warren, the Wolverines' hopelessly green, volatile secondary has been on the verge of breaking almost from the beginning, and they paid again for their generosity with the official elimination of their long-shot Big Ten title hopes.

All of which, it must be said, has been true from the beginning, down to the alternating precociousness and inconsistency from the pup signal-callers. It just seems a little more ominous when Forcier isn't there to manufacture a happy ending.

digg delicious
more

34 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. genius_man16
    1. Posted by genius_man16 Sun Oct 11, 2009 2:10 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    I too was wondering why Forcier wasn't put back in the game on the last drive of the game. Does Rich Rod not remember anything that's happened the past few weeks?
    One of the many reasons he is a terrible coach for Michigan. He's not the type of coach that is suited for a big time program like the Wolverines, and it will show itself in the long run.
  2. jim j
    2. Posted by jim j Sun Oct 11, 2009 2:23 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    typical wolverine football no suprise to me they lost
  3. awood
    3. Posted by awood Sun Oct 11, 2009 2:44 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    "typical wolvering football"? what are you, two years old? there's nothing typical about this season or last season. they'll be national title contenders within Forcier's time at Michigan. If their D was halfway decent this year instead of inept, they'd likely still be undefeated.
  4. Jon B
    4. Posted by Jon B Sun Oct 11, 2009 3:22 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Who wrote your headline, Doc, Jeremiah Wright?
    But, yeah... I agree with what all you wrote. Although, I think if you take FIVE, count 'em, FIVE turnovers out of the equation, that defense looks a lot better.
  5. Jeremy
    5. Posted by Jeremy Sun Oct 11, 2009 3:25 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    You ladies in post #1 and #2 need to calm down. I'm a MSU fan and I must admit that Michigan will be a title contender in 2-3 years. I usually won't comment on blogs because of idiots like CHat Bully who doesn't have a clue about the issue at hand but I must on this one. 'Typically' in years past Michigan is at least a contender for the BIg Ten and sometimes a national title. Just have to give Rich Rod another year or two.
  6. Benji S
    6. Posted by Benji S Sun Oct 11, 2009 4:35 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    If Rich Rod was making a point to Forcier he sure did send a lot of boder line fence fans over the wall on this. I'm waiting for the PR machine to spin this as Tate's hand was hurt, but really Denard as fast as he is in no Divison 1 QB. Basically Rich Rod cost U of M a run at a Little Ten title with an assist from Greg Robinson who can't scheme to cover tight ends. In defense of Robinson he's dealing with a walk on at Saftey, go Rudy.
  7. film381
    7. Posted by film381 Sun Oct 11, 2009 9:16 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Once again, Hinton the blogger, does inept and has to retreat to being sarcastic, caustic and totally insensitive to the real issue... This is a VERY YOUNG TEAM... five turnovers make for a very bad way to win a game... plus, sorry to inform you Hinton, but NOBODY that will post on this site, including myself and ESPECIALLY YOU, were not on the sidelines to KNOW EXACTLY what was going on. RR is an extreemly competant coach, as you have so boldy written in your previous accounts but he is not perfect LIKE YOU SEEM TO THINK YOU ARE, and he may... I write , MAY have made some mistakes but leaving Robinson in was not one of them... You forget the for the most part of the game, Forcier was haveing a bad game and I totally agree that what RR was trying to do was get a spark... They way Forcier was throwing into coverage and being EXTEEMLY LUCKY to come out with fewer interceptions was only prelude for him to be relieved from this game and hopefully the next game will be batter. BUT YOU ALSO FORGET Hinton, that RR has said ALL ALONG that BOTH quaterbacks would play and the best one will play at game time... no matter the interception, Robinson was better last night... GET A REAL LIFE HINTON and stop being so myoptic and caustic about stuff YOU DON"T REALLY KNOW ABOUT NOR UNDERSTAND
  8. Da Man
    8. Posted by Da Man Sun Oct 11, 2009 9:30 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    RichRod owned the Big Least but the Big Ten is totally different. Teams come to play in this league. RichRod will be run out next year only because he recruits offense minded players. Defense wins games there Rich.
  9. Ron
    9. Posted by Ron Sun Oct 11, 2009 9:43 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    One thing about RR that we WVU fans learned is that he holds grudges, even against his own players. Ask punter Scott Kozlowski: against Louisville a few years ago, back when both teams were in the top 10, Kozlowski was supposed to send a punt to the left, where the coverage would go. Instead, he mis-hit it to the right, and it was brought back for an easy touchdown. Kozlowski never punted again as long as RR was coach. Pat McAfee also turned out to be a great punter in addition to a terrific kicker, at least after a few games, so it didn't hurt the team, but the point is that RR will not hesitate to make a point even to the detriment of his team.
  10. Brad J
    10. Posted by Brad J Sun Oct 11, 2009 9:49 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    WTF Rich Rod.......I can't believe you don't go with the QB that has had three miracle finishing drives.....did you forget?? Robinson can't throw and you put him in with 2 min left in the game...WTF! I'm starting to wonder about your coaching abilities........I take that back I've always wondered!!!!!!
  11. bl1731atc
    11. Posted by bl1731atc Sun Oct 11, 2009 9:52 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Matt, no one will run the ball well when a defense puts 9 in the box, as Michigan did. That's why Iowa was hitting the big plays. Michigan chose not to defend the pass and thus force Stanzi to beat them.
    In regard to Forcier doing little and then being pulled: this is what Iowa has done to four QBs this season (ISU, Ariz., PSU, and Forcier). Three were benched in the course of these games; Clark should have been. Iowa already has 19 takeaways on the season. Michigan ran okay, except that they didn't: their longest run was 12 yards, and how many times will that happen this year?
  12. Brad J
    12. Posted by Brad J Sun Oct 11, 2009 9:58 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Great article, Hinton.......I'd say you hit the nail right on the head!!!!!!! 3 more losses coming this year, 7and 5 might get us the Motor City Bowl
  13. Lori
    13. Posted by Lori Sun Oct 11, 2009 10:02 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Rich Rod has an ego larger than the state of Michigan itself. He acts like a child tirading on the sidelines like that and has almost no respect for his players. I am a Buckeye fan and will always hate Michigan, however what message did he send to his young quarterback at the end of the game? With him you are a hero or a zero. People can say what they want about Tressel, but he respects his players and always shows class. Take a note Rich Rod.
  14. troot_60
    14. Posted by troot_60 Sun Oct 11, 2009 10:37 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    As a Buckeye fan, I miss the days of Michigan being a class act. Lloyd Carr was many things, and not all of them good, but he was a MICHIGAN MAN and he dedicated his career to that "school up north. The end of the Big Ten's days of smashmouth football and big Midwestern meathooks of men on both sides of the ball ended with the BCS. Winning the conference used to mean something. Now everyone across the nation acts like a team's season is a waste if they don't end up in the BCS title game. Rich Rodriguez is a ladder-climber. He'll stay at UM long enough to get what he needs and then move up to the NFL, or a college job he thinks is "bigger" or pays more. UM backed the wrong horse on this guy. They should have paid up for Les Miles.
  15. kass0809@...
    15. Posted by kass0809@... Sun Oct 11, 2009 11:25 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    In all honestly, I thought that the Iowa QB was pretty substandard. Iowa would be a legitimate top 5 team if they had competent QB play.
  16. Marion
    16. Posted by Marion Sun Oct 11, 2009 11:33 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    GO BLUE.......But you can not win games with 5 turn overs! Michigan is a young team they will only get better.
  17. Marion
    17. Posted by Marion Sun Oct 11, 2009 11:36 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    OH YEAHHHH........... Ohio State SUCKS!
  18. AaronS
    18. Posted by AaronS Sun Oct 11, 2009 11:54 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    This is the first time I've actually seen Michigan play and if you would have asked me beforehand I would have said that while this is probably not going to be their year they have a good chance of making an impact in the next couple of years. Now I'm not so sure. If Rodriguez is ripping on his players like that on national TV one wonders what he's like at practice or meetings. During the offseason there were stories about people leaving the Michigan program and alluding to the fact that it's not really a family atmosphere and after last night it's easy to see why. Morale can't be good if your coach is a petty tyrant. I can't imagine being a recruit and wanting to play for a coach that is going to lay into you on national TV and while Forcier has a ton of potential I don't know if he can reach it if every time he makes a mistake he's getting reamed and benched. I'd rather have Stanzi, who aparently can't throw to the left side of the field but at least has confidence, than a shaken Forcier next week.
  19. kris
    19. Posted by kris Sun Oct 11, 2009 11:58 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Someone needs to infor Lou Holtz on what UNI has done this year since losing to Iowa...Lou seems to think that Iowa is a terrible team for barely beating a top five 1-AA team. And that lisp kills me!
  20. Teddy B
    20. Posted by Teddy B Sun Oct 11, 2009 11:58 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    I am a solid Iowa Fan. Iowa got out of that one thanks to the turnovers. My main point in this post is, Iowa has had trouble recruiting. Thanks to the Michigan coach, it might be easier next year. Easier for Iowa that is. I ask you all to put yourself in the shoes of young recruits coming to play ball at a good college in the next two years. Then think of those recruits watching the Michigan coach yelling and abusing his ball players. These guys are young student athletes,,, and I stress students. Some guys wont make it in the pros, in fact most wont. What must it feel like to be giving it your all, just to be yelled at the end of each play. If you ask me, I wouldnt sign up for Michigan with this coach for any reason, and until this guys learns that its not all about him, not all about winning and loosing, and starts respecting his players for the effort they give, starts treating them with the respect they deserve, then i only hope for your sake, someone wakes someone up, or all the good reputation that Michigan has built in the Big Ten over all these years may be washed away with an arragant coach that needs to grow up and realize there is more to being a coach then the win loss collumn.
  21. G-Man
    21. Posted by G-Man Sun Oct 11, 2009 12:01 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    This game just shows you how incredibly sad the Big Ten has become. Barely a "major" conference anymore.
  22. kris
    22. Posted by kris Sun Oct 11, 2009 12:10 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Just to reply to my own comment - Northern Iowa is 5-0 since the Iowa loss...beating opponents 235 to 48. Still Lou Holtz picks Iowa to lose every game because Iowa barely beat UNI. That man needs to be fired from ESPN.
  23. RYAN
    23. Posted by RYAN Sun Oct 11, 2009 12:13 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    RR Forgets he has a freshman qb, it really looked like he cared about his players, rr only cares about rr and the almighty dollar, many more losses will come this yr. Atleast 5 losses this yr for UM.
  24. Douglas
    24. Posted by Douglas Sun Oct 11, 2009 12:47 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I was a huge RR supporter and still think he can win but what an idiot not putting Tate in with 1:30 to go. Are you kidding? Was his screwed uo ego in the way of an obvious decsion. Moron!!!!

Dr. Saturday

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Matt Hinton

Dr. Saturday is a college football blog edited by Matt Hinton. Email him tips and feedback.

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Dr. Saturday Recent Readers