Dr. Saturday - NCAAF

Here's a new one for Pete Carroll, a guy whose school last year sold t-shirts touting USC's 69-0 victory over helpless bottom dweller Washington State but was reduced to Saturday to charging the other team with running up the score after Stanford had the gall to go for two with a 48-21 lead and the boulder rolling full speed downhill against the Trojans:

When Jim Harbaugh and Pete Carroll met at midfield after Stanford completed its 55-21 defenestration of USC here Saturday, their conversation was brief, pointed and seemingly unsatisfying.

"What's your deal? What's your deal?" Carroll said, according to two sources near enough to hear.

"What's your deal?" Harbaugh retorted, and that was that.

See, those NFL guys are just so sophisticated, you know?

The funhouse mirror on the field suits Harbaugh's burgeoning status as the new Carroll -- if not in record (yet, anyway, and at Stanford, quite likely never in terms of longevity) then at least in style: Besides beating Carroll's blue-chip charges twice in as many tries on their home field, Harbaugh may be the only in the Pac-10 or possibly in the entire country who can match Carroll blow for blow in over-the-top, rah-rah enthusiasm*, and increasingly for annual rumors that NFL teams are angling for his services.

It's no coincidence that "the timing was not great" for Stanford to extend Harbaugh's contract back in February, despite obvious leaps forward on the field in his first two seasons, but off back-to-back blowouts of league heavies Oregon and USC, will probably have an extension finalized by the end of the week. A loss by the front-running Ducks in either of their last two games against Arizona and Oregon State could throw the Cardinal into a a wild, four-way mix for the Pac-10 championship if they take care of business Saturday against California.

That may not be such a wild revelation these days, given Stanford's nearly straight-up trajectory over the last three seasons, but it certainly would have been if you'd predicted it when Harbaugh was snatched from obscurity at I-AA San Diego to revamp the worst BCS conference team in the country. Walt Harris' last team in Palo Alto finished 1-11, was outscored by nearly three touchdowns per game and finished dead last in the Pac-10 in almost every major category, scraping bottom nationally (118th out of 119 teams) in both total and scoring offense. Harbaugh wasn't just young and inexperienced -- at 43, he was only five years removed from the end of his NFL career and had no Division I-A coaching experience in any capacity -- but also that he seemed to eager to stick his foot in his mouth, alternately calling out Carroll for his alleged wandering eye and taking shots at his alma mater for trumping up its academic reputation before he'd coaching a game with the Cardinal.

So it's hard to blame anyone watching at the time in retrospect for failing to predict what's beginning to look like the single most impressive turnaround of the last five years this side of Nick Saban:

Now comes the next phase of that arc: With the goodwill of a pair of eye-opening thumpings in their pocket the last two weeks and the full attention of hard-to-reach pollsters, pundits and blogs like this one, can Harbaugh keep his overachievers on track for a run at the top 10 and a possible insurgent BCS berth by plowing Cal and Notre Dame in the same fashion to close the regular season? If not it certainly won't be for lack of exposure to those games, which have the potential to propel hulking tailback Toby Gerhart to the top of the Heisman charts and redshirt freshman quarterback Andrew Luck into the pipeline of hyped, star passers over the rest of his career, as well as the team to heights it hasn't reached in decades -- or to cut Stanford back down to size after a brief bit of pique against a couple of conference bullies.

As quickly as Harbaugh and Co. have discovered the college football world at their feet, it can be gone just as suddenly with flops against the Bears and Irish, against whom Harbaugh's first two teams were 1-3. If this operation has the kind of staying power the last two weeks have suggested, sustaining the tide when everyone expects it -- including opponents who suddenly find themselves underdogs to a former doormat -- may be the toughest phase of the process.

- - -
* Though Carroll's former assistant, Steve Sarkisian, may take the enthusiasm crown yet at Washington. Hat tip: Get the Picture.

digg delicious
more

13 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. Festus
    1. Posted by Festus Mon Nov 16, 2009 7:44 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Look I hate U$C as much as anyone. How many times have they robbed my Golden Bears of a shot at the Rose Bowl? I am delighted to see Pete Carroll having a down year. But comparing Jim Harbaugh to Pete Carroll? That is very, very premature. Harbaugh doesn't even have a winning record at Stanford. How do Carroll's first three years compare to Harbaugh's? How about some of the other Pac 10 coaches to take over moribund programs? Harbaugh is YEARS away from earning the praise you give him here. Let's keep it in perspective.
  2. conor b
    2. Posted by conor b Mon Nov 16, 2009 8:31 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Are you suggesting an at large birth for stanford? Is that possible?
  3. bobby
    3. Posted by bobby Mon Nov 16, 2009 8:41 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    now thats class complaining about running up scores after 69-0 of washington st
  4. Oliver Klosov
    4. Posted by Oliver Klosov Mon Nov 16, 2009 8:45 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    HAHAHAHA - how's it feel Pete??? U$C should not be bowl eligible for 2 more years, due to the Reggie Bush payoffs... but everyone quickly forgot all of that, when the cash hit the NCAA... God bless Oregon, Stanford and anyone else that beats "The University that Cash Built"!!!!!
  5. Steve T
    5. Posted by Steve T Mon Nov 16, 2009 9:02 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    "Annual rumor that NFL teams are angling for his services."? Based on what? The author of this column has based his entire article on the fact the Stanford has defeated USC twice in the LA Coliseum in the last three years, therefore Jim Harbaugh is the new collegiate genius the NFL is waiting for. Now Jim Harbaugh may turn out to be a fine football coach, college or pro, but his track record so far is insufficient to make an educated judgment. As Festus says in Post #1, "Harbaugh is YEARS away from earning the praise you give him here."
  6. SonicSpeed
    6. Posted by SonicSpeed Mon Nov 16, 2009 9:58 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    If I calculated correctly there could only be a three way tie at the top (Oregon State, Oregon, and Stanford), which would result in them not making the Rose Bowl (that would go to Oregon State, because they would have beaten Stanford and Oregon).
  7. A!
    7. Posted by A! Mon Nov 16, 2009 10:37 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    how can you compare a 69-0 beat-down of Wazzu with the Cardinal win at USC.
    In the 2008 game, the Trojans pulled their starters after halftime. Mustain attempted all of two passes in the 2nd half- he really mastered the art of handing off. The fourth string RB, Broderick Green, rushed for 120 yds. Joe Mcnight didn't even play in that game.
    Point is the Cougars were just plain FUTILE that year... they gave up 58+ points six times in conference play.
    It was hard NOT to score on that WSU [lack of] defense... Harbaugh did it because he is a Jack arse.
    I would love to see Jim go back to his his alma-mater and beat down the nerd in the sweater vest.
    Go Blue!
    Fight On!
  8. Paolo X
    8. Posted by Paolo X Tue Nov 17, 2009 7:51 am EST

    Report Abuse

    Solid content and post on this site -- new commenter here after getting a recommendation from someone off another very popular sports blog that has been lacking severely in college football content. It seems hard to find a sports blog that covers college football without the corporatism of ESPN and the homering of most independent such sites that cover it.
  9. Kurt R
    9. Posted by Kurt R Tue Nov 17, 2009 8:57 am EST

    Report Abuse

    sonic speed - stanford makes the rose bowl with a win over cal, and losses by oregon, oregon st, and arizona. most likely way for that to happen is zona beats oregon, oregon beats OSU, and zona loses to USC or ASU. an oregon win over arizona would require wazzu to beat OSU for stanford to make the rose bowl.
  10. Tom
    10. Posted by Tom Tue Nov 17, 2009 11:27 am EST

    Report Abuse

    #7 -- A!, my thoughts exactly.
  11. jaz
    11. Posted by jaz Tue Nov 17, 2009 3:28 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Pete stop crying when the shoe is on the other foot..........you have ABUSED so many other teams with your 'pro' players..........suck it up!!
  12. Jethro
    12. Posted by Jethro Tue Nov 17, 2009 3:54 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Stanford s/b able to handle Cal easily. Cal has nothing with or without all their team perfectly healthy.
    Stabdford s/b able to finish off Oregan State because this year they own Oregon.
  13. Uncle Rico
    13. Posted by Uncle Rico Tue Nov 17, 2009 9:20 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Come on guys, when your on top for so long and then suddenly get pushed down, one is going to be a little sensitive. It was stupid for Jim to go for two. He is not going to keep his team to these standards like USC has been able to maintain. Let us get real for once. Enjoy it while you can jimbo.
    There is a lack of coaching continuity this year and it is glaringly obvious. I have never ever seen the USC defense THIS bad. The players are top notch but if you have them out of position there is so much that athletism can make up for. Coaching is a huge part and USC is currently deficient. Numerous coaches left over the years but none more then last. Let's face facts, bad coaches don't get asked to leave to new teams.

Dr. Saturday

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Matt Hinton

Dr. Saturday is a college football blog edited by Matt Hinton. Email him tips and feedback.

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Dr. Saturday Recent Readers