Dr. Saturday - NCAAF

At least you can't say nobody saw this coming.

Jacquizz Rodgers is a star Thursday night, yes, but this has to be a 12-alarm siren for USC, and much more so for the pundits who keep voting the Trojans into the mythical championship on September. Four losses to unranked teams as a double-digit favorite in three years is more than mere cracks in the facade.

And this one is much tougher to dismiss than the others -- against Oregon State in '06, against Stanford last year, the Trojans still controlled the game on a down-to-down basis, as expected, and lost by giving the ball away. But there was nothing remotely flukey or dismissible about Oregon State's slashing consistency: USC didn't turn the ball over until late in the fourth quarter and was physically manhandled throughout the first half. A 5-foot 6-inch true freshman isn't supposed to make it out of the Trojans defense alive; Rodgers ran 36 times for 186 yards. The Beavers -- the same rodents that lost to Stanford and rolled over from the opening gun at Penn State -- controlled the ball for more than 38 minutes, converted more than half their third downs (to USC's 20 percent), allowed all of three first downs in the first half and made the USC offense one-dimensional from the first snap of the game. All ye praises be unto Mike Riley, because his team looked irredeemably terrible through its first three games, up until it convincingly outplayed the No. 1 team in the country.

That's a black swan of nearly Stanford-level magnitude, but USC can't keep getting passes for games like this. Three years in a row it's dropped out of the top two or three in the polls with a shocking, inexcusable loss to a vastly inferior outfit, with the same set of problems: inconsistency at quarterback, a sketchy, makeshift running game and no go-to playmakers anywhere on an offense ostensibly overflowing with them. The Trojans will be back, they'll probably still carry the Pac-10, and by the end of the year they'll be lined up for another Rose Bowl massacre with talking heads braying about the team "playing the best football in the country right now." We'll continue to be awed by their talent against other elite teams.

But if Ohio State deserves to be ridiculed and scorned and run out the mythical championship picture on a rail for its primetime, big game failures, when are we going to hold USC accountable for repeatedly losing the little one?

- - -
Photo of Jacquizz Rodgers via Getty Images.

digg delicious
more

334 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. New Orleans Dawg
    1. Posted by New Orleans Dawg Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:12 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    While I certainly agree that USC was manhandled for most of the game, Joe McKnight fumbled the ball at the end of the 2nd half, leading to a last second touchdown for the Beavers. Definitely agree that USC needs to stop being coronated so early in the season. Maybe, if UGA wins this weekend, it can finally be rewarded for doing so
  2. Jim Cramer
    2. Posted by Jim Cramer Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:38 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    maybe this loss will diminish the number of times we have to hear that usc%26%2339%3bs %28offense, defense, team%29 is the best ever. anyway, kudos to oregon state. that rogers dude was something else.
  3. Jim Cramer
    3. Posted by Jim Cramer Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:38 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Not really sure how I got all the weird charters in there but you get the idea.
  4. Andrew S
    4. Posted by Andrew S Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:10 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I'm a member of the Oregon State University Marching Band and that win was one of the biggest that I have ever been to. Reser was so loud and crazy that me and fellow band members had problems hearing our conductor. USC is highly over rated and they finally got what they had coming to them. GO BEAVS!!!!!!
  5. Linton
    5. Posted by Linton Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:11 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    USC & 9 cupcakes, heh? Looks like 10 cupcakes.
    Tuck USC "Goodnight" until the media over-hype starts again next August. Last year USC was unimpressive early, but the media hype for USC, Cal and Oregon was ridiculous. All nose-dived before mid-season. This year it only took 3 games to write-off the conference.
    Now we can focus on the two super-conferences. SEC has 4 teams in Top 10, 2 more in Top 25. Big 12 is 8 deep with 4 teams in Top 10, 1 more in Top 25 and 3 just barely out of Top 25. Colorado will enter if they beat FSU and Oklahoma State should already be in there. What awesome college football battles ahead in these 2 conferences.
  6. baxterhawk7
    6. Posted by baxterhawk7 Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:35 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Beavs do it again! Must've been a nice night for the Rodgers' parents...2 TDs from one son and the other 2 TDs from the other son, against the " #1 " team in the nation. Crazy.
  7. Qaz
    7. Posted by Qaz Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:23 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    they got up for the wrong OSU team
  8. lou77
    8. Posted by lou77 Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:50 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    hat off to jaquizzz
  9. The Crow
    9. Posted by The Crow Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:49 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    HA! USC lost! This is a great day! :D
  10. Thomas M
    10. Posted by Thomas M Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:13 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    As an SC fan I had an awkward feeling as I was rushing home from work to catch the game. It couldnt happen again could it? I then remembered the first two games of the season for us as we dominated Virginia and held up against Ohio State. Oregon State had no chance. So I thought... Then I see this 5'6" running back breaking tackles, making SC miss every which way and that awkard feeling came back as we reached half-time. 21-0. WOW.
    All that I can say is Oregon State played a hell of a game and deserved to win. Period. SC didn't show up at all. Makes me wonder if they didn't take their usual game by game approach and slept in today, and never woke up....
    Hope Rey Maualuga is alright. Fight On!
  11. mp_homes
    11. Posted by mp_homes Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:27 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Pac 10 stinks. They are worse than the Big Ten
  12. mp_homes
    12. Posted by mp_homes Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:27 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Hey jackass, I mean turkey. USC stinks. Take the loss like the loser you are tonight. The best team in the land doesn't lose games like that LOSER!!!!
  13. Bossy Princess
    13. Posted by Bossy Princess Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:55 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    lol #9 loves it!! you said it all. excellent day
  14. baxterhawk7
    14. Posted by baxterhawk7 Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:35 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Please. "Things like that happen" all the time to USC. Three times in the last year to unranked teams, twice to the Beavers. I think the SEC is a tad overrated, but the Pac-10 is ridiculously so. there are 3-4 teams in the SEC that would pound USC, and 2-3 in the Big 12 that would. Open your eyes.
  15. mtomkiewicz@...
    15. Posted by mtomkiewicz@... Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:29 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Time to face the facts. The Big 10 and Pac 10 are weak. We've known this about the Big 10 for the last two years, although it took Ohio State's two title game blow outs and last week's loss for he media to finally admit it. Now the Pac 10 is showing it's true colors. Plus they don't even play a championship game. It's time for the SEC and Big 12 to just form their own league. Congrats to the Beavers though.
  16. winterman93
    16. Posted by winterman93 Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:47 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I should have known when I saw USC on the cover of Sports Illustrated...that again..this year was too good to be true...
    someone at SI deserves to get shot for that BS...I don't know how the SI curse began...or why it happens...I just know it will never die...
    that said...Carroll and his staff have NO confidence in their team when it comes to little games like this...
    all I DO know...is I saw this coming and I should have bet my house on it....I would be a rich man this evening...
    Trojans have lost 3 of 4 in Corvallis...playing there is a cancer and USC flat out SUCKS in weeknight games..why they keep accepting the bait from ESPN to be shown nationwide is beyond me...stick to saturday Carroll...most marquee teams do and they don't go through the same hell you put trojan nation through....
    I love my team...but this was not them...
  17. lobosfan23
    17. Posted by lobosfan23 Thu Sep 03, 2009 6:55 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Really,
    Turkey come on. I hate LSU and USC equally, but to say that the SEC would get manhandled by the Pac 10... You're dreaming. I'm not saying that Ohio State wasn't overratted but everybody's weak this year. Pac 10 went 0-4 vs the Mountain West. The Mountain West?!? That just shows you how level the competition is. The days of college football needing a playoff system is evident. USC lost to unranked Oregon State PERIOD! That means they need to prove that they deserve to be ranked. OSU has been overranked forever as evident by the SEC @$$whoopings in titlegames. So what they beat OSU, there's probably another 15 teams out there that could beat them.
  18. QuickSix
    18. Posted by QuickSix Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:24 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    man i am so happy to see USC lose...the the entire media wanted to crown them since last year and gave them an automatic pass to the national Championship . Games are played on the field and I am so thankful that it is not up to the media to ddecide the BCS Championship. the game is played on the field and not in sports columns!
  19. First L
    19. Posted by First L Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:33 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    its just week 4 and so ppl stop judging who is better and who gonna win the nationals, we still got a long way to go and we wud still lot of so called BIG teams crumble
  20. MattH
    20. Posted by MattH Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:50 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Way to go Beaves and Beaver Nation!
    As an OSU fan, I think I can speak for most of Beaver Nation when I say that that was certainly an outstanding performance by the men in black and orange! However, after watching my team seemingly suffer an '"upset" at the hands of Stanford on week one, and then be completely humiliated by a very good Penn State team in week two, I had very little faith in the Beaves. I also have very little faith in teams being ranked seriously early on in the season. Too many "upsets" early in the college football season over the last few years has me convinced that preranking these teams (mostly based on brand names and previous season performances) stacks the polls and makes it more possible for teams that play lackluster schedules to be considered for BCS games with sometimes two losses.
    The bottom line is this: A team is only as good as it plays the day of the game. Also: Even though brand name schools receive higher recruited players year in and year out, it doesnt matter in the grand scheme of things when it comes to losses at the hands like my Oregon State team. For know, I will gladly take the conference victory over a number one ranked team any day of the week! Congrats to Oregon State, and to the other teams in the top five to ten: watch out. There are plenty of lower ranked teams out there ready to steal your thunder and prove that these "meaningless" games can be huge steps for their programs.
  21. james s
    21. Posted by james s Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:04 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Whats sad is USC wont drop as far as Ohio State did when they lost to them. I bet the media darlings stay in the top 5. Ohio State lost to USC (top 3 team) on the road and droped 9 -10 down in the polls. Depending on the out come of this weekends games, I think it would be fair if USC dropped out of the top 10 for losing to a 1-2 unranked team. I find it funny when other teams with young inexpierenced players lose get beatup by the media (FSU), but they make excuses for USC.
  22. drgreenthumb2025
    22. Posted by drgreenthumb2025 Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:48 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Second most overrated program in the nation behind Ohio St.
  23. Bad Juju
    23. Posted by Bad Juju Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:32 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Gee, Musberger goes gaga over USC and everyone takes the bait after USC drills a TERRIBLE Virginia team and a TERRIBLY OVERHYPED Ohio State team.
    We should just ignore the pundits when they talk about a team in a major media market because they LOSE ALL OBJECTIVITY.
    Real football is played in the SEC and the Big 12 to a lesser extent. Just set the TV to mute whenever they talk about the PAC-10 or the Big-11. Seriously.
  24. LAKERSAREAJOKE
    24. Posted by LAKERSAREAJOKE Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:21 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    #17 Your facts are not facts. One this weren't a big game and that's why USC lost, they weren't ready for it. They were coming off a bye week and a big win over the much more overated Ohio State. Two they did not get handled, they made 2 stupid mistakes, the fumble and the interception. If they did not fumble that ball at the end of the second quarter they WOULD have won. They got caught sleeping first half, straight up. Defense was not the normal USC defense and the offense made some stupid mistakes. You just wait there's ALOT

Dr. Saturday

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Matt Hinton

Dr. Saturday is a college football blog edited by Matt Hinton. Email him tips and feedback.

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Dr. Saturday Recent Readers