Dr. Saturday - NCAAF

Scroll down or click here to join the Doc's game day live blog, covering every game, all day long.

Northwestern 17, Iowa 10. Anytime a nondescript, 16.5-point underdog rebounds from a quick 10-point hole to upend a 9-0 national-title contender on the road, that is a "shocking" result. There was no reason to think Iowa might lose to a team with a gimpy starting quarterback and whose marquee wins to date included unlikely, skin-of-the-teeth comebacks against Purdue and Indiana. The Hawkeyes' miracle season obviously was not supposed to end here -- next week at Ohio State, maybe, but not at home, to Northwestern.

I find it hard to believe, though, that anyone who pays greater heed to probability than to miracles is actually experiencing anything like actual shock, especially after quarterback Ricky Stanzi's ignominious exit with an ankle injury on the end zone fumble turned Northwestern touchdown that turned the game in the second quarter and collapsed the Hawkeyes' Jenga tower of a season in a matter of seconds. At some point, it had to happen: Iowa had already survived the loss of its top three running backs and a starting offensive lineman for the season, as well as its best offensive player for a crucial three-game stretch earlier in the season, and emerged unscathed after fourth-quarter comebacks against Northern Iowa, Penn State, Michigan State and Indiana. When you're saddled with one of the worst offenses in the conference, there are only so many miracles at your disposal.

As much heat as he's taken for his perfectly mediocre performance through the first two months (and his five-interception schizo act against Indiana, in particular), Stanzi's injury was the obvious breaking point. At least the resourceful junior gave the Hawkeyes a chance to move the ball: Their first three drives covered 159 yards and put 10 points on the board off a 74-yard touchdown pass from Stanzi to Marvin McNutt and a 30-yard strike to Trey Stross that set up the field goal. The final eight drives, all led by redshirt freshman James Vandenberg, covered 131 yards, entered Northwestern territory only once and produced zero points. Vandernberg's first pass was a laser directly into the chest of a linebacker that set up the Wildcats' go-ahead touchdown, and his longest completion was just 16 yards. He repeatedly missed open receivers Stanzi may have hit. The high wire snapped when No. 12 went down.

So, too, did the nation's second-longest losing streak, as well as the most plausible threat to something other than a Texas vs. Alabama/Florida showdown for the BCS championship. Well, maybe not a threat so much as a protest -- an undefeated Big Ten champion being left out of the title game carries a lot more potential for angst and vitriol than a snub against one of the would-be insurgents from the Big East, Mountain West or WAC. If Iowa had won at Ohio State, run the table and been relegated to the Rose Bowl as a consolation prize, a substantial segment of the punditocracy would have been (justifiably) up in arms, again.

But the Hawkeyes finally drew a club and the BCS doesn't have to worry about them anymore; if Stanzi isn't back for the next Saturday's trip to Ohio State, the Rose Bowl probably won't have to think about them anymore, either. Now if Florida, Alabama and Texas can only keep winning and somebody can finally do something about Cincinnati, everything will be falling into its proper order.

digg delicious
more

29 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. LongTrans
    1. Posted by LongTrans Sat Nov 07, 2009 4:45 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Wow! Shocker. What a surprise. Oh well, at least we don't have to hear that whining anymore about how they deserve a title shot. And the cream rises.
  2. Jacob
    2. Posted by Jacob Sat Nov 07, 2009 4:54 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    This isn't that surprising - the Haweyes have fat little girlfriends as well!
    Actually, this is OK. If Texas or Floribama loses, there needs to be someone to get into the National Title game, and it might as well be Boise State or TCU. This is one step closer to making that happen!
  3. JAMES
    3. Posted by JAMES Sat Nov 07, 2009 5:18 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    They would have lost next week to ohio anyway
  4. Sean
    4. Posted by Sean Sat Nov 07, 2009 8:04 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    As an Iowa fan, I knew we weren't up to calibre yet. Without decent running backs(Jewel Hampton and Adam Robinson) and now the quarterback, I'm certain we will lose once again to Ohio State and the Buckeyes will go to the Rose Bowl, only to stink up another bowl game like they always. Maybe Iowa wasn't as good as the hype, and some of us Hawkeye fans know that. But the truth is it gave us a teamt o cheer for who is NOT OHIO STATE, MICHIGAN OR NOTRE DAME . Even if Ohio State wins the Big Ten, do they really deserve it? Here's hoping at least Cincinatti still makes it through. As Eddie George said recently, they're the best team in Ohio.
  5. buckelchris
    5. Posted by buckelchris Sat Nov 07, 2009 8:56 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    I am an Iowa fan and I believe they deserved to be considered for a national championship. The loss to Northwestern was tough, but when you are on a 13 game winning streak a loss is bond to happen. I wish we had a schedule like Florida, Boise State, TCU, or Oklamhoma--then the winning streak probably would continue. I wonder what bandwagon ESPN will jump on now that the "unbeatable" Oregon Ducks got beat. Lets see. Not USC, not Oregon...maybe Arizona? Oh wait, Iowa already beat them. I guess its back to Florida and Alabama..in the SEC conference that is the so great.
  6. ronr52973
    6. Posted by ronr52973 Sat Nov 07, 2009 8:56 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    All you people who are bad mouthing Iowa are just jelouse because we got more attention than your suck ass teams got. So we lost one. Big deal. We still are going to go to a bowl game and we still have a shot at the rose bowl. All we need to do is win next week. I think we can. Even though OSU is good at cheating all the time.
  7. scooter
    7. Posted by scooter Sat Nov 07, 2009 9:11 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Iowa lost because injuries finally caught up with them. If Stanzi does not go down, they win. Simple as that. 10-0 before his injury. This is still a solid team but losing the experience at QB will be hard for them to replace. The season is not over and they will make a New Years Day bowl game and more than likely be the only Big Ten Team to win like last year. This team will never get any credit for anything since they are not part of the SEC which is unfair. I would have loved to see Iowa go to Columbus undefeated with Stanzi in but not this year. Keep in mind, next year this team will be returning all key starters from this years team on both sides of the ball along with both injured RB's that were lost for the season and Ohio State will be visiting Iowa City.
  8. Theresa
    8. Posted by Theresa Sat Nov 07, 2009 9:11 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    2nd longest losing streak??
  9. buckelchris
    9. Posted by buckelchris Sat Nov 07, 2009 9:13 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    ronr52973...I like your style!
  10. buckelchris
    10. Posted by buckelchris Sat Nov 07, 2009 9:20 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Everyone rips on the Big Ten, but I guarantee if you put any team in the Big Ten they will lose at least one game per year---including Florida and USC. If you put Iowa, Ohio State, Penn State, and Wisconsin in the SEC, I guarantee they contend for the SEC championship each and every year.
  11. buckelchris
    11. Posted by buckelchris Sat Nov 07, 2009 9:25 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    ...also, if you put Purdue, Illinois, and Minnesota in the PAC-10 they will contend for the PAC-10 championship each and every year.
  12. kevin
    12. Posted by kevin Sat Nov 07, 2009 9:38 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    To all you Iowa haters. Hows your team doing? Oh and I'm not talking to the band wagon junkies.
  13. same old,same old
    13. Posted by same old,same old Sat Nov 07, 2009 9:43 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    To Mr. Matt Hinton- Proper order according to who?!
  14. mjb465q
    14. Posted by mjb465q Sat Nov 07, 2009 9:47 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Here is to you Mr. Matt screw u buddy! Iowa is still a great team u are an ?ss! take your post n -hove it!
  15. kent s
    15. Posted by kent s Sat Nov 07, 2009 10:12 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    As always the pretenders fall by the wayside and the teams that the NCAA wants in the BCS keep winning. All the others pretenders will lose before November is over. TCU will lose to Utah next week and Cinncinati will lose to Pitt Dec. 5th. It always happens this time of the year. Enjoy the ride Iowa!
  16. buckelchris
    16. Posted by buckelchris Sat Nov 07, 2009 10:39 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Hey Florida fan (postalmoose)...how many teams have you beat that have a winning record (beside Troy)?
  17. buckelchris
    17. Posted by buckelchris Sat Nov 07, 2009 10:42 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    TCU hasn't beatin a team in the top 25, Boise State beat a very weak Oregon team, and Cinnici will lose a couple of games before the year is over, and the SEC is weak. In reality, there is no conference that is dominate. the Hawks may not be in the BCS championship but I guarantee that who ever they play in a bowl game they will beat handily. Probably Arizona since they will be the PAC-10 champion.
  18. Lucas
    18. Posted by Lucas Sat Nov 07, 2009 10:54 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Haters, it's time to find someone else to hate. Iowa was no pretender - they have demonstrated the ability to hang with anyone, and I guarantee you they'll win their bowl game.
    Frankly, Iowa was dominating Northwestern and easily headed to another win until the fumble-return-TD-injury-first pass-picked-TD. That sequence of events demonstrates nothing about Iowa or Northwestern, and they STILL managed to hold NW to 0 points that weren't off turnovers.
    Iowa can beat Ohio State next week and still end up in the Rose Bowl. A crushing blow, but they'll move on.
  19. genius_man16
    19. Posted by genius_man16 Sun Nov 08, 2009 12:45 am EST

    Report Abuse

    #13 the proper order of all the dickwads that control the BCS.
    As he correctly stated, Iowa was the only hope this year to have any legitimate crying at the end of the year if they went undefeated and were left out of the title game.
    The best case scenario of 6 teams being unbeaten at the end of the year might have been the breaking point that we fans needed to finally get a playoff. But now that the marquee team is gone, there won't be as much grumbling. And that's too bad.
  20. Gary
    20. Posted by Gary Sun Nov 08, 2009 1:24 am EST

    Report Abuse

    The quarterback is the single most important player among ALL team sports. What's Oklahoma been like without Bradford? After Stanzi was hurt Iowa did nothing offensively today, they will lose at Ohio St., and will possibly lose to Minnesota. If Stanzi recovers competely for a bowl game Iowa can match-up well with an SEC team again(3-1 vs. SEC under Ferentz , with the one loss partly a result of such a bad call from a Sunbelt official that the BCS will no longer allow officials from non-BCS conferences at their bowl games.) The only way to judge who's a better team is when they play each other. All else is just fun speculation. Cincy barely beat Conn tonight at home(and will probably lose at Pitt) , Boise barely beat Lousiana Tech(not Louisiana State) on the road. TCU hasn't beat anyone except Clemson(at Death Valley). But who knows how any of these teams might do in a bowl game vs a BCS conference team? Let's shorten the season to 10 games(which might help eliminate the cupcake games), and have an 8 or 10 team play-off.
  21. buckelchris
    21. Posted by buckelchris Sun Nov 08, 2009 1:26 am EST

    Report Abuse

    screw the pac-10 and the SEC... THERE WILL BE A GRUMBLING BECAUSE THEE BEST TEAM wont come from the pac ten or the sec....
  22. AzN pRyDe
    22. Posted by AzN pRyDe Sun Nov 08, 2009 5:57 am EST

    Report Abuse

    Go u nu
  23. Arthur
    23. Posted by Arthur Sun Nov 08, 2009 6:03 am EST

    Report Abuse

    Iowa would be a 4th place team in a real conference. Are they better than Oregon? USC? Oregon State? Stanford even? I doubt it. They would lose 3 or 4 games in the Pac 10 and probably 5 or 6 in the SEC. NO team from the Little 11 deserves to be in a BCS game and they haven't for years. Between the pathetic Little East, Small 12 and Little 11 they will get 3 or 4 BCS Bowl births which is a complete joke. The MWC is better than the Little 11 straight across. Northwestern better than Nevada or Fresno? No. If you want to figure out a true national champion every year take the top 4 SEC teams, top 3 Pac 10 teams, The MWC champ, The WAC champ, Little 11 champ, Little East Champ and a 12th at large team and let them play it out. Top 4 get a bye. Simple.
    Does anyone think that any Little East or Eleven team could beat Boise on a neutral field for the past five years? No one but a brainless living in the 60s Big Ten fan would think that. Its a joke.
  24. Arthur
    24. Posted by Arthur Sun Nov 08, 2009 6:05 am EST

    Report Abuse

    Whoever comes out the Little 11 will get destroyed by whoever comes out of the Pac 10. Happens every year. I would love to see Iowa get blown out by 20 by Arizona just to prove a point.
  25. Timo
    25. Posted by Timo Sun Nov 08, 2009 6:34 am EST

    Report Abuse

    Hey Arthur, did you happen to see Iowa beat Arizona this year? Blathering fool.

Dr. Saturday

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Matt Hinton

Dr. Saturday is a college football blog edited by Matt Hinton. Email him tips and feedback.

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Dr. Saturday Recent Readers