Dr. Saturday - NCAAF

We told you they were the best, and now we back it up. There's the top of the polls and the Heisman finalists, and if you needed another measure of how thoroughly the SEC and Big 12 dominated the media mind this season, check the AP's all-America team: Not including specialists, a full two-thirds of the 22 first-teamers are from one of those two conferences, including 9 of 11 on the first-team offense (all but running backs Shonn Greene and Javon Ringer, who carried the bell for the Big Ten along with three defenders, Penn State defensive end Aaron Maybin and Buckeyes James Laurinaitis and Malcolm Jenkins). The SEC had eight on the first team; the Big 12 had six. The ACC and Big East: Zero. USC: Two. The rest of the Pac-10: Zero. Real quickly, I'm looking at my Athlon from the summer and count at least 28 on one of their three all-America teams that made one of the three AP team released Tuesday.

On the entire first team, there were two players, Tennessee safety Eric Berry and Wake Forest cornerback Alphonso Smith, from a team that's not either a) playing in a Jan. 1 or BCS game or b) Was playing for a BCS bid in the last three weeks of the regular season and finished in the top-25, i.e. from teams that had important games on national television within the final month of the season. Half of the second team selections fall under this category. I guess the writers can't vote for what they can't see.

So that explains it. Finally, finally, we get the real story behind Michigan's worst season in 80 years -- it's all Scott Shafer's fault, as the deposed defensive coordinator told reporters on his way out Tuesday:

"Bottom line is, I take full responsibility for the demise of the Michigan program," Shafer, 41, said by phone Tuesday afternoon. "I accept all the responsibility."

That's it then. The 108th-ranked passing offense, 109th-ranked total offense, 98th-ranked scoring offense, 10-point effort in the loss to Toledo, seven-point effort in the blowout loss at Ohio State? That's on the defensive coordinator. The unique circumstances that left the Wolverines stuck with Steven Threet and Nick Sheridan at quarterback? Scott Shafer's fault. Okay, everyone, back to four more decades of uninterrupted success.

From Shafer's perspective, I'm not sure what school now will be able to justify hiring the self-described Man Who Destroyed Michigan Football, but at the top of the early list to fill his shoes is ex-Southern Miss coordinator Jay Hopson, who spent this season as the Wolverines' linebackers coach. My unique perspective on Hopson's tenure at my alma mater from 2005-07 is "Meh." As a coach, he's just a guy -- a highly stressed guy, if he takes over the dire situation in Ann Arbor, but not exactly a prodigy to date.

One last time for the road. In polar opposite coordinator news, Dan Mullen will be in the booth for Florida in the mythical championship game, though he's spent the last week and will spend next week going full-time as the new boss at Mississippi State before rejoining the Gators after Christmas. Even Urban Meyer laughed at the question of whether Mullen will "give 100 percent," because "of course he's not. He's got a job to do." But he also thinks Mullen gives Florida the best chance to beat Oklahoma and stay in the same rhythm that Tim Tebow's known for the last three years. And Meyer calls the plays, anyway.

Favorite to replace Mullen: Gregg Brandon, Meyer's old offensive coordinator and successor at Bowling Green, from whence he was fired a few weeks ago. And as for Meyer's "dream job": It's Notre Dame and Florida. Just calm down, guys. There's room for all of you in Urban's dreams.

Quickly ... Ohio State's Nathan Williams, who last admitted to shoplifting on behalf of a friend, pled not guilty on Tuesday. ... Does Dan Hawkins think Colorado fans won't remember his early prediction for 2009? ... South Carolina's leading tackler, Emanuel Cook, is academically ineligible for the Outback Bowl and will probably declare for the draft. ... Maybe Jim Tressel should spend Christmas boning up on the all-Big 12 team. ... Charlotte's Car Car Bowl sells out for North Carolina's date with West Virginia. ... Southern Miss has requested additional tickets for the New Orleans Bowl. ... The Des Moines Register writes its second "coaching search" article in as many days without listing a single name as a potential successor to Gene Chizik. ... If coaches can't attend high school all-star games, what's the point? ... And Miami must be the first bowl team in history to name a kicker its MVP.

digg delicious
more

8 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. hr209
    1. Posted by hr209 Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:21 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Ohio State named Mike Nugent as its MVP in 2004, when they defeated Oklahoma State in the Alamo Bowl.
  2. Dave
    2. Posted by Dave Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:21 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Small typo -- The ACC had one non-specialist on the AP first team, Alphonso Smith.
  3. Chanthia's best
    3. Posted by Chanthia's best Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:56 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Who would you say should not be on this list?
  4. Woekie
    4. Posted by Woekie Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:23 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Hmmm - four years after turning down Touchdown Jesus, a guy with a name befitting a Pope is contemplating two at the same time and is also considering hiring a character from an obscure British musical television series who attempts to lure fishermen into marrying him by exposing his hypnotic "mangina," and is, technically, a sea creature. I think it's safe to say that if John XXIII had known that Second Vatican would lead to this, he probably wouldn't have bothered.
  5. pine tar
    5. Posted by pine tar Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:55 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    i really do like sam bradford. he seems like a great kid. i saw him play at the cotton bowl.
    i think he threw 5 td's and looked damn good. but he is a kid who won a popularity contest.
    there is no denying he is a winner on a winning team playing for a winning program, but
    the heisman trophy and the nat champ game was given to popularity contest winners this year!
    thats how i see it!
  6. ltownokie
    6. Posted by ltownokie Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:29 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    thanks armchair for your opinion but colt cant get everything even though you think he should.
  7. man29
    7. Posted by man29 Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:05 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    post 5 is on point...bradford..macklin...dez bryant are over rated..they were the most popular players..there teams were in the spot light alot this year..and for no reason
  8. man29
    8. Posted by man29 Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:05 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    but who cares let's get to the bowl games ....

Dr. Saturday

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Matt Hinton

Dr. Saturday is a college football blog edited by Matt Hinton. Email him tips and feedback.

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Dr. Saturday Recent Readers