Dr. Saturday - NCAAF

Wed Oct 21, 2009 9:51 am EDT

Headlinin': Pryor losing his base?

The people are a beast. The criticism of Terrelle Pryor in Columbus reached a fever pitch so quickly following Saturday's four-turnover debacle at Purdue that Jim Tressel actually had to spend "a lot of words" defending Pryor as Ohio State's starting quarterback Tuesday at his weekly media session. (He could have gotten by with just seven: "Have you seen our depth at quarterback?") As of this morning, an astonishing 47 percent of respondents in a Columbus Dispatch online poll (unscientific, of course) voted "Yes" to the question "Should Ohio State make a change at quarterback?" despite Pryor's obvious talent and 13-4 record as a starter. And Dispatch reporter Ken Gordon went out of his way to calculate the impact of Pryor's turnovers in each game this season, and doesn't pull any punches for the sophomore's benefit, beginning with the headline:

Pryor TOs the difference between 5-2 and 7-0?
[...]
Pryor has accounted for 11 turnovers: 8 interceptions and 3 lost fumbles (out of 8 fumbles overall). Opponents have converted those turnovers into 30 points.
[...]
... I determined that Pryor’s turnovers prevented OSU from scoring at least 3 points [in the three-point loss to USC], and maybe as many as 18.

Add those together, and you have a total turnover cost of between 33 and 48 points. It could also be argued that his turnovers made the difference in both of OSU’s losses.

Reckless as he may be with the ball, the notion of pulling a wildly hyped athlete with huge upside and a co-Big Ten championship/BCS bid under his belt as a true freshman is fairly insane, even if there was a viable backup. But Pryor is one more upset from becoming officially "embattled," and obviously has a huge portion of the fan base to win back over.

Bradford speaks. Beleaguered Oklahoma quarterback Sam Bradford is set to go before the microphones today to discuss his immediate future, an appearance that could broach a wild array of topics, including his potential return this season from a re-aggravated shoulder injury and his intentions regarding the NFL after the season:

Stoops said Bradford would "answer a couple of questions and address that for a few minutes after practice tomorrow," and talk about "what the plan will be" regarding his availability for the rest of the season, whether or not he'll have surgery, and, if he does take the rest of the season off, his concerns about returning in time for next April's NFL Draft, where he's projected as the potential No. 1 overall pick.

Re: the No. 1 overall pick, if Bradford doesn't come back and light it up this season, it seems that ship has sailed. But if he's still a first-rounder, depending on how he feels about his shoulder and the Sooners' offensive prospects in 2010, it might be time to cut his losses and take the Josh Freeman money.

BCS lobbyin' up. At least one good indicator that the new Congressional playoff lobby has the BCS' attention: The Series is contemplating hiring its own "point man," a full-time position that would take over most of the duties of the current commissioner's role, which has outgrown the time constraints of the conference commissioners who fill it on a rotating basis. His first priority? Justifying the existence of the beast in the face of its increasingly powerful, organized and vocal critics:

"I think there is a sense (among conference commissioners) that the BCS hasn't really done a good job over the years of defending itself," said [new Big East commissioner John] Marinatto, who's been involved in four BCS meetings since taking over for [Mike] Tranghese in the spring.

Defending the BCS certainly has been the primary function of the coordinator. And that coordinator's role has grown in part because of all the attention - much of it negative - college football's postseason system for determining a champion receives.

I hereby declare my candidacy for the position. ... What? Bring the system down from the inside? No, of course not. I love the BCS. I would never intentionally steer it toward a Hindenberg-like finish in a Navy-Fresno State title game. Read the masthead.

Bierra booked. Terrible story out of Louisiana, where former Georgia safety Terreal Bierria, who went on to play with the Seahawks, was charged with first-degree murder Tuesday in a suspected drug-related killing. A 29-year-old man was found dead with "wounds indicating a violent struggle" in his home, where Bierra's car was spotted and police later found drugs, and Bierra allegedly checked himself into a local hospital with cuts to his hands and arms. He's being held without bond.

Quickly ... Lane Kiffin finally puts his name on the dotted line. ... Steve Spurrier questions the legality of Alabama's tape-wielding field goal kicker in the Tide's win over South Carolina, when he should be questioning the legality of Mark Ingram's existence. ... Bad to worse for winless Ball State: Starting quarterback Kelly Page is out for the season with a broken thumb. ... Wisconsin will be without its leading tackler, freshman linebacker Mike Taylor, for the rest of the season due to a knee injury. ... N.C. State cornerback Rashard Smith, a starter, is out for the season with a knee injury. ... Spindly Michigan quarterback Tate Forcier, who sat out last week's curb-stomping of Delaware State after one series, declared himself "completely healthy" despite a mild concussion against Iowa and ongoing shoulder issues. ... USC's lack of fumble-recovery skills drives Pete Carroll crazy. ... "Matt Barkley for Heisman" sort of baffles Matt Barkley. ... Ralph Friedgen is sticking with quarterback Chris Turner at Maryland, but backup Jamarr Robinson will play against Duke. ... A checklist for Georgia's bye week ahead of the Florida game. ... L.A. Times headline writers pass up the real cliché for a more banal one. ... And Georgia Tech gives its goal posts a proper send-off, "student injuries" be damned.

digg delicious
more

13 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. PurdueMatt
    1. Posted by PurdueMatt Wed Oct 21, 2009 10:54 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    -Troy Smith wasn't spectacular as a sophomore either.
    -The good news for Pryor is that he doesn't have to face Ryan Kerrigan again.
  2. just4funsies
    2. Posted by just4funsies Wed Oct 21, 2009 11:35 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Pryor needs to get his head on straight and become more interested in the team concept.
  3. Wayne M
    3. Posted by Wayne M Wed Oct 21, 2009 12:21 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Tommie Frazier dropped one against Iowa State when he was a freshman, then led Nebraska to three straight undefeated regular seasons, three straight National Championship Bowl Game appearances, and two National Championships.
  4. Ancient Chinese Secret
    4. Posted by Ancient Chinese Secret Wed Oct 21, 2009 1:12 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Maybe I haven't been paying close enough attention to Buckeye land, but the turn on Pryor honestly caught me off guard. It seems like just yesterday this kid was the Second Coming of Vince Young. Were OSU fans skeptical of Pryor at the beginning of this season, or are they surprised too?
  5. Dwayne
    5. Posted by Dwayne Wed Oct 21, 2009 1:33 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Aren't these the same guys who wanted him to start after the QB before him stunk it up @ the Coliseum vs USC last year?
  6. just4funsies
    6. Posted by just4funsies Wed Oct 21, 2009 2:15 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    It all started for Pryor when he "held out" on announcing his commitment until the last moment, so he would not have to share the attention with other players. He was looking for rockstar treatment before he had done a damn thing for OSU or for college football. "Me" mentality often hides the truth about how much is hype, and how much is tripe...
    Pryor has time to attitude-adjust, but the question is whether he's willing. Maybe he feels the hype will serve him better at the next level, and is looking beyond his college career at this point. He's not blazing new trails, as egos nowadays are a dime a dozen.
  7. mangere_bridge
    7. Posted by mangere_bridge Wed Oct 21, 2009 2:27 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    You don't think a guy who hasn't started a competitive game since 2003 would've led the Buckeyes to 7-0? You doubt the Bauserman?
  8. whomever
    8. Posted by whomever Wed Oct 21, 2009 2:45 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Wayne M: Pryor isn't a freshman... and he isn't Tommie Frazier. As a matter of fact, Pryor prolly should've committed to Nebraska, so they could put back in the Wishbone, there. I would've still redshirted him.
  9. whomever
    9. Posted by whomever Wed Oct 21, 2009 2:50 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Also, I'm gald you Ohioans finally realize... there wont ever be another VINCE YOUNG, on the collegiate level. Vince was spectacular on the collegiate level, evident in what he did vs Michigan, as a Sophmore (Rose Bowl MVP), and vs USC (the team ESPN called the greatest of all-time... LMAO), when he decimated the Trojans and all those legendary future 1st Round Draft Picks (once again, Rose Bowl MVP/BCS NC MVP... and the true 2005 Heisman Trophy Winner).
    Pryor simply doesn't have the intagibles... the arm, SPEED, or overall leadership attitude. VY was a legend, playing before his own legendary-time. Pryor hasn't done one single thing to prove he's nothing more than a very good basketball player, playing QB for the Ohio State Butteyes!
  10. whomever
    10. Posted by whomever Wed Oct 21, 2009 2:51 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Also, Im gald you Ohioans finally realize... there wont ever be another VINCE YOUNG, on the collegiate level. Vince was spectacular on the collegiate level, evident in what he did vs Michigan, as a Sophmore (Rose Bowl MVP), and vs USC (the team ESPN called the greatest of all-time... LMAO), when he decimated the Trojans and all those legendary future 1st Round Draft Picks (once again, Rose Bowl MVP/BCS NC MVP... and the true 2005 Heisman Trophy Winner).
    Pryor simply doesnt have the intagibles... the arm, SPEED, or overall leadership attitude. VY was a legend, playing before his own legendary-time. Pryor hasnt done one single thing to prove hes nothing more than a very good basketball player, playing QB for the Ohio State Black-eyes!
  11. Nolan
    11. Posted by Nolan Wed Oct 21, 2009 3:26 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Troy Smith wasn't Spectacular!
  12. bigboo's bro
    12. Posted by bigboo's bro Wed Oct 21, 2009 3:51 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    The problem is that TP's learning curve is a negative function this year. Coming in as the biggest egotistical a@@hole in his recruiting class doesn't help either. Nor does his Michael Vick solidarity show. The fact is that he is also extremely ineffective in distributing the ball reinforces the negatives of selfishness. Time for a grow up or sit down talk from the coach.
  13. Scott
    13. Posted by Scott Thu Oct 22, 2009 8:59 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Actually #11, he was. He is just too short and hasn't really been given a great chance in the NFL. In fact, his record is fairly good when he starts. So...shut it.
    And #5, yes, he is...but now we realize FOR SURE--that isn't the players so much anymore as the sucky nuts coaches that OSU has hired. Weak. Weak. Weak.
    I am going to put this out there: I don't think that Ohio State's team, if put in the Mountain West conf. this year, could win the conference. We would get beat by BYU, Utah...etc.

Dr. Saturday

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Matt Hinton

Dr. Saturday is a college football blog edited by Matt Hinton. Email him tips and feedback.

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Dr. Saturday Recent Readers