Dr. Saturday - NCAAF

Big changes over the weekend on the big coaching board:

With Brady Hoke jetting to sunny San Diego and Auburn in full-scale torch-and-pitchfork mode over Gene Chizik, most of the remaining coaching questions are at obscure MAC jobs. Foremost among them:

WTF with Turner Gill? This was Gill's moment: He took Buffalo to a conference championship. Somebody should be taking the bait here. You take Buffalo to the title, you get a bigger, better job. You do not get passed up in favor of a guy whose team just lost 10 games in a row. I have a very hard time swallowing the race bait; we are talking about educated, wordly people who can't afford to be racist, from a competitive standpoint, and it's not like people at Syracuse and Auburn didn't want to hire him, or weren't aware of the very good PR if they had (though clearly they weren't expecting such bad PR for not hiring Gill). Maybe he's a bad interview. Whatever: These windows are small and precious, and this one seems to have closed.

With Auburn and Syracuse both falling to uninspiring names on Friday and Saturday, it looks now like Gill has two choices: Take the scraps (i.e. Iowa State) or remain at Buffalo and wait for the next round of openings next winter. What happens, though, when Buffalo looks more like Buffalo again? Who calls then? And is the high likelihood of regression there really less likely to lead to a major gig down the road than assuming another dead-end rebuilding job at Iowa State, where he's liable to go 5-19, too? Either way, the historical odds in both cases are against his continued success, and the longer it takes for Gill to land the big fish, the less likely it is to ever come within his reach again.

Iowa State. The Cyclones are feeling betrayed by Chizik's departure, especially athletic director Jamie Pollard, who said today that Chizik told him twice he was going to turn down Auburn, including once on Saturday, the same day he took the job. Of course they were taken off-guard: Why in the world would anyone want a coach on the hot seat at Iowa State?

With no advanced warning, the first name that came to mind for the ISU faithful was an old one, Dan McCarney, whose five bowl games in six years from 2000-2005 looks pretty good after two years of Chizik. That's sort of a joke -- McCarney's no Bill Snyder, and Snyder's return to Kansas State is a bizarre move, anyway -- but you got any better ideas on short notice? Of all the initial names thrown against the wall -- including a couple old standbys, Gary Barnett and Dennis Franchione (what, no Terry Bowden?) -- Gill is certainly the fan favorite, just like he was at Auburn, if he wants to get out of Buffalo and on to a bigger job that badly.

But even the Cyclone message boards aren't quite in the "name I just heard ..." mode yet. Iowa State has no competition in the major conferences and can afford to take its time.

Army. Please please please let Army hire a head coach named "Steed Lobotzke." Please.

digg delicious
more

14 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. Jeff K
    1. Posted by Jeff K Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:51 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    isu should hire tuberville. they could beat chizik and auburn at the independence bowl next year.
  2. Paul
    2. Posted by Paul Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:00 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Completely puzzling. Marrone to Syracuse was a bit of a surprise, but at least he's been spearheading a very successful NFL offense for a little while now. If you take race out, I can only comprehend two reasons for Chizik over Gill at Auburn. First would be Gill simply rejecting the job, which I don't think we've heard. Maybe he wanted to hold on for a year and put himself in the mix elsewhere (which I see as feasible if you look at what got Tuberville booted and see a lack of job security). Second would be money; perhaps Gill wanted too much, and Auburn wanted to get a bargain in Chizik since they still owe $5 million to Tuberville? Doesn't make sense for a die hard football school, though. The closest I can get to a third is Chizik having a stock of Scarecrow's fear gas from Batman Begins, and, after pumping the conference room full of it, showing the Auburn AD a crayon rendition of Saban eating Gill's brains.
  3. D from TC
    3. Posted by D from TC Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:12 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Hey WTF aka Rob Blago.......If the MAC is such an obscure league and you make it sound as though the coaching jobs are inferior to those at other conference schools or at a minimum they are a "last resort or undesireable", then why are you so concerned about Gill (from such an obscure school) getting his "just desserts" for a job well done. There are many fine coaches out there and he could have been a better candidate but just for the sake of journalism and debating-keep your thoughts parellel if you can. Go MAC
    and yea little ol' (I assume) obscure Iowa State.
  4. Joshua H
    4. Posted by Joshua H Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:23 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    This doesn't make any sense. Turner Gill was clearly the best candidate out there and NOBODY hired him. He was a finalist for the Nebraska job last year and he wins the MAC in just three years? Buffalo was scheduling fodder and nothing more before he got there... maybe he can turn Iowa State around?
  5. BOSOX406
    5. Posted by BOSOX406 Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:13 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    who is charles barkley????
  6. SnowedIn'Bama
    6. Posted by SnowedIn'Bama Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:01 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Rumor is Auburn put too many conditions on any offer to any coach for anyone other than Chizik to bite. Gill is better off at this point. If he pulls off a repeat at Buffalo next season, there might be a good chance at openings at ND and Penn St. between Weis' getting axed (finally) and JoePa retiring (probably better odds next year). For his sake, I hope he turns down any future ISU offer to coach against his alma mater.
  7. JP Girouard
    7. Posted by JP Girouard Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:37 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    While I'm not entirely enamored with the Chizik hire either, we have to face facts - Iowa State is a tough place to win. For anyone.
    And while everyone's all hot and bothered about Turner Gill and the job he's done at Buffalo, let's all take a deep breath. Buffalo plays in the MAC. In the MAC, unless you're Eastern Michigan or Temple, you will eventually get to a bowl game and/or play for a conference title if you wait around long enough. It's certainly possible the Bulls were a one-year wonder, and Gill's resume isn't anything special otherwise.
    http://bestbigeastblog.blogspot.com
  8. howarjo1943
    8. Posted by howarjo1943 Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:21 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Who is Barkley? Thomas asked from an earlier post. Well my young friend, he is a former Auburn basketball player from the mid eighties who became a star in the NBA during the nineties. He has a great personality, but as he's gotten older he has become a raving lunatic. For some reason, people think his opinion is important. He is a constant race baiter and he has made plenty of racist comments himself against whites and asians(Yao Ming) in his commentaries. The fact is, if AU thought that Turner Gill, or any other black person out there, could help them win the most football games; they would have been hired yesterday. Turner Gill is BARELY more qualified than Chizik, but Chizik has been at AU already as DC so he is fat least amilar with the region with probably got him the nod over Gill and others. I don't think either coach was AU material, though. Leach, Johnson, or Kelly were the best hires.
  9. PJ Q
    9. Posted by PJ Q Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:03 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Im getting sick of hearing how terrible of a coach Chizik is. I've said this a hundred times, you can't judge what a coach does by 2 years at Iowa St. No one could turn that program around, especially in 2 years. Its a disaster. I don't think Chizik knew exactly what he was getting into when he took that job and I can't blame him for leaving. As for Turner Gill, If he was that great of a coach why does he keep getting passes up on all these jobs? This isn't the first time. College football is too much of a business to think that they didn't hire him because of the color of his skin. They take the person that they think is the best coach for the job.
  10. slumpbuster
    10. Posted by slumpbuster Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:03 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Iowa State will end up with a better coach no matter who they get. Next years schedule is the easiest in years. A good offensive unit returns. Add a couple of JUCOs at d-line and linebacker and the next coach will be bowl bound.
  11. IDGAD
    11. Posted by IDGAD Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:27 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Auburn should have gone for an experienced head coach like Tyrone Willingham, talk about a resume: Stanford, Notre Dame and Washington. It's clear Tyrone's the designated black coach for Div 1. With Tyrone available Turner doesn't stand a chance at Iowa State. HawkInsider must be smoking some of that stuff growing in the middle of the corn stand in the south 40.
  12. Kelly S
    12. Posted by Kelly S Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:04 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Sorry PJQ, but I have to disagree with you on this one. Granted, ISU is a difficult place to win consistently, and plays a tremendously difficult schedule year in and year out, but even at that, Chizik showed little ability to run a Division I football team. His sideline was in disarray, his assistants received little guidance from him, and the players that he inherited from the McCartney era (such as Todd Blythe, who let he Big XII in receiving for a season or two), were terribly under utilized.
    As an ISU season ticket holder, I don' blame Chizik for jumping ship and going to his "dream" job. However, from what I have seen from his sideline management, play calling, and ball management, he is a train wreak of a coach. I am glad his train has left the station in Ames.
  13. chi nu vike!
    13. Posted by chi nu vike! Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:07 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I dont know if race has anything to do with Gill not being hired, but i do know that Chizik did not have the best resume. I read above there may have been some contract issues, as a LSU supporter and having the inside track with the LSU athletic foundation and how athletic foundations operate, if they really wanted to hire him, money would not have been an issue.
  14. chi nu vike!
    14. Posted by chi nu vike! Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:07 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    i know many people dont like charles, many of you think he's an idiot but i hope all of you dont believe racisim does not exsist. Its unreal to believe that there arent more A-American coaches in college football. No one can make me believe that there arent enough qualified or derserving.

Dr. Saturday

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Matt Hinton

Dr. Saturday is a college football blog edited by Matt Hinton. Email him tips and feedback.

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Dr. Saturday Recent Readers