Dr. Saturday - NCAAF

Tebow gazing from the proprietor of Tim Teblog.

Given some of the local media's scolding of the apparent legions of fans and media naysayers questioning the way the Gators are winning, you'd think Florida's next opponent was "The Strawmen." I'm not sure I see it. You can always find cranky fans on message boards, but the vast majority are pretty content with 9-0 and the BCS pole-position. And the "national" media obviously doesn't see it, given that Florida maintained its choke-hold on the No. 1 ranking in the AP, Coaches, Harris and aggregate of the six BCS computer polls.

However, there is an instructive lesson to be learned from the 2009 New York Yankees: Expectations are everything. The Yankees were under more pressure than any baseball team in history -- it wasn't enough to get back to the playoffs. They didn't spend all that money to win an American League pennant. They were in it to win a World Series championship, period. Anything less was failure.

And more power to them that they accomplished that -- even if it was "just" meeting expectations. Exceeding expectations is nice -- it's a pleasant surprise. And certainly not every fan (few teams' fans, actually) can expect a title of any kind, especially in college football. But if your team is that good, expecting championships is fine, even healthy. Does it lead to all sorts of bitter disappointment when you fall short of those expectations, like perhaps not appreciating the fine bowl invitation or perfectly decent 10-win season? You bet. But appreciating what you have is not a champions' mindset.

As a Florida fan -- as a college football fan -- I don't think it's unreasonable to expect that this Florida team will win the national title, or that the expectation has been in place since January. Florida fans should be used to it; the 2007 Gator basketball team had precisely the same expectations after returning its entire lineup from the '06 title run, and delivered.

This is the important part: The "how" doesn't matter, as long as the expectations are met. Who cares how Florida is getting it done? They're getting it done. So the offense doesn't look good while doing it? So the offense isn't meeting expectations of being some sort of 2008 model juggernaut?

The only stat that matters is "and-oh." As in "9-0." And "14-0." The 2007 Patriots were the greatest offense in NFL history, but they're only remembered as the biggest chokers in NFL history. Alternatively, think of the 2000 Ravens: Dominant defense, good-enough offense. Their legacy? NFL Champions. In college football, the same goes for Alabama in 1992, Tennessee in 1998, Ohio State in 2002 and, yes, Florida in 2006, all teams that frequently "won ugly," but ultimately won it all on the biggest stage.

Tim Tebow's legacy as one of the greatest players in college history has never been based on his ability to put up the absurd numbers that propelled him to the Heisman in 2007, or even to win another Heisman (although it's worth pointing out that, for better or worse, Tebow's mojo is still so strong that even in a "down" year statistically, he's still a top-five Heisman contender). No: Tebow's legacy remains entirely predicated on his ability to lead the team to a second straight national title, its third in four years, and Florida's first undefeated season ever, while they're at it.

(The Miami Herald's Jo Goodman had a pretty good blog post earlier this week about how Gator fans should enjoy this ride. It's a good reminder.) By all means, your expectation for this team should be "National title or failure." That's why all those recruits came to play at Florida. It's why Urban Meyer came to Florida over Notre Dame. It's why Tim Tebow and Brandon Spikes came back to school for their senior years. It's why Florida is the best college football program in the country right now.

Hell, that was a huge appeal for me when I converted to Florida fandom: The expectation that the team would compete for championships, every year. (And it's not like I carpet-bagged in for the Meyer Era; I started in Spurrier's final year, which meant I experienced every minute of the Zook debacle.) When your team is this good, expectations -- the highest expectations -- are not just normal; they are fair.

That goes for Florida, for Texas, for Alabama and for almost any other top-tier program. I can only imagine what it's like to be a fan of USC the past few seasons, when your team is arguably the best in the country but you find yourself locked out of the national title after midseason sloppiness.

What isn't fair is to complain about how your team is meeting those expectations. If Florida loses along the way? Absolutely, go ahead and gripe -- be epically disappointed. I know I will. But as long as they are winning -- which, appropriately, seems to be the focus from Meyer to Tebow -- that's all that matters. The ultimate comeback to anyone questioning "how" your team is playing: "And-oh."

- - -
Dan Shanoff is obsessively covering Tim Tebow all season long at TimTeblog. Other times, he can be found writing every weekday morning at SportingNews.com and all the time at DanShanoff.com.

digg delicious
more

32 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. Tim
    1. Posted by Tim Fri Nov 13, 2009 11:25 am EST

    Report Abuse

    It's a concern about future gamese thing, Dan. It's fine if they keep winning in the regular season, but we all expect them to get hit by a truck against Alabama or Texas.
    Well, that's a bad analogy given that their defense will keep the game bland and boring. Perhaps a slow bloodletting disappointment would be more accurate. We can always go back and rewrite history in hindsight if they do win out.
  2. Mike
    2. Posted by Mike Fri Nov 13, 2009 11:38 am EST

    Report Abuse

    "when I converted to Florida fandom"
    Dear lord, awful.
  3. mikep
    3. Posted by mikep Fri Nov 13, 2009 11:40 am EST

    Report Abuse

    Tebow shoud have cut on of the legs off of his heisman and send it to Percy Harven....Harven is the only reason he won it...Yes he is a good quarterback but I have heard 2-CBS anchor men say he is one of the greatest players to play the game....Well his numbers don't look that good this year to me..Oh wait unless you count the teams that where 1-a division teams they paid thousands of dollars to play them so they could run the score up....... and get Tim high rushng yards.........
  4. Jacob
    4. Posted by Jacob Fri Nov 13, 2009 11:44 am EST

    Report Abuse

    Florida fans should indeed savor this time and moment. It's true that Urban Meyer could leave, Tebow will leave, Florida's D will lose talent, and other teams will catch up. Beleive me, I'm a Husker fan. From 1993 to 1997, NU fielded teams that competed for National Championships. 1993 lost to Fl St. 1994 beat Miami. 1995 greatest team ever, beat Florida badly. 1996 had a couple slips against ASU and Texas. 1997 beat Tennesee for share of National Championship. Then... Osbourne left, recruiting slowed, things coasted, seemed OK, then in 2001... 63-36 against Colorado. Ever since, NU's been trying to get back. It's a slippery slope, and a cruel one. Like getting dumped by the prettiest girl in school. Doesn't seem like it can happen. Then it does.
  5. cantcatchuf
    5. Posted by cantcatchuf Fri Nov 13, 2009 11:52 am EST

    Report Abuse

    To add onto what timjames99 said: the concern is not just the post-season this year, but all of next season as well. Tebow seems to be somehow making up for all of Addazzio's inept play calling, but Brantley will require a competent offensive coordinator to become the secondary-killing machine he is designed to be.
  6. Spacemonkey
    6. Posted by Spacemonkey Fri Nov 13, 2009 12:41 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    I thought this got cancelled.
    Dan Shanoff sucks.
  7. A!
    7. Posted by A! Fri Nov 13, 2009 1:40 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    that's funny... Dan says Tebow came back to win another championship. Everybody knows he stayed because not one NFL team even remotely considers him a QB prospect.
  8. maxlangford
    8. Posted by maxlangford Fri Nov 13, 2009 2:46 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    How did it ever get to Tebow leading the Gators to the title over Ohio State? The re-writing of history when it comes to Tebow is revolting. Made even worse by this bandwagon hack.
  9. archcityonecorps
    9. Posted by archcityonecorps Fri Nov 13, 2009 5:27 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    "Tebow's mojo is still so strong that even in a "down" year statistically, he's still a top-five Heisman contender."
    This kind of stuff drives me crazy. The only reason Tebow is a top-five Heisman contender is because the media has been slobbering all over him for the last 3 years. He's a good, even great, player, but he's not having a Heisman-type season this year.
  10. bulletproof
    10. Posted by bulletproof Fri Nov 13, 2009 5:35 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    why dont you writers try not boring us to death with ALL your ego crap. think about somebody else for a change...or does meyer pay your salary too??
  11. bulletproof
    11. Posted by bulletproof Fri Nov 13, 2009 5:45 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    this writer will make tebow a good wife, he clearly is already infatuated with the ball hoggingest qb ever in history... how come nobody's got the guts to mention that. i'm just not bowing to him, ya'll can make an idol if you want!!
  12. Albert
    12. Posted by Albert Fri Nov 13, 2009 5:59 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    maxlangford.........you're comments is so typical for a OS fan. You and many others still think there is no team in America that is on the same level of OS. How sad. Check their records for the past several years and their schedule. No one has beat Florida and I am not a gator fan. But I'm not blind. The Big Ten has become almost a second tier conference and the teams are weak. There are many teams better than OS.
  13. Darla
    13. Posted by Darla Fri Nov 13, 2009 10:36 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    if not tebow for heisman than who? we all see him playing in the balls out toughest conference still undefeated
    i guess ingram could probaly get the votes if the tide handle the gators but thats a big if given the gator d
  14. ROBERT G
    14. Posted by ROBERT G Fri Nov 13, 2009 11:53 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    with both florida and alabama already have had the beefit of 2 losses each reversed by mike slive's crooked sec officiating crews, what could stop slive's plan now?
    undefeated on paper only florida and alabama meet in the sec title game, with the winner going to the bcs national championship game, the loser going to another big payout bcs game and many other sec teams going to other big payout bowl games, with all of those funds flowing through the sec conference and huge bonuses for slive and his crooked officiating crews.
    the problems with the standard con operations for the 2009 season are that slive and his sec accociates will not get to keep any of their material possessions and florida and alabama will forfeit whatever they win.
    we are not going to watch any of these games and we will boycott the products and services of any person or entity contributing to attempting to con the public into belieiving that these things are for real.
    we will bring shareholders derivatives actions on behalf of the many companies in which we own shares that spend any of our corporate assets on these con operations.
    no person or entity associated with crooked college sports enterprises will be back next season or will have any material possessions left after we finish them off in the civil courts, just as we did with enron and worldcom.
  15. See the Light
    15. Posted by See the Light Sat Nov 14, 2009 1:14 am EST

    Report Abuse

    Try this one Dan:
    "I can only imagine what it's like to be a fan of [Boise State] the past few seasons, when your team is arguably the best in the country but you find yourself locked out of the national title after [BCS favoritism]."
    Had the 2006 Oklahoma not lost to the refs at Oregon (on one of the worst blown calls in football history), Oklahoma would have been playing for the BCS Championship - not the Gators. Boise State beat Oklahoma straight up and had the best claim for National Champion in the Country. (Only undefeated team. Beat one of the teams that should have been playing for the championship. The other team with a perfect record going in - Ohio State - turned out to be what they have been for most of the decade - pretenders.)
    It's one thing to have the "best talent" and screw up (we call that a "loser"). It's quite another to have the best team and have a bunch of shysters at the BCS "rule" you out of the BCS championship.
    As for the baseball comparisons - who gives a flip about baseball? We're all here because we like FOOTBALL.
    And what is Robert G. smoking?
  16. Mike
    16. Posted by Mike Sat Nov 14, 2009 1:42 am EST

    Report Abuse

    Yes, The Gators do have a few gimmes(as does most everybody)...but we always seem to shut down the juggernauts (Ohio St., Oklahoma, LSU...etc.) that are supposedly going to destroy us as well...GatorHaters- gotta love 'em!! If your not a Gator your just Gatorbait!
  17. Ron
    17. Posted by Ron Sat Nov 14, 2009 11:40 am EST

    Report Abuse

    Like it or not, the SEC is the top conference in the country right now. It generates the most money, it has the most publicity, the most rabid fanbase, some of the nicest facilities, and many top-tier teams. Every conference has contenders. But even in a "down" year, I'll put the SEC's conference schedule up against any other, and that weekly grind is a tough challenge. Florida alumni and fans should be happy about Tebow and Florida's success. But we are spoiled. Just remember the "unofficial" success of the 1984, 1985, and 1990 seasons, and today's current criticism should just go away. At least the program isn't on NCAA probation and a bowl ban anymore!
  18. Brian
    18. Posted by Brian Sat Nov 14, 2009 12:58 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    florida sucks, they have nobody except tebow, only play they run is triple option with tebow keeping 90% of the time.
  19. bulletproof
    19. Posted by bulletproof Sat Nov 14, 2009 1:00 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    useless article again about u of f...by gollie, you have to run em down their throats even when there are alot of subjects out there, way more important...media pull at its shamless best!
  20. bulletproof
    20. Posted by bulletproof Sat Nov 14, 2009 1:18 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    your a thief, if your getting paid for crap like this!
  21. tannerj05
    21. Posted by tannerj05 Sat Nov 14, 2009 2:44 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    If the only stat that mattered was "And-Oh", then Florida would be trying for their SECOND title in four years. But a Florida fan wouldn't recognize that would they?
  22. TuCkFeBoW
    22. Posted by TuCkFeBoW Sat Nov 14, 2009 5:29 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    I have been saying this all year....Gayterbandwagoners,your house of cards are getting ready to be lit on fire.Charlie Strong is gone after this season and Herban Meyer is right behind him. It doesn't matter though, the NCAA was getting ready to shut down your program for all the illegal recruit money and the Degree ATM machines anyways.Karma is a
    BEEEEEEEEEEEOTCH!!!
  23. TuCkFeBoW
    23. Posted by TuCkFeBoW Sat Nov 14, 2009 5:36 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    13. Posted by jondar.carver Fri Nov 13, 2009 10:36 pm EST Report Abuse
    if not tebow for heisman than who? we all see him playing in the balls out toughest conference still undefeated
    i guess ingram could probaly get the votes if the tide handle the gators but thats a big if given the gator d
    Dude! Are you doing whipits or something??????????? Timmy is NOT the best player in the league by far,heck the kid from Houston is better than that fake god worshiper Tebow...and you think that the SEC is THE best conference???? STEP AWAY FROM THE PIPE,stupid!
  24. stephen d
    24. Posted by stephen d Sat Nov 14, 2009 9:01 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    everybody can whine and [profane] all they want about how the gators are winning this year but the fact of the matter is that the "stupid triple option they run with tebow keeping it 90% of the time" seems to be effective. how else do you go 9-0 in the SEC to this point? (granted having a beast mode defense helps)
    And to TuckFebow: Im sure that Tebow would have some VERY impressive stats himself if he played such highpowered defensive teams like UCF, SMU, Tulsa, and Tulane. "That kid from Houston" would be "just another good player" in a major conference. Ever heard of Colt Brennan and Timmy Chang? Really good playing in the WAC, not so much after that.
  25. MarkyPants
    25. Posted by MarkyPants Sat Nov 14, 2009 10:43 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    This article is complete garbage. Texas would destroy Florida. Bama prob would beat Florida. TCU would probably also beat Florida. I can't wait til the media realizes how overrated Florida and Tebow are.

Dr. Saturday

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Matt Hinton

Dr. Saturday is a college football blog edited by Matt Hinton. Email him tips and feedback.

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Dr. Saturday Recent Readers