Dr. Saturday - NCAAF

At the beginning of November, three-quarters of the way into the season, our hard knowledge of Penn State as it heads into its season-making date with Ohio State Saturday amounts to the following set of observations against a very un-illuminating schedule:

They can still play defense. The Lions lead the nation in scoring defense and rank in the top six in rushing, pass efficiency and total D, as well as sacks; they've given up a total of 26 points in the last four games, including a shutout against Minnesota. In PSU's only loss, the defense picked off Iowa's Ricky Stanzi twice and held the Hawkeye offense to 13 points, 10 of them coming on drives that began inside the Penn State 25 following turnovers in the fourth quarter.

They prefer to spread the ball around. This is a pretty balanced offense -- 36 runs per game to 31 passes, and that includes plenty of garbage-time clock-killing -- and though tailback Evan Royster is carrying the bulk of the running game, four different receivers have hauled in at least 25 passes for 340-plus yards on the season. Derek Moye is the deep threat, but Chaz Powell, Graham Zug and Andrew Quarless (as well as Royster and Joe Suhey, who have 25 catches between them out of the backfield) have all been reliable targets.

They're healthy. The defense has endured various injuries over the course of the season, notably to star linebackers Navorro Bowman and Sean Lee, but shouldn't be missing a single starter on either side of the ball Saturday.

For a top-15 team with serious BCS hopes and lingering (though very distant, thanks to unfriendly tiebreaker scenarios) designs on another Big Ten title, that's not very much, especially where the offense is concerned. That's what you get when your schedule to date includes one team that received votes in the latest polls, and you were held to 10 points by that team. As solid as the Lions have been offensively in every other game -- including their subsequent four Big Ten games, in which they're averaging 31 points on 453 yards -- their inability to score over the last three quarters against Iowa follows overhead like one of those tiny, personal storm clouds in the old Looney Tunes shorts as they come up against the only other defense on the schedule that measures up to the Hawkeyes'.

In the two most relevant precedents for taking on Ohio State Saturday -- the loss to Iowa earlier this year and PSU's win in Columbus last year -- Penn State's offense turned the ball over four times in the former case and was held to 281 total yards in the latter, its lowest output with Daryll Clark as starting quarterback. In both games, the Lions were held three straight quarters without a touchdown and finished with grand totals of 10 and 13 points, respectively.

So it's not going out on much of a limb to suggest Penn State won't be doing much scoring against the Buckeyes' typically stout, top-10 defense, at least nothing on the order of its 31-point average for the season; the Lions may be lucky to achieve half that. But Ohio State, of course, is in the same boat: Including last year's six-point, zero-touchdown effort against PSU, the Buckeyes' last four games against top-10 opponents since the start of the '08 season have netted 45 points and only three touchdowns, two of them with Todd Boeckman leading the offense in the fourth quarter of last year's Fiesta Bowl loss to Texas. OSU was held to 265 yards and had to settle for a pair of field goals after scoring an early touchdown in the 18-15 loss to USC in September, the first of four games this season in which Terrelle Pryor has looked distinctly underwhelming as a passer. The Nittany Lions have a way of intensifying that effect -- they lead the Big Ten in sacks and haven't allowed a touchdown pass with the game still in doubt this season -- and neither Pryor nor Ohio State's offense in general has shown much to earn the benefit of the doubt against a defense of Penn State's caliber.

If it's going to be that sort of mistake-magnifying defensive standoff, then, the central question should be, which gunslinger do you trust? As a fifth-year senior (and reigning All-Big Ten pick, with much better passing numbers this year) at home, the answer has to be Clark, if only because he still seems somewhat less likely to make the killer error in a tense game, as Pryor did last year on the fourth-quarter fumble that led to the only touchdown of the game -- the game-winner for Penn State. That's not the sort of history that's particularly likely to repeat itself, specifically. But if Pryor has The Leap in him this season, this is the time for it to finally come out; against Penn State's defense, not bloody likely.

digg delicious
more

14 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. genius_man16
    1. Posted by genius_man16 Fri Nov 06, 2009 4:58 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    I feel really bad for Terrelle Pryor. Mostly because he went to a school who refuses to fully utilize his talents and also that doesn't know how to develop him into a better football player.
    He is at this point, still playing like a high school quarterback, which is terrible. Should have gone to PSU or Michigan. Oh well. Sucks to be him I guess.
  2. brian b
    2. Posted by brian b Fri Nov 06, 2009 5:36 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    regardless of where he goes, his passing still needs to develop.... a better situation would have been not being thrown into the spotlight too quickly. imagine him developed, redshirtted, at texas next year once mccoy left. i mean are you kidding me, he would be so fun to watch. and this is coming from an sc fan!
  3. Jacob
    3. Posted by Jacob Fri Nov 06, 2009 6:38 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    RichRod at Meet-Chicken would have used him very very well, but Pryor followed conventional wisdom that
  4. Jacob
    4. Posted by Jacob Fri Nov 06, 2009 6:39 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    RichRod at Meet-Chicken would have used him very very well, but Pryor followed conventional wisdom that low pressure was key for freshman development. Turns out that Ohio State does not run an offense suited to his skills in the same way Meet-Chicken does...
  5. A!
    5. Posted by A! Fri Nov 06, 2009 7:22 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    C'mon... the entire Big Ten conference does not have one solid QB- among 11 teams
    Penn St has the spread analog, which puts up big numbers against teams who don't play defense (353 pass yds vs Akron; 225 pass ypg vs all others)
    Ohio St - Prior is a great athlete, but he's not suited to play QB at this level... Just like Vince Young is not suited to play QB in the NFL
    Michigan has the read option, which does not develop QBs but rather teaches them how to hand-off
    Wisconsin hands off from the I-form.
    Iowa, Minnesota, Purdue and Indiana have the closest things resembling pro-style passing attacks... but they throw too many INTs
    then there's KAFKA... he's just fun to watch, BUT, he's not a pro-style QB
  6. ebentley711
    6. Posted by ebentley711 Fri Nov 06, 2009 8:07 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    A! - Your logic doesn't compute. No "solid" qbs because of the schemes the teams run? Clark is probably the epitome of solid and Pryor still could be very good and I would expect the same from Forcier. Weber and Cousins aren't too bad either.
  7. Pen-head
    7. Posted by Pen-head Sat Nov 07, 2009 12:42 am EST

    Report Abuse

    Pryor will be fine , After he shuts the mouths of all penn state followers who think he made the wrong decision going to osu. GO BUCKS!
  8. A!
    8. Posted by A! Sat Nov 07, 2009 8:25 am EST

    Report Abuse

    711 - "epitome of solid" ?!?!?!? you must have low standards. Clark inflates his numbers against Div I-AA teams and MAC also-rans... and remind me how he has fared against ranked opponents.
    I'll give you Cousins as 'not too bad'... but that falls short of 'solid'.
    Weber has more picks than TDs... but he should fare well next two games- Illinois and South Dakota St
    Pryor has the ability... he needs to LEARN how to be a QB
    Spread and shotgun formations mask deficiencies in QB play... that's why college players who operate them rarely make NFL teams- ask Graham Harrell. Its easy to get credit for a 60 yd TD pass when the ball is in the air for 10 yds from the line of scrimmage and the receiver runs 50 yds after the catch
    I am assessing the present... not what they COULD develop into
  9. Tim F
    9. Posted by Tim F Sat Nov 07, 2009 9:29 am EST

    Report Abuse

    Let's face it: There is no team dominating college football this year. Moreover, even the good SEC teams don't have the grueling schedule that most folks think. Olin Buchanan has a good piece on this entitled: They play football outside the SEC too. So, let's not start saying some one has "inflated" stats when pretty much every top 20 team this year has played their share of cupcakes in and out of conference.
  10. ebentley711
    10. Posted by ebentley711 Sat Nov 07, 2009 9:50 am EST

    Report Abuse

    A! - Clark had one bad game, and that was against Iowa in a monsoon. But my point is more: you can't tell me a Masoli or a Harrell is a bad a QB because they run a non pro-style offense. Maybe it's a niche role that won't translate to the NFL, but that's irrelevant. What good would Ryan Mallett do for Rich Rodriguez or Chip Kelly?
  11. Clifford B
    11. Posted by Clifford B Sat Nov 07, 2009 10:55 am EST

    Report Abuse

    You guys who say Pryor is under the wrong scheme obviously aren't watching Ohio State actually play. OSU pretty much went to a carbon copy of the Michigan spread and shred after the USC game:
    http://www.elevenwarriors.com/2009/10/diversification-strategies.html
    OSU's problems on offense are more a result of youth (and possibly talent) at QB and on the O line. Also some injuries and illness on the O line haven't helped.
  12. jeremy
    12. Posted by jeremy Sat Nov 07, 2009 3:13 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Go Penn State, I want game day to head to Fort Worth for the TCU/Utah game
  13. A!
    13. Posted by A! Sat Nov 07, 2009 6:21 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    711- you were saying about Clark?????????
  14. Josh P
    14. Posted by Josh P Sat Nov 07, 2009 9:14 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Eat it.
    GO BUCKS

Dr. Saturday

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Matt Hinton

Dr. Saturday is a college football blog edited by Matt Hinton. Email him tips and feedback.

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Dr. Saturday Recent Readers