Dr. Saturday - NCAAF

Hey, Houston Nutt -- how's that untenably huge recruiting class at Ole Miss shaking out for ya?

"It's going real smooth right now because you've got about seven guys right now that we know for sure aren't going to make it academically," Nutt said last week at a news conference to discuss spring practice. "However, they love Ole Miss and so what we're doing, to help out Mississippi junior colleges, is we are going to place them in the schools."
[...]
"There are about four or five that are on the fence and probably won't make it academically," Nutt said. "The relationship you build with Mississippi junior colleges is important to me because we won't ever be a staff that will sign 15 to 16 junior college kids a year. We won't do that, but we will sign some needs."

Knowingly signing non-qualifiers with explicit intent of hiding them away in the most JUCO-saturated state in the South? That sounds like ... what's the word I'm looking for, recruiting guru Tom Luginbill?

"He's creating a farm system," Luginbill said. "If it works, it's a heck of a deal for their program."

Actually, the many, many Mississippi junior colleges have been fertile havens for the academically challenged for years -- Florida State and Alabama, for example, had a reputation for routinely stashing non-qualifiers in hard-to-find places like Copiah-Lincoln and Pearl River County in the nineties. Nutt is different here, though, in both scale (up to a dozen non-qualifiers in one class?) and unabashed design: He may not use the term, "farm system," but otherwise Nutt is putting the blueprint out there. It's one thing to sign a kid on the fence and later find out he's falling short; Nutt is the first coach I know of who's publicly wide open to kids who are certain to fail academically.

This is not exactly a loophole in the face of the NCAA's scholarship limits, since Ole Miss presumably isn't just signing everybody it can get its hands and hoping the right number of guy don't make the cut. With the exception of those few inevitable borderline cases, it knows who's in and who's out; the kids themselves almost certainly know, too, so they're not getting checks the program won't be able to cash in the fall. But to the extent that the JUCO-bound players remain betrothed to Ole Miss for "taking a chance" on them or something, intentional oversigning disingenuous in light of the scholarship restrictions, and inherently sketchy: To some extent, Nutt has to be actually looking for red flag academic cases to fill the excess roles. Then these kids "sign" with no intention -- in some cases, probably, no chance -- of ever enrolling at Ole Miss, and everybody in the system must know it. Their inclusion is a sort of charade -- if it wasn't, they (or one of their qualified classmates) wouldn't be included, because there's not enough room to risk oversigning with actual qualifiers.

And if it works, and a few once-hopeless cases matriculate back to Oxford, the open, JUCO farm club race will be on in earnest.

digg delicious
more

17 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. 4.0 Point Stance
    1. Posted by 4.0 Point Stance Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:55 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Never thought I'd see a coach say "Good news! We've got a bunch of kids flunking out!"
    Sack of rabid weasels, etc.
  2. PSEagle
    2. Posted by PSEagle Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:25 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    it is a shame that the ncaa allows this. however, it must not be too difficult to get into ole miss (see jerrell powe) so some of these hopeless cases will probably end up there in the end.
  3. TA
    3. Posted by TA Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:59 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I gotta say that I've always sort of pulled for Nutt since he was summarily dismissed from Arkansas. And I've never really had a problem with Ole Miss though I'm much more of a Big Ten-ner than an SEC guy, but this situation just doesn't sit right with me.
    I really hope that the players are told up front that they won't be academically eligible to play for Ole Miss unless they take a JUCO route, because otherwise you're potentially signing a kid who may or may not have the possibility to play elsewhere in Div I or I-AA with a school that would be more committed to the kid's academic success and would possibly vouch for him with the NCAA. I fear that there may come a day when some of those kids do unexpectedly clear the NCAA academic hurdles and Nutt's stuck cutting someone simply for math's sake and it blows up in his face.
    I just don't think anything positive can come out of this.
  4. kass0809@...
    4. Posted by kass0809@... Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:47 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Is there really anything questionable about this? These players know they are academically eligible, and its not like they HAVE to sign with Ole Miss. It seems these kids really want to play for Nutt, have bad grades, then go to JUCO college where, lets be honest, is there really a good juco school vs. a bad juco school. I think at times people imagine issues where none exists.
    Great pic of Nutt, thought. Love this blog.
  5. The Ghost of Jay Cutler
    5. Posted by The Ghost of Jay Cutler Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:10 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Nutt's biggest obstacle at Ole Miss is going to be getting kids to qualify. For such a small state, Mississippi is freaking STACKED with legitimate, SEC-level talent but too many of them never make it to the next level. This is because so many Mississippi public high schools let their football stars just breeze through school without preparing them for their ACT's or, heaven forbid, their lives after HS. What you end up with are guys like Jerrell Powe (no lie: he has one of the highest GPA's on the team) who has shown that these kids aren't inheirently stupid, but rather just the product of a poor system.
  6. Barrett M
    6. Posted by Barrett M Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:35 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    "Big Stinky", you nailed it. Powe is an example of hard work overcoming not only learning disabilities but also a horrible school system. He is a hard worker and a great example. There are plenty of people who will devote themselves to tearing down people like Powe and schools like Ole Miss, count on it.
  7. JimBo
    7. Posted by JimBo Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:31 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Nutt is a weasel and always has been. The best indicator of what a man will do, is what he has done.
    Beopig
  8. Michelle B
    8. Posted by Michelle B Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:12 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Nutt was not summarily dismissed, there was a long list of misdeeds including his wife and her circle of friends sending hate email to players. There was not enough "homework" done by the national media on the reasons on his dismissal. He is, to use a term from his former Boise St. players, an used car salesman.
  9. sellingmidgets
    9. Posted by sellingmidgets Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:12 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    He's signing these imbeciles so that he could save face. Without the dummies, his recruiting class was a bag of suck and he was embarrassed. He's whined for years that you can't recruit to Arkansas and Petrino proved him wrong....quickly.
    Pre-morons his class was in the 50's
    Post-morons his class moved into the top 20.
    All ego. All car salesman. Orgeron recruits running out....tick, tock.
  10. Kenneth B
    10. Posted by Kenneth B Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:26 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    this last post is the correct summation. he had to save face because arkansas fans were really gonna get a good laugh out of that ridiculous recruiting class with one 4 * he had in early january. lets see where it is rated come august when rivals re-ranks the class of 2009 based on who actually makes campus.
  11. Drew F
    11. Posted by Drew F Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:50 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Houston Nutt was not "summarily dismissed". He RESIGNED. In fact, John White and Frank Broyles offered him a raise to stay with the Razorbacks. Please do you homework. Although, I can see why you might think he was fired. HDN likes to labor under the premise that he was mistreated.
  12. Krissy R
    12. Posted by Krissy R Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:55 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    e you a dummy or just don't know what your tlking about. He was "FIRED". There was no raise & Frank & White got booted with the way they allowed Nutt to leave with all that money. He was offered only the door with a boat load of cash, No raise. We've did our "homework" over here. Guess you haven't.
  13. Eric
    13. Posted by Eric Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:52 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Krissy R...
    Really??? LOL!!! I really needed a good laugh!!!
    Eric
  14. Roger G.
    14. Posted by Roger G. Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:38 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    The state and school have changed, but Hootie's traveling roadshow and tent revival/snake oil salesmanship stay the same...the guy is pure sleaze. The rubes at Ole Myth think he walks on water, hilarious! Hootie is a cross between a used car salesman, tent preacher and carnival barker. I can't wait to see the webel fans faces when they find out they've been had. On 2nd thought, they'd probably trade one good year for a bunch of underachieving ones...
  15. Leave
    15. Posted by Leave Thu Sep 03, 2009 6:47 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Sports fans are finally starting to see the light about Houston Nutt with this article. Although he is a great motivator, there isn't much else about him as a coach that is positive. After this next year, with such high expectations, more people will really start to see what kind of a coach he is.
  16. BlaineG
    16. Posted by BlaineG Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:41 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Why use this forum to attack a decent man?
    He is very big into charity work...if you don't believe me ask Donna B.
  17. mshogfanhflat
    17. Posted by mshogfanhflat Thu Aug 13, 2009 7:42 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    It seems like we have seen the houston nutt early success story before, then it went to pot. He'll use anybody and everybody to make himself look good. My advice to Houston is hire Orgeron as the recruiting coordinator, since that's where his players now came from.

Dr. Saturday

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Matt Hinton

Dr. Saturday is a college football blog edited by Matt Hinton. Email him tips and feedback.

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Dr. Saturday Recent Readers