Wed Nov 19, 2008 12:03 pm EST
I touched on their quotes this morning in a different context -- Michigan's unprecedented badness and impending implosion heading into the Ohio State game -- but I wanted to come back to Chris Spielman's comments Tuesday on Kirk Herbstreit's radio show in Columbus, especially in light of the two Michigan games he's worked this year, against Michigan State and Penn State.
It's one thing to say "Michigan is bad." This is an objective statement: Michigan is 3-8. You can call them the worst team in Michigan history; Desmond Howard almost disowned his alma mater on the same show, calling the current Wolverines "Michigan Tech" and suggesting patience with Rich Rodriguez might be growing thin. Howard happens to be in a position to know this is probably true, and within objective editorial bounds. Kirk Herbstreit, who will still get excited at Ohio State games and occasionally put his bawling children on national television in Buckeye gear, is the reigning master of walking the line between a legitimate editorial statement like "Michigan is bad" and the unacceptable "I hate Michigan." Take this statement from Tuesday's show, for example:
"I think they're just looking forward to getting the season over and hitting the recruiting," Herbstreit said.
Yeah, they probably are. Michigan fans can probably agree with that. Let's get on to recruiting.
Another former Buckeye, Chris Spielman, has been calling games for ESPN for a while now, including quite a few Michigan games, especially when he partnered with Pam Ward in the early afternoon Big Ten slot before joining Sean McDonough's roving team last year. But he hasn't quite bridged that gap between passion, which comes in second to testosterone in "Things Chris Spielman Exudes," and analysis. His comments on Herbstreit's show started off alright:
"[The Wolverines] stink, they're not very good. They don't play offense ... they can't run it consistently, they can't throw it consistently, they can't stop the run, they're not very good defending the pass, they're not very good covering kicks, they're not very good returning kicks," Spielman said.
Harsh, but all legitimate editorial criticism, until we get to ...
"I love seeing them beaten down, man. It's great," Spielman said.
And thus ends (or should end) Chris Spielman's license to call any Michigan game. I like Spielman, I like his transparent love for football, I like that he still seems more like a player than an announcer and that he obviously would rather be on the field colliding with people than in a suit and tie in a booth. I think he's one of the best color guys on the network. But unless ESPN's new strategy is to openly antagonize its viewers, it can't have a born, bred and admitted hater calling the team he hates. Born and bred, like Herbstreit (a second generation Buckeye captain), fine, as long as he keeps his biases in check on the air. But an admitted hater, on a very public radio program: No.
Dr. Saturday is a college football blog edited by Matt Hinton. Email him tips and feedback.

RivalsMinute - Oklahoma State rallies over Colorado
Posted Nov 20 2009
Eddie George on Ohio State/Michigan
Posted Nov 20 2009
Posted Nov 20 2009
Edited by MJD
Edited by 'Duk
Edited by J.E. Skeets
Edited by Greg Wyshynski
Edited by Matt Hinton
Edited by E. Brennan
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Steve Cofield
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Andy Behrens
76 Comments
1 - 24 of 76
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
If any current broadcaster formerly from UM says this week "I hope OSU blows this game because the tears of their fans will feed my soul" I don't think I'd even notice...
Heck they had Desmond Howard sing Hail to the Victors on top of Ohio Stadium! Now that is crossing the line.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
It seems that, if you are running a network that places great value in maintaining the image of professional and impartial broadcasters, you can't have one of your broadcasters expressing a personal opinion like Spielman's statement on a public program and then calling a game involving the team at which he directed his statement.
You can't have it both ways- at least, you shouldn't. Even if you are the Worldwide Leader...
Report Abuse
Unless the set-up is a Michigan guy vs. an Ohio State (or whoever Michigan is playing) guy in the booth. That would be interesting, but it's not happening. He shouldn't be fired or anything, he just shouldn't do Michigan games. It's antagonistic and unfair to Michigan fans, in the same way having a known cheerleader in the booth would be unfair; it doesn't "add to the rivalry" if it's one-sided. I always think about this when Herbstreit does Ohio State games, even though he's always professional on the air (children aside). You can't have a guy in the booth who says he loves seeing one of the teams on the field lose.
Report Abuse
They get big sloppy kisses from the booth. Getting games called by an unabashed rival is just the flip side of that coin.
Report Abuse
Are you just worried that Michigan fans may have suddenly found out that the most intense linebacker in OSU history might have bought into this whole rivalry thing and doesn't like their team too much?
Report Abuse
(that category being 'annoying, but not nearly bad enough to make me change the channel')
Report Abuse
It annoys me to no end to turn on something like First Take and hear these people go on and on about Michigan and Ohio State and whoever elses alma mater.
This year is karma for Rich Rodriguez.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
This is, in my mind, entirely different from a situation in which the person doing the analysis has an admitted favorite (Herbie for his team, or Griese for his son). Having a favorite doesn't cause one to change one's analysis; but hatred most definitely can have that effect - or it can seem that way, which to the observer has the same effect (that of discrediting the analysis).
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
but what goes around comes around and eventually uofm will win several in a row, right now osu is clearly the superior program in the big ten. however, the league as a whole is pretty pathetic...
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Besides, he wouldn't be enjoying Michigan's stumble so much, if the rivalry didn't mean so much to him...which if you think about it, is a huge sign of respect since no one would be that passionate if it didn't matter to them.
Report Abuse
The one that before you make a comment to, you look at someone and whisper; "watch this"?
That is Chris Spielman.
Report Abuse
5 consecutive loses to Ohio State will be another record for Rich-Rod to be a part of.
Prediction:
Ohio St 38 - U of M 10. Tressel will try to be nice and not run up the score.
Report Abuse
pulling for Michigan. I remember Desmond Howard rubbing salt in open Buckeye wounds with his infamous
Heisman pose after a touchdown. If Michigan goes winless from here to the next milenium I do not care. i am
a Buckeye fan always, may get discouraged but proud of Ohio State and its traditions. Jim Tressel is a class
act as a coach. Woody Hayes was good, but all I see is Woody grabbing a Clemson player and embarrassing
a university. All I can say is GO BUCKS!!!!
Report Abuse
Go Blue crack them nuts.
Report Abuse
ESPN announcer, Mr. Tony "no hair or comb over". Why is he even affililiated with football, he shld be
detained in Guantanamo for misrepresentation of a reporter or announder.
1 - 24 of 76