Dr. Saturday - NCAAF

As an amateur observer, you probably think college stars Percy Harvin and Michael Crabtree are absurd athletes and proven winners that any team on any level would be beating its brains out to recruit, draft, sign or otherwise employ. That, reader, is why you're just sitting at a desk, staring blankly at a screen, trying to keep your expanding gut off the space bar. Because if you actually knew anything, like the professionals, you might be able to grasp what the prospect of drafting Harvin, Crabtree or Rey Maualuga is really like:

One top-ranking official, who said he would not draft any of them, compared the exercise to trying to decide between whether he’d rather eat cow manure, drink monkey urine or ingest rabbit turds.

So there you have it: The consensus All-American who caught 41 touchdown passes, led his team to the greatest season in school history and was never arrested, suspended or quoted in any remotely controversial way is not only not worth drafting, but is no more valuable to a team than consuming various forms of animal excrement. The same official said he feels ill when he considers watching sunsets on the beach, test-driving sleek sports cars or receiving greeting cards from his grandmother.

Actually, none of the likely first-rounders -- Harvin, Crabtree, Maualuga, Vontae Davis and B.J. Raji -- cited last week by Pro Football Weekly's panel of NFL honchos as risky picks because of "suspect track records" was ever "in trouble" at any point in their college career, via arrest or suspension (though Raji and Crabtree both missed seasons due to academics before working their way back into school and their teams' good graces). Read the tea leaves, though, and the red flags everywhere: Harvin has issues with "coachability" and "respect for authority" (based on this, maybe?); Crabtree's "abnormally large ego" can't finish once he's had a taste of success; Maualuga may be prone to struggle with accountability, intelligence and "ability to responsibly handle alcohol"; and Raji reportedly failed a drug test while in college (a "verified" failed drug test, specifically, which presumably distinguishes it from the sketchy rumors about Raji, Harvin and Davis the last couple weeks). All have big question marks about their "maturity."

Just a reminder the next time you're really impressed by one your favorite college stars: In all likelihood, if at any point in college they acted like college-aged males, your stars make the scouts sick.

digg delicious
more

8 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. squirrelyearl
    1. Posted by squirrelyearl Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:37 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    To some degree you gotta wonder if that scout was playing mind games. I mean these guys are undeniably studly, but maybe he's trying to downgrade their value in the eyes of others for the sake of his own team, or maybe his team really doesn't need those positional players. I just don't really trust this being on the level if he's using that kind of language. Entertaining though.
  2. gtne91
    2. Posted by gtne91 Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:43 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Did Calvin Johnson admitting to smoking pot hurt his draft status (well, maybe it did, he ended up in Detroit, I guess he should have tried harder to seem uncoachable or something). Was it the admission that caused them to overlook it?
  3. squirrelyearl
    3. Posted by squirrelyearl Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:37 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Keep in mind that Detroit under Millen was insane in their draft methodologies so that's definitely the wrong team to try to prove an argument with.
  4. TheTruth
    4. Posted by TheTruth Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:27 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    No doubt squirrelyearl. That's exactly what's going on. Teams who are drafting below where these guys are expected to be picked have a definite incentive to see that they are tarred as being risky so that they fall to their spot in the draft. There are certainly plenty of GMs in the NFL gullible/stupid enough to fall for this. Even if they don't, it can influence public perception and pressure teams to shy away from players.
  5. A C
    5. Posted by A C Thu Sep 03, 2009 2:47 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Um... Rey Maualuga was one of many USC players who has trouble with the law. http://www.usatoday.com/sports/college/football/2005-11-02-roundup_x.htm
    but like the good caring coach he is, Pete made sure the charges were all handled: Maualuga apologized. there, everything is better now. Rape/sexual assault is taught during USC football player's freshman year. Looks like Sanchez was enrolled in the same class: http://cbs2.com/local/Mark.Sanchez.Sexual.2.516119.html
  6. squirrelyearl
    6. Posted by squirrelyearl Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:37 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Of course I don't mean to rain on the Doc's mocking of the NFL parade, being realistic about things just isn't quite so funny. I'm all in favor and enjoyed the post.
  7. just4funsies
    7. Posted by just4funsies Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:44 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    It's a crapshoot. If the guys evaluating the talent were any more expert than WE are, then ALL the NFL teams would be fantastic. But they're not. That's why a dozen or so teams SUCK EVERY YEAR. Yet, people print what they say as though it were Scripture. Ridiculous. My guesses are just as good as theirs, maybe better. And that really ain't saying much.
  8. you've been pwned!
    8. Posted by you've been pwned! Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:28 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    now that's funny!

Dr. Saturday

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Matt Hinton

Dr. Saturday is a college football blog edited by Matt Hinton. Email him tips and feedback.

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Dr. Saturday Recent Readers