Wed Oct 28, 2009 12:32 pm EDT

Now in its fifth year, the Blog Poll is a weekly effort of dozens of college football-centric Web sites representing a wide array of schools under the oversight of founder/manager/guru Brian Cook at MGoBlog, and now appears on CBS Sportsline. It’s an effort to provide a more rigorous check on the mainstream polls that actually, like, count toward the mythical championship, and enthusiastically shines a light on its voters' biases. But mainly, it’s fun. The entire poll will be released later today.
This week's ballot is brought to you by the state song of Iowa, "The Song of Iowa," which reminds readers to:
See yonders fields of tasseled corn, Iowa in Iowa,
Where plenty fills her golden horn, Iowa in Iowa,
See how her wonderous praries shine.
To yonder sunset’s purpling line,
O! happy land, O! land of mine, Iowa, O! Iowa.
As always, the lineup is constructed exclusively on resumé to date, with no regard to predictions, abstract notions of inherent strength or any previous rankings this season; it's only reflective of games played so far. The full resumé chart for this week's poll is below the jump.
Iowa! Yes, I was persuaded by the Hawkeye-loving computers that the object of their affection has navigated a tougher schedule than the other six unbeaten teams, including Florida and Alabama, but that was true last week, too, when I kept Iowa No. 3 because of their much narrower margins of victory. What turned the tide for Iowa in my mind this week, after a couple close calls by the Gators and Tide against mediocre opponents, was a reconsideration of how well the Hawkeyes stack up in their biggest games:

Iowa has beaten six BCS-conference teams with .500 or better records, twice as many as any other undefeated team except Alabama (with four; see resumé chart below), and handled the best of those with roughly the same aplomb as the SEC killers, whose big overall margins of victory came via blowouts against cupcakes. The best arguments against the Hawkeyes right now are their close calls against their only pushovers, Northern Iowa and Arkansas State, but I'm willing to call it a a, 1b and 1c situation and give Iowa the benefit of the doubt for putting more, better skins on the wall. But that's just this week -- the call is close and certainly won't survive Florida beating Georgia or Alabama beating LSU over the next two weeks, when the Hawkeyes' schedule lightens considerably against Northwestern and Indiana.
+/–: Average margin of victory; SoS: Strength of schedule (calculated by Jeff Sagarin); Oppt %: Combined winning percentage all opponents.

As always, everything will be completely different next week.
Dr. Saturday is a college football blog edited by Matt Hinton. Email him tips and feedback.

RivalsMinute: Breaking down Texas vs. A&M
Posted Nov 26 2009
Posted Nov 26 2009
Posted Nov 26 2009
Edited by MJD
Edited by 'Duk
Edited by J.E. Skeets
Edited by Greg Wyshynski
Edited by Matt Hinton
Edited by E. Brennan
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Steve Cofield
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Andy Behrens
19 Comments
1 - 19 of 19
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
BTW, Troy is ranked higher than a few teams in the big 10? (Purdue, Northwestern, Indiana, according to the Sagarin rankings.)
Report Abuse
Not only do they get to play 2 of those teams (and the two worst ones), then they go out and schedule
all 4 games with teams much worse than Troy!
At least the SEC teams have to play a bunch of top 20 teams...????
Report Abuse
So the best Sunbelt team, and FSU is not exactly a weak ooc!!
It's not strong either....
I would call it average.
Report Abuse
Have you seen Florida State play this year, by chance?
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Look at WVU vs. OSU. OSU's "best" loss is better than WVU's. OSU has a better SoS, MOV, and opponent win %. Compare the wins: in my opinion Wisconsin UConn, Minn Marshall, IND ECU, Navy Colorado, and Toledo Syracuse. So every single thing about OSU is better than WVU except for the one extra loss, where WVU has played fewer games. So the one extra loss is enough to more than cancel out every other factor considered here?
This isn't OSU griping, this is griping that this poll absolutely fails to do what it promises, using some examples of teams I'm particularly familiar with. OSU should be ahead of both WVU and Arizona, but they're not - the question is why.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
by the end of the regular season, the SEC will have played 25 games vs MAC, C-USA and SunBelt also-rans PLUS another 11 against I-AA teams... that's exactly 75% of their league's out of conference schedule (I omitted the 2 games vs Troy- the only team to be consistent this decade)
When you ask one of their pundits why they schedule so many cupcakes, they reply with "The SEC plays 5-6 tough games, so they play some cupcakes to even it out" (see #4 above)
Ask them how they know those teams are tough, and you get "ten SEC teams will be bowl eligible"
Exactly HOW will they get to the 6 wins to make them bowl eligible? SEC pundits will never admit to it, but here it goes.
(Take note of the formula PAC-10; Big 12, Big Ten are getting it; ACC & Big East are over scheduling the I-AA teams)
**get 2-3 wins vs the fellow bottom feeders (Ky, Miss St, Ark, Vandy, Miss, Tenn), then get 3-4 wins vs cupcakes**
NOTE: Bottom feeders NEVER schedule OOC top 25 teams (computers prefer easy win over tough loss)
Kentucky: MIami (OH), Louisville, East Kentucky, La-Monroe
Vandy: West Carolina, Rice (a loss to Army & Ga Tech next week means Vandy stays home for the Holidays)
Tenn: West Kentucky, Ohio, Memphis (Lost to UCLA-who is winless in Pac10)
Miss St: Jackson St, Mid Tenn (Houston and Ga Tech were scheduled before their current rise in talent)
Ole Miss: Memphis, Southeast La, UAB, Northern Arizona (better brush after two cupcakes)
Arkansas: Missouri St, Tex A&M, East Mich, Troy
That's is a total of TWO worthy opponents OUT OF 24... a whopping 8%
By the way, its the same formula that DELIVERS the SEC champ to the Mythical Championship game each of the past 3 years, via artificially inflated SOS ratings.
Being a math guy, I will give props to the SEC brass for cracking the BCS formula
Report Abuse
1 - 19 of 19