Dr. Saturday - NCAAF

Once again we're gobsmacked by the routine passage of time: Ten years have passed like that, and to commemorate the artificially grouped events therein, the Doc Sat team is counting down the best of 2000-09. Today's category: Best play.

Matt Hinton: Leinart to Jarrett (Oct. 15, 2005)
I'm in the unusual position of selecting a play I didn't actually see as it unfolded, only heard -- in fact, my entire sense of the drama of Matt Leinart's last gasp, fourth-and-9 completion to Dwayne Jarrett at Notre Dame in 2005 comes from where I heard the play unfold: In a press box at an obscure Conference USA stadium, where more than a dozen veteran beat writers were blatantly ignoring the highest-scoring first half in Southern Miss history to catch a glimpse of mighty, invincible USC's final drive in South Bend on a TV at the back of the box.

The No. 1 Trojans trailed 31-28 and faced a desperate fourth down to save their 27-game win streak following a second-down sack and a short dump pass to Reggie Bush on third down. There is a staunch "no cheering" policy in every press box; reporters are practiced experts at stifling emotion. But none of the paunchy, cynical scribes lingering around the set bothered to conceal their gasps, groans and general shrieks of amazement at this:

That set up the infamous "Bush Push" touchdown on the final snap that eventually propelled SC into the ill-fated championship showdown with Texas in the Rose Bowl, but the bomb to Jarrett is more memorable for the sheer guts of it. Aside from being an audible from Leinart, and from Jarrett reportedly suffering from double vision in one of his eyes, the deep call was as classic a case of one-on-one, "our guy will beat your guy" swagger as you'll ever see with so much riding on one play.

Honorable Mention: Pretty much any catch by Calvin Johnson, Larry Fitzgerald or Braylon Edwards, especially Johnson's whirling, one-handed grab against N.C. State as a true freshman and Edwards' game-winning leap against Michigan State in 2004; Mike Williams' glue-handed snag against Oregon State in 2003; and Darren McFadden splitting LSU's safeties with a ridiculous burst of speed in 2006.

Holly Anderson: Tyrone Prothro's Catch (Sept. 10, 2005)
For college football fans, "The Catch" has nothing to do with Joe Montana. With Alabama trailing Southern Miss 21-10 after three unanswered USM touchdowns, the Bryant-Denny crowd was getting restless with 'Bama facing fourth-and-forever just before what promised to be a very sober halftime. Under pressure, Brodie Croyle had to heave up a blind prayer to Tyrone Prothro, who was just as blind on the other end with safety Jasper Faulk in his face. Not that he was going to let that stop him:

Mouths dropped across America; officials reversed their initial call of incomplete and spotted the ball at the 1 for an easy Tide touchdown. 'Bama would dominate the second half and win, 30-21. Prothro would win an ESPY for his end zone heroics. And three games later, his playing career would end forever after sustaining a gruesome leg injury against Florida that's become as infamous as the catch is celebrated.

Honorable mention: In honor of one of our favorite things, Fat Guy Touchdowns, see Troy's Junior Louissant rumbling 60 yards against Missouri in 2004, Kentucky's Myron Pryor's "310 pounds of glory" run against Louisville in 2008 and Iowa's Adrian Clayborn busting through and taking it to the house to lift the Hawkeyes over Penn State earlier this year.

Doug Gillett: The Mississippi Miracle (Oct. 27, 2007)
During a 2007 season marked by wild upsets that saw top-five teams crumbling on almost a weekly basis, the most amazing play of the decade (and maybe ever) was pulled off on a tiny football field in Jackson, Miss., at a Division III game hardly anyone saw -- until the winning touchdown made the YouTube rounds, of course, and then every highlight show in the country. Millsaps College is up 24-22 at home, and conference rival Trinity (Texas) has the ball at its own 40 with two seconds left to make something happen:

Didja get all that? For the record, the "Mississippi Miracle" lasted 62 seconds, involved 15 laterals tossed by seven different players, and -- as more than a few people pointed out -- didn't incur a single flag. As far as anyone knows, it was the longest play (in terms of time elapsed) in college football history. I don't think I've ever seen a more heroic example of a team staying focused and sticking with a play to the bitter end. Just for good measure, Trinity went on to win the Southern Collegiate Athletic Conference title -- and this play beat out everything that happened in I-A that year to earn ESPN's "Game-Changing Performance of the Year." As well it should have.

Chris Brown: The Bluegrass Miracle (Nov. 9, 2002)
Kentucky doesn't have too many notches on its belt from wins against top SEC teams, so when it looks like they're gonna get one, the natives get very excited. So it was on Nov. 9, 2002, as the hometeam Wildcats had snagged a 24-21 lead off a field goal. A Kentucky player called timeout before the field goal, saving 11 seconds on the clock, but no matter: LSU began its drive on its own 9-yard-line. Quarterback Marcus Randall completed a pass to Michael Clayton to get the ball to LSU's own 26-yard-line; only two seconds remained between Kentucky and its biggest SEC upset in years. Yet what unfolded instead was straight out of a Wed Anderson montage (or Wes Craven, if you're a Kentucky fan):

In all its folly, excitement, randomness and cruelty, this is sports: Kentucky coach Guy Morriss getting the Gatorade bath before the final play; LSU quarterback Marcus Randall buying time and heaving it as far as he could; the ball cruelly and seemingly purposefully skirting off no fewer than four players' fingers, into the waiting arms of Devery Henderson; Henderson not only catching the ball, but doing so in full stride, between two defenders, allowing him to turn on the afterburners and stride into the end zone; Kentucky fans storming the field and dangling from the goal posts in the opposite end of the field. (My personal favorite is the student in the GQ look jeans plus blazer, non-tucked in shirt, and tie, who storms the field in glee and until it becomes painfully evident that his team has lost.) It's one of the most amazing plays of any decade, because all of college football is in it.

- - -
Please tell us what we missed! Previously on "Best of the Aughts": Best Upset, Best Scandal, Best Innvation, Best Villain, Best Game.

digg delicious
more

43 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. spencerO96
    1. Posted by spencerO96 Wed Nov 11, 2009 1:47 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=julW9Eroqcw
    please save the buckeye hate...that was a great play.
  2. iowacityriverotter
    2. Posted by iowacityriverotter Wed Nov 11, 2009 1:54 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Best plays of the decade have to include Iowa's last second win over LSU in the 2005 Capitol One Bowl on a bomb from Drew Tate to Warren Holloway: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1sU2LAJ2UKA
  3. Doghouse Reilly
    3. Posted by Doghouse Reilly Wed Nov 11, 2009 2:21 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    People in the South sure do love them miracles and football.
  4. sodahq
    4. Posted by sodahq Wed Nov 11, 2009 2:28 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    McFadden through LSU in '06 didn't end up making a difference in the game but damned if that wasn't the most amazing display of speed I've ever seen in a football game.
  5. alex P
    5. Posted by alex P Wed Nov 11, 2009 2:49 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    How about App state blocking a Michigan chip shot field goal for the win as time expires?
  6. thronedoggie
    6. Posted by thronedoggie Wed Nov 11, 2009 3:16 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    It's funny seeing the Mississippi Miracle after The Catch; for one thing, "The Catch" created the graphic for the Pontiac Game Changing Performance (and won that award for the year) - and then the Trinity/Milsap shenanigans won that award for 2007.
    But it's a little-known fact that the coach on the losing end of the hook-and-lateral was Mike Dubose, former Alabama head coach. Lo, how the mighty have fallen....
  7. thronedoggie
    7. Posted by thronedoggie Wed Nov 11, 2009 3:18 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    (#4) Doghouse Reilly - excuse me. A bit of a grammatical correction:
    that's "them *there* miracles and football".
    I'm glad we had this little talk.
  8. PurdueMatt
    8. Posted by PurdueMatt Wed Nov 11, 2009 3:23 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    "Quarterback Marcus Randall"
    ?????
    Do you mean Jamarcus Russell?
  9. quzybuk
    9. Posted by quzybuk Wed Nov 11, 2009 3:54 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    How can Boise State's hook and ladder not even merit a mention?
  10. jackwraith1
    10. Posted by jackwraith1 Wed Nov 11, 2009 4:17 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    That's not actually the game-winner by Edwards in the 2004 UM-MSU game. The winner was a drag route to that same corner where he just outraced the entire MSU secondary (followed by a 2-point conversion to Massaquoi, as the game was in the 3rd OT by then.) That catch was the one that eventually tied the game and pushed it into OT after UM had come back from being down 17 late in the 4th.
  11. lee j
    11. Posted by lee j Wed Nov 11, 2009 4:26 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    #8, no it was Marcus Randall in 2002. Jamarcus didnt get to LSU until 2003
  12. Brian B
    12. Posted by Brian B Wed Nov 11, 2009 4:51 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Boise State? Gotta remeber the Fiesta Bowl
  13. Wayne M
    13. Posted by Wayne M Wed Nov 11, 2009 5:00 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    I nominate 2QB Mike Stuntz's touchdown pass to 1QB Eric Crouch when Nebraska defeated Oklahoma in 2001. This play was miraculous and also had national implications. Nebraska became a serious NC contender and Oklahoma was eliminated from contention. Eric Crouch pretty much won the Heisman Trophy based on that play.
  14. Eric
    14. Posted by Eric Wed Nov 11, 2009 5:07 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Roy Williams Superman: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2d6cU2DwQRg
    The Boise State hook and ladder in the Fiesta Bowl also comes to mind. And the Tyler Sash interception to help save the day for Iowa earlier this year is an easy candidate for miraculous play this year: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qOYWmlYm5Xw
  15. PurdueMatt
    15. Posted by PurdueMatt Wed Nov 11, 2009 5:12 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    My bad. Don't remember Marcus Randle.
  16. Eric
    16. Posted by Eric Wed Nov 11, 2009 5:13 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    That Crouch play was a good one, but hardly a miracle. The Huskers sucked in an aggressive Oklahoma defense that didn't account for Crouch who caught a wide-open pass and ran it downfield for a touchdown.
  17. Deacon Blues
    17. Posted by Deacon Blues Wed Nov 11, 2009 5:22 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    The App State FG block was on a right-hash 37-yarder--not a chip shot for a college kicker. And App State had just blocked a FG a couple minutes earlier, so one could see it coming.
  18. Steve G
    18. Posted by Steve G Wed Nov 11, 2009 6:56 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    How soon we forget: What about the Boise State perfectly executed hook and lateral that scored the touchdown against OU in the Fiesta Bowl, followed by the Statue of Liberty for the go-ahead 2-point conversion. The hook and lateral was beautiful but there a lot of great plays out there; but where else can you find CONSECUTIVE plays like that?
  19. Steve G
    19. Posted by Steve G Wed Nov 11, 2009 6:56 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    How soon we forget: What about the Boise State perfectly executed hook and lateral that scored the touchdown against OU in the Fiesta Bowl, followed by the Statue of Liberty for the go-ahead 2-point conversion. The hook and lateral was beautiful but there a lot of great plays out there; but where else can you find CONSECUTIVE plays like that?
  20. Stachey
    20. Posted by Stachey Wed Nov 11, 2009 8:20 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Miraculous plays, I like Bosie state Hook and Ladder or statue of liberty, no others really were that great next to the tyrone catch for D 1 I mean
  21. ROBERT G
    21. Posted by ROBERT G Wed Nov 11, 2009 8:45 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    matt, you left out the bush push itself and all of the after the time had expired activities by the dishonest pac 10 officiating crew at the 2005 notre dame/usc game.
    if you need the films of those events from many different angles, we have it and will be happy to sent you copies, along with the names and current home addresses and teephone numbers of every one of those dishonest pac 10 officials at that game.
  22. Eric
    22. Posted by Eric Wed Nov 11, 2009 9:23 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Steve G, the beautiful thing (and awful, too, for this OU fan) about that game was the sheer number and variety of amazing plays. Just in the last stretch of the game, Marcus Walker grabbed a Jared Zabransky pass and took it the other way for a pick-six, OU forced a 4th and twentysomething in the last series of regulation, only to have the infamous hook and ladder sprung on them to tie the game. Then Adrian Peterson runs for 25 yards in his last run as a Sooner, only to have Boise State come back with a touchdown and the aforementioned Statue of Liberty two point conversion. A great game for any sports fan, even a Sooner fan on the losing end.
  23. ns
    23. Posted by ns Wed Nov 11, 2009 9:51 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    All of these plays are excellent, but most relied on a lot of luck. Boise State's three do-or-die trick plays in the 2007 Fiesta Bowl all went off exactly as designed. To me, that makes them, collectively, the play of the decade (but if you forced me to pick just one, I'd go with the Statue Of Liberty game-winner. That was just filthy.)
  24. Bruce
    24. Posted by Bruce Wed Nov 11, 2009 10:01 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Let's go back to the 2002 game between Georgia and South Carolina. Georgia DE David Pollack sacked the Gamecock quarterback in the end zone and intercepted the ball for a touchdown all in one play as the quarteback attempted to throw the ball away. This was certainly Houdinuesque as Pollack was just beginning to cement his legacy at Georgia. Speaking of, the Dawgs could certainly use David Pollack these days.
  25. MOSScomeBACK2vikes
    25. Posted by MOSScomeBACK2vikes Wed Nov 11, 2009 10:48 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    I cant take that Trinity play as a legit contender. Half of the other team quit during the play! That is their fault and cost them the game but it is not as good as that LSU miracle. When the fans are all around Randall and he starts jumping for joy, they are all like WTF is he cheering!?!

Dr. Saturday

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Matt Hinton

Dr. Saturday is a college football blog edited by Matt Hinton. Email him tips and feedback.

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Dr. Saturday Recent Readers