Dr. Saturday - NCAAF

Once again we're gobsmacked by the routine passage of time: Ten years has passed like that, and to commemorate the artificially grouped events therein, the Doc Sat team is counting down the best of 2000-09. Today's category: Best Innovation.

Matt Hinton: The jump-ball receiver. What I've most enjoyed with the increasing sophistication of passing offenses is the formerly spectacular catch made somewhat routine. It's to the point that I would say most games now feature at least one acrobatic grab that a decade ago would have been considered one of the highlights of the week, or of the year, and a major aspect of that is the emergence of the physical, small forward-type who can go up and come down with balls almost regardless of the coverage or the throw.

The All-American receivers of a decade ago were almost exclusively short, quick types prized for their speed, guys like Peter Warrick, Troy Walters, Dennis Northcutt, Torry Holt, Troy Edwards, Bobby Engram, David Palmer, Desmond Howard and pretty much anyone who played for the most sophisticated passing offense of the era at Florida (Jacquez Green, Ike Hilliard, Reidel Anthony, et al). There have still been plenty of great receivers in this mold. (See Mark Clayton, DeSean Jackson, Jarrett Dillard, Percy Harvin and Jeremy Maclin.)

But the guy who really changed the deep passing game in retrospect was Randy Moss, whose high-wire act on a couple dominant Marshall teams in 1996-97 forecast the rise of the tall leapers that have made the last 10 years hell for secondaries: David Terrell, Charles Rogers, Larry Fitzgerald, Braylon Edwards, Mike Williams, Dwayne Jarrett, Calvin Johnson, Michael Crabtree, Dez Bryant and A.J. Green are a very new kind of species, derived from the Moss branch as a natural adaptation to better quarterbacks and more aggressive passing philosophies. They're practically uncoverable, and they've changed the nature of the deep passing game both strategically -- they don't necessarily have to be open to be in a position to make the catch, because they're always in position to out-jump smaller DBs or otherwise contort themselves to make the catch -- and aesthetically, just by being the slinky-like physical absurdities they are.

If nothing else, Larry Fitzgerald (2003) and Calvin Johnson (2006) both should have won the Heisman Trophy, which I contended during those seasons and only become more convinced of as they continue to light up the next level.

Holly Anderson: SkyCam.
There's not a whole lot to say about it beyond the obvious -- it flies overhead and shows pretty pictures for a rapt home viewing audience -- but its benefits to students of the game have been immeasurable.

Pair it with a knowledgeable announcer and you'll learn more than you cared to know about, say, offensive line play in the span of an afternoon. And even with a blowhard in the booth, it's a lot easier to see the inner workings of a particular scheme on your own. Also, in the interest of full disclosure, I feel obligated to point out that the SkyCam looks just a little too much like those probe droids from the opening sequence of The Empire Strikes Back, and as such scares the bejeezus out of me. Such is the essence of progress.

Doug Gillett: Fan culture thrives on the Web.
I know this is a more recent development, but can I say Erin Andrews in glasses? No? Then I'll go with the general proliferation of CFB blogs and fan-run Web sites, which -- and I know I'm biased here -- have provided an outspoken, creative, and (for the most part) very witty point of view independent from the usual mainstream-media sources. They've also been pretty fearless in pushing back against, or at least BS-checking, the "narratives" that the mainstream outlets so often seem preoccupied with prematurely constructing and then forcing down our throats. At first those mainstream sources were openly disdainful of the blog trend -- and you still see a few pompous diehards like Tim Brando and Buzz Bissinger kvetch about it every chance they get -- but more and more the big movers like ESPN and CBS have been buying into what the little guys have to offer. For example, you can now find Brian Cook's BlogPoll -- a fascinating and worthwhile innovation in its own right -- featured on the CBS Sports' Web site with CBS's official imprimatur. And I think this trend has gathered enough steam to have solidified itself as an integral part of the CFB experience.

Runner-up would be the Wildcat formation. When you've invented something that can break into an institution as monolithic (and homogenized) as the NFL, that qualifies as an important innovation in my book.

Chris Brown: The games (all of them) at our fingertips.
Broadband Internet, YouTube, ESPN360, expanded Cable channels, and DVR. This might appear to be similar to Doug's point but I'm not talking about all the commentary around, I'm talking about the simple fact that there is more football available to the average fan on a Wednesday afternoon than there ever was on game day.

Now, none of it is live football, but entire games can be watched after they've been played; highlights can be rewatched, redigested, and repackaged at the viewer's whim; and games from recent years or even eras gone by live perpetually on hulu, ESPN Classic, the Big 10 Network, and a bunch of other sources around the web. The 2000 Michigan upset by Northwestern? Why, hulu has a rebroadcast of it on right now. How did Danny Wuerffel avoid FSU's rush to light them up to win a national title? The highlights are there to see. What did Bear Bryant's wishbone look like in practice? Let me show you, not tell you. Yes, the greatest innovation in college football over the last decade is college football, more of it than ever.

[Editor's note: I can't believe nobody said the superimposed first down line. Or instant replay. And if anyone takes the "Improvement by Glasses" prize, man, it has to be Wendi Nix. But that's just an opinion]

- - -
• Previously on "Best of the Aughts": Best Upset, Best Scandal.
• Have an offbeat category you'd like to see tackled in "Best of the Aughts?" Drop me a line: sundaymorningqb -at- yahoo, etc.

digg delicious
more

12 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. PurdueMatt
    1. Posted by PurdueMatt Wed Oct 21, 2009 2:07 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Michael Crabtree is only 6 feet tall.
  2. PurdueMatt
    2. Posted by PurdueMatt Wed Oct 21, 2009 2:08 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    "which I contended during those seasons and only become more convinced of as they continue to light up the next level...."
    The Heisman isn't a most likely to suceed in the NFL award.
  3. kass0809@...
    3. Posted by kass0809@... Wed Oct 21, 2009 2:44 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    "as a natural adaptation to better quarterbacks and more aggressive passing philosophies."
    I am not sure this makes sense. Wouldn't taller receivers with higher vertical leaps be more of a benefit relative to speedier receivers with worse QB play, not better. Esp. since you follow it up with this statement:
    "they don't necessarily have to be open to be in a position to make the catch, because they're always in position to out-jump smaller DBs or otherwise contort themselves to make the catch."
    I would say that throwing to covered receivers is more indicative of poor QB play, not good. What would be curious is if there was a way to determine if QBs are actually better or worse than 10 years ago. Probably impossible, too much noise. For instance, one couldn't just look at completion % since how could you control the effect of the receiver.
  4. ess-eee-seee
    4. Posted by ess-eee-seee Wed Oct 21, 2009 2:48 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Big second on Wendy Nix. Though not as fast as Johnson or Fitzgerald, Sidney Rice was as good as anybody at the college level at going up and getting the ball.
  5. Brian M
    5. Posted by Brian M Wed Oct 21, 2009 2:52 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    None of that expanded viewing of games is live? Really? NBC has really gone all out in terms of broadband viewing innovation. I can watch Notre Dame home games live on the web or even on my phone! There are certain other, less reputable outlets for live streams of other games (and sure they're not exactly above-board, but neither was Napster when it first launched and it utterly revolutionized the world of music distribution before it was bought out and legitimized).
    I would agree that the superimposed first down line (and associated advertising and, now, the superimposed play line as well) should probably be mentioned. That has really had a dramatic impact on the viewing experience.
    When was instant replay introduced to college football as an officiating device? It seems like that was a development of the last decade, but I could be wrong.
  6. bignasty9600
    6. Posted by bignasty9600 Wed Oct 21, 2009 4:51 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I watched UConn/Ohio live on ESPN 360. I even caught the end of Florida State/Jacksonville State on ESPN 360 when I saw it was close. ESPN 360 also has the regional ABC games you don't get. And if there's a game being televised...it's being streamed online somewhere, legally or illegally.
  7. 4.0 Point Stance
    7. Posted by 4.0 Point Stance Wed Oct 21, 2009 5:31 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    PurdueMatt, do you sign on just to [profane] about every single article? I will go to my grave convinced of the injustice of Fitzgerald's snub in the 2003 Heisman race.
    Also I'm not 100% sure the first down line was a product of the aughts? I seem to remember that being a feature of late nineties games as well. Which means there are high school kids out there today who cannot conceive of the idea of a football game without the first down line.
    In general ESPN has done a great job of increasing the amount and flow of information on the screen at one time without imposing on the action. The first down line was the first sign of that trend.
  8. GTman
    8. Posted by GTman Wed Oct 21, 2009 6:15 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    4.0, The first screen information innovation was actually the continuous scoreboard at the top or bottom of the screen, which I'm pretty sure was a 90's innovation so doesn't count for this. According to Wikipedia, the first down line came to be in 1998, so it doesn't count either...Watching football without them is definitely a pain in the arse.
    I agree with you on the Heisman. The trophy should be given to the best player, regardless of whether or not their team is in the NCG. If the Heisman folks want to give a trophy to the MVP of the NCG, they should just wait until the end of the game and hand out the Heisman trophy instead of the MVP trophy.
  9. 4.0 Point Stance
    9. Posted by 4.0 Point Stance Wed Oct 21, 2009 6:36 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    On the other hand, I could live without the line of scrimmage line (there has to be a better way to say that).
  10. gtne91
    10. Posted by gtne91 Wed Oct 21, 2009 8:07 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Coming back from the Jan 1, 1999 Gator Bowl, I ended up, due to snow delays, drinking in an airport bar with an ESPN guy who worked on the first down line technology.
  11. OldSouth
    11. Posted by OldSouth Thu Oct 22, 2009 12:04 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    I never knew about the Buzz Bissinger thing until now and I just watched the Leitch/Bissinger/Braylon Edwards debate for the first time. I never realized Bissinger was so single-minded. He showed no interest in anything Leitch said, and if it weren't for Costas' moderating, he would've just been on an angry diatribe the entire time. It really makes me question the objectivity of someone who just claimed to be spending the better part of 50 years trying to "perfect his craft."
    It really makes me appreciate that I can come to Hinton for quick news and solid, sober-minded opinion, then bounce over to smartfootball.com for analysis and strategy, and finally edsbs.com for some humor.
  12. cheatypants mcsweatervest
    12. Posted by cheatypants mcsweatervest Thu Oct 22, 2009 12:52 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    SkyCam, brought to you by Vincent Kennedy McMahon.

Dr. Saturday

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Matt Hinton

Dr. Saturday is a college football blog edited by Matt Hinton. Email him tips and feedback.

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Dr. Saturday Recent Readers