Dr. Saturday - NCAAF

Once again we're gobsmacked by the routine passage of time: Ten years has passed like that, and to commemorate the artificially grouped events therein, the Doc Sat team is counting down the best of 2000-09. Today's category: Best game.

Matt Hinton
  Ohio State 31, Miami 24 (Jan. 3, 2003): It would be hard to invent a team as dominating as the Hurricanes -- defending national champions on a 34-game winning streak, overflowing with All-American and future NFL talent -- or a team that seemed to belong less in a winner-take-all championship than Ohio State: The Buckeyes had survived five of their last six regular season games by a touchdown or less and statistically looked like a team that should have been playing in the Outback Bowl rather than for No. 1 in the Fiesta against a monolitcally talented outfit that barely been tested.

The win, though, was quintessential Ohio State -- the defense held the Hurricanes' high-flying offense in check by forcing five turnovers, while the endlessly resourceful Buckeye offense converted one improbable fourth-and-long pass in overtime and drew a controversial pass interference flag on another to keep an eventual touchdown drive alive and force a second round of OT, from which it emerged triumphant as the patron saints of winning ugly.

Arkansas 58, Ole Miss 56 (Nov. 3, 2001): One test of a great game that doesn't have especially far-reaching consequences is when you can remember almost everything about it except which team actually won. And after four and a half hours and seven excruciating overtimes in Oxford, no one here deserved the ignominy of defeat.

Of 16 total touchdowns and 114 points for the game, 12 touchdowns and 80 points came in the extra frames, which were twice extended when both teams converted two-point conversions, twice extended when both teams failed to convert two-point conversions and extended once when, somehow, neither team managed to score at all. Eli Manning set a school record with six touchdown passes, five of them in OT, and when Ole Miss tight end Doug Zeigler was stopped short of the goal line on the Rebels' two-point attempt to tie in the seventh overtime, it was like a kind of shock. Nobody seemed to see any good reason that it had to end.

Chris Brown.
  Northwestern 54, Michigan 51 (Nov. 4, 2000): When the documentaries are made about this decade, it will be known as the age of the spread offense. And while the late nineties saw a few renegade buccaneers (including one future head pirate) experimenting with the spread, it was Northwestern's sudden resurgence in 2000 that really deserves notice as the tipping point for the spread's promulgation to every corner of the country, and the Wildcats' dramatic, 54-51 over the mighty Wolverines stands out specifically as ground zero.

The perception had been that spread schemes were the exclusive domain of pass-happy coaches, a legacy descended from the defunct (and largely discredited) run and shoot. And, sure enough, in Northwestern's upset, quarterback Zak Kustok had over 300 yards through the air. But there was another stat that made everyone take notice: Northwestern also had more than 300 yards rushing against a vaunted Michigan defense coming off back-to-back shutouts in its previous two games, led by 268 yards from Damien Anderson in a wild, back-and-forth affair that wasn't decided until the final minute. Kustok's 55 yards on 16 carries -- mostly on the innovative zone read -- also announced something new to coaches: You can run the ball from the shotgun, and with a somewhat mobile quarterback, it may even be preferable to running from under center. Randy Walker, Northwestern's coach, had installed the scheme based on visits with Clemson offensive coordinator Rich Rodriguez, and the rest was history: Less than a decade later, the zone read is at least a small part of almost every offense, even at powerhouses like Florida, Texas and, yes, Michigan.

Texas 41, USC 38 (Jan. 4, 2006): Flash forward five years for the true arrival of the spread on possibly the most outsized stage in college football history. There aren't really adjectives that can do the '06 Rose Bowl justice: It was one of the most thrilling bits of football a major bowl game had seen in years, between two historically great teams at historically great programs, and it cemented Vince Young as one of the few truly mythical players in the amateur pantheon.

At the time the game was billed as a star-studded matchup between supremely talented, undefeated teams that routinely hung 50 points on opponents and came in loaded with top-shelf stars like Young, Michael Griffin, Matt Leinart, Reggie Bush, LenDale White, Dwayne Jarrett and dozens more who are still making a living on Sundays. But I see the legacy of the Longhorns' heart-stopping, triumphant fourth-quarter comeback as this: The pure, zone-read spread offense was completely adopted not only by the renegade, lesser talented teams as a way to compete with and confuse the big boys, but also by the big boys themselves, led by the typically conservative Longhorns. (The 2005 season also saw cloud-of-dust bastions Penn State and Ohio State begin utilizing the zone read to take advantage of their athletic QBs, and Urban Meyer's introduction of the spread at Florida.) And with Vince Young, the spread had the perfect triggerman -- he was definitely the most terrifying runner out of the gun, which helped him complete 30 of 40 passes and roll up 467 yards against a USC defense that tried to defend the whole field, and never could.

Doug Gillett
  Boise State 43, Oklahoma 42 (Jan. 1, 2007): I count myself very fortunate to have been able to watch this one from start to finish, and what people forget in all the breathless discussion of Boise's overtime heroics is just how amazing the game was in regulation: There was the shock of the Sooners finding themselves in a 28-10 hole in the third quarter, followed by the shock of them digging themselves out of that hole to tie the game with less than a minute and a half left. Then, of course, you had Boise quarterback Jared Zabransky throwing the world's ugliest pick-six to give OU the lead, then rebounding to throw the fourth-and-long pass that was famously lateraled for the tying touchdown -- in a span of less than a minute. After all that, the fourth-down trick-play TD in overtime and the winning Statue of Liberty two-point play were almost gravy:

The upset angle obscures what an amazing game this would have been even if it hadn't involved a hopelessly outmanned WAC underdog defeating the Big 12 champion.

Georgia 24, Auburn 21 (Nov. 16, 2002): When I die, I'm going to ask God three things: 1) The meaning of life, 2) Who really shot JFK, and 3) What Georgia offensive tackle Jon Stinchcomb said in the locker room at halftime of the 2002 Georgia-Auburn game, probably the most memorable game I've ever attended, not to mention one of the absolute coldest. From a 14-3 halftime deficit, a Georgia team with its first-ever SEC East championship on the line clawed back to within four points, and then the fourth quarter settled into perhaps the most nerve-wracking 15 minutes of football I've ever witnessed: Seven punts, one first down, a fumble and a failed fourth-down conversion by Georgia, all in Auburn territory. With a minute and a half left and everything on the line, David Greene completed the go-ahead fourth-down TD pass to Michael Johnson known to this day as the "Prayer on the Plains," a new generation's Buck-Belue-to-Lindsay-Scott, opening the door for the Bulldogs' first SEC championship in 20 years. A non-Georgia grad probably wouldn't have nearly as much reason as I do to consider this one of "the best," but I know my heart has never pounded harder and my throat has never been sorer from screaming than it was that night.

Holly Anderson
  West Virginia 48, Oklahoma 28 (Jan. 2, 2008): It doesn't quite have the feel-good on-field marriage proposal angle of Oklahoma's horrific Fiesta Bowl ending against Boise State a year earlier, but Bill Stewart's first win as head coach at West Virginia is made all the more poignant by the briefly proud program's decline in his hands since. With architect Rich Rodriguez already bound for the head job at Michigan following the shocking home loss to Pittsburgh that cost the Mountaineers a certain bid in the BCS title game in the final hours of the regular season, the vivisection of the heavily-favored Sooners was the mountaintop for Rodriguez's handiwork at WVU, even if he wasn't on the sideline to experience it.

It's also a peak West Virginia's not likely to see again anytime soon sans Rodriguez and hall-of-fame quarterback Pat White, but at least the Mountaineers will always have Owen Schmitt's "runaway beer truck" moment and tearful post-game tribute to remember it by.

LSU 28, Florida 24. (Oct. 6, 2007): This had all the big-game trappings -- two top-10 rivals, Saturday night in Tiger Stadium, etc. -- but is memorable mainly as the game in which right-thinking observers became convinced that LSU coach Les Miles' genius lay entirely with the whims of a chaos-peddling trickster god. There's no other explanation for the Tigers' rally from 10 points down in the second half, which required every one of four successful fourth down conversions to finish off three separate touchdown drives -- including two critical fourth-and-one plunges by running back Jacob Hester to extend an epic 60-yard, 15-play, eight-minute march that would come to define the Tigers' championship season when Hester went straight ahead for the winning touchdown with just over a minute to play.

LSU would go on to finish three other fourth-quarter comebacks and have a BCS Championship berth against Ohio State fall into its lap at the last possible second, an appropriate ending for a coach who proved against the Gators that the twenty-sided die he keeps tucked under his hat is every bit as good as some elaborate game plan.

- - -
• Previously on "Best of the Aughts": Best Upset, Best Scandal, Best Innovation, Best Villain.
• Have an offbeat category you'd like to see tackled in the series? Drop me a line: sundaymorningqb -at- yahoo, etc.

digg delicious
more

31 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. Amos
    1. Posted by Amos Wed Nov 04, 2009 5:55 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    "I count myself very fortunate to have been able to watch this one from start to finish, and what people forget in all the breathless discussion of Boise's overtime heroics is just how amazing the game was in regulation"
    Thank you Doug, I thought I was the only one.
  2. LongTrans
    2. Posted by LongTrans Wed Nov 04, 2009 5:57 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    What? No Iowa v. Northern Iowa??? Or Iowa v. Michigan State??? Oh, I see, you only want to talk about GOOD teams.
  3. Gabe
    3. Posted by Gabe Wed Nov 04, 2009 6:00 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Perhaps the McGahee injury was worth mentioning in the Ohio State debacle as well. Without that game, all the credibility that tOSU carried over the next 6 seasons or so wouldn't have existed and perhaps we would've seen some actually entertaining and competitive championship games in 2006 and 2007.
    Oh well.
  4. peoplespigskin
    4. Posted by peoplespigskin Wed Nov 04, 2009 6:06 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    OK, since Holly mentioned the 20-sided die, I have to ask her what Les' saving throw will be this weekend against Bama.
    And I'm surprised no one mentioned the 2005 "Bush Push" game between Notre Dame and Southern Cal.
  5. bluelightning11
    5. Posted by bluelightning11 Wed Nov 04, 2009 6:21 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Painful though it may be as an Auburn grad, I have to agree with Doug about the 2002 Georgia/Auburn game. It is one of the most memorable I have ever attended and I have been to some huge games over the last 10-12 years including upsets of number 1 teams, national title games and tension filled wars (not all involving Auburn)
  6. Ben
    6. Posted by Ben Wed Nov 04, 2009 6:22 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    "Texas 41, USC 38 (Jan. 4, 2006)"
    As good and as awesome as that game was . . . Keith Jackson working the broadcast made it even better.
  7. tony p
    7. Posted by tony p Wed Nov 04, 2009 6:26 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Great stuff guys. Only possible addition that I would seriously consider is App State - Michigan which was a legitimately great game all the way through.
    I also have a personal fav in the 05 Rose Bowl of Michigan - Texas, because it really signaled the arrival of Vince Young as a pretty amazing force in college football which set the stage for the following year.
  8. Adam S
    8. Posted by Adam S Wed Nov 04, 2009 6:31 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    The one game not on there that I think should be mentioned in the 2005 Rose Bowl between Texas and Michigan. It was an absolute shootout and Vince Young's breakout moment. It's right up there with the Title game the next year as one of the best Rose Bowls of all time.
    USC/Fresno state from 2005 was also a great one with Reggie Bush basically saving the Trojans from a huge upset all by himself. 294 yards rushing, 513 total yards....probably the greatest individual performance I've ever seen.
  9. Jeremy R
    9. Posted by Jeremy R Wed Nov 04, 2009 6:41 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Seriously how can you leave both the Vince Young performances in the Rose Bowl? That would be like leaving off Boise St-Oklahoma. You lose credibility.
  10. Reed
    10. Posted by Reed Wed Nov 04, 2009 6:55 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Sorry, I just can't get with your synopsis of NU/Michigan. I was at that game. It was in so many ways a terrible, terrible football game. Sure, both teams had strong offenses, but neither defense was at all prepared for that game. Missed tackles, bad angles, poor adjustments - everything was a mess.
    One could argue that the offenses were just performing that well. Perhaps this is true. But even so, the game's finish was marred by three extremely ugly mistakes. First Damien Anderson dropped a sure touchdown while wide open in the endzone. Then, after gaining the necessary yardage for a game-sealing first down, Anthony Thomas fumbled, giving NU another chance. Finally, after Michigan drove into range for a last chance, long field goal only to see the high snap slip through John Navarre's hands. The only people who think this was a great game are people who prefer Arenaball to football or remember it wrong.
    I gotta agree that Texas USC must be at or near the top of the list.
    Michigan OSU in 2006 suffered from the undue hype (and certainly in retrospect given how their bowl games turned out), but at the time, that game had a little of everything.
    Also, 2007 had a crap-ton of amazing games. LSU/Florida may top the list, but it was one of the most exciting seasons we'll ever see.
  11. Jerkwheat
    11. Posted by Jerkwheat Wed Nov 04, 2009 7:22 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    I've lived through too many multiple overtime games this decade. That Ole Miss game remains my favorite of the lot.
  12. TCMcG
    12. Posted by TCMcG Wed Nov 04, 2009 7:39 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Oh, Reed, you may be a very nice person in real life, but you're the wrongiest wrong what ever wronged. That game was the most delightful game I've ever been to in any sport. And I was at the NU/Minnesota "Victory Right" comeback the week before, which was also joyous in the pass-happy-comeback kind of way. High emotions, back-and-forth game, a night game - which Northwestern almost never hosts - combined to make it unbelievably memorable. Yes, Damien lost a wide-open pass in the lights (as I recall, I was clinically dead for some time thereafter - but no, you're right, being emotionally wrenching does not a "great game" make), but after A-Train had his mysterious fumble, The Mighty Zak Kustok got things back together and managed a brisk, surgical mini-drive to take the lead. If you hate a shootout of this caliber, I assume you also would vote "con" on a proposition to sit with a puppy beneath a rainbow while being fed cupcakes by January Jones.
    Bravo for choosing 54-51, "Chris Brown." You are a true American.
  13. andyd
    13. Posted by andyd Wed Nov 04, 2009 7:58 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    No mention of App State - Michigan?
  14. CuseFanInSoCal
    14. Posted by CuseFanInSoCal Wed Nov 04, 2009 8:09 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Apparently Gabe@6 lives in some bizarro world where a team that
    - has the fewest losses (not tied for the fewest, but absolutely the fewest) of any major-conference team AND
    - is the champion (not co-champion, champion straight out) of a major conference
    would not be selected by the pollsters and computers as one of the top 2 teams, regardless what that team did in prior years.
    In some happy bizarro world where my Orange went 12-0 next year, their poor showings for most of this decade would not keep them out of the title game.
  15. Grant
    15. Posted by Grant Wed Nov 04, 2009 8:58 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    My opinion: Michigan @ Wisconsin, 2005. Final: Wisconsin 23, Michigan, 20
    First Badger game I ever attended, and I couldn't have had a better view of what could be the greatest upset in Wisconsin history.
    But the feeling, the roar of emotion washing over the entire crowd after Calhoun wouldn't be denied and Stocco's game winning QB draw was like no other game I've seen. That team sent Barry Alvarez out a winner for only the second time against the Wolverines. It wasn't the most recent one; in 2007 a ranked Michigan squad took a beating from unranked Wisconsin, 37-21.
  16. bobby
    16. Posted by bobby Thu Nov 05, 2009 12:06 am EST

    Report Abuse

    only fitting the first game you mentioned was the one decided and awarded by the refs instead of the players it has kind of set the tone for refs for the decade. if the team they want to win is not throw a flag still working today just ask ga, indy., or ark from this year off the top of my head
  17. cheatypants mcsweatervest
    17. Posted by cheatypants mcsweatervest Thu Nov 05, 2009 1:35 am EST

    Report Abuse

    A few other great/memorable ones:
    2007 Navy 46 - Notre Dame 44 (Streak Over)
    2001 Georgia 26 - Tennessee 24 (Hobnail Boot)
    2000 Oklahoma 27 - Kansas State 24 (Big XII Championship)
    2008 Auburn 3 - Mississippi State 2 (Fascinating Train Wreck)
    2004 Georgia Tech 28 - Clemson 24 (Calvin Johnson game)
  18. J-D
    18. Posted by J-D Thu Nov 05, 2009 2:10 am EST

    Report Abuse

    The Boise-Oklahoma game was also the one that really started the pejorative Big Game Bob meme, too.
  19. Scott
    19. Posted by Scott Thu Nov 05, 2009 8:14 am EST

    Report Abuse

    Great List. What about the Arkansas Game--McFadden and his boys beating down LSU a couple years ago. LSU lost, but got final revenge beating OSU in the National Championship. Strange year that was---both OSU and LSU really didn't deserve to be there--there was no clear cut best team...like this year.
    History repeating itself?
  20. Rob R
    20. Posted by Rob R Thu Nov 05, 2009 8:51 am EST

    Report Abuse

    It's gotta be either Boise-Oklahoma or Texas-USC...and I'd go with Boise-Oklahoma. That entire game was fun to watch, and the ending (starting with the Oklahoma drive before the Pick 6) will never be outdone.
  21. Adam S
    21. Posted by Adam S Thu Nov 05, 2009 9:30 am EST

    Report Abuse

    Also, LongTrans, just know that Iowa feeds on your anger and disrespect. You have just powered them to another two point miracle victory.
  22. Mitt Romney
    22. Posted by Mitt Romney Thu Nov 05, 2009 10:22 am EST

    Report Abuse

    "Texas 41, USC 38 (Jan. 4, 2006)"
    As good and as awesome as that game was . . . Keith Jackson working the broadcast made it even better.
    "He'll be man-sized if he eats his cornbread."
  23. Robert C
    23. Posted by Robert C Thu Nov 05, 2009 10:28 am EST

    Report Abuse

    The best game I saw was Texas Tech v. Minnesota in the 2006 Insight Bowl.
    I guess this one did not have enough prestige to make it on people's lists...but it was the best game I have ever seen.
    Tech was getting stomped and they were down 31 points at one point. They won the 4th quarter 24-0 after a nearly impossible, in college, 52 yard field goal as time expired. This put the game into overtime where Tech was destined to win and they did.
    I am not even a Tech fan, but watching that comeback was exciting as it gets. My second choice is TX/USC.
  24. Misopogon
    24. Posted by Misopogon Thu Nov 05, 2009 12:41 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Didn't, like, college football's signature rivalry come down to a 1 vs 2 game this decade?
    Didn't that came come down to a thriller 3-point margin?
    Didn't that game essentially decide the destiny for the next three years and counting of these teams?
    Has there ever been a better game, from hype to final whistle, than Michigan/Ohio State 2006, in all of history?
    The games above are great, but this is like making a list of "Greatest Baseball Players of the 1920s" and leaving off the Babe.
  25. PHUC NUTT/as in houston
    25. Posted by PHUC NUTT/as in houston Thu Nov 05, 2009 1:40 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    arkansas - tennessee 1999 naked streaker's followed by goalpost being carried down dickson st.

Dr. Saturday

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Matt Hinton

Dr. Saturday is a college football blog edited by Matt Hinton. Email him tips and feedback.

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Dr. Saturday Recent Readers