Dr. Saturday - NCAAF

Once again we're gobsmacked by the routine passage of time: Ten years have passed like that, and to commemorate the artificially grouped events therein, the Doc Sat team is counting down the best of 2000-09. Today's category: Best Teams.

1. Miami (2001) and Texas (2005). Take your pick.

As you might expect, Doc Saturday's usual four-man panel turned in top-10 ballots that generally disagreed on every point, with one notable exception: All of us agreed that the two best teams of the decade, without question, came out of Miami in '01 and Texas in '05, two dominant, balanced, undefeated BCS champions that ran roughshod over tough schedules and have stocked NFL rosters for years hence. We did not agree on which team to put on top.

The Hurricanes, assembled by Butch Davis and fully resurgent in their first year under his successor, Larry Coker, led the nation in scoring defense behind an insane depth chart that included an incredible nine future first-round draft picks -- Phillip Buchanon, Ed Reed, Mike Rumph, William Joseph, Jerome McDougal, Sean Taylor, Jonathan Vilma, D.J. Williams and Vince Wilfork -- opposite an offense led by stars Andre Johnson, Jeremy Shockey, Clinton Portis and four future NFL offensive linemen in front of the Big East Player of the Year, quarterback Ken Dorsey. We won't get into embarrassment of riches further down the depth chart, in the name of brevity.

Man for man, those 'Canes may be the most monolithically talented outfit ever assembled, and played like it en route to a perfect regular season, a 37-14 Rose Bowl rout over Nebraska and possibly the most undisputed national championship in the history of the sport. And yet Texas, the only national champion of the decade to average 50 points per game, matched the '01 Hurricanes note for dominant note just four years later behind the most electric individual athlete of the era, Vince Young:

There's no reason to split hairs: Both teams were exceptionally dominant against first-rate opposition and rank easily among the greatest teams of all time. But if you insist ...

1. Texas (2005). Because the Longhorns have one notch on their resumé that Miami doesn't in the epic Rose Bowl comeback against the USC juggernaut at its peak, arguably the greatest single win by any team of this decade, and maybe of the last several.

If USC had held on to win, we'd be arguing about those Trojans in this spot, and that's not the case with any team on the Hurricanes' otherwise impressively deep schedule in 2001.

2. Miami (2001). But I still would not want to line up against this bunch under any circumstances.

3. USC (2004). Led by Heisman-winning quarterback Matt Leinart and the nation's stingiest defense, the best of Pete Carroll's Trojan dynasty won by 25.2 points per game and smoked undefeated Oklahoma -- a mere one-point underdog after a season-long pas de deux with SC for No. 1 in the polls -- by 36 in the Orange Bowl to finish 13-0.

4. Florida (2008). The 13-1 Gators are the best team on the list with a loss, winning each of their last ten by double digits to join '01 Miami and '05 Texas as the only BCS champs with an average margin of victory over 30 points per game. Besides the prolific, Tebow-led offense, UF finished in the top 15 nationally in every major defensive category and led the country in non-offensive touchdowns.

5. USC (2005). The Trojans spent the entire season at No. 1 and reign as probably the most hyped team on this list thanks to an offense that averaged 579 yards and 49 points per game, and boasted the unmatched star power of back-to-back Heisman winners Matt Leinart and Reggie Bush. But the "greatest team ever" now appears vastly overrated thanks to the mediocre defense's collapse in the Rose Bowl loss to Texas.

T-6. LSU (2003) The darkhorse Tigers led the nation in total and scoring defense, spanked preseason SEC favorite Georgia twice and completely shut down Heisman winner Jason White in the Sugar Bowl to finish 13-1 and place the program firmly among the national elite for the first time in decades. Yes, this is properly regarded as a split championship with Associated Press No. 1 USC, but in lieu of the dream Tiger-Trojan showdown, LSU's schedule gives it the narrow edge here.

T-6. Auburn (2004). Pending a successful finish by Florida or Alabama this year, the other Tigers are still the only undefeated SEC team of the decade, yet ironically aren't among the league's four BCS champions in that span despite beating five ranked teams and leading the nation in scoring defense. Again, Tigers-Trojans for all the marbles exists only in our dreams.

8. Oklahoma (2000). One of the most surprising national champions of any decade came from way back in the polls to finish undefeated in Bob Stoops' second year, beating four teams in the AP's final top 12 by double digits along the way.

9. Texas (2008). The Longhorns topped 35 points in 10 of 12 regular-season games and finished with four wins over teams in the final polls, eventually setting a new standard for Best Sustained Grieving when the BCS formula opted for Oklahoma instead in the Big 12 (and subsequently the BCS) Championship game despite the Longhorns' 45-35 win over the Sooners in October. This would not have happened if UT had caught the freaking interception one play before giving up the dramatic winning touchdown at Texas Tech, its only loss.

10. USC (2008). The counterpart to the high-flying 2005 Trojan offense, the best defense of the decade actually helped USC outscore opponents by a touchdown more per game than the '05 edition and outgained opponents by almost twice as much -- in fact, USC's yardage spread in '08 (455 yards per game to 222 yards allowed) was easily the widest of any team on this list. Alas, Thursday night slip-ups at Oregon State do not a legend make.

Also receiving votes: Miami (2002); USC (2003); Ohio State (2005); Alabama (2009). That's right, Buckeye fans, no votes for the 14-0, crystal ball-toting Houdinis of 2002. Let us have it. We're ready.

- - -
Previously on "Best of the Aughts": Best Upset, Best Scandal, Best Innvation, Best Villain, Best Game, Best Sleeper.

digg delicious
more

66 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. Richard R
    1. Posted by Richard R Wed Nov 25, 2009 12:02 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Short memories? Three teams from '08 seems silly.
  2. Peter D
    2. Posted by Peter D Wed Nov 25, 2009 12:07 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    pure talent wise no one is close to that Canes squad, that is just sick
    funny tho that dorsey was the worst of the bunch in the pros
  3. slipdog6
    3. Posted by slipdog6 Wed Nov 25, 2009 12:11 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Haha, I'm an OSU alum and to this day wonder how that '02 team did. Glad to see the '05 team god at least a thought. One of the top 3 defenses of the decade I'd say. Only team to hold Texas under 40 points that year, and Hawk and the boys held them under 30. And a similar situation to '08 Texas - if only Hamby caught the freaking touchdown pass to put us up 2 scores. List looks good to me.
  4. JJ
    4. Posted by JJ Wed Nov 25, 2009 12:29 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Yeah, some definite recent memory bias on this list. 3 teams from 2008? Alabama 2009 as an honorable mention? Was that a joke?
    As for OSU '02, any team that can overcome Jim Tressel and Craig Krenzel 14 times in one season, let alone against a team as stacked as Miami was, deserves a little bit of credit.
  5. mikez34
    5. Posted by mikez34 Wed Nov 25, 2009 1:00 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    You can't have 3 USC teams in the top ten. I do agree with Texas 1, Miami 2
  6. shubago
    6. Posted by shubago Wed Nov 25, 2009 1:10 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    ohio state 2005? despite the fact that a preseason unranked psu team beat them and then finished #3 in the nation after winning orange bowl?
  7. A!
    7. Posted by A! Wed Nov 25, 2009 1:16 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    So the #5 team on your list is "vastly overrated" because it lost to the #1 team on your list in an epic game...
    keep in mind that the 'vastly overrated' team was but 2 yards away from a first down and sealing the victory (still can't believe Bush was not on the field for that play)
    3 teams in the top 10 and a fourth just outside... can you say program of the decade
    FIGHT ON!
  8. Doghouse Reilly
    8. Posted by Doghouse Reilly Wed Nov 25, 2009 1:54 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    The 2004 Utah team was absolutely sick. They manhandled everyone they played -- including 4 BCS teams (remember what that was like, Urban Meyer?) -- and I firmly believe they would have had a good shot at taking down USC, Auburn or Oklahoma.
  9. josh.martinez82
    9. Posted by josh.martinez82 Wed Nov 25, 2009 2:12 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    What a surprise a Michigan fan snubbing an Ohio State team. Nice work Matt.
  10. buck i
    10. Posted by buck i Wed Nov 25, 2009 2:23 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    How could you not put '02 Ohio State in these ranking. They went 14-0 and beat a Miami team that had a roster full of future NFL stars. Not putting them in the top ten is one thing but not evening giving them an honorable mention is completely stupid. Just because they werent a team that was full of future well-known NFL players you cant overlook a team that played a spectacular as that Ohio State team. Its funny how you put the '05 team on there which shows that unless a team has a lot of NFL star-power then they cant make this terrible list.
  11. Doug G
    11. Posted by Doug G Wed Nov 25, 2009 3:15 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    What a surprise, an Ohio State fan not being able to tell the difference between Michigan and Southern Miss. Nice work, josh.martinez82.
  12. josh.martinez82
    12. Posted by josh.martinez82 Wed Nov 25, 2009 4:06 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Matt used to write for MgoBlog, now unless the "M" stands of Mississippi, you probably shouldn't be running your mouth.
  13. allhailcale
    13. Posted by allhailcale Wed Nov 25, 2009 4:22 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    I'm still upset that the supposed 'Grandaddy of them all' hasn't been renamed the 'Vince Young' Bowl, seeing as in two appearances, he racked up 839 total yards of offense and 8 touchdowns. And lest anyone think he just did all of that with his feet, don't forget that he completed 68% of his passes in those two games. Just to give you an idea of how good that is, only Bobby Petrino's two Louisville QBs, Jason Campbell, and Colt Brennan had better completion percentages than that in '04-'05.
    Much like Ron Dayne breaking Ricky Williams' record just a year later, were it not for the Tebow's appearance immediately after VY's departure, we'd still be touting him for what he was: the greatest college football player of all time.
  14. Adam
    14. Posted by Adam Wed Nov 25, 2009 5:14 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    The Ohio State 2002 team who shut down Miami (remember the team that "could beat the Bengals"), behind multiple entries from 2008 and a 1-loss team?... This is obviously a shortsighted garbage list. If Matt is a kindred spirit to the mush-mouthed fight-starting UM derelicts at the stadium in Ann Arbor last weekend... it comes as no surprise.
  15. MikeLew
    15. Posted by MikeLew Wed Nov 25, 2009 5:41 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    #13.....Actually, Matt Hinton wrote Sunday Morning Quarterback. Brian Cook is the guy who does MGoBlog
  16. Holly
    16. Posted by Holly Wed Nov 25, 2009 6:11 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Y'all, can we please get back to what's important here, which is that no matter who you root for, we hate your football team?
  17. bobby
    17. Posted by bobby Wed Nov 25, 2009 8:07 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    well first texas and miami are backwards but really disagree with usc 08 being on this list at all should have been 02 miami
  18. GeorgeK
    18. Posted by GeorgeK Wed Nov 25, 2009 10:56 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    when you really think about it that 2002 Buckeyes team HAD to be the best team ever. the fact that it survived the horror that is tressel ball and still won 14 games and beat that Miami team proves that fact. everyone makes a big deal about the talent gap in the natl title game and how osu was the "luckeyes" but when you look at it OSU had tons of NFL talent on that roster:
    michel jenkins, chris gamble, ben hartsock, nick mangold, alex stepannovich, shane olivea, craig krenzel(!), santonio holmes (redshirt, but still), kenny peterson, will smith, matt wilhelm, mike nugent, mike doss, aj hawk and dont forget maurice clarett would have been awsome if he kept his head on straight.
    everyone of those players listed has started an NFL game and most are current starters or pro bowl caliber players. that team was STACKED. if they had a coach who took the kid gloves off and let them play they would have won most games by 20 points too. credit jim tressel he did wht was necessary to win, but if urban meyer or pete carrol coached that team they would have been legendary. remember that team was very young, the year after OSU had 14, yes 14 players drafted into the nfl in 2004. unreal.
    just food for thought.
  19. Judas
    19. Posted by Judas Wed Nov 25, 2009 11:17 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    that 2002 O$U team shouldn't even be considered. How much did they pay Clarett in cocaine and hookers that year? I've heard it was somewhere between $50,000 and Tony Montana.
  20. CuseFanInSoCal
    20. Posted by CuseFanInSoCal Thu Nov 26, 2009 1:57 am EST

    Report Abuse

    You don't hate my football team, Hinton. Like your football team, my Orange have accomplished far too little this decade to be worthy of hate by anyone, except perhaps Louisville fans.
  21. A!
    21. Posted by A! Thu Nov 26, 2009 3:22 am EST

    Report Abuse

    #18... cry me a river. Players the 2002 USC team have started more games in the NFL than the players from 2002 Ohio St.... and USC didn't even win the Pac10 outright hat year
    Krenzel and Clarett as legit NFL starting talent... ROTFLMAO
  22. bobby
    22. Posted by bobby Thu Nov 26, 2009 7:05 am EST

    Report Abuse

    #14 AND #18 not only did the 2002 suckeyes not shut down miami if you watched the game the refs gave it to them with bad calls as for all those "nfl starters" you named not a name anyone has heard of for nfl starters from 2002 check with usc, fsu and miami. but the one thing you did have on the 2002 suckeyes was paid players remember clarett and company and that list of car dealers that still are not allowed to even talk to a player. the thing i never understood was why the ncaa has not striped that title after clarett and company got busted. any other school would have spent years on probation and had wins removed oh wait that would be the big 10 not the acc differant rules for the big 10 and nd i forgot
  23. GeorgeK
    23. Posted by GeorgeK Thu Nov 26, 2009 1:11 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    #22 the NCAA dosent award a championship dumbass, therefore there is nothing to strip, and the NCAA spent months investigating OSU and found nothing outside of clarett. the NCAA didnt suspend him, jim tressel suspended clarett. and the buckeyes totally dominaterd the trnches in that game, mcgahee had like 50 yards on 20 carries before getting hurt. we totally shut down miami. to blame it on the pass intereference is just ignorant and embarassing. you lost, end of story. and at #21, name these USC players, palmer and polamalu, who else? krenzel was 3-0 as a starter for the bears, so i guess thats legit. and clarett was going to be a first rounder for sure, dont kid yourself.
  24. VN
    24. Posted by VN Thu Nov 26, 2009 3:57 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Its still funny seeing U Miami fans crying about the NC game in 2002. Anyone that watches that play and doesn't see a hold (although it was wrongly called pass intereference, happened before ball was thrown - but ball placement would have been same), is delusional.
    I can understand why OSU '02 isn't on this list simply based on talent level and their dominance. But if Miami had won that 2002 NC game, they would have gone down as THE most dominant team ever. Do people forget this? They were being crowned the best team ever before the NC game was even played. Shouldn't it count for something that OSU beat "the best team eva!" and also went 14-0 (I believe the only team in the history of NCAA football to go 14-0). I think its short-sighted to ignore the accomplishments of that team - especially when you are rewarding so many 1-loss teams on this list.
  25. A!
    25. Posted by A! Thu Nov 26, 2009 4:10 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    #23... Since you listed all 15 Suckeyes that made an NFL roster-at one time or another- here's the list of Trojans: * Marcell Allmond * Kevin Arbet * Collin Ashton * Darnell Bing * William Buchanon * Dominique Byrd * Matt Cassel * Shaun Cody * Keary Colbert * Justin Fargas * Matt Grootegoed * Gregg Guenther * Alex Holmes * Norm Katnik * Kareem Kelly * Ryan Killeen * David Kirtman * Winston Justice * Jason Leach * Matt Leinart * Oscar Lua * Malaefou MacKenzie * Tom Malone * Grant Mattos * Fred Matua * Chris McFoy * Sultan McCullough * Jason Mitchell * Carson Palmer * Mike Patterson * Troy Polamalu * LaJuan Ramsey * Bernard Riley * Jacob Rogers * Frostee Rucker * Dallas Sartz * Lofa Tatupu * Kenechi Udeze * Lenny Vandermade * John Walker * Lee Webb * Kyle Williams * Mike Williams * Manuel Wright * Justin Wyatt
    Leinart, the lest successful of the THREE QBs has started 4x as many games as Krenzel

Dr. Saturday

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Matt Hinton

Dr. Saturday is a college football blog edited by Matt Hinton. Email him tips and feedback.

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Dr. Saturday Recent Readers