Dr. Saturday - NCAAF

I recounted Thursday the long chain of calls, apologies, complaints and threats that put the SEC in the position of potentially fining or suspending Florida coach Urban Meyer for criticizing conference officials, with one looming question: Did the conference really have the guts to drop the hammer on its most visible, most successful and highest-paid coach for a mild line in a press conference? Today, the SEC office answered authoritatively: Yes, yes it does.

Florida coach Urban Meyer was fined $30,000 by the Southeastern Conference for his public comments concerning officiating, Commissioner Mike Slive announced Friday.
[...]
"Coach Meyer has violated the Southeastern Conference Code of Ethics," Slive said. "SEC Bylaw 10.5.4 clearly states that the coaches, players and support personnel shall refrain from public criticism of officials. The league’s Athletics Directors and Presidents and Chancellors have made it clear that negative public comments on officiating are not acceptable."

Give the league this: It stepped up to enforce its stated policy, and brought enough heat to finally bring the escalating series of mini-scandals over the last month to an end. Meyer apologized for publicly suggesting officials failed to flag Georgia for an illegal hit on Tim Tebow last Saturday in the Gators' 41-17 win, and the SEC's other 11 coaches will think five or six times before calling out the refs with a microphone in their face again.

It's the "again" part, of course, that made the fine necessary, and the SEC's decision to repeatedly, publicly undermine its own officials opened the door to those circumstances. Meyer was the sixth coach to publicly criticize conference officials in the last three weeks, following Arkansas' Bobby Petrino, Mississippi State's Dan Mullen and Tennessee's Lane Kiffin (all of whom were publicly reprimanded by the conference) as well as Vanderbilt's Bobby Johnson and Tennessee assistant Ed Orgeron, after the SEC itself publicly acknowledged a bad call at the end of Georgia's loss to LSU on Oct. 3 and then suspended the same crew for several sketchy calls in Florida's win over Arkansas two weeks later. The conference's sudden willingness to acknowledge mistakes to the media obviously emboldened coaches to point them out, too, and the conference felt compelled after reprimanding Kiffin to raise the stakes of such insolence by mandating a fine or suspension for the first offense.

So the end result of the SEC's effort to bring "transparency" to the policing of bad calls is the coach of the No. 1 team in the country being fined $30K over a comment he made at a press conference -- in response to the suspension of his own player for a bit of unnecessary roughness -- about a play barely anyone would have ever remembered in a game that was decided by 24 points. Now that the league has made its point clear to the coaches, maybe it will keep its own opinions about bad calls behind closed doors from here on.

digg delicious
more

12 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. Brad
    1. Posted by Brad Fri Nov 06, 2009 1:49 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    It's a joke that Meyer is criticizing officials in the SEC, when his team was able to beat Arkansas solely because of improper officiating in Florida's favor. The SEC is a sham conference that gives preferred treatment and attention to whatever the star players and teams are in a given year, so that they can be in the BCS title game.
  2. saturdaynitelights.com
    2. Posted by saturdaynitelights.com Fri Nov 06, 2009 2:27 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    The "Joke," Brad, is that there exists droves of hard-of-thinking "fans" that , like the Birthers and other fringe groups marginalized by the success of their betters, spout dribble about conspiracies in the SEC. The Arkansas calls occurred early and mid-second half and were hardly the difference in that game. The same can be said about Cody's helmet incident. Florida fans remember well the FSU "Fumble-Gate" that ultimately segued into the SEC's use of replay, but most did not (and still don't) think the ACC was responsible for the refs calls.
    The SEC will be in the BCS game because one of its team will deserve to be there. And, when they kick the crap out of whichever team the BCS anoints as the opponent, there will be another round of bitter naysayers that will no doubt maintain that the SEC's conspiracy also involves BCS officials, and that the 2 groups have joined forced to ensure that the SEC is ALWAYS the BCS Champ. Why stop there? The Russians? Iranians? Who knows how high this goes!
    In a related story, Obama's presidency is the work of Globalist Elites bent on undermining U.S. hegemony!!! Right, Brad?
  3. Jacob
    3. Posted by Jacob Fri Nov 06, 2009 2:29 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    $30k is not very much money for the highest paid coach in America. If I were him, I'd take it out of my annual charity giving, and force the SEC to explain to the charities why they're not getting their $30k.
    Coaches commenting on officiating is not the problem. The problem is the unwillingness to get the calls perfectly correct using real time replays against fouls. There were fouls on plays, obvious ones, that Meyer is complaining about. Holding, pass interference, and some other calls are strictly judgement calls, and cannot be reviewed. But dead ball fouls and personal fouls such as face-masking, or in this case, eye-gouging, should be reviewable, at least in terms of the refs using the jumbo-tron big screens the EVERYONE has access to. Of course, jumbo-tron reviews may be affected by biased employees of the home team (See replays of Boise State punch).
    Coaches SHOULD be allowed to comment on the referees. EVERYONE ELSE in the world does, whether or not it affects their life. I do, you do, everyone does. In fact, Urban Meyer's opinion would be better than mine because he's coached for so long, and been exposed to more calls.
  4. EricB
    4. Posted by EricB Fri Nov 06, 2009 2:37 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Backed into a corner my ass. The SECs lack of respect for the ref stem from the refs inability to preform.
  5. Jacob
    5. Posted by Jacob Fri Nov 06, 2009 2:37 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    I_need_nitelights: Any time there is an appearance of impropriety, there's an issue. The appearance of impropriety, in this case, arrises because the SEC benefits by having a team in the BCS title game. If refereeing is used as a way to make this happen, or if there is an appearance that's the case, that's the problem. The appearance of impropriety would be negated by nationalizing the refs. The ref team that does Bama-LSU one week would to BYU-Utah the next. The refs would have no reason for preference - their check is written by people who don't benefit from either team winning.
    If Notre Dame were to trot out their own referees for home games, would you see a problem there? If Oregon trots out Pac-10 refs against Oklahoma, can you see a problem there? If the person who writes your paycheck benefits in any way by your preference, there's going to be preferences.
  6. AgentUtah
    6. Posted by AgentUtah Fri Nov 06, 2009 2:38 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Maybe someone Dan Mullen or Bobby Johnson has to watch what they say, but Meyer? I'm guessing that $30,000 check will be mailed from Beaverton, OR.
  7. Jacob
    7. Posted by Jacob Fri Nov 06, 2009 2:53 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Meyer can raise some of the funds by writing to Chip Kelly, impersonating an Oregan fan, and demanding money after their next humiliating loss.
  8. Carl V
    8. Posted by Carl V Fri Nov 06, 2009 3:08 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    @ Jacob:
    "$30k is not very much money for the highest paid coach in America"
    ... what does Pete Carroll have to do with this?
  9. saturdaynitelights.com
    9. Posted by saturdaynitelights.com Fri Nov 06, 2009 3:26 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Jacob, comment #7 is hilarious. As for #5, it is well documented that the appearance of impropriety is often as damaging as impropriety itself. That said tmy point was only that the calls in the Arkansas game didn't cause Arkansas to miss a field goal, or allow Florida to drive the field with a couple of minutes on the clock.
    Irrespective, te remedy you've proposed is without any presumptive force due to the inherent inequities in CFB, which houses about 30 to 40 real money-making programs and conferences, and 90 more small-time schools. Hence the concept of nationalizing refs and flying them hither and yon (presumably under the governance of the NCAA), while palatable in the abstract, is on par with the quaint notion of a playoff and you hooking up with a hot chick-not going to happen.
    Kidding aside, your argument is undermined by the fact that neither Florida nor the Domers trot out their OWN refs, it is the conference (for Florida, anyway) that assigns, grades, hires, fires or suspends as the case may be. Arguments of a viable conspiracy are simply fodder for the fans (like us), and the result of human error rather than any league wide mandate in the SEC, Big 12, Pac 10, or any other conference with BCS aspirations, to ensure that the favorites win.
    Now stop wasting my time with your Boggle skills and tell me if the Domers can cover the 12 against Middies.
  10. mikez34
    10. Posted by mikez34 Fri Nov 06, 2009 5:46 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    saturdaynitelights.com - I think you might want to recheck those Arkansas/Florida penalties. One of the phantom unnecessary roughness calls was on the go ahead touchdown drive and there was a huge offensive pass interference no call that allowed a touchdown. Both of which the SEC cited.
    The Cody helmet incident was in the final seconds of the game, and had it been called (like the rule states) Tennessee would have had another field goal try to win the game. Not exactly insignificant.
  11. Christiane
    11. Posted by Christiane Sat Nov 07, 2009 1:36 am EST

    Report Abuse

    Tenn would not have gotten a re-kick in that game. Alabama would have retained possession. And the Ark-Fla penalties were called on first downs. Hardly handing the game away.
  12. bobby
    12. Posted by bobby Sat Nov 07, 2009 7:18 am EST

    Report Abuse

    refs and bad calls are nothing new just ask miami refs gave tressel his only bowl WIN

Dr. Saturday

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Matt Hinton

Dr. Saturday is a college football blog edited by Matt Hinton. Email him tips and feedback.

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Dr. Saturday Recent Readers