Sun Oct 26, 2008 10:33 pm EDT
In a perfect world, the Doc would be given carte blanche to publicly torch the Bowl Championship Series in effigy and institute the elaborate, double-elimination battle royale of his dreams. But we live in the world we live in, so each Sunday the Doc looks at what the new BCS numbers mean for the rest of the season. Rooting interest: chaos. Always chaos.
Not much changes in the big picture this week, with the exception of Penn State's leap in the computer polls: PSU is third after its win over Ohio State, up from seventh according to the machines last week. It's nice to see everyone getting along, all the way up to the inevitable train wreck when the various tracks fail to sort themselves out over the last month. The computers can't agree on anything past the top three teams, with Oklahoma and Georgia sharing No. 4, Oklahoma State, Utah and Boise State sharing No. 7 and Texas Tech and Florida tied for tenth, all in defiance of the human polls. Past the top three, verily, it is the madness we bargained for.
Sitting pretty. Status quo still favors Texas and Alabama, which both remain ahead of Penn State by a miniscule but solid margin that will only grow if the Longhorns and Tide keep winning -- both UT and 'Bama have better wins on their existing resumés and tougher schedules down the stretch than the Lions and won't be budged from the top by anything short of an upset. And even if Texas loses this weekend at Texas Tech, PSU has to look out from below: the Raiders could be rocketing up the polls with the chance to keep rising against Oklahoma, Oklahoma State and the Big 12 Championship still in front of them. In other words, if there are three major undefeated teams at the end of the year, strength of schedule virtually guarantees Penn State is the odd man out.
The flipside of that -- assuming any undefeated team from a BCS conference will play for a championship ahead of a one-loss team -- is that the Lions have a much better chance of running the table against Iowa, Indiana and Michigan State than any of the other undefeated teams on their stretch runs:

Texas has at least two, possibly three (depending on what happens to Kansas) ranked opponents left, assuming the requisite date in the Big 12 Championship; even if Texas Tech does come out of next Saturday unblemished over the Horns, it has an even tougher road to navigate. Alabama has annual bugaboos LSU and Auburn (the Tide has lost 11 straight to division rivals named "Tigers") and the SEC Championship against the Florida-Georgia winner. So Penn State's task now is to take care of its business, then sit and wait for the others to fall by the wayside.
A little help? USC is in very bad shape here. The Trojans remain in front of Florida and Georgia for the moment, but that won't last past this weekend, when the winner of the Cocktail Party earns its biggest win of the regular season and effectively punches its ticket to the SEC Championship. SC can't compete with that with only one ranked team (Cal) left on its schedule. So the Trojans not only need at least three of the four unbeatens to lose, but also need Oklahoma and the Georgia-Florida winner to go down with a second loss, as well. Even if it keeps winning, I wouldn't expect USC to advance any higher than fourth without some highly improbable dominoes falling in its favor.
Oklahoma's chances hinge on winning the Big 12 South, and for that to happen, the Sooners need a Texas loss this weekend and subsequent wins over Texas Tech and Oklahoma State to create a two or three-way logjam that somehow ends with OU crashing the Big 12 Championship. The Georgia-Florida winner needs a Texas or Penn State loss, too, with the added bonus that it can knock Alabama out of the way itself in the SEC Championship.
For chaos' sake. Best case scenario: Texas, Alabama and Penn State all finish undefeated and the Lions complain about the snub all the way to Pasadena. Short of that, losses by Texas and Bama could create an insolvable bottleneck of teams with equally legitimate claims -- between a one-loss Big 12 champion, a one-loss SEC champion and one-loss USC, the difference could be a couple hundredths of a point in some algorithm no one understands.
It's quite possible Texas, Texas Tech and Oklahoma all end the season with one loss and a mind-bending win triangle against one another. Maybe Georgia edges Alabama on a field goal or something to win the SEC in far less impressive fashion than Bama won in Athens in September. That's the dream, anyway.
Dr. Saturday is a college football blog edited by Matt Hinton. Email him tips and feedback.

Posted Feb 3 2010
RivalsMinute: Bama wins the title
Posted Feb 3 2010
Posted Feb 3 2010
Edited by MJD
Edited by 'Duk
Edited by J.E. Skeets
Edited by Greg Wyshynski
Edited by Matt Hinton
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Steve Cofield
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Brooks Peck
Edited by Andy Behrens
55 Comments
1 - 25 of 55
Report Abuse
This year, multiple teams will likely meet the guideline of being a non-BCS conference champion ranked higher than a BCS conference champion (probably ACC and BEast), but because of that restriction, we may be left with a team ranked in the top 10 of the BCS and being left out of a BCS bowl.
Imagine what would happen if we get your final scenario, DrS -- with all these one-loss BCS teams knocking each other down. Utah beats BYU, and Boise State remains undefeated, as do Ball State and Tulsa. What then? You could have multiple non-BCS teams in the top ten, yet not able to go to a game. After all, if the bowls aren't forced to pick these teams via automatic qualifiers, they'll go with a lower-ranked but more telegenic team instead. And that's a real tragedy.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
There's five BCS bowls: Rose, Sugar, Orange, Fiesta, and the BCS championship. That's a total of ten teams. Let's imagine a worst-case scenario with a Big 12 and SEC matchup in the championship game. There will be at least one other team from each of those conferences eligible -- taking up four spots of those ten. Then there's the champions of the ACC, Big East, Big Ten, and Pac-10. That's four more spots, leaving two. The highest non-BCS school will take one of those spots with the automatic bid. That leaves just one spot.
Will that one spot be filled by an at-large non-BCS team? Probably not. There will be at least one additional Big 10 team available (either Ohio State or Penn State), and it's hard to believe that a bowl would pass up that team to take someone like Ball State. Let me know if I'm off on my logic, but I think that eliminates an at-large non-BCS selection.
Report Abuse
I'm ready to see the BCS computers fry.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
i see texas smashing penn state in the title game and ohio state doing the same to oregon state. although i do see oregon state losing at least 1 more game.
so the highlight bowl game that every college football fan wants to see is would be that sugar bowl with usc vs. florida/georgia. 1 month to prepare and on a neutral site? i see about half the first round of the draft going out in that game alone.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Heck, I don't even get why Ohio State is everyone's favorite whipping boy, and Oklahoma is not. I mean, both teams won a BCS title early in the decade, and have been blown out in one BCS title game and lost another more recently. Except that Ohio State has won its non-title game BCS bowls, and Oklahoma hasn't.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
or considered that psu's record against opponents in common with usc is 2-0,whereas usc is 1-1.
what that means is that penn state hasn't lost.maybe i'm old fashioned and outdated,but i woud actually like to see the two best teams play for the national title.not the programs that recruit well and have the most talent,yet can't get the job done against "inferior" schools.
Report Abuse
Where is the logic in the statement "USC would destroy Penn State in the national title game by 35." Penn State crushed Oregon State, made them look like a high school team and USC couldn't even beat them? Penn State would destroy USC. If PSU doesn't make the championship game then I look forward to them playing USC in the Rose Bowl just to shut you up. Pac-10 is one of the few major conferences that is even weaker than the Big 10 this year. GO PSU!
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Time for bed my lil man. You must be 10 yrs old and listening to your lil buds carry on vs knowing what you are talking about. If PSU doesn't make it to the natl. chapionship its only because: 1. Bama and Tx win out and that is fair enough or 2. the Lions get clipped by one of their 3 remaining Big 10 rivals. Other than that, they should, repeat Should, get the nod.
Better yet - let's have a playoff, we can speculate all we want and just like in baseball, hoops, and pro fb the answer will be proven in a REAL title game.
Report Abuse
1 - 25 of 55