Dr. Saturday - NCAAF

North Carolina 20, Virginia Tech 17. In the big picture, the Tar Heels' season-saving upset is on the ACC-leading defense: Carolina shut out Virginia Tech for a half, held the Hokies to 256 yards, sacked Tyrod Taylor three times and forced two turnovers, one setting up the game-winning field goal. Twice with its back against the goal line, the Heel defense was inches away from turning Tech away on its only two touchdowns. The Hokies had to work for everything they got, and they didn't get much.

But that was more or less expected from the UNC defense -- if you gave Virginia Tech 17 points coming into this game, Frank Beamer and a large percentage of the betting public on Tech would probably have taken it, because North Carolina's struggling, lo-fi offense was too hopeless to make anything happen against a Bud Foster defense on the road, where this fading season was set to go to black. And it should have, right after T.J. Yates' disastrous dump-off into the arms of Tech's Rashad Carmichael set up a five-yard touchdown "drive" to put the Hokies up 17-14 early in the fourth quarter, a classic coffin moment if ever there was one, especially for a team that collapsed in the second half last week against Florida State.

Instead of taking solace in a strong underdog effort and crawling into the fetal position for the last 10 minutes, though, UNC responded with an epic 16-play, nearly nine-minute march, converting three third downs and a fourth down on the way to the tying field goal, then took the Hokies' own disastrous turnover, drained the last three minutes off the clock and chipped in the winner. Just like that, catastrophe averted; shot at a respectable season salvaged, in probably the least likely setting for pulling off such a turnaround.

Now, the bigger reassessment is of Virginia Tech, whose longstanding alpha dog role in the ACC hierarchy is almost certainly finished for the season with a second conference loss, barring an utter collapse by new Coastal Division frontrunner Georgia Tech -- and given the typically unpredictable, cutthroat nature of this conference as it unfolds again, there's no good reason not to expect the Yellow Jackets to take a similar dive at some point, too. Virginia Tech is as close as this league has had to a sure thing from the moment it entered in 2004 -- four division titles in five years, three conference titles and the highest final poll finish in the conference five years in a row. Right now, though, the Hokies are just one of the rabble, a half-game ahead of Miami for fourth place in the Coastal Division, sitting behind Virginia and Duke going into the weekend (and since Virginia and Duke play Saturday, coming out of the weekend, too).

That can change -- Va. Tech was in the same wobbly position after losing three out of four at Boston College, Florida State and Miami in late October and early November last year, and wound up back in the conference penthouse by December. But with the same old issues with the passing game continuing to bog them down and a clearly less-than-killer defense by Hokie standards, there's nothing right now that clearly separates Tech from the pack. If this is still their conference, the Hokies will have to prove it down the stretch again, and get plenty of help along the way.

digg delicious
more

5 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. ZacharyD
    1. Posted by ZacharyD Fri Oct 30, 2009 9:19 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    I'm sure that "SEC" and Alabama fans will continue to trumpet Alabama's "impressive" win over a "Top 10" opponent just like last year. I'm sure just like last year, Alabama will be exposed as a fraud once again - my prediction LSU will beat them and it won't be their last loss of the season. I also think there is a good chance that LSU will win the rematch with Florida in the SEC Championship game and the reason is opening their season in hostile territory against what turns out to be a respectable opponent in Washington. Heck, by this point of the season Washington has more impressive wins than Virginia Tech does (USC would demolish Nebraska and destroy Miami).
  2. genius_man16
    2. Posted by genius_man16 Fri Oct 30, 2009 9:34 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Tech's defense just isn't as good as it usually is. It's still really good, but as you said, by their standards it's kind of "sub par". The biggest problem this creates is that it FINALLY exposes the offense for what it really is, and that's one-dimensional. Tyrod Taylor still refuses to learn how to throw the ball, and his underdevelopment as a passer is what has kept this team from going to the National Championship game the past few years. Virginia Tech is a lot like Nebraska actually. Amazing defense, and a flawed offense, and like Nebraska, until they figure out their offensive issues, they won't go as far as they hoped.
  3. bigboo's bro
    3. Posted by bigboo's bro Fri Oct 30, 2009 10:25 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Now maybe people will start realizing that Beamer isn't such a great coach or guy too. You look at some of the scum he has forced through the VT program and you really have to wonder who runs the university.
  4. just4funsies
    4. Posted by just4funsies Fri Oct 30, 2009 10:40 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Yo, ZacharyD... Exactly WHAT has your ridiculous comment got to do with this topic? I guess they don't teach people to READ at LSU...
    As for the UNC/VT game, it just looked to me like VT phoned it in, expecting to win without any effort. UNC certainly looked like the better team last night, and all the folks trumpeting the triumphant return of the Hokies are eating some crow this morning...
  5. STRANGLE HOLD
    5. Posted by STRANGLE HOLD Fri Oct 30, 2009 8:16 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Bah hahahahahahahahaha Big Bad VT got punked last night bye north carolina LMFAO VT dont look so tuff now !

Dr. Saturday

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Matt Hinton

Dr. Saturday is a college football blog edited by Matt Hinton. Email him tips and feedback.

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Dr. Saturday Recent Readers