Sun Oct 25, 2009 11:03 am EDT
Seven undefeated teams went in Saturday, and seven came out. But both Alabama and Iowa put their old-school, salt-of-the-earth personas through the ringer:
With Florida's tight struggle with Mississippi State for three-and-a-half quarters and USC's total inability to stop Oregon State in the second half, it was a harrowing evening in the top five, which may or may not rear its head in the polls in the short term. In the long term, though, championship survival is tradition.
In 1997, Nebraska's incredible "flea kicker" to force overtime in its eventual win at Missouri briefly dropped the Huskers from No. 1 to No. 3 in both , but I recall watching it at the time and thinking only the No. 1 team could have possibly made this play, in this fashion:
Eventually, the voters agreed: Nebraska won its last two in the regular season, blew out Texas A&M in the Big 12 Championship and then Peyton Manning-led Tennessee in the Orange Bowl, erasing those doubts and sharing the mythical championship with Michigan.
No team anywhere, ever has played the opportunistic, skin-of-the-teeth game better than Ohio State in 2002, which won five games by six points or less and two more -- including the Fiesta Bowl upset over No. 1 Miami -- in overtime. But none of those quite personified "life from the jaws of death" like Craig Krenzel's fourth-down heave to Michael Jenkins for the Buckeyes' only touchdown at Purdue:
OSU escaped Illinois in overtime the following week, hung on to beat Michigan by five and stunned the dominant 'Canes -- which had managed its own Houdini act against Florida State in October -- for the crystal ball, despite impressing practically no one at any point since mid-September.
Florida wasn't particularly impressive in 2006, either, following up a loss to Auburn with increasingly narrow wins over Georgia (21-14), Vanderbilt (25-19) and, most memorably -- and most damningly to the Gators' critics at the time -- South Carolina:
There's a reason Ohio State was a near-unanimous favorite in the mythical championship game less than two months later: The Buckeyes hadn't needed to block a kick against an unranked team at home to get there -- in fact, they'd hardly been challenged at all en route to 12-0, hadn't launched a fourth-quarter comeback or made any dramatic defensive stand at the end of a game.
But no eventual champion in recent memory has lived on the edge like LSU in 2007, which not only lost twice in overtime (effectively eliminating the Tigers as a true model for any other aspiring contender) but had to deliver three dramatic fourth-quarter comebacks in a four-game span at midseason, beginning with the epic, game-winning touchdown drive to beat Florida and reaching its thrilling peak in the final seconds against Auburn two weeks later:
The Tigers had to come from behind to beat Alabama in the final minutes two weeks after the Flynn-to-Byrd miracle, and again to get past Tennessee in the SEC Championship game; hours later, LSU was bequeathed losses by No. 1 Missouri and No. 3 West Virginia to pave its unlikely path to the championship date with Ohio State, where the Tigers earned the title of best team that didn't always pull it out in the end, yet still finished on top.
Et cetera: Fill in your favorite "Don't you die on me!" moment here. Dream seasons always hang in the balance for the handful of teams good enough to be on the high wire to begin with. The fact that Alabama and Iowa -- and no doubt Florida, Texas, USC, TCU, et al at some point over the next month -- had to scrape by in photo finishes at the tape may be a sign of some intrinsic soft spot (passing game, anyone?) that will be their downfall in the stretch run. Or it may be the great escape that eventually defines all great seasons. We won't be able to discern transcendent virtue from fatal flaw for a while yet.
Dr. Saturday is a college football blog edited by Matt Hinton. Email him tips and feedback.

Posted Feb 3 2010
RivalsMinute: Bama wins the title
Posted Feb 3 2010
Posted Feb 3 2010
Edited by MJD
Edited by 'Duk
Edited by J.E. Skeets
Edited by Greg Wyshynski
Edited by Matt Hinton
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Steve Cofield
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Brooks Peck
Edited by Andy Behrens
16 Comments
1 - 16 of 16
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
HOOK 'EM HORNS! and kepp winning Iowa too!
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
And Tebow for the Heisman, what a joke.
PLAYOFF SYSTEM NOW.
Report Abuse
I know, it's like wishing for world peace (unlikely), but it would be so very cool.
Report Abuse
You would be one of 20 ppl that would actually WANT to watch that game if it really happened. I understand the intent, but do you really really want to see that game. Would you watch that game this Saturday over a game between, say, LSU and USC this Saturday... if those two matchups were to happen?
Doubt it.
Report Abuse
As for the Nebraska win in 1997--I was a Mizzou junior that year and was at that game, and to this day, I refuse to acknowledge that Nebraska won. That catch was clearly kicked into the air and was therefore, illegal. And yes, it is sad that I'm spending my lunch hour arguing about the final score of a 12-year-old football game.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
And, I don't think the WAC and MWC will ever get any respect until they start playing and beating ranked SEC, ACC, PAC 10, Big 10 and Big 12 teams on a regular basis on the road. Beating a top ten Alabama or LSU would get BSU or TCU more respect than any amount of hand wringing on these blogs. And, just stir the pot, who among you really believes that BSU or TCU could beat USC on a neutral field? And be honest.
Just my humble opinion. For what it's worth.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
I get so tired of statements like yours. Apologists like you can't see the forest for the trees. "If it ain't broke, don't fix it" huh? Let's see, how exciting is seeing Florida play some podunck division 3 girls school? How exciting is it to see LSU play some rednecks from the deep swamps of Louisianna. What people like you fail to realize is that coaches know that the best way to make the MNC game is to win all your games. Nobody cares in the end who they are against. If you are in a big 6 conference school (especially the SEC) and you win all your games, you will probably go to the MNC game. So, they are de-incented to play top tier teams in the regular season. So we are relegated to a steady diet of pathetic competition and 56-3 games. Ridding the world of the BCS means that teams only need to make a playoff and not win all their games. So A.) You get better in season games. B.) You get better competition in a playoff because in the later rounds quality teams play quality teams, C.) The teams will have played better competition in the regular season and thus have evaluated talent better and better learned how to utilize that talent so the games will be inherently better (big weakness for Ohio state was always playing no solid competition all year until bowl season). Under your scenario, it is perfectly fine that we have one or maybe two decent games out of conference each season, get preassigned bowls with teams often far from evenly matched and a NC game that routinely (other than Ohio St - Miami and USC - Texas) are not that entertaining. In my world (and most college football fans) that qualifies as broken and in serious need of fixing.
Report Abuse
1 - 16 of 16