Dr. Saturday - NCAAF

Scroll down or click here to join the Doc's game day live blog, covering every game all day long.

Alabama 12, Tennessee 10. Every championship team has to win one like this, when its offense fails to reach the end zone all game, it's outgained two-to-one in the second half, its sure-handed, Heisman-bound tailback fumbles away the clock-killing drive in the final two minutes and its escape comes only via the nearly impossible combination of two 50-yard field goals in its favor and two field goal blocks on the other end. A perfect season is nothing without its death-defying moments.

More than at any other point this season, though, Alabama's presumptive perfection has to be in doubt. At the very least, as insanely good as it is on defense (and, apparently, at blocking crucial kicks), 'Bama may have to prepare for a few of these close shaves -- this one, in fact, has been brewing for almost a month, as the Tide passing game has increasingly declined and the emphasis has increasingly shifted to running Mark Ingram at every available opportunity.

Tennessee's defense, though, is the first 'Bama has encountered this year that ranks in the top 70 nationally against the run, and the consequences for the Tide offense were clear: Ingram pounded out some yardage (99 on 18 carries before the nearly fatal fumble in the fourth quarter), but Greg McElroy never found a rhythm with his receivers, was never able to challenge the Vol secondary deep (the long completion on the day was 19 yards) and 'Bama was only able to sustain one drive into the UT red zone, where it stalled before the half and had to settle for another three. Julio Jones had seven catches after being completely ignored against South Carolina, but only for a pedestrian 7.7 yards per catch with no real damage. For the second time this year, Tennessee went on the road against the No. 1 team and gave its offense all it could handle.

Still, if not for Ingram's fumble at the end, the Tide would have almost certainly closed out their third straight game without allowing a touchdown, without incident. The drama down the stretch was totally at odds with the rest of the game, at no point in which did Tennessee's offense seriously threaten to crack the end zone. The Vols finished with season highs against the 'Bama D in passing and total yards only after the fumble and onside kick recovery, and the Tide found a way to get out of it. But next up is LSU following a bye week, where the luxuries of settling for field goals and tossing out lifelines ahead of an adrenaline rush at the gun can't be taken for granted.

digg delicious
more

29 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. marcillac
    1. Posted by marcillac Sat Oct 24, 2009 8:55 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Its official: They all suck. Still, you're qualifications about the Bama D and the usual problem with moral, Tennessee does seem to be making almost remarkable progress under Kifikins.
  2. boomercooks
    2. Posted by boomercooks Sat Oct 24, 2009 9:02 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Forget that Gators!!! BABY!!
  3. KurtB
    3. Posted by KurtB Sat Oct 24, 2009 9:16 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    The refs blew the last play. The blocked punt was live and as you see in the play, the side judge blows the play dead long after the player who blocked the punt took his helmet off. A 15 yard unsportsman penalty should have been assessed and a re-kick. I don't know if Tennessee would have won... but we'll never know.
  4. h
    4. Posted by h Sat Oct 24, 2009 9:27 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    It show that Bama is not almighty as they seem; Bama could not beat Tenn like its should be; they barely escape to day..Gator will be # 1
  5. lakedrink
    5. Posted by lakedrink Sat Oct 24, 2009 9:27 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Being a Vol fan and proud of it, I will have to say Alabama has a much better team than Florida. The new and improve Vols are showing the nation that they aren't no push over.
  6. frosty
    6. Posted by frosty Sat Oct 24, 2009 9:36 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    If Grasshoppers had machine guns the birds would not mess with them. ROLL TIDE ROLL!
  7. joefwlr
    7. Posted by joefwlr Sat Oct 24, 2009 9:41 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Tennessee played a heck of a game---outplayed us, I will admit. Next time we are in a close ballgame maybe Saban will just hand the ball to Ingram until he passes out---that would be better than watching McElroy mess things up. Well, at least we won!!! ROLL TIDE
  8. G
    8. Posted by G Sat Oct 24, 2009 10:08 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I keep wishing for someone to say it, and I haven't heard it, so I will say it: GMac is afraid of being hit. Ever since facing Ole Miss's front four and getting smacked into the turf repeatedly, he has been gun-shy. He rushes his reads, he makes dumb throws into tight coverage, can't get into a rhythm-- you name it. It's obvious he just wants to get the ball out of his hands and away to someone, anyone. The boy needs to grow a pair and accept his knocks. But thank heavens for the rest of the team, and maybe we'll make it through the next few without another such scare. Roll Tide!
  9. Benjamin
    9. Posted by Benjamin Sat Oct 24, 2009 10:19 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    The Vols have a tough defense...........not only this year but traditionally. It is a huge rivalry game. The Tide was supposed to struggle on offense this year (has everyone forgotten the retooled o-line and new starter at QB). Ingram but more importantly the o-line has been a nice surprise. But bama's d........championship quality........no doubt. I've been thinking all season........if Bama gets behind.......they are in trouble (has been Bama's problem for years).........but now, I don't think they are going to get behind..........reminds me of '92. Plus I think Bama could score points if they were willing to take the risks........but why would you when your RB is averaging.........averaging.........almost 10 yds a carry over the past three games. I'd play conservative too!
  10. AaronS
    10. Posted by AaronS Sat Oct 24, 2009 10:58 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Analysts all over the internet are questioning whether Bama's offense is good enough to continue winning after this close shave, and rightfully so because maybe they should have lost. At the same time, McElroy had a better day passing against the Vols than Tebow (115 yards/3 sacks/1 int) and Ingram had a better day rushing than anyone on the Gators against the Vols (Leader:Tebow 76 yards/3.2ypc 1 TD). So aside from the question of whether Tebow really deserves to be considered for a Heisman (his line against Miss State is terrible compared to what Keenum did) the real question is why Alabama is suddenly in deep trouble while Florida is looked at as resiliant for their close games.
  11. Jim, J.R.
    11. Posted by Jim, J.R. Sun Oct 25, 2009 12:06 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Not to detract from Bama, but Tennessee was the better team today. Granted, we got help from Ingram's fumble, but had it not been for Cody there would be no dispute over #1 right now. My question is where was the unsportsmanlike conduct penalty after the kick was blocked? He obviously had his helmet off in celebration before the play was dead, which is as blatant a penalty as you can get. Lincoln should have had a second try, which would have probably changed the outcome. Are the officials afraid of suspension because of the LSU/UGA FLA/ARK squad? Oh well, I guess we have something to hang our hats on, we held Ingram to less than 100 yards and our offense looked solid. Go Vols
  12. The Heffalump
    12. Posted by The Heffalump Sun Oct 25, 2009 12:30 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Per the helmet, so says SEC spokesman Charles Bloom:
    "The foul for taking helmet off is a live ball foul treated as a dead-ball foul," Bloom wrote in an e-mail Saturday night. "That is, if it happens on a play where time does not expire then the penalty is enforced on the following play. However since the clock ran out on that play, then there is no next play, so there is no penalty to mark off."
    Wouldn't have been an issue if the holding a few plays earlier had been called. Crompton should have been sacked ten yards back at the start of that drive. Either way, I'm tired after watching that game.
  13. just4funsies
    13. Posted by just4funsies Sun Oct 25, 2009 9:58 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Buncha homers around here. If a disputed call goes your way, you clam up, but if it goes again' ya, THEN starts the "woulda, shoulda, coulda dance". This act is tired. Let's move on.
  14. George B
    14. Posted by George B Sun Oct 25, 2009 9:59 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    You have got to wonder what this story would have been if they had called the obvious pass interference call on Julio in the end zone.
  15. W-mann
    15. Posted by W-mann Sun Oct 25, 2009 10:36 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    I haven't seen anyone criticize Kiffin yet, but how about the late game strategy? Tennessee was in questionable field goal range (especially considering the earlier misses) with a little more than 30 seconds left. They basically let the clock run down for the kick. I couldn't believe they didn't try to run a few more plays to make that an easier kick. You see it all the time - teams that set up a FG to win as if a 40+ yarder is a given. And those teams lose an awful lot.
  16. hippa
    16. Posted by hippa Sun Oct 25, 2009 10:51 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Carl, you've made a good point.
  17. Jeremy B
    17. Posted by Jeremy B Sun Oct 25, 2009 11:03 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    The fix is on in the SEC!!!!!!!!!!!
    Maybe the SEC rules guy should read the rule about the game not ended on an accepted penalty. With the only exception being if part of the penalty ends the game (i.e. the 10 second runoff). And really, the guy wasn't saying the penalty shouldn't be called, he just tried to explain it wouldn't matter, which it would.
    Now, on to the other guilty party in all of this. Lane Kiffin. Did the SEC commishes get in his headphones and say "Whoa, close enough!" 45 seconds on the clock and looking at a 45 yd field goal, that has already failed once on a block, Kiffin says, "Yeah, we don't need any more yards" and runs the ball and runs the clock. WHAT? No coach outside the SEC hierarchy would decide that was close enough if they had time to run several more plays. It's not like there were 20 seconds or less, where if you get caught in bounds, you may run out of time. This is 45 seconds with the clock stopped while they were resetting the chains!
    Why do I blame the whole SEC for Kiffin's incompetence? Because it happened in the Florida game too. Let's put aside that every one in the stadium saw the fumble at the 2 that was ruled a Touchdown, but the announcers on TV saw it too. Apparently not the SEC replay official though.
    SO your team is down 10 with the ball at midfield and a minute to go. What do you do? Well if you are a coach in the SEC who used to coach Florida, you decide, "Eh, we gave it a good shot." and let the clock pretty much run out, WITH A TIMEOUT LEFT!
    Say what you will about other conferences, but at least their teams play until the end of the game and try to win against the good teams. What has happened is that the SEC isn't so sure a 1-loss team from their conference is automatically in the title game anymore. Texas has the high poll numbers that would squeeze them out if they finish unbeaten, and a 1-loss SEC team would be well behind Iowa in the computer polls if the Hawks finish unbeaten, not to mention Cincy, Boise St and TCU all lining up unbeaten seasons.
    The SEC is fixing anything it can to make sure it's too babies don't get a loss going into that SEC Championship, come heck or highwater.
  18. Jesse
    18. Posted by Jesse Sun Oct 25, 2009 11:42 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    you people get on here and wine about the most stupid things! everyone should stop talking about what would have happened if something else would have happened, blah, blah, blah. whatever. the [profane] is done and over with. bama won! barely but its still a win. it seems all you gator fans do is [profane] and cry. and the SEC is by far the strongest conference out there. bet that. if nothing else the damn officials are slowing us down by getting in the way and stopping plays! none of us can change how our team plays. all we can do is support them and talk about what happened not what should have happened. ROLL TIDE!!!!!!
  19. lege
    19. Posted by lege Sun Oct 25, 2009 11:56 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/2009/writers/andy_staples/10/24/alabama-tennessee/
    this is a link for all you idiots who dont know the rules . for you whining tennessee rednecks .
    rogers redding was on finebaum.com last week. if you can post here you can go listen to his hour long discussion on the rules.
    pull the flag line bama up and give them the ball with zero seconds on the clock. the kick was made with 4 seconds. time was expired. so what was the point. know the rules or go back to school.
    there is only one conspiracy. you have a child with add for a coach at ut and i hope you keep him for 10 years
  20. what
    20. Posted by what Sun Oct 25, 2009 12:09 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    when the game is over and a player take his helmet off after the game is over on the field it ok! hell I seen Tenn players take their Helmet off too and saw the whole team on the field after the miss field goal! and their was miss calls on both sides so should the SEC get robots to call the game (J/K) so I don't think any game will be done to our liking but that here or their the SEC is a hard place to get a win at!
  21. Zach d
    21. Posted by Zach d Sun Oct 25, 2009 12:35 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I'd say the excessive celebration penalty was with the pass interference penalty on Julio Jones in the endzone early in the game!
  22. Larry B
    22. Posted by Larry B Sun Oct 25, 2009 2:50 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    The no call on the excessive celebration penalty handed the game to Bama. The SEC has to protect it's two top teams. Oregon State or USC would have wiped the floor with them.
    The SEC will be gifted into the NC, just as it has for the past few years. Truth is, neither Bama or Gators would be competitive in PAC 10. We desperately need a playoff system. The BCS is a joke.
  23. rtr
    23. Posted by rtr Sun Oct 25, 2009 6:47 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    The no-call on the obvious pass interference on Julio creted a close game. The SEC has to protect its TV ratings and avoid blowouts. Alabama would have wiped the floor with UT with Pac-10 refs who protect offenses.

Dr. Saturday

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Matt Hinton

Dr. Saturday is a college football blog edited by Matt Hinton. Email him tips and feedback.

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Dr. Saturday Recent Readers