The Dagger - NCAAB

Thu Oct 08, 2009 8:30 am EDT

Why Billy Gillispie is a dying breed

Billy Gillispie's modus operandi as a coach was well-known but rarely talked about: He was a jerk. He screamed at players, he ran them hard in practice, and he played the role -- whether he was playing a role or not is up for debate -- of old-school nose-to-the-grindstone tough guy. And if you didn't like it, you could play somewhere else. Which is what most players decided to do. Which got Billy Gillispie fired.

We sort of know all this, even if anecdotes about Gillispie's time at Kentucky are rare. Fortunately, we have one today, courtesy of the Lexington Herald-Leader's John Clay. Get a load of this:

[Kentucky center] Josh Harrellson verified to our own Jerry Tipton the rumor that during halftime of last year's game at Vanderbilt, the sophomore forward was banished to a bathroom stall, apart from the team, apparently as punishment for poor play. Then after the Cats' 77-64 loss to the Commodores, Gillispie ordered Harrellson off the team bus and into the team equipment truck for the long ride back to Lexington.

I'm no coach, and I'm no expert on coaching, but I'm going to go ahead and guess that that's not the best way to treat your players. Just a thought.

That's Clay's whole point, actually; after using Harrellson's anecdotes as a lead, Clay theorizes that there's a reason why this sort of old-school surliness doesn't work on college basketball players anymore. Frankly, they're smarter:

Kids today don't want to play for those coaches, nor should they. They're too smart for that. They know too much. They've been exposed to too much. While some argue that kids today don't know the difference between right and wrong, I'd argue that they know the difference now more than ever. They can think for themselves.

It's not that college basketball players in the modern era just inherently smarter. The system does this to them. By the time college hoopsters -- the really good ones, the ones who would consider playing at Kentucky -- get to college, they've had plenty of coaches in orbit. They've played high school ball and AAU and gone to hundreds of summer camps. They get to see nearly every kind of coach, and they get to figure out what sort of man they want to play for. They're experienced. Things weren't always like this.

And sure, maybe some of these kids are spoiled, uber-stars before they ever set foot on a professional court. That's a byproduct of the system. But there are just as many kids who are anxious to play and eager to please -- Harrelson's quotes make him sound like a confused puppy; he still says he and Gillispie had a "good relationship" -- and who can't figure out why their coaches are like this. They just don't know what their screaming coaches want from them.

This, ultimately, was Billy Gillispie's undoing. Stories like the one above are why he's not a coach anymore. And the lack of such stories about the Jim Calipari, the man who replaced, speak almost as loudly. There's a new order in place. And it's not even all that new. Do the names Dean Smith and John Wooden ring a bell?

digg delicious
more

7 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. David E
    1. Posted by David E Thu Oct 08, 2009 8:59 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    But the stories about Calipari are about Probation, Vacated Wins, NCAA Investigation, and skipping town 1 step ahead of the law. Which one would you rather have?
    Not to compare Gillespie to Bob Knight, but their styles are similar. Knight found out that the hard line coach does not work anymore at schools that get top recruits, but is still excellent at the overlooked major schools. I think that the reason for this is that the good players that go to the Texas Tech or Texas A&M's of the world have a huge chip on their shoulder for being overlooked by the Indiana or Kentucky's of the world and are willing to accept the tough love coaching to improve and show the world. The top recruits at the big name schools have been coddled, told the world revolves around them, showered with cash/bribes, and planning on a one (or two) and done. They don't feel they should have to listen to anyone because they are about (or already) to rich.
  2. y2andru
    2. Posted by y2andru Thu Oct 08, 2009 11:04 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Billy Clyde was also a poor game coach at UK....don't overlook that.
  3. chadf
    3. Posted by chadf Thu Oct 08, 2009 12:30 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    His name is "John Calipari" not Jim calipari. WOW
  4. matt
    4. Posted by matt Fri Oct 09, 2009 2:30 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Does anyone actually edit these posts? Every one of them has a handful of grammatical and/or spelling errors. Come on editors, get it together.
  5. Montana
    5. Posted by Montana Fri Oct 09, 2009 6:35 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    "the Jim Calipari"... this man has no credibility. Fraud.
  6. Jeremy S
    6. Posted by Jeremy S Mon Oct 12, 2009 3:37 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    "They just don't know what their screaming coaches want from them." Really...Did you happen to watch any minute of the first half of the Vandy game. 6' 10" Harrellson was pushed around by smaller Vandy players. In that game, Patterson wasn't available. BG needed Harrellson to step up and play like a big man. Harrellson didn't. Did BG really need to tell a 6'10" center to rebound? If so, BGs problem was he had stupid players.
    For all of BGs faults, making Harrellson sit on a toilet at halftime and subsequently making him ride the bus home with the equipment manager isn't one of them.
    Most college basketball players aren't smarter. They are lazier. They are part of the new generation of college player that want something for nothing - so typical with society as a whole. College basketball players are given a free education and (at Kentucky at least) a chance to improve their basketball game to get to the NBA. The cost for that should be hard work on the court and in the class room. I have no sympathy for Harrellson or players like him. Time to take off the diaper and grow up.
  7. Rob
    7. Posted by Rob Mon Oct 12, 2009 4:49 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Maybe Billy needed a drink

The Dagger

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Jeff Eisenberg

The Dagger is a college basketball blog edited by Jeff Eisenberg. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Contributors:
Chris Chase, Matt Norlander,

Related Photo Gallery

Featured NCAAB Video

Y! Sports Blogs

The Dagger Recent Readers