The Dagger - NCAAB

One of the minor offseason subplots worth following is the Renardo Sidney investigation. After USC withdrew its scholarship offer for Sidney (perhaps the most talented big man in the 2009 recruiting class), Sidney took an offer from Mississippi State coach Rick Stansbury. It didn't take long for the NCAA to initiate an investigation of just how Sidney's parents supported themselves during their recruiting sojourn to Southern California, where they were allegedly living in a house that might have been beyond their means. None of this is particularly pretty or fun.

That investigation continues, and we have officially reached another notch of mess, as the NCAA has asked for more information from Renardo's family. Specifically, the NCAA wants Sidney's parents' and grandparents' tax returns. So Sidney's representative, Alabama attorney Don Jackson, dropped the lawyer's version of an thermonuclear warhead: the race card.

Jackson said the latest request "represents an illegal intrusion" into the family's right to privacy and that the investigation has "troubling racial overtones." "In effect, this investigation has required that two generations of an African-American family prove to the NCAA that they have the financial ability to support themselves," Jackson said.

Eesh. Jackson might have a point on the invasion of privacy bit; it is disconcerting that the NCAA can prevent Sidney from playing for MSU this season unless his extended family turns over their tax returns, which the NCAA has threatened. But it is equally troubling that Jackson's first recourse here has to do with race.

It's obvious what the NCAA is trying to do. They're trying to figure out whether Sidney's parents could have supported their stay in California during Sidney's recruitment to USC. If they're unable, they want to see if maybe Sidney's grandparents footed the bill. It's transparent enough. The NCAA doubtless cares little for whether the Sidneys can support themselves, and surely they can. Investigators want to know if the Sidneys can support living in million-dollar homes, which a source told the Los Angeles Times was the case, without obvious means of financial income.

So, yeah, is it a little bit of an invasion of privacy? Maybe. Is it racially based? Hardly. And if the Sidneys have nothing to hide here, they ought to go ahead and turn over their tax returns. Until then, investigators -- and college basketball fans -- will be right to wonder.

digg delicious
more

12 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. Ricky B
    1. Posted by Ricky B Thu Jul 30, 2009 11:22 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    sounds like the lawyer is getting desperate for a defense...
  2. Hambone
    2. Posted by Hambone Thu Jul 30, 2009 11:35 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Someone should just send the lawyer a link to every article written about USC's potential NCAA violations in the last year, and suggest that maybe there's cause for investigation there.
  3. John C
    3. Posted by John C Thu Jul 30, 2009 12:07 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Wow, black people dropping the race card...that never happens.
  4. Capital
    4. Posted by Capital Thu Jul 30, 2009 12:15 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    There's only one MSU.. MICHIGAN STATE!
  5. Aaron
    5. Posted by Aaron Thu Jul 30, 2009 2:19 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Wow. I'm shocked....Someone losing a fight pulls out the race card...shocking. Again, I'm shocked. Wow. No really, that is shocking. I'm not kidding, really. Ok, I'm done.
  6. Karl Marx
    6. Posted by Karl Marx Thu Jul 30, 2009 5:10 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Race!!!!
    i am biased and i dont know the circumstance,
    but he is stupid.
    have a beer and chill out
  7. Rick
    7. Posted by Rick Thu Jul 30, 2009 8:29 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Well maybe if black people didn't be apart of so much racism towards them in their lifetime then they wouldn't play the race card. White people don't know what it's like to suffer this so it's no reason they should comment on racial discrimination. Now, there may not been a race case in this case but that doesn't mean it should be ruled out.
  8. John C
    8. Posted by John C Fri Jul 31, 2009 9:08 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    "White people don't know what it's like to suffer?" Really? There aren't any poor white people? Additionally, how exactly have you suffered due to racism? The only reason racial tension still exists in this country is because black people shove it in everyone's face every chance they get. Got fired...racism. Didn't get that job...racism. Didn't get into that school...racism. Stop living up to the stereotypes, stop blaming everything on racism.
  9. John C
    9. Posted by John C Fri Jul 31, 2009 9:08 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    "White people don't know what it's like to suffer?" Really? There aren't any poor white people? Additionally, how exactly have you suffered due to racism? The only reason racial tension still exists in this country is because black people shove it in everyone's face every chance they get. Got fired...racism. Didn't get that job...racism. Didn't get into that school...racism. Stop living up to the stereotypes, stop blaming everything on racism.
  10. John C
    10. Posted by John C Fri Jul 31, 2009 9:09 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    "White people don't know what it's like to suffer?" Really? There aren't any poor white people? Additionally, how exactly have you suffered due to racism? The only reason racial tension still exists in this country is because black people shove it in everyone's face every chance they get. Got fired...racism. Didn't get that job...racism. Didn't get into that school...racism. Stop living up to the stereotypes, stop blaming everything on racism.
  11. jim m
    11. Posted by jim m Sun Aug 02, 2009 2:48 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    As a white man.... it is not about race to me... but in no way can ncaa require anyone to provide such private information..... so if the kid is dirty.... find it out... what kind of foolishness is asking for tax returns for parents and grandparents.... in seeking a pell grant one must provide tax info.... so if ncaa wants to know about tax returns... just like to see if he can have a pell grant.... but don't ask for tax returns.... hello ... ncaa basketball is professional sports.... get over it.... check out many outstanding players and notice after the sign with college living standard is on the rise.... ncaa knows it.... this is bs on the public.... want to buy a bridge? want the same healthcare coverage as congress.... bs goes on and on in the usa and public knows it..... ncaa can check any college program in usa and find flaw.... that is fact.... see tax returns.... give me a break...
  12. dominique
    12. Posted by dominique Fri Aug 07, 2009 8:26 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    John C. you obviously are sadly mistaken if you think racism doesn't exist in this world. Until you open your blind eyes and realize what stands before you then you should not be commenting on a post like this. The proverbial "race card" as other races so delicately put it, is a dillusion of what really is there and blatant to see. Its better to think that everybody is racist than to be blindsided wth the truth when it goes wrong. I guess black people are only good enough to "root" for our amazing athleticism and when we play for your favorite sports team, right? This will never change, I bet you are the ypical tight a** fox news so called middle class blue collar worker right? Grow up and realize that a black man is running the free world, a world that was just taken to hell by one of your own. So before you speak or think stupidly, be cognisent of your situation before any other ignorant comments

The Dagger

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Jeff Eisenberg

The Dagger is a college basketball blog edited by Jeff Eisenberg. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Contributors:
Chris Chase, Matt Norlander,

Related Photo Gallery

Featured NCAAB Video

Y! Sports Blogs

The Dagger Recent Readers