Mon May 12, 2008 12:42 pm EDT
Before we begin, it's probably important to hammer home that I don't
believe O.J. Mayo or Rodney Guillory or USC or anyone, really, is
blameless in the now-certain cheating that surrounded USC's basketball program this year.
It's pretty obvious that Mayo was complicit in the scandal, that Tim
Floyd probably knew something was up but stuck his head in the parquet,
and that everyone around the program could have imagined, if they even
needed to, that money was changing hands somewhere along the way.
Here's the thing, though: How do you stop it? Is the NCAA even built to
deal with this? Or is the one-year rule making it impossible?
It's simple for coaches: With the new breed of one-and-done (soon to be
two-and-done) players on campuses, programs have to very, very carefully
weigh the potential consequences of signing such players. If a player
seems to carry too much baggage -- which Tim Floyd should have realized
the minute a Mayo handler walked in to the coach's office -- the coach
needs to stay away. Pretty easy stuff.
But for the NCAA at large, there will always be a coach willing to
accept a player with Mayo-esque baggage. If big programs, fearful of
NCAA retribution, ignore the one-and-done player, there will always be
outposts (ahem, Kansas State, ahem) looking for the brief surge of
national attention that comes with All-American talent. There will
always be places for these players to go. There will always be places
for them to cheat.
Which brings us back to the one-year rule. When the NCAA and NBA forged
the agreement, it was with the knowledge that both sides benefited: the
NCAA got to keep all that talent, and the NBA got to stave off the
flood of high school prospects seen to be ruining the league's cohesive
image. Both sides are benefiting. Lest we forget, this year's NCAA title game was
chock with NBA-ready talent, while the NBA is having one of its most competitive seasons in recent memory.
But the NCAA is also forced to deal with a new problem: the Mayo-esque mercenary
with the ability to ruin a program just before jumping to the pros.
It's silly to think that in today's recruiting environment, this is
limited to only one-year players, but the lack of commitment on the
player's side of things makes this a uniquely dangerous situation for
programs, and for the NCAA's reputation. These are not
scholar-athletes, no matter what those NCAA commercials tell you, and
what's worse, they're not staying anywhere close to four years -- Mayo's
punishment won't come down for years, long after he's made his pro money. You think he cares if USC gets hit with the NCAA's death penalty?
These players' ability to take the money and run, as Mayo did, with
little fear of direct retribution ... well, in the words of that fat
Texas cop in No Country for Old Men*: How do you defend against it?
The NCAA can't. Not really. So when the next O.J. Mayo happens -- and
it will soon enough -- let's remember that it's not just the evil deeds
of an 18-year-old trying to get paid, or the car salesman basketball
coach or the shady backroom booster. It's also the NCAA, and its
incredibly persistent systemic hypocrisy. Blame everyone.
*Yes, I'm still referencing No Country for Old Men at every opportunity. Get over it.
The Dagger is a college hoops blog edited by Eamonn Brennan. Email him, and follow his Twitter.

RivalsMinute: Texas rolls over WCU
Posted Nov 19 2009
Posted Nov 19 2009
Posted Nov 19 2009
Edited by MJD
Edited by 'Duk
Edited by J.E. Skeets
Edited by Greg Wyshynski
Edited by Matt Hinton
Edited by E. Brennan
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Steve Cofield
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Andy Behrens
1 Comment
1 - 1 of 1
Report Abuse
1 - 1 of 1