The Dagger - NCAAB

As we all know, the Indiana Hoosiers are suffering their worst season of all-time. Yesterday's home loss to Illinois put Indiana at 1-11 in Big Ten play, and handed them their 18th loss of the season. That latter tally is a school record. It's true: Never before in the history of IU basketball has a single team lost 18 games. That's a down season.

We also all know the reasons why. Kelvin Sampson was fired after the school self-reported him for violating the terms of his NCAA probation. In the offseason, Indiana lost several key players to the NBA draft (Eric Gordon, D.J. White), transfers (Jordan Crawford, Eli Holman, DeAndre Thomas) and dismissals (starters Jamarcus Ellis, Armon Bassett). Those players comprised the core of the 2007-08 Hoosiers. Without them, new coach Tom Crean was left with one returning scholarship player. His name is Kyle Taber. He is not very good at basketball.

Hence, a down year. Crean's first season at IU has seen him take the helm of a group of ragtag recruits, JUCO transfers, and walk-ons, and the result has been predictable. It's not rocket science. If your talent is subpar, you're going to lose a lot of college basketball games. Fine.

Then again, if you read Rick Chandler at Deadspin, you would assume Crean took over a team of talented malcontents; that Crean is in over his head at a dying program; and that Bloomington is "backwater." You would assume this horrible year -- and it has been a horrible year -- is the new state of Indiana basketball. How, I'm not sure. But that's what Rick would have you believe.

(For the record, Rick, who seems like a perfectly nice dude and has been a key contributor to one of my favorite sites of all time, isn't the only one working the Indiana Know-Nothing beat today. Josh Q. Public, on whose post Chandler apparently based his riff, might have written the weirdest blog post of all-time, which is fine. It happens. I write horrible blog posts all the time. Nature of the game. But we should expect slightly better from the 'Spin, which is why the following is so distressing.)

It starts with a bit about Devan Dumes that makes no sense -- apparently, Tom Crean was supposed to suspend his player before he threw an elbow; this sort of pre-emptive punishment would be truly groundbreaking -- and then comes the money shot:

For those waiting for a resurgence in Indiana basketball: It ain't going to happen anytime soon. The system's not designed for sleepy backwaters like Bloomington, Indiana, to have powerhouse teams in the revenue sports unless there's a great coach to draw them in, or a coach who's willing to play fast and loose with recruiting rules. Indiana had the latter with Kelvin Sampson, and they're still looking for the former. Tom Crean — even though he hasn't really had a chance to prove what he can do with his own players — isn't the answer. Have you been to Bloomington? What multi-talented player is going to go there to play for Tom Crean?

Actually, yes, some of us have been to Bloomington. It's small! But also really pretty and pastoral and basically the same thing as every other Big Ten college town (but warmer!), with the exception of, like, Evanston. Is Cham-bana not "sleepy?" Ann Arbor? Where is the Mendoza Line for "backwater?" That's confusion No. 1.

No. 2: Tom Crean isn't the answer? Really? After a half-season of at the helm of (no disrespect here, IU fans) a motlier version of "The Replacements?" "The Replacements" at least had Keanu Reeves. Indiana has Tom Pritchard! Tom Pritchard, man! And this part is true: Crean "hasn't really had a chance to prove what he can do with his own players." So how can he not be the answer? I'M SO CONFUSED, RICK.

Finally, the last question: "What multi-talented player is going to go there to play for Tom Crean?" That's a tough one. Fortunately, there's this thing called Rivals. They track recruiting. Because of this service, I can give you the names, positions, and 2009 recruiting ranks of such multi-talented players as: SF Christian Watford (34), SG Maurice Creek (59), SF Derek Elston (98), PG Jordan Hulls (106), C Bawa Muniru (111). That's good for the eighth-ranked class in 2009; all five players will be on campus this fall. Why, it's almost as if multi-talented high schoolers want to play for Tom Crean. (To say nothing of Dwyane Wade, Jerel McNeal, and the host of stars Crean convinced to go live in Milwaukee and play for him at Marquette.)

Of course, navigating to Rivals.com can be a complicated venture. It requires one to minimize his inbox, first of all; it also requires one to put a little more thought into a college basketball post than "Wow. They sure are losing a bunch of games. How should we spin this?" Bad blog posts are common. Like I said, I author them constantly. Being bad is not a crime. Being utterly thoughtless is. That post landed smack in the latter category. Maybe that Pac-10 beat is a better fit.

digg delicious
more

14 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. D. Witt
    1. Posted by D. Witt Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:38 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    That second blog really was rambling...
    And indiana will be back. Damn, I'd go play for Indiana. It's rich in basketball history and tradition.
  2. Chris
    2. Posted by Chris Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:01 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    deadspin knows NOTHING about sports. none of those guys do; this is not news. this rick fellow is a particularly egregrious offender.
    I do not like tom crean, he has never struck me as a good "game" coach. that said, that just means he's like most coaches. he can recruit, but did not actually bring in wade; he committed when mike deane (glugglugglug) was still the coach at mu.
    the hoosiers are playing hard and their fans feel good about the program again; they will be fine in a few years but crean just doesn't have the Xs and Os needed order to take a team deep into the tourney. he will need superior, duke-type talent and I don't know that he'll be able to do that consistently at IU. his teams at mu were notorious for a lot of wasted talent/lack of progression and an offense predicated upon the 3 point shot.
  3. insomniacslounge
    3. Posted by insomniacslounge Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:41 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Tom Crean was 15-14 his first season at Marquette and things worked out OK for him there.
    Ben Howland had to clean up Steve Lavin's mess at UCLA, and finished his first year at 11-17. It wasn't the end of the Bruins' program.
    Perhaps the best analogy tho would be in Oklahoma. After Kelvin Sampson left OU for IU, Jeff Capel came in to the sleepy backwaters of Norman, Oklahoma and went 16-15. I think that program has had some moderate success since then.
    So let's not bury Indiana just yet....although it's harder to get pageviews with that take.
  4. Lucky
    4. Posted by Lucky Thu Sep 03, 2009 6:48 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    To think Indiana basketball isnt going to regain its glory and tom crean isnt the answer is an ignorant statement. Players will (and are) flock to bloomington with the opportunity to play young. Tom Crean brings a great brand of basketball to the big ten. However, I love the fact they fell on their faces. I am an illini fan and hope weber and crean will bring back the unforgettable battles, that made this rivalry great.
  5. Jose A
    5. Posted by Jose A Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:41 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Hey they might suck this year, but they're selling out nearly every home game, and aren't going down without a fight... given 3-4 years and they'll compete w/ Illinois, MSU again
  6. scott g
    6. Posted by scott g Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:08 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    i am very happy with who indiana picked as coach and am very pleased with what he and our boys have done this year. sure they have made some mistakes but what player has played flawless this season or any other season for that matter. give them another year or two and they will be back at the top of the big ten and nationally ranked. mark it down. go hoosier nation
  7. dale a
    7. Posted by dale a Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:34 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Program in the crapper since Bobby left! Yes they won under Nolan Richardson but he cheated again! They really hurt themselves hiring him. I hope they turn it around!
  8. PurdueMatt
    8. Posted by PurdueMatt Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:11 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Well said. Although IU didn't fire Sampson after self reporting his violations. They discovered the violations in November, tried to sweep it under the rug, and only fired him in March when they faced pressure from the NCAA and had no other choice.
  9. grubsteak
    9. Posted by grubsteak Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:41 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    They didn't try to "sweep it under the rug", they reported the potential violations to the NCAA.
  10. crazylegs
    10. Posted by crazylegs Thu Sep 03, 2009 2:46 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I feel bad for iu fans...but I'm a Uof A fan and even tho we are have a decent year, the kids we got due to Lute Olson and Josh Pastner will not be replaced unless we get a coach with a name. Crean's gonna get better quality players then Russ Pennel will. Two teams, different conferences, rich in history and facing a few years of disappointment.
  11. crazylegs
    11. Posted by crazylegs Thu Sep 03, 2009 2:46 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I feel bad for iu fans...but I'm a Uof A fan and even tho we are have a decent year, the kids we got due to Lute Olson and Josh Pastner will not be replaced unless we get a coach with a name. Crean's gonna get better quality players then Russ Pennel will. Two teams, different conferences, rich in history and facing a few years of disappointment.
  12. ChrisG
    12. Posted by ChrisG Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:10 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Haha PWNED!!!! How can somebody not respect Tom Crean for what hes doing? I'm an MSU fan but Indiana does have rich basketball tradition and I'm sure they will return to being a respectful program and probably in the near future.
  13. PurdueMatt
    13. Posted by PurdueMatt Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:11 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    @grubsteak,
    Yes they did sweep it under the rug. They docked themselves one scholarship and one raise for Sampson and tried to move on as though it wasn't a big deal. It took the NCAA stepping in to discover that Sampson deliberately skirted the sanctions resulting in his resignation.
  14. jennystephen@...
    14. Posted by jennystephen@... Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:48 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    I too think that Indiana is a rich football tradition. It is a great type of post to know about the full posting. Thanks for sharing this experience.
    by games

The Dagger

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Jeff Eisenberg

The Dagger is a college basketball blog edited by Jeff Eisenberg. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Contributors:
Chris Chase, Matt Norlander,

Related Photo Gallery

Featured NCAAB Video

Y! Sports Blogs

The Dagger Recent Readers