The Dagger - NCAAB

Since there's been a day or so to reflect on the whole thing, today's Extra Onions is a round up of Calipari-based opinions from around the 'Webs. Anger, malice, and ill will sold separately. As always, email or follow me on Twitter to send along your stuff.

John Gasaway, Basketball Prospectus: "Since the moment Kentucky decided that Gillispie was their man in early April of 2007, every significant decision and/or action that the University has made with regard to its basketball program has been 180 degrees wrong ... On April 1, 2009, Kentucky hired Memphis coach John Calipari knowing full well, they now tell us, that Calipari’s program was being investigated by the NCAA. True, it could well be that Calipari knew nothing of shady doings related to Derrick Rose and an SAT whose results may or may not have been fraudulent. But if you’re Kentucky and you have knowledge of the NCAA’s Notice of Allegations, do you really go ahead and pull the trigger on the Calipari hire? Indiana raised some eyebrows in 2006 by hiring Kelvin Sampson at a time when he was under NCAA investigation at Oklahoma. Say this for the Hoosiers, though: at least Sampson’s status was public knowledge. By contrast Kentucky gives the appearance of having hustled Calipari into town furtively before the news could gum up their plans."

Spencer Hall, The Sporting Blog: "The real gusty laughter should be reserved for the NCAA, the sloth- footed firemen who by design are forever pulling up with the firehoses and slapping their foreheads at the sight of a scorched and still smoking foundation. As with the Tim Floyd case at USC, the NCAA's role here is to play the coroner, not the sheriff. At this point, they are less of a regulatory agency than a kind of verification service for cheats, happy to confirm that rule-breaking occurred, spend a good amount of money doing so, and then shelve the report without action except in the tiniest, most kickable offenders' cases. Under Myles Brand's leadership, they remain what they've always been: the country hanging judge who'll give a small-time pot dealer 15 years but lets a banker skate when a few mil go missing at the bank."

Luke Winn, Sports Illustrated: "In Memphis' locker room shortly after its heartbreaking overtime loss to Kansas in the 2008 national championship game, forward Chris Douglas-Roberts tried to console teammate Joey Dorsey by telling him, "The Fab Five never won a title. Douglas-Roberts' belief was that the Tigers were an iconic team, like Michigan's 1992 and '93 squads, that wouldn't be forgotten despite their lack of title rings. He most certainly wasn't expecting that the Tigers, like the Wolverines, might eventually have to vacate their title-game appearance. The irony in that analogy is now thick." 

Truzenzuzex, A Sea Of Blue: "But assuming that no surprises crawl out of the woodwork implicating Coach Cal, I think we should all reread this sage advice and once again, embrace the hate.  'Why,' you ask?  Because if you are honest with yourself, you know as well as I do that if St. Peter himself came down from Heaven and testified in open court that John Calipari was as blameless as a newborn babe in any and all these allegations, it would not matter one iota to this program's detractors, nor to many who find Calipari's occasional close proximity to NCAA violations troubling.  That's the way the game is played, and the only antidote is skin as thick as an M1A1 Abrams' armor.  Many of us were glad to have Coach Cal, and we got him, warts, baggage and all. So embrace that hate, Big Blue Nation, and take pleasure in the loathing.  I know I will."

Rick Bozich, Louisville Courier-Journal: "It's not Kentucky's shame — at least not yet. But Mitch Barnhart's shame? That's more like it. Barnhart, the University of Kentucky athletic director, has questions he needs to ask — and answer. About his old basketball coach, Billy Gillispie. About his new coach, John Calipari. And about his new basketball coach's newest recruit, John Wall. [...] It's the Calipari situation that should make Barnhart squirm."

Matt Jones, Kentucky Sports Radio: "The Calipari situation doesnt bother me at this point. Why? Its simple…we knew what we were getting when Calipari was hired. When UK made the decision to get Calipari, we knew that we would have one of the best coaches in America, the top recruiter and a guy who immediately could get Kentucky back to the top of the basketball mountain. And you know what, he has done all of those things. But we also knew that we were getting a coach that had a reputation nationally of being on the edge of the NCAA rules. Face it, before he came to Kentucky, you thought things were fishy with Calipari. Everyone did. There has never been any proof of anything, but when you mentioned Cal’s name to non-Memphis fans, they all thought something was up. It may not have been fair, but it was reality. The day UK hired him, they inherited that as well, and we all knew it going in."

Jason Brubaker, College Hoops Net: "With the news of the allegations breaking on the same day that Wall pleaded guilty, Calipari's reputation appears to be catching up to him. And for an image-conscious program like Kentucky, you have to think the administration is sweating just a bit right now as this process plays out. Calipari supporters, and UK fans, will be quick to point out that Calipari himself has never had any violations, and that Wall is just a young kid who made a mistake (over-zealous UK fans could probably justify signing Christian Laettner right now if they thought he could deliver victories). But a look at the big picture delivers a disturbing reality, namely that trouble just seems to follow Calipari around. "

Dan Wetzel, Yahoo! Sports: "It might have been Memphis, an obvious beneficiary of his eligibility, which did it. It also might have been someone who wanted to curry favor with him and his family so that after he did his six months at college, he might sign with them. Rose might not have even known about what the NCAA richly describes as “fraudulence and misconduct.” Rose probably didn’t do it himself, because if you’re capable of figuring out how to fix the SAT you probably don’t have to. [...] For everyone else the details don’t matter. Calipari might be cleared (or never charged) but he was cleared and never charged with the Marcus Camby situation at Massachusetts. Eventually there are too many cleared and never charged to remember. He’ll survive because head coaches always survive; especially when they have a killer team for next season. But perception is reality as Cal likes to say. And the reality is that after two months of glorious, worshipful sunshine, it just got really cloudy in Lexington."

RTMSF, Rush The Court: "And of course Kentucky fans are all too familiar with Eric Manuel’s sad tale of academic fraud from the late 80s which ultimately led to some of the darkest days in the program’s history. You have to wonder if the school’s frustration with Tubby and then Gillispie has opened the door to another era of the ‘anything goes’ mentality in Lexington.  After all, it’s been a generation since Eddie Sutton was run out of town; most of the students at UK weren’t even alive yet for that particular abomination. One thing’s for sure about this whole mess.  Calipari is starting to remind us a little of Elijah Price in “Unbreakable” - bad shhtuff seems to follow him around wherever he goes, but nothing ever seems to get pinned directly onto him.  Whether this is something Kentucky fans are worried about is up for debate, but this has to be a tad unsettling for Kentucky fans over the age of 30."

digg delicious
more

12 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. Marco
    1. Posted by Marco Thu May 28, 2009 4:22 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    No one likes the mets.
  2. John C
    2. Posted by John C Thu May 28, 2009 5:32 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    SEE THIS... 4 of Rose's HS team mates are apart of the SAT/Grades scam.
    1 of the HS players is thought to have cheated on his SAT.
    4 other players on his HS team are invovled in a HS transcript scam.
    2 of the players play DiV I basketball!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    http://www.suntimes.com/sports/1596666,derrick-rose-simeon-grades-cheat-memphis.article
  3. The World Famous Butt Pirate
    3. Posted by The World Famous Butt Pirate Thu May 28, 2009 5:54 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Brennan, you fool. You've compiled a slew of opinions here, but in your haste you left out the only one that really matters - Kige Ramsey.
  4. John C
    4. Posted by John C Thu May 28, 2009 6:15 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Make the numbers clearer
    4 HS players on Rose’s Team
    * 2 may have cheated on their SAT * 4 cheated on school submitted transcripts * 3 played Div I basketball…
  5. mickey m
    5. Posted by mickey m Thu May 28, 2009 6:39 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    did we really expect anything different? we are talking about memphis, just open your eyes and what do you see? thug, thug, thug, the thug capital of the country!! when you put a crook like calipari and a city of (well you know) this is what you get. most of those thugs probably cant even spell their name but i bet they can fire a gun over someones nikes! this really should not be that shocking!!
  6. PurdueMatt
    6. Posted by PurdueMatt Fri May 29, 2009 9:02 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Say this for the Hoosiers though, they hired a known cheater and got what they deserved.
  7. JC
    7. Posted by JC Fri May 29, 2009 9:04 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Pretty ignorant post mickey m...just because someone has tattoos doesn't make them a thug. Go sit down with some of these kids, get to know them and have a conversation, then go sit in a jail cell with some real thugs, and get back to me. As for UK knowing what they were getting with Cal...well hey, they did pull the trigger supposedly knowing what was going on. Memphis fans stood behind him as our coach because by the time we hired him UMass was resolved, he had gone [and failed] in the NBA...and was unemployed - so it was a fresh start of sorts. If this all pans out to have happened on his watch - that's 2 for 2 in programs he's left in shambles. Who knows, he may or may not be shady at UK - but is the fact he might be worth the risk?
    UK for the most part has been a more traditional program as far as letting team chemistry and time played together over the years make their team a force in the NCAA....how long is UK willing to be the leagues new one-and-done machine? We all know the only team to win with a significant O&D was Syracuse with Carmello Anthony.....things are about to be very interesting for UK.
  8. Memphis2008
    8. Posted by Memphis2008 Fri May 29, 2009 1:53 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Somehow Calipari's unethical tactics keep going unnoticed. Places like Memphis are so starved for something to be proud they will overlook anything. The problems with the UM program are well documented check out onlyinmemphis.wordpress.com
  9. Kay
    9. Posted by Kay Sat May 30, 2009 8:22 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    And Memphis2008, what does that make UK? They knew about 2007 unresolved allegations and hired Cal anyway. Memphis hired an unemployed coach with no unresolved issues.
  10. mickey m
    10. Posted by mickey m Sat May 30, 2009 4:44 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    to nope, i would try to sit down and have a conversation with some of the memphis players but i would bet it wouldnt be a intelligent one. rose couldnt even take his own sat and had to get his high school grades change, we are talking about high school classes. the government has made it now where a monkey can pass high school and well we see that still hasnt changed anything. lets stop making excuses for these kids and hold them accountible for what they do and dont do. the excuse that they come from poor families and no father and being from inner cities is getting old. in reallity they have more of a chance than a kid that does right, gets good grades and stays out of trouble does. and another thing why is it the certain schools (memphis, umass, nc state, michigan, etc) are the same schools that ALWAYS are the ones that this happens to. we dont ever hear of unc, duke, stanford etc. getting in this kind of trouble, oh wait i know its racist but hey they have players with tatooes also. it seems to me that you are the one being ignorant. nope i know this really hurts but 2 and 2 is 4 however you look at it
  11. Michael K
    11. Posted by Michael K Mon Jun 01, 2009 3:12 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    John Calipari It looks like Kentucky enjoyed its stay NCAA violations list. Sure he brings the talent but will the school be able to keep their National Titles after he leaves. Sorry to hear this for Kentucky and also how many of these top recruits were heading to Memphis before the John announced he was going to Kentucky.
  12. markd
    12. Posted by markd Tue Jun 02, 2009 3:48 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    The only thing i will say is good luck Kentucky. If the NCAA changed it's policy! If they find out a coach breaks NCAA rules they should not punish the schools. The coach should receive a lifetime ban.As for Kentucky basketball all good things come to an end.Look at Florida States football program.

The Dagger

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Jeff Eisenberg

The Dagger is a college basketball blog edited by Jeff Eisenberg. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Contributors:
Chris Chase, Matt Norlander,

Related Photo Gallery

Featured NCAAB Video

Y! Sports Blogs

The Dagger Recent Readers