| Rank | Name | Pos | Location | Stars | Ht | Wt | School |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| #1 | Chad Voytik | QB | Cleveland, TNCleveland Voytik capped high school career with 296-yard, four-TD effort; had 5,000-plus career yards. | 4 stars | 6'1" | 183 | Pittsburgh |
| #2 | Drae Bowles | WR | Jackson, TNJackson Christian As a senior, Bowles recorded 31 receptions for 519 yards and five scores. Had 171 catches for his career. | 4 stars | 6'1" | 198 | Tennessee |
| #3 | Jovon Robinson | RB | Memphis, TNWooddale Robinson had 133 carries for 1,249 yards and 14 total touchdowns, playing running back, quarterback and wide receiver in 2011. | 4 stars | 6'0" | 215 | Auburn |
| #4 | Brian Kimbrow | RB | Memphis, TNMemphis East Kimbrow rushed for more than 3,600 yards combined his final two seasons, including 1,900 as a senior. | 4 stars | 5'9" | 165 | Vanderbilt |
| #5 | Graham Shuler | OL | Brentwood, TNBrentwood Academy Shuler had 30-plus pancake blocks and graded out over 92 percent for the season. | 4 stars | 6'5" | 275 | Stanford |
| #6 | Caleb Azubike | DE | Nashville, TNMcGavock Shuler had 30-plus pancake blocks and graded out over 92 percent for the season. | 4 stars | 6'5" | 240 | Vanderbilt |
| #7 | I'Tavius Mathers | RB | Murfreesboro, TNBlackman Mathers rushed for 2,210 yards and 25 touchdowns this season and finished with more than 5,500 yards for his career. | 4 stars | 6'0" | 195 | Mississippi |
| #8 | Will Redmond | ATH | Memphis, TNMemphis East A two-way standout, Redmond scored 13 touchdowns as a senior. | 4 stars | 6'0" | 179 | Mississippi St. |
| #9 | Blake Bars | OL | Nashville, TNMontgomery Bell Academy Bars anchored offensive line for team that reached second round of the playoffs. | 4 stars | 6'5" | 275 | Michigan |
| #10 | Andrew Jelks | OL | Paris, TNHenry County Top linemen for state championship squad. | 4 stars | 6'6" | 260 | Vanderbilt |
| #11 | Sheldon Dawson | ATH | Memphis, TNRidgeway Dawson was a standout on offense, defense and special teams. | 3 stars | 5'11" | 169 | Georgia |
| #12 | Jaylen Walton | RB | Memphis, TNRidgeway Walton produced more than 2,000 yards of offense in 2011. | 3 stars | 5'8" | 164 | Mississippi |
| #13 | Brandon Hill | OL | Collierville, TNSt. George's Hill played both ways to help lead squad to the Division 2-A state championship. | 3 stars | 6'6" | 352 | Alabama |
| #14 | Nathan Cole | WR | Memphis, TNMitchell Cole recorded 600-plus receiving yards during senior campaign. | 3 stars | 5'11" | 170 | Cincinnati |
| #15 | William Gross | QB | Memphis, TNMelrose Completed 57 percent of his passes for 1,200 yards and 14 touchdowns before sustaining knee injury. | 3 stars | 6'1" | 170 | Memphis |
| #16 | Barrett Gouger | OL | Chattanooga, TNBaylor School Gouger was named the state's Division II-AA Mr. Football Lineman of the Year. | 3 stars | 6'5" | 285 | Vanderbilt |
| #17 | Jay Guillermo | OL | Maryville, TNMaryville Guillermo anchored line for state championship team. | 3 stars | 6'2" | 287 | Clemson |
| #18 | Patton Robinette | QB | Maryville, TNMaryville Robinette accounted for more than 2,500 yards of offense in 2011. | 3 stars | 6'5" | 200 | Vanderbilt |
| #19 | Woody Baron | DE | Brentwood, TNBrentwood Academy Barron was selected for the Tennessee East vs. West All-Star game. | 3 stars | 6'3" | 252 | Virginia Tech |
| #20 | Cordale Boyd | OL | Memphis, TNRidgeway Boyd anchored line for team that scored 39 points a game. | 3 stars | 6'4" | 290 | Arkansas |
| #21 | Brandon Lewis | DE | Memphis, TNRidgeway Lewis was top defensive line performer for third-round playoff squad. | 3 stars | 6'5" | 225 | Arkansas |
| #22 | Jamil Golden | QB | Memphis, TNRidgeway Golden quarterbacked team to third round of the playoffs and competed in Tennessee East vs. West All-Star game. | 3 stars | 6'4" | 206 | list |
| #23 | Dyshawn Mobley | RB | Powell, TNPowell Mobley set a state record with 3,068 rushing yards in 2011. | 3 stars | 6'0" | 205 | Kentucky |
| #24 | C.J. Beathard | QB | Franklin, TNBattle Ground Academy Beathard threw two touchdown passes in the Tennessee East vs West All-Star game. | 3 stars | 6'2" | 180 | Iowa |
| #25 | Cory Batey | WR | Nashville, TNEnsworth Baty finished the 2011 season with over 800 receiving yards. | 3 stars | 6'0" | 183 | Vanderbilt |