| Rank | Name | Pos | Location | Stars | Ht | Wt | School |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| #1 | Sterling Shepard | WR | Oklahoma City, OKHeritage Hall Shepard tallied three receptions for 29 yards in the Under Armour game. | 4 stars | 5'10" | 175 | Oklahoma |
| #2 | Barry Sanders | RB | Oklahoma City, OKHeritage Hall Sanders ran for a 10-yard touchdown during the Army Bowl. | 4 stars | 5'11" | 190 | Stanford |
| #3 | Alex Ross | RB | Jenks, OKJenks Despite missing much of the season to injury Ross rushed for 652 yards and 10 touchdowns on only 72 carries. | 4 stars | 6'1" | 205 | Oklahoma |
| #4 | Michael Onuoha | DE | Edmond, OKSanta Fe Onuoha helped Santa Fe to an undefeated district record in 2011. | 3 stars | 6'5" | 225 | Oklahoma |
| #5 | Keon Hatcher | WR | Owasso, OKOwasso Hatcher recorded 100 receptions for 1,610 yards and 20 touchdowns as a senior. | 3 stars | 6'2" | 205 | Arkansas |
| #6 | Donovan Roberts | RB | Norman, OKNorman Roberts rushed for 1,595 yards and 23 touchdowns as a senior. | 3 stars | 6'0" | 200 | Arkansas |
| #7 | Kevin Peterson | DB | Wagoner, OKWagoner Peterson is an outstanding cover corner. | 3 stars | 5'11" | 170 | Oklahoma St. |
| #8 | Levi Copelin | DB | Broken Arrow, OKBroken Arrow Copelin lined up at receiver, corner, safety and kick returner for Broken Arrow and he recorded nine interceptions. | 3 stars | 6'2" | 170 | Missouri |
| #9 | Cayman Bundage | OL | Oklahoma City, OKDouglass Bundage could play either guard or center at the next level. | 3 stars | 6'2" | 293 | Arizona |
| #10 | Zac Veatch | TE | Broken Arrow, OKBroken Arrow Veatch was a standout at both tight end defensive end in helping Broken Arrow reach the state title game. | 3 stars | 6'4" | 245 | Oklahoma St. |
| #11 | Blake Belcher | OL | Guthrie, OKGuthrie Belcher helped lead Guthrie to a state championship as a senior. | 3 stars | 6'6" | 271 | Tulsa |
| #12 | Jared Collins | DB | Tulsa, OKBooker T. Washington Collins picked off a pass from his corner spot in 2011. | 3 stars | 6'0" | 170 | Arkansas |
| #13 | Michael Thomas | DB | Lawton, OKMacArthur Thomas recorded 30 tackles and two interceptions in 2011. | 3 stars | 6'1" | 195 | Tulsa |
| #14 | Daniel Burton | OL | Oklahoma City, OKPutnam City North Burton could play offensive tackle or guard in college. | 3 stars | 6'4" | 270 | Iowa St. |
| #15 | Damian Gibson | DE | Tulsa, OKEast Central Gibson recorded 112 tackles and six sacks while also catching 29 passes for 444 yards and six scores as a senior. | 3 stars | 6'4" | 250 | Tulsa |
| #16 | Quintaz Struble | DE | Oklahoma City, OKHeritage Hall Struble recorded 63 tackles and five sacks in 2011. | 3 stars | 6'2" | 235 | Arkansas St. |
| #17 | Conner Sherwood | LB | Tulsa, OKCascia Hall Sherwood heped lead Cascia Hall to a 14-1 record and a spot in the state finals. | 3 stars | 6'2" | 218 | Tulsa |
| #18 | James Flanders | RB | Midwest City, OKMidwest City Flanders rushed for 2,456 yards and 44 touchdowns as a senior. | 3 stars | 5'10" | 181 | Tulsa |
| #19 | Tyler Wilson | TE | Ponca City, OKPonca City Wilson caught 28 passes for 306 yards as a senior. | 3 stars | 6'7" | 260 | Tulsa |
| #20 | Cory Rahmings | DE | Broken Bow, OKBroken Bow Rahmings helped Broken Bow reach the postseason in 2011. | 3 stars | 6'3" | 255 | Tulsa |